Class 11 English Book 3 Chapter 26 The Story NCERT Solutions in English

Model answers to every exercise of NCERT Woven Words (Book 3 on this site), Essays 6 (chapter 26 in this
site’s numbering), “The Story” by E.M. Forster, with the questions given as printed in the book: the in-text word box,
Understanding the Text, Talking about the Text, Appreciation, and Language Work. Write your own answer first, then compare it with the one
given here.

1 In-text Question

Look for these expressions

Q. Look for these expressions and guess their meaning from the context: atavistic, shock-heads, ingenious.

Answer:

atavistic: belonging to, or going back to, very early and primitive ancestors; Forster wishes the novel’s basis were “something different—melody, or perception of truth, not this low atavistic form,” and he says story-telling “is immensely old—goes back to Neolithic times, perhaps to Palaeolithic.”

shock-heads: people with thick, rough, untidy masses of hair; “The primitive audience was an audience of shock-heads, gaping round the campfire.”

ingenious: clever and inventive, full of original ideas; Scheherazade was “ingenious in her incidents”, and Proust, “still more ingenious,” kept altering the hands of the clock.

2 Understanding the Text

Question 1

Q. What do you understand of the three voices in response to the question “What does a
novel do?”

Answer: Forster imagines three very different men answering this question. The first,
placid and vague, “probably driving a motor-bus,” says he supposes a novel “kind of tells a
story, so to speak”; Forster calls him “quite good tempered and vague.” The second, aggressive and
brisk, imagined on a golf-course, says “give me a good story” above art, literature and music, and
“I like a story to be a story, mind.” The third, in “a sort of drooping regretful voice,” is
Forster himself: he agrees, reluctantly, that “the novel tells a story,” though he wishes it
“could be something different—melody, or perception of truth.” Forster states his attitudes
without giving reasons: “I respect and admire the first speaker. I detest and fear the second.
And the third is myself.”

Question 2

Q. What would you say are “the finer growths” that the story supports in a novel?

Answer: The “finer growths” are everything a good novel adds on top of its bare
time-sequence of events: character, values, meaning, style and “the life by values,” which
Forster says the entire novel includes “using devices hereafter to be examined.” The story
itself, isolated from these finer growths, looks bare and unattractive, “the naked worm of
time,” but the finer growths are what make the difference between a mere sequence of events and
a rich, complicated novel.

Question 3

Q. How does Forster trace the human interest in the story to primitive times?

Answer: Forster says the story “is immensely old—goes back to Neolithic times,
perhaps to Palaeolithic,” adding that “Neanderthal man listened to stories, if
one may judge by the shape of his skull.” He imagines the earliest audience as “shock-heads,
gaping round the campfire,” exhausted from fighting off “the mammoth or the woolly rhinoceros”
and “only kept awake by suspense.” If they ever guessed what would happen next, “they either
fell asleep or killed” the storyteller. Later he adds that this want to know what happens next
is, in his word, “universal.”

Question 4

Q. Discuss the importance of time in the narration of a story.

Answer: Time is the basis of a story: Forster defines a story as “a narrative of events arranged in their time sequence—dinner coming
after breakfast, Tuesday coming after Monday, decay after death.” Without this time-ordering, a
story would simply be a list of disconnected events. Forster extends this to the whole novel: “in
a novel, there is always a clock,” and a novelist “must cling, however lightly, to the thread of
his story,” “otherwise he becomes unintelligible.” Even novelists who play tricks with time, hiding
it, inverting it, or altering it, still depend on a working time sequence underneath; none of them
escape it altogether.

3 Talking about the Text

These points are for classroom discussion in pairs or small groups; a model answer for each is
given below.

Discussion Point 1

Q. What does a novel do?

Answer: According to Forster, at the most basic level, a novel tells a story: “a
narrative of events arranged in their time sequence.” This is the one thing every novel, however
complicated, has in common, which is why he calls the story “the highest factor common to all”
novels, even though, taken alone, it is “the lowest and simplest of literary organisms.” A good
novel, however, does more than this: “what the entire novel does—if it is a good novel—is to
include the life by values as well; using devices hereafter to be examined.” So the novel, “also,
pays a double allegiance,” as daily life does, though in it “the allegiance to time is
imperative.”

Discussion Point 2

Q. “Our daily life reflects a double allegiance to ‘the life in time’ and ‘the life by
values’.”

Answer: Forster illustrates this “double allegiance” with a single sentence: “I only
saw her for five minutes, but it was worth it.” The “five minutes” belongs to the life in time,
an exact, measurable duration; “it was worth it” belongs to the life by values, a judgement made
by intensity rather than the clock. He notes that, looking back, our past “does not stretch back
evenly but piles up into a few pinnacles,” and looking ahead, the future feels like “a wall,” “a
cloud” or “a sun,” never a plain “chronological chart.” In daily life, this allegiance to time can
sometimes be denied, though at the risk of seeming “unintelligible”; inside a novel, by contrast,
the allegiance to time is imperative, since “no novel could be written without it.”

Discussion Point 3

Q. The description of novels as organisms.

Answer: Forster calls the story “the lowest and simplest of literary organisms,” and
yet, in the same breath, “the highest factor common to all the very complicated organisms known
as novels.” The word “organism” suggests something living and structured, not a mechanical list.
One way to read the comparison (our analogy, not the book’s): a simple story is like a very simple
organism, needing only to keep its audience awake with curiosity, while a complex novel is like a
far more developed organism built on top of that same basic structure. However elaborate a novel
becomes, Forster’s point is that the story is still “the highest factor common to all” of them,
running through each one.

4 Appreciation

Question 1

Q. How does Forster use the analogy of Scheherazade to establish his point?

Answer: Forster first lists Scheherazade’s many genuine talents: “exquisite in her
descriptions, tolerant in her judgements, ingenious in her incidents, advanced in her morality,
vivid in her delineations of character, expert in her knowledge of three Oriental capitals.” He
then insists that none of this mattered to her survival: “it was yet on none of these gifts that
she relied when trying to save her life from her intolerable husband. They were but incidental.”
What actually kept her alive, night after night, was suspense alone: she “only survived because
she managed to keep the king wondering what would happen next,” stopping “at this moment,” as the
sun rose, and staying “discreet” and silent. Forster’s conclusion universalises the example: “we
are like Scheherazade’s husband in that we want to know what happens next.” By reducing
Scheherazade’s survival to this one trick, Forster suggests, through a single vivid case, that
the wish to know what happens next is “universal,” which, he says, “is why the backbone of a novel
has to be a story.”

Question 2

Q. Taking off from Forster’s references to Emily Bronte, Sterne and Proust, discuss the
treatment of time in some of the novels you have read.

Answer: Forster names three novelists who each manage “the clock” differently; “all
these devices are legitimate but none of them contravene” his thesis. Emily Bronte, in Wuthering Heights, “tried to hide”
the clock, disguising the novel’s time sequence rather than removing it. Sterne, in Tristram
Shandy
, “turned it upside down,” playing with the ordinary order of events.
Marcel Proust, “still more ingenious,” “kept altering the hands” so that his hero seemed to be
doing two things at once, entertaining a mistress and playing with his nurse. A student can extend
this idea to novels they have read: a detective novel, for instance, often withholds events out of
their true order (revealing the crime’s cause only after its effect), while a novel told through
diary entries or letters can skip large stretches of time between one entry and the next. Whatever
the trick, Forster’s point holds: hiding, inverting or altering a clock still assumes a clock is
there in the first place, so even the most experimental novel still rests on a story, “a narrative
of events arranged in their time sequence.”

5 Language Work

Question 1

Q. “Qua story”: what does the word mean? Find other expressions using the word qua.

Answer: “Qua” is a Latin word meaning “as,” “in the capacity of,” or “considered
strictly as.” When Forster writes “qua story, it can only have one merit,” he means: considered
strictly as a story, and judged on nothing else. Other expressions that use “qua” in the same way
include “qua artist” (considered strictly as an artist, apart from any other role a person might
have), “qua citizen” (in one’s capacity as a citizen, rather than, say, as a private individual),
and “qua teacher” (acting strictly in the role of a teacher).

Question 2

Q. Study the Note to Aspects of the Novel given at the end. Discuss the features that
mark the piece as a talk as distinguished from a critical essay.

Answer: The Note explains that these were originally spoken lectures, the Clark
Lectures, “delivered under the auspices of Trinity College, Cambridge, in the spring of 1927,” and
that “it seemed safer when presenting them in book form not to mitigate the talk, in case nothing
should be left at all.” Several features mark this as a talk
rather than a polished critical essay: the frequent, informal use of “I,” “you,” “one” and “we”;
conversational fillers like “curiously enough,” “so to speak,” “only imagine” and “of course,”
which “occur on every page”; and a personal, first-person voice throughout, rather than the more
distant, impersonal tone of formal literary criticism. Forster defends keeping these features,
arguing that removing them might let other, “perhaps more distinguished,” words escape too, and
that “since the novel is itself often colloquial it may possibly withhold some of its secrets from
the graver and grander streams of criticism and may reveal them to backwaters and shallows.”

Question 3

Q. Try rewriting the lecture as a formal essay and examine Forster’s statement: “…since
the novel is itself often colloquial, it may possibly withhold some of its secrets from the
graver and grander streams of criticism.”

Answer: Rewritten formally, Forster’s opening might read: “The fundamental aspect of
the novel is its narrative, or story-telling, function; however, opinions differ regarding the
emphasis this function ought to receive.” Compared with the original (“Well—I don’t know—it
seems a funny sort of question to ask… I suppose it kind of tells a story, so to speak”), the
formal version loses the personality, humour and hesitation of the three imagined voices,
becoming clearer but flatter and less memorable. One reading of Forster’s statement follows from
this: because the novel itself is “often colloquial,” an informal, talkative style
can capture something true about how people actually think and argue about stories, a truth that
a “graver and grander,” more formal critical style might smooth away entirely.