Class 10 Social Science Chapter 22 Outcomes of Democracy NCERT Solutions

Complete solutions to the NCERT exercise questions from Democratic Politics II, Chapter 5, Outcomes of Democracy. All eight questions are reproduced in the textbook’s own wording, in the book’s own order. The questions printed in boxes and margins inside the chapter text are answered at the end, in the book’s own order.

1Exercises

Questions 1-2
  1. 3 marksHow does democracy produce an accountable, responsive and legitimate government?
  2. 3 marksWhat are the conditions under which democracies accommodate social diversities?
Question 3: Give arguments to support or oppose the following assertions
  1. 4 marksGive arguments to support or oppose the following assertions:
    (i) Industrialised countries can afford democracy but the poor need dictatorship to become rich.
    (ii) Democracy can’t reduce inequality of incomes between different citizens.
    (iii) Government in poor countries should spend less on poverty reduction, health, education and spend more on industries and infrastructure.
    (iv) In democracy all citizens have one vote, which means that there is absence of any domination and conflict.
Question 4: Identify the challenge and suggest a mechanism
  1. 3 marksIdentify the challenges to democracy in the following descriptions. Also suggest policy/institutional mechanism to deepen democracy in the given situations:
    (i) Following a High Court directive, a temple in Orissa that had separate entry doors for dalits and non-dalits allowed entry for all from the same door.
    (ii) A large number of farmers are committing suicide in different states of India.
    (iii) Following an allegation of killing of three civilians in Gandwara in a fake encounter by Jammu and Kashmir police, an enquiry has been ordered.
Questions 5-7
  1. 1 markIn the context of democracies, which of the following ideas is correct: democracies have successfully eliminated:
    (a) conflicts among people   (b) economic inequalities among people   (c) differences of opinion about how marginalised sections are to be treated   (d) the idea of political inequality
  2. 1 markIn the context of assessing democracy, which among the following is the odd one out. Democracies need to ensure:
    (a) free and fair elections   (b) dignity of the individual   (c) majority rule   (d) equal treatment before law
  3. 1 markStudies on political and social inequalities in democracy show that:
    (a) democracy and development go together.   (b) inequalities exist in democracies.   (c) inequalities do not exist under dictatorship.   (d) dictatorship is better than democracy.
Question 8: Read the passage below
Nannu is a daily wage earner. He lives in Welcome Mazdoor Colony, a slum habitation in East Delhi. He lost his ration card and applied for a duplicate one in January 2004. He made several rounds to the local Food and Civil Supplies office for the next three months. But the clerks and officials would not even look at him, leave alone do his job or bother to tell him the status of his application. Ultimately, he filed an application under the Right to Information Act asking for the daily progress made on his application, names of the officials who were supposed to act on his application and what action would be taken against these officials for their inaction. Within a week of filing application under the Right to Information Act, he was visited by an inspector from the Food Department, who informed him that the card had been made and he could collect it from the office. When Nannu went to collect his card next day, he was given a very warm treatment by the Food and Supply Officer (FSO), who is the head of a Circle. The FSO offered him tea and requested him to withdraw his application under the Right to Information, since his work had already been done.
  1. 4 marksWhat does Nannu’s example show? What impact did Nannu’s action have on officials? Ask your parents their experiences when they approach government officials to attend to their problems.
Answer Key and Explanation
Descriptive Questions, 1-2
  1. Q1. Democracy produces an accountable, responsive and legitimate government in several ways. Whenever possible, citizens must be able to participate in decisions that affect them, so the most basic outcome should be a government that is accountable to citizens and responsive to their needs. Democratic decisions take longer because they follow deliberation and procedure, but the chapter says the cost of time is perhaps worth paying, because a decision reached through correct procedure may be both more acceptable to the people and more effective. Democracy is also expected to provide transparency: it ensures that decision making is based on norms and procedures, so a citizen has the right and the means to find out whether a decision followed the correct procedure, a factor often missing from non-democratic government. Measured by regular free and fair elections, open public debate and the right to information, democracies show a mixed record, doing well on regular elections and in setting up conditions for open debate, but falling short on giving everyone a fair chance, on subjecting every decision to public debate, and on sharing information: democratic governments do not have a very good record when it comes to sharing information with citizens. Even so, democratic government is certainly legitimate: it is people’s own government, which is why there is overwhelming worldwide support for the idea of democracy, in both democratic and non-democratic countries.
  2. Q2. Democracies usually develop a procedure to conduct their internal social and political competition, which reduces the chance of tensions between groups turning violent, as Belgium’s negotiation of its ethnic differences shows. But no society can fully and permanently resolve conflicts among its different groups; we can certainly learn to respect differences and evolve mechanisms to negotiate them, and democracy is best suited to produce this outcome. The Sri Lanka example shows two conditions a democracy must meet to accommodate social diversity: first, democracy must not simply mean rule by majority opinion, since the majority must always work with the minority and majority/minority positions are not permanent; second, rule by majority must never become the permanent rule of one religious, racial or linguistic community, since a person barred from ever joining the majority by birth finds democratic rule no longer accommodative for them.
Question 3: Arguments for and against each assertion
  1. (i) “Industrialised countries can afford democracy but the poor need dictatorship to become rich.” Oppose: the chapter’s own data shows that comparing poor countries alone, the growth-rate gap between democracy (4.28%) and dictatorship (4.34%) is negligible, so poor countries do not need to give up democracy to grow. Democracy also delivers other outcomes (legitimacy, dignity, accountability) that a growth-only argument for dictatorship ignores.
  2. (ii) “Democracy can’t reduce inequality of incomes between different citizens.” Support, with a qualification: the chapter agrees that in real life, democracies have not been very successful at reducing economic inequality (for example, the top 20% take over 60% of national income in South Africa and Brazil). But this is a record of limited success, not proof that democracy structurally cannot ever do so, since some democracies (Denmark, Hungary) show much lower inequality.
  3. (iii) “Government in poor countries should spend less on poverty reduction, health, education and spend more on industries and infrastructure.” Oppose: the chapter argues democracies, precisely because the poor are a large share of voters, should be expected to attend to poverty, health and education; it criticises democracies for not being as keen on these questions as one would expect, implying they should do more on this front, not less.
  4. (iv) “In democracy all citizens have one vote, which means that there is absence of any domination and conflict.” Oppose: the chapter is explicit that political equality (one vote each) exists alongside continuing and even growing economic inequality, and that no society can fully resolve conflicts among its different social groups. One vote each is political equality, not a guarantee against all domination or conflict.
Question 4: Challenge and mechanism
  1. (i) Temple entry case. Challenge: caste-based discrimination and denial of dignity and equal access to a public place of worship, even decades after untouchability was constitutionally abolished. Mechanism: continued judicial enforcement (as the High Court directive shows), and local-level awareness and monitoring so such practices do not silently persist without being challenged.
  2. (ii) Farmer suicides. Challenge: democratic government not being sufficiently attentive to the economic needs of a large section of citizens, despite farmers being a significant voting bloc, which the chapter names as a real shortcoming of democracies on the substantive side. Mechanism: stronger institutional support for agriculture (fair prices, credit access, crop insurance) and mechanisms for farmers’ own organisations to make their distress heard between elections, not only at election time.
  3. (iii) Gandwara fake-encounter case. Challenge: abuse of power by an arm of the state (the police) against citizens, and the risk that such abuse goes unaccounted for without independent scrutiny. Mechanism: the enquiry itself is the correct democratic mechanism, an example of accountability and transparency in action, since it uses due process to examine whether the correct procedure was followed; strengthening independent oversight bodies would make such enquiries more consistently available.
Objective Questions, 5-7
  1. Q5. (d) Democracies are based on political equality: all individuals have equal weight in electing representatives, so the idea of political inequality has been eliminated. They have NOT eliminated conflicts among people (a): the chapter says no society can fully and permanently resolve conflicts among different groups. They have NOT eliminated economic inequalities (b): Table 2 shows the top 20 per cent taking over 60 per cent of national income in South Africa and Brazil. And differences of opinion about how marginalised sections are to be treated (c) clearly continue.
  2. Q6. (c) The odd one out is majority rule: the chapter is explicit that democracy does NOT simply mean rule by majority opinion, and warns that unchecked majority rule (especially by a majority community) can make democracy stop being accommodative. Free and fair elections (a), dignity of the individual (b) and equal treatment before law (d) are all outcomes the chapter says democracies must genuinely ensure.
  3. Q7. (b) The chapter’s own evidence is that economic inequalities persist within democracies (Table 2’s income shares); it does not show democracy and development going together in a guaranteed way (a is wrong, since the growth-rate data is mixed), it does not show inequalities absent under dictatorship (c is wrong, since dictatorship data isn’t claimed to be more equal), and it explicitly refuses to conclude dictatorship is better than democracy (d is wrong) because of democracy’s other positive outcomes.
Question 8: Nannu’s case study
  1. Q8. Nannu’s example shows the real, practical value of transparency and the Right to Information Act as accountability tools in a democracy. For three months, ordinary requests to the Food and Civil Supplies office produced no response at all: officials would not even look at him. But the moment he formally exercised his legal right under the RTI Act, asking for the daily progress, the names of the responsible officials, and what action would be taken against them, the response changed within a week: an inspector from the Food Department told him his card had been made, and when he went to collect it, the Food and Supply Officer, the head of the Circle, gave him a very warm treatment, offered him tea and even requested him to withdraw his RTI application, although for three months the clerks and officials would not even look at him. This is exactly the outcome the chapter expects transparency to deliver: the citizen’s right and means to check whether correct procedure was being followed, and to name responsibility for delay, forced officials to act where ordinary requests had failed. It shows that in a democracy, citizens are not powerless before officialdom even when the everyday system is slow or unresponsive, because the law itself gives them a lever to demand accountability. Students should discuss this with their own parents and record their family’s own experience of approaching government officials, since the book invites a personal, non-fixed answer to that part of the question.

2In-text Questions

These questions are printed in boxes, captions and margins inside the chapter text. The book prints no answers; the model answers below follow the book’s order. Questions asked inside the running text (for example “Is the democratic government efficient?” or “Do democracies lead to peaceful and harmonious life among citizens?”) are answered by the chapter’s own paragraphs, which the notes cover.

In-text Questions
  1. Did we reach these conclusions in Madam Lyngdoh’s class? (margin question)
  2. Is democracy all about coping with multiple pressures and accommodating diverse demands? (cartoon caption)
  3. Can you think of what and how the government knows about you and your family (for example ration cards and voter identity cards)? What are the sources of information for you about the government?
  4. So, the best outcome of democracy is that it is a democracy! That is what we have discovered after all this mental gymnastics? (margin question)
  5. Cartoon on this page and next three pages tell us about the disparities between the rich and poor. Should the gains of economic growth be evenly distributed? How can the poor get a voice for a better share in a nation? What can the poor countries do to receive a greater share in the world’s wealth?
  6. What would be your verdict on democracy if you had to base it purely on economic performance of democratic regimes in terms of growth and equal distribution?
  7. Democracy is a rule of the majority. The poor are in majority. So democracy must be a rule of the poor. How can this not be the case? (margin question)
  8. All you are saying is that democracy ensures that people do not break each other’s head. This is not harmony. Should we be happy about it? (margin question)
  9. The two images depict two different kinds of effects democratic politics can have on social divisions. Take one example for each image and write a paragraph each on the outcome of democratic politics in both situations.
  10. The above cartoon and graph illustrate a point made in this section (Dignity and freedom of the citizens). Underline the sentences from this section which connect to the cartoon or graph.
Answer Key and Explanation
In-text Questions
  1. Students answer from their own memory of Chapter 2 of the Class IX textbook. The five conclusions recalled at the start of this chapter (democracy promotes equality among citizens, enhances the dignity of the individual, improves the quality of decision-making, provides a method to resolve conflicts and allows room to correct mistakes) emerged from that class’s conversation; as the margin remark puts it, students “were not being dictated any conclusions”.
  2. No. Coping with pressures and accommodating diverse demands is one outcome among several the chapter examines: accountable, responsive and legitimate government, economic growth and development, reduction of inequality and poverty, accommodation of social diversity, and the dignity and freedom of citizens.
  3. The government knows our names, ages, addresses and family members through voter identity cards, ration cards, Aadhaar, birth certificates, school admission records, the census, and tax and bank records. Our sources of information about the government are newspapers, television and radio, government websites and portals, official notices and gazettes, reports laid in Parliament and the legislatures, and applications under the Right to Information Act. This links to the chapter’s point that democratic governments do not have a very good record of sharing information with citizens.
  4. Read literally, the line is circular. The paragraphs that follow answer it: there is one respect in which democratic government is “certainly better than its alternatives”: it is legitimate government, people’s own government, and democracy’s ability to generate its own support “is itself an outcome that cannot be ignored”.
  5. Yes, the gains of growth should be shared so that every citizen can meet basic needs such as food, clothing, house, education and health; the chapter notes that in South Africa and Brazil the top 20 per cent take over 60 per cent of national income while the bottom 20 per cent get less than 3 per cent. The poor can get a voice by using their vote (they form a large proportion of voters), by organising in associations, unions and movements, by using the Right to Information, and by electing representatives who take up their demands. Poor countries can press for fairer trade rules, cooperate with one another in international forums, invest in education and health of their people, and reduce dependence on rich countries even for food supplies.
  6. On economic performance alone the verdict would be mixed: dictatorships had a slightly higher growth rate from 1950 to 2000 (4.42 against 3.95), though among poor countries the difference is negligible (4.34 against 4.28); and democracies have not been very successful in reducing economic inequality. So democracy is not a guarantee of economic development or equal distribution. But the chapter warns against judging democracy on economics alone: it can be expected not to lag behind dictatorships, and it has other outcomes, such as accountable and legitimate government, accommodation of social diversity and dignity of citizens, which make it preferable.
  7. Because political equality does not automatically become economic power. The chapter notes that the poor form a large proportion of voters, yet elected governments do not appear as keen to address poverty as one would expect, and a small number of ultra-rich people enjoy a highly disproportionate share of wealth and incomes. So the majority of the poor does not by itself produce rule by the poor.
  8. It is not full harmony, but it is a real achievement. The chapter says no society can fully and permanently resolve conflicts among different groups; what democracy does is develop a procedure to conduct competition, so tensions do not become explosive or violent, and help people learn to respect differences and negotiate them, as Belgium did. Non-democratic regimes often ignore or suppress such differences. So we should value this outcome, while working towards the two conditions (majority working with minority, and no permanent majority community) that make accommodation real.
  9. The book does not say which country each cartoon refers to, so any suitable example is acceptable. Greeting (positive effect): for example Belgium, which this chapter recalls as having successfully negotiated differences among its ethnic populations (NCERT Democratic Politics II Ch 1, Power Sharing, describes how its Dutch-speaking and French-speaking communities shared power). Enemies (negative effect): for example Sri Lanka, the case the chapter cites as a warning; the Power Sharing chapter describes how the majority Sinhala community imposed its preferences on the Tamil minority and distrust turned into widespread conflict. The two images show that democratic politics accommodates diversity only when the majority works with the minority and majority rule does not become the permanent rule of one community.
  10. Sentences that connect to them: “Democracy stands much superior to any other form of government in promoting dignity and freedom of the individual.” “The passion for respect and freedom are the basis of democracy.” “Most individuals today believe that their vote makes a difference to the way the government is run and to their own self-interest.” The graph shows that about 65 per cent of people in South Asia say their vote makes a difference, and the Rosa Parks cartoon recalls an ordinary citizen’s struggle for equal dignity.