Class 9 English Chapter 6 Twin Melodies Notes in English

What this unit covers
  • “Twin Melodies”, a play in three acts by Mitra Phukan: characters, the story act by act, themes and the meaning of the title
  • “A Friend Found in Music”, a poem by Bryanna T. Perkins: meaning, poetic devices, rhyme scheme and message
  • The grammar and vocabulary the unit teaches: aside, non-lexical fillers, music words, exclamatory sentences, reported speech, phrasal verbs
  • The two writing formats: a play script and an invitation letter
Mitra Phukanplay in three actsShruti SharmaNabin SharmaIndo-Western fusioneach bay, its own windBryanna T. Perkinsmetaphorabcb rhyme

1 Twin Melodies: the Play at a Glance

“Twin Melodies” is a short play in three acts written by Mitra Phukan. It is about Shruti, a young violinist who wants to play in an Indo-Western fusion group with her friends, and her father, a strict classical violinist who is against fusion music. In the end, her mother reminds the father of his own past, and he supports his daughter.

Indo-Western fusion simply means music that mixes Indian and Western styles and instruments. In the play, the group mixes the tabla and flute with the keyboard and violin.

Learn by heartDefinition 1: Stage directions

Stage directions are the instructions in a play script that tell the actors what to do and how to deliver their lines. They are not spoken aloud. Words in brackets show the manner of delivery or an action, for example “(very loudly)” or “(getting up)”: “Brackets (parentheses) serve to convey to the actor the manner in which to deliver the words.” Scene descriptions such as “The scene opens to the notes of a beautiful Indo-Western fusion music piece…” are stage directions too.

2 Characters

Character Who they are (the book’s own description) Key trait in the play
Shruti Sharma “A young aspiring violinist” Talented, respects her father, but torn between his wishes and her wish to try fusion
Guru Nabin Sharma Shruti’s father, a violinist, and the Principal of Sangeetika Music School Strict, proud of classical music; changes his mind in Act III
Leela Devi Shruti’s mother Humorous, fair; scolds Shruti for hiding, then opens Nabin’s eyes
Avinash Tabla player of the fusion group Cheerful, teasing; practical advice: talk to your father
Iqbal Flutist of the fusion group Reassuring and funny; the practice happens in his room
Peter Keyboard player of the fusion group Encouraging; first suggests just telling the parents about the practice

3 The Story, Act by Act

3.1 Act I: in Iqbal’s room, after rehearsal

The rehearsalFour friends finish playing a fusion piece in Iqbal’s room: Iqbal on flute, Avinash on tabla, Peter on keyboard, Shruti on violin. The room has a small rack, a wooden table stacked with books, and posters of flute players Pandit Hariprasad Chaurasia and Shashank Subramanyam.
↓
The newspaperIqbal reads out praise of Shruti from the Parbatpuri Daily Clarion: “Melody runs in the veins of Miss Shruti Sharma”. Avinash says she must “throw a party”. Shruti, worried, is lost in her thoughts.
↓
The secretShruti has not told her father about the practice or the concert. She fears he will think it a “desecration” (disrespect of something sacred) to play the violin to Western tunes, because he believes only classical Hindustani music is worth playing.
↓
The friends’ adviceIqbal: “All ways are right ways”. Avinash: he may scold, but will “come round”. Encouraged, Shruti decides to “bite the bullet” and promises to bring it up at dinner. Peter: “That’s the spirit!”

3.2 Act II: at the dinner table

Light-hearted startShruti sits over her last bite, lost in thought. Her parents joke about the dosa. She asks her father not to get too angry; he says, “No promises, child. But speak up.”
↓
Nabin’s ruleHe refuses at once. His rule is one performance in every six months, because “familiarity breeds contempt” (too much exposure makes people value you less). He also dislikes drowning her “individual style in the hubbub of an orchestra” (hubbub means a loud noise).
↓
The word “fusion”When Shruti timidly says it is an Indo-western fusion concert, Nabin gets up, upset: “I never thought any of my students, let alone my own child, would lose their sense of musicality”. She pleads with him to attend one practice; he mocks it as “‘phoo’ music” and leaves.
↓
Leela’s scoldingLeela scolds Shruti for acting without her father’s knowledge and teases her about her “practice classes”. Shruti promises: “Sorry mummy, won’t hide from you again.”

3.3 Act III: back at Iqbal’s house

Shruti’s planIn an aside, Shruti says she will practise one last time and then tell her friends she cannot join the performance.
↓
The surpriseHer parents enter during practice and stand in a corner. They become engrossed; Nabin taps his feet and then “claps furiously” with pride.
↓
Nabin’s praise“Wah, how soulful!” He says Shruti did not lose sight of the notes of the raga even once, and offers the children the music room for regular practice.
↓
The truth about the pastNabin admits “it was Leela who opened my eyes”. Leela tells Shruti that her father, too, went against his family to play the violin.
↓
AcceptanceNabin: “each bay, its own wind”. He trusts Shruti and will root for (support) her group. Shruti hugs both parents. Curtain down.
Common Mistake

Shruti does not tell her father during Act III that she is dropping out. Her plan, given in an aside, is to tell her friends that she cannot join the performance, but her parents arrive during the practice before she can do so. Also, it is Shruti’s mother, not a friend, who changes Nabin’s mind.

4 Two Stories, One Pattern: Why “Twin Melodies”

Leela’s revelation in Act III shows that the father and the daughter lived through the same conflict, one generation apart. Nabin’s family were vocalists who had “painstakingly nurtured” their musical heritage. Nabin chose a Western instrument, the violin, at a time when it “had not yet been incorporated into classical Indian music”. His father saw this as “a kind of betrayal of family values and tradition”, but Nabin “worked his fingers to the bone” (worked very hard) and succeeded.

Figure 1: Father and daughter each broke away from what the family expected, one generation apart. This matching pattern is one reading of the title "Twin Melodies".
Figure 1: Father and daughter each broke away from what the family expected, one generation apart. This matching pattern is one reading of the title “Twin Melodies”.
Exam Tip: justifying the title

Give at least two readings of the title “Twin Melodies”: (1) two kinds of music, classical and fusion, which the play shows can live together (Shruti keeps the raga’s notes even in fusion); (2) two matching life stories, father and daughter who both followed their own path; (3) tradition and modernity in harmony, like two melodies played together. Quote “each bay, its own wind” to finish.

5 Themes

5.1 Five themes these notes draw from the play

1

Tradition and modernity

Nabin stands for classical Hindustani music “with its ragas and aalaaps”; Shruti wants to try Indo-Western fusion. The ending shows the two can meet: her fusion playing keeps the raga’s notes.

2

The generation gap

Children and elders see music differently. In the play, the gap narrows through honest talk and through the elder remembering his own youth: “I had forgotten my own past.”

3

Duty to family vs personal passion

Shruti cares about her father’s opinion (“because I do”) but also wants to “give this a try”. She hides the practice, then chooses honesty.

4

Every artist’s own path

“Each bay, its own wind” means each person has a unique journey and style; one rule does not fit everyone.

5

Friendship and cultural diversity

Four friends play Indian and Western instruments together (tabla, flute, keyboard, violin) and support one another. The mix of players and instruments is itself the “fusion” the play celebrates.

6 How Nabin Changes

Nabin in Act II

  • Refuses at once: “No is the answer.”
  • Believes fusion ruins musicality
  • Mocks it as “‘phoo’ music”
  • Gets up with a start and leaves

Nabin in Act III

  • Taps his feet, claps with pride
  • “Wah, how soulful!”
  • Offers the music room
  • “I trust you Shruti”

The reason for the change: he sees that his fear was “baseless”. He had been “afraid you would be lost to us”, that fusion would pull Shruti away from their own musical tradition. Hearing that she “did not lose sight of the notes of the raga even once and performed it to excellence” shows him the “power of our own music”.

7 Lines to Remember

“I don’t want papa to feel that I don’t care about his opinions, because I do.”

Shruti, Act I: her inner conflict in one line

“All ways are right ways, Shruti. He is your father, he will understand.”

Iqbal, Act I: reassurance

“More than that, familiarity breeds contempt.”

Nabin, Act II: his reason for one performance in six months

“I must admit it was Leela who opened my eyes. I had forgotten my own past.”

Nabin, Act III

“After all each bay, its own wind.”

Nabin, Act III: the key line of the play

8 Language of the Play: Grammar and Vocabulary

8.1 Aside and non-lexical fillers

Learn by heartDefinition 2: Aside

An aside is a dramatic device where a character speaks directly to the audience. The other characters on stage are taken to be unaware of it. Example: Shruti’s “(Aside) Oh, how much I enjoy performing this piece.”

Learn by heartDefinition 3: Non-lexical fillers

Non-lexical fillers are words or sounds like “uh” or “um” used in speech to fill pauses while the speaker gathers their thoughts or moves between ideas. Examples from the play: “Ahem ahem”, “I … er …”.

Filler Feeling it shows
arrgh frustration, panic
ahem-ahem clearing the throat, drawing attention
whew relief
hmmm thinking, doubt
err hesitation

8.2 Words from the world of music

Word Meaning
notes a single sound at a certain pitch, shown as a symbol on a music sheet
crescendo a gradual increase in the volume or intensity of sound
rhythm the pattern of beats or time intervals in music
tempo the speed or pace at which music is played
bass (said “base”) the lowest tone or part in music
baritone a male voice between the higher and lower ranges
cacophony a mixture of loud unpleasant sounds
pitch how high or low a sound is
scale a series of notes moving upwards or downwards

8.3 Words and phrases from the play

Word / phrase Meaning
bite the bullet face a difficult situation with courage
bring it up start talking about a topic
come round / come around change one’s mind and agree
desecration disrespect towards something sacred
ragas and aalaaps elements of Hindustani classical music
contempt a strong feeling of dislike and disrespect
hubbub a loud noise
iterated repeated
painstakingly with great care and effort
worked his fingers to the bone worked very hard
root (for) show support
drown your individual style lose your own special style by blindly following others
sense of musicality a natural feel and talent for music
go down the drain be wasted

8.4 Literal or figurative? (Reflect and Respond IV)

The book asks whether the phrases in its box have a literal or a figurative meaning. Most are figurative (idioms). Three of them, in the play, describe what a person visibly does, so they stay close to their literal sense.

Phrase Literal or figurative Meaning
winding up figurative finishing (a practice, a meeting)
bite the bullet figurative face a difficult situation with courage
bring it up figurative start talking about a topic
come around figurative change one’s mind and agree
throw a party figurative hold a party (nothing is thrown)
lost in his thoughts figurative so deep in thought that one does not notice others
wearing a look of distress close to literal looking upset; in the play, “Shruti wears a look of distress on her face”
found words close to literal managed to say what one wanted; in the play, “while Shruti finds the words”
sweating on close to literal in the play Peter’s “sweating on the vi-o-lin!” means working hard at the violin

8.5 Exclamatory sentences in reported speech

Learn by heartDefinition 4: Exclamatory sentence

An exclamatory sentence expresses strong feeling and ends with an exclamation mark, for example “Wah, how soulful!”

Rule box: exclamatory to reported (declarative) form
Use “exclaimed” or “exclaimed with (feeling)” instead of “said”
Remove interjections (Wow, Wah, Bravo), the exclamation mark and the quotation marks · change pronouns and tense as in normal reported speech
Worked Example (the book’s own)

Direct: “Wow Shruti! You’re a sensation!” suggested Avinash.
Reported: Avinash exclaimed with wonder that Shruti was a great sensation.

8.6 Speaking: stress and intonation

The book’s Speaking Activity shows that stress (which words are spoken more strongly) and intonation (the rise and fall of the voice) can change the meaning or emotional impact of a line.

Line Stress Intonation and effect
“I don’t want papa to feel that I don’t care about his opinions, because I do.” “don’t” in the first part and “do” in the second part start with a slightly lower tone, conveying concern, and rise towards the end; this highlights the contrast in Shruti’s internal conflict
“Tonight, at dinner, I promise to bring this up.” “promise” and “bring this up” a decisive tone on “promise”, then a slight rise in pitch and volume on “bring this up”, to show resolve
“Why are you lost in thought my dear child?” “lost” and “thought” a gentle tone, raised on “lost”; it draws attention to the concern in Leela’s question
“Each bay, its own wind” “each” and “own” a thoughtful, slightly philosophical tone; it highlights the uniqueness of each path

9 Writing a Play Script

The play itself is the model for the unit’s writing task. The book’s box explains why a script looks different from a story: brackets do the job of a reporting verb.

Play script format (template)
Title · Characters (name: one-line description) · Setting
SPEAKER: words spoken (no inverted commas) · (manner of speaking or action) in brackets, never spoken aloud · (Aside) for a private thought to the audience · … ellipsis for a short pause · fillers like “err”, “hmmm” · CURTAIN DOWN at the end
Model opening (Writing Task: Anuradha)

Characters: Anuradha, a teenage tabla player · Father, a vocalist and music teacher · Mother · Brother
Setting: The family’s living room, evening.
ANURADHA: (sitting alone, tapping the table softly) The event is next week … and Papa still wants me to be a vocalist, not a tabla player.
BROTHER: (entering) Still thinking? Just tell him, Anu. Mummy and I are with you.
ANURADHA: (Aside) If only it were that easy. Hmmm …

10 Listening Text: the Yazh

The unit’s listening passage (NCERT Appendix, p. 270) describes an ancient instrument. These facts come straight from that transcript.

Three ancient Tamil yazh harps in a museum display case
Yazhs, the ancient Tamil harps, on display at the Government Museum, Egmore, Chennai. Note the boat-like resonators and the long curved stems. Picture: Yercaud-elango / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 4.0
Point Fact
What it is an Indian harp, used in ancient Tamil music
Called the ancestor of the modern day veena
Name comes from its stem tip, carved into the head of the mythological animal Yali
Build open-stringed; gut strings; a wooden, boat-shaped, skin-covered resonator; an ebony stem
Tuning by pegs, or by rings of gut moved up and down the string
Varieties mayuri (peacock), makara (crocodile), matsya (fish), vil (bow string) yazh
Did you know?

The Recycled Orchestra of Cateura, Paraguay, formed in 2012, has children as part of it. They play instruments made from scrap materials collected from landfills. (Learning Beyond the Text)

Did you know?

Indigenous musical instruments are made from natural materials like bamboo, gourds, animal hides and shells. They range from percussion instruments like drums and rattles to wind instruments like flutes. (Learning Beyond the Text)

Read and enjoy: “Music” by Walter de la Mare

The unit ends with another poem about music, “Music” by Walter de la Mare. It opens “When music sounds, gone is the earth I know,” and each part begins with “When music sounds”. A Naiad, named in it, is “a water nymph said to inhabit a river, spring, or waterfall”.

11 A Friend Found in Music: the Poem

“A Friend Found in Music” is a short poem of twelve lines by Bryanna T. Perkins. The speaker (“I”) describes what music means to her: it comforts her when she is sad, stays with her when she is happy, and is a friend when no one else seems to care.

11.1 Meaning, four lines at a time

Lines 1 to 4Music is compared to an ocean that pulls her to the shore and a rhythm that moves her “to the core” (deep inside). Music draws her in and touches her feelings deeply.
↓
Lines 5 to 8Music is her “therapy” when she feels “blue” (sad). It lifts her spirits so that she can “pull through” (get through a hard time successfully).
↓
Lines 9 to 12Whenever she has been most cheerful, music was there. Music is “the needed friend / When no one seems to care.”

11.2 Poetic devices

Learn by heartDefinition 5: Metaphor

A metaphor compares two things by saying one thing is another, without “like” or “as”. Example: “Music is the ocean”.

Learn by heartDefinition 6: Personification

Personification gives human actions or feelings to a thing that is not human. Example: music “moves me” and “lifts my spirits”.

The book explains the phrase: “‘moves me’ means ‘to make somebody do something'”. “Move” also means to change position, to make progress, to take action, or to cause strong feelings.

Learn by heartDefinition 7: Rhyme scheme

The rhyme scheme is the pattern of rhyming words at the ends of lines, shown with letters (a, b, c…), the same letter for lines that rhyme.

Device Line(s) from the poem What it does
Metaphor “Music is the ocean” · “Music is the rhythm” · “Music is the therapy” · “Music is the needed friend” shows music as vast, moving, healing and loyal
Personification “That moves me to the core.” · “Music lifts my spirits” music acts like a caring person
Repetition (anaphora) “Music” begins lines 1, 3, 5, 7 and 11 keeps music at the centre; adds a song-like beat
Idiom “I need when I feel blue.” · “To make sure I pull through.” “feel blue” = feel sad; “pull through” = succeed in a hard time
Rhyme shore/core · blue/through · there/care the 2nd and 4th lines of each group of four rhyme, giving a musical flow
Rhyme scheme

abcb · defe · ghih

Only the 2nd and 4th line of each group of four rhyme (shore/core, blue/through, there/care). The regular rhyme makes the poem sound like a song, which suits a poem about music.

11.3 Central idea, mood and speaker

1

Central idea

Music is a dependable friend: it comforts in sadness, is present in happiness, and is there “When no one seems to care.”

2

Mood

Thoughtful: the speaker reflects on what music does for her.

3

Speaker

The poet herself, speaking in the first person: “me”, “I” and “my” run through the first nine lines.

12 Language of the Poem: Vocabulary

12.1 Words for feelings

Positive (happiness)

  • lifts my spirits
  • most cheerful
  • elation, jubilant, euphoric

Mixed

  • nostalgia: a fond longing for cherished past moments

Negative (sadness)

  • feel blue
  • despondence, anguish, despair, melancholy

12.2 Phrasal verbs

Learn by heartDefinition 8: Phrasal verb

A phrasal verb has two parts: a verb, and a preposition or adverb. Together they give a completely different meaning. Example: “pull” + “through” = pull through, “to succeed in doing something very difficult”.

Phrasal verb Meaning
move out leave a place where one has been living
move in begin living in a new home or place
move on start doing or discussing something new
move over shift position to make space for someone
move along go to a new position, to make room for others
move off start moving; leave

13 Writing an Invitation Letter

Informal invitation letter (the book’s format)
Sender’s address · Date · Salutation: Dear …
Body: ask about their well-being → mention the event with date, time and venue → request them to attend · Complimentary close: Yours affectionately, · Name of the sender · Language: first person (“I”, “We”) and second person (“You”), warm and personal

The task: invite your grandparents to your school’s musical evening on 21 June, World Music Day, where you are presenting a Sitar recital. A full model letter is in the NCERT Solutions for this unit.

14 Listening Text: Jaspreet and the Santoor

WhereA music centre about to close
→
WhoJaspreet and his mother
→
ProblemThe santoor teacher comes “just twice a week”
→
Failed fixWatching videos did not help much
→
SolutionBorrow his mother’s friend’s santoor till they buy their own
Did you know?

India’s own texts discuss music’s effect on the mind. Raga Chikitsa describes the healing properties of music, and Sangita Sudha, a seventeenth-century work, gives an account of the effects of music on emotions. (Learning Beyond the Text)

All definitions in one place
Stage directionsInstructions to the actors, not spoken aloud; brackets show how to deliver a line or what to do, e.g. (very loudly); scene descriptions are stage directions too
AsideA character speaks directly to the audience; the other characters are taken to be unaware
Non-lexical fillersSounds like “uh”, “um” that fill pauses while a speaker gathers their thoughts
Exclamatory sentenceA sentence expressing strong feeling, ending with an exclamation mark
MetaphorSays one thing is another, without “like” or “as”
PersonificationGives human actions or feelings to a non-human thing
Rhyme schemeThe pattern of end rhymes, shown with letters
Phrasal verbVerb + preposition/adverb with a new meaning, e.g. pull through
Quick Revision: read this the night before the exam
  • “Twin Melodies”: a play in three acts by Mitra Phukan; “A Friend Found in Music”: a 12-line poem by Bryanna T. Perkins
  • Act I: Iqbal’s room; the fusion group (Iqbal flute, Avinash tabla, Peter keyboard, Shruti violin); Shruti fears her father; decides to “bite the bullet”
  • Act II: dinner; Nabin refuses (one performance in six months, “familiarity breeds contempt”, “‘phoo’ music”); Leela scolds Shruti for hiding
  • Act III: parents hear the practice; “Wah, how soulful!”; music room offered; Leela reveals Nabin once went against his vocalist family to play the violin
  • Key line: “each bay, its own wind”, every artist has a unique path
  • Themes: tradition and modernity, generation gap, duty vs passion, honesty, friendship and diversity
  • Poem: metaphors (ocean, rhythm, therapy, friend); rhyme scheme abcb defe ghih; mood thoughtful; message: music is a faithful friend
  • Grammar: aside, non-lexical fillers, exclamatory sentences reported with “exclaimed”, phrasal verbs with “move”
Check yourself before the exam
  • Can I name all six characters and the instrument each friend plays?
  • Can I tell the story of each act in three lines?
  • Can I give two meanings of the title “Twin Melodies”?
  • Can I explain “each bay, its own wind” and say who says it?
  • Can I list the poem’s four metaphors and write its rhyme scheme?
  • Can I report an exclamation using “exclaimed”?