Class 11 English Book 1 Chapter 17 Father to Son NCERT Solutions in English

Complete solutions to the “Think it out” questions of NCERT Hornbill, “Father to Son” by Elizabeth Jennings (book page 69), exactly as printed in the book, with a full model answer under each. The book gives this poem only these four questions: there is no glossary, no “Notice the poetic devices” box and no “Try this out” for it, so nothing else is missing from this page. Write your own answer first, then compare.

1 Think it out

Question 1

Q. Does the poem talk of an exclusively personal experience or is it fairly universal?

Answer: The poem is told as a personal experience: one father speaks in his own voice (“I do not understand this child”), and the book’s note describes it as “autobiographical in nature”. But the experience it describes is fairly universal. Neither the father nor the son is named, and no particular town or time is mentioned, so they could be any parent and grown-up child. Living under one roof yet speaking “like strangers”, being unable to share “what he loves”, blaming oneself for the distance, and longing to forgive are feelings found in many families, on both sides of the generation gap. So the poem starts from one man’s life but can speak for many parents who feel a child slipping into “His world”.

Question 2

Q. How is the father’s helplessness brought out in the poem?

Answer: The father’s helplessness shows in almost every stanza:

  • He openly admits failure: “I do not understand this child” and “I know / Nothing of him”, although they have lived “In the same house for years”.
  • He can only “try to build / Up a relationship” from memories of the son “when small”, because he has no way into the son’s present life.
  • He cannot even tell whose fault it is, asking “have I killed / The seed I spent or sown it where / The land is his and none of mine?”
  • He cannot share in his son’s interests: “what he loves I cannot share”.
  • He can only wish, not act: “I would have / Him prodigal, returning to / His father’s house”.
  • Even when “He speaks”, the lines that follow show only confusion: “I cannot understand / Myself, why anger grows from grief.” (The colon most directly makes these the son’s words; some readers take the “I” as the father.)
  • At the end he can offer only “an empty hand”, with nothing in it to give.
Question 3

Q. Identify the phrases and lines that indicate distance between father and son.

Answer: The phrases and lines that show the distance are:

  • “I do not understand this child”
  • “I know / Nothing of him”
  • “The land is his and none of mine”
  • “We speak like strangers, there’s no sign / Of understanding in the air.”
  • “Yet what he loves I cannot share.”
  • “Silence surrounds us.”
  • “Rather than see him make and move / His world.”
  • “He speaks: I cannot understand”
  • “We each put out an empty hand”

Together they show that, though father and son share a house and even a likeness (“built to my design”), they share neither understanding nor interests.

Question 4

Q. Does the poem have a consistent rhyme scheme?

Answer: Yes. Each of the four six-line stanzas follows the same rhyme scheme, ABBABA: lines 1, 4 and 6 rhyme with one another, and lines 2, 3 and 5 rhyme with one another.

Stanza A (lines 1, 4, 6) B (lines 2, 3, 5)
1 child / build / killed now / know / how
2 where / air / share mine / sign / design
3 have / move / love to / knew / too
4 live / grief / forgive land / understand / hand

The pattern stays the same throughout, but not every rhyme is exact: some are half-rhymes (child / build / killed) and some are eye-rhymes that look alike but sound different (have / move / love). Like the father and son, the rhymes come close without always quite matching.