All 12 “Questions and activities” from the NCERT textbook Understanding Society: India and Beyond, Part I, Chapter 9, “The Price Puzzle: What Drives the Market”, as printed in the book, with a full model answer for each. A few of the later items are field, survey or graph-drawing activities rather than written questions; a model approach and the ideas your own answer should cover are given for those too. Try your own answer first, then check it against this one. The in-text question boxes printed inside the chapter (Let’s Explore, Think About It and the others) are answered in the last section, in the order they appear in the book.
1 Questions and activities
Q. An increase in income always leads to a rise in demand for goods. Defend or refute, giving reasons for the same.
Answer: This statement should be refuted, at least as a blanket rule. It is true that, for most ordinary goods, a rise in income makes people more confident about spending, and demand for many goods does rise as a result, which is exactly why the chapter lists income of the consumer as a determinant of demand. However, “always” is too strong a claim. A rise in income does not automatically raise demand for every good: for goods a person buys mainly because they cannot afford anything better (economists elsewhere call these “inferior goods”), a rise in income can actually make a person switch to a costlier alternative instead, lowering demand for the cheaper good. Demand for a good can also stay unchanged if income rises but the person’s taste, needs or the season have not changed, since income is only one of several determinants working together, not the sole cause of every change in demand. So the correct position is: a rise in income generally raises demand for most goods, but not always and not for every good.
Q. If petrol prices double, what happens to: a. Demand for diesel cars b. Demand for electric cars c. Demand for car accessories d. Demand for public transport?
Answer: (a) Diesel cars: demand is likely to rise, since diesel and petrol cars are substitute goods for a car buyer, and diesel becomes the relatively cheaper running cost once petrol doubles. (b) Electric cars: demand is likely to rise as well, since electric cars do not use petrol and become an alternative once petrol running costs double. (c) Car accessories: demand is likely to fall. Cars and petrol are complementary goods (the chapter’s own example), and car accessories are complementary to cars. When petrol doubles, fewer people buy and use petrol cars, so demand for the accessories that go with them falls. (This assumes diesel prices do not rise too; the more buyers move to diesel or electric cars instead, the smaller the fall.) (d) Public transport: demand is likely to rise, since public transport is a substitute for using a personal petrol car, and it becomes relatively cheaper the moment petrol doubles in price.
Q. A farmer traditionally irrigates fields manually (labour-intensive). He installs drip irrigation (a technology upgrade) that reduces water use by 40 per cent and increases yield by 30 per cent. How does this affect: a. His cost of production b. His willingness to supply at different prices c. The overall market supply if many farmers adopt this technology?
Answer: (a) Cost of production: it falls, since drip irrigation uses 40 per cent less water and less manual labour than the old method, lowering the cost of producing each unit of the crop. (b) Willingness to supply at different prices: it rises at every price level, because a lower cost of production combined with a 30 per cent higher yield means the farmer can now profitably offer more of the crop even without any rise in its price; this shifts his individual supply schedule so that he offers a larger quantity at each price than before. (c) Overall market supply: if many farmers adopt the same drip-irrigation technology, the market supply of that crop rises overall, since market supply is the sum of every individual farmer’s supply, and each of their individual supplies has now increased.
Q. During online festival sales, the prices of many products are very low. Use the concept of demand and supply to explain why the sellers sell at such a low price. What happens to the equilibrium when the price is lowered? Does this benefit only consumers or sellers as well? Explain.
Answer: Sellers cut prices during festival sales because, according to the Law of Demand, a lower price raises the quantity demanded sharply, and sellers expect the resulting jump in the number of units sold to make up for the lower profit margin on each unit, alongside clearing out existing stock and attracting new customers. Equilibrium is the point where quantity demanded equals quantity supplied. When the sale price is set below it, quantity demanded rises above quantity supplied, which is excess demand (a shortage) at that price; the chapter notes that “at a lower price, there is excess demand”. The equilibrium itself moves only if supply or demand changes, for example when sellers add extra stock for the sale; then a new equilibrium at a lower price and a larger quantity can be reached. This benefits both sides, not just consumers: consumers clearly benefit by paying less for the same goods, but sellers benefit too, since selling a much larger volume of goods, even at a lower price per unit, can raise their total revenue, and it also lets them clear old stock and attract new, repeat customers, both of which help their business beyond the sale period itself.
Q. Suppose the government sets a maximum sale price for an essential vaccine below the market-driven price. What is likely to happen? Choose from the options below and elucidate your point. a. Surplus b. Shortage c. No effect d. Fall in demand.
Answer: The correct choice is (b) Shortage. A maximum sale price fixed below the market-driven price is a price ceiling. At this artificially lower price, the quantity of the vaccine that people want to buy (quantity demanded) stays high, or may even rise, since the vaccine is now cheaper, but the quantity manufacturers are willing to supply at this lower, less profitable price falls short of what they would have supplied at the higher market price. Because quantity demanded now exceeds quantity supplied at the capped price, the result is a shortage, the excess demand at a low price that the chapter shows in Table 9.3 (₹40: 38 kg demanded, only 6 kg supplied).
Q. The government levies higher taxes on products such as tobacco and alcohol to promote healthier choices among citizens. Can you find out other goods where price controls have been set in place? What are the reasons for the same?
Answer: (This is a find-out/research activity; a model answer using examples from this chapter and general awareness is given below.) Besides higher taxes on tobacco and alcohol, this chapter itself describes a price ceiling placed on essential medicines, so that life-saving drugs remain affordable to everyone regardless of what the free market might otherwise charge; the same logic applied during the COVID-19 pandemic: after a surge in demand led to stockouts and sharp price increases, and some shopkeepers began hoarding and black-marketing, the government declared sanitisers essential commodities under the Essential Commodities Act, 1955, capping the maximum retail price at ₹100 for 200 ml bottles. On the other side, the government also sets a price floor through the minimum wage, ensuring workers are not paid less than a basic amount for their labour. Note that tobacco and alcohol are controlled through higher taxes, which raise their price to discourage consumption; they are not price-capped. The price controls the chapter describes are the ceiling on essential medicines (and sanitisers) and the minimum wage as a price floor. The reason is the chapter’s own explanation of why government intervenes: to correct a market outcome that would otherwise be unfair, whether that means keeping essentials affordable (medicines, sanitisers) or making sure workers earn enough for their work (minimum wage).
Q. Can excessive government regulation hurt markets? Explain with suitable examples.
Answer: Yes, excessive government regulation can hurt markets, even when each individual rule is well-intentioned. This chapter names three specific ways this happens. First, price distortions and reduced producer incentives: if the government fixes the maximum price of wheat at ₹20 per kg while the free market would have paid ₹30 per kg, farmers receive less than they would in a free market, and this may lead to reduced production and shortages. Second, compliance burdens: too many licences, permits and regulations can be a heavy load for small businesses; a small restaurant, for example, may need separate clearances for food safety, fire safety and pollution control and local clearances; the time and cost involved can discourage small entrepreneurs from starting or expanding businesses, hampering a country’s “ease of doing business”. Third, discouraged innovation and entrepreneurship: if farmers cannot earn adequate returns because of price controls, they won’t invest in better seeds, irrigation or technology, which reduces long-term productivity and output. So while some regulation is genuinely necessary wherever markets alone would be unfair, the chapter is clear that overdoing it can create new problems of its own.
Q. In the table below, different prices of guava are given. a. Think and write how much guava you will buy at each price. b. Ask the same question to three of your friends and fill in the table. c. Also make a graph for each one of you and one final graph for the total quantity. (Prices given: ₹100/kg, ₹80/kg, ₹50/kg, ₹20/kg.)
Answer: (This is a personal survey and graph-drawing activity; there is no single fixed answer, since it depends on your own and your friends’ real preferences.) To complete it: (a) for each of the four prices, honestly write down the quantity of guava (in kg) you would personally buy, keeping in mind that your quantity should generally rise as the price falls from ₹100 to ₹20, following the Law of Demand. (b) Ask three friends the same question at the same four prices and record their answers in the same table, then add a “Total” column that sums your quantity and your three friends’ quantities at each price. (c) Draw one demand-schedule graph for each of the four individuals (price on the Y-axis, quantity on the X-axis), and a fifth graph plotting the “Total” column against price; this final graph is the market demand curve for guava among your small group, and, just like the mango example in the chapter, it should be flatter than any single person’s own demand curve, since it adds together everyone’s individual responses to the same price change.
Q. Visit the nearby vegetable market and try to find answers to the following questions. a. Who decides the prices of different vegetables in the vegetable market? b. Sometimes the prices of a few vegetables is too high, and sometimes too low. Why is this? c. The price of tomatoes is high in the morning and eventually gets lower by the evening. Have you ever noticed this? Comment.
Answer: (This is a field activity; the model approach below applies the chapter’s own concepts to what you are likely to find and hear at a real vegetable market.) (a) Prices in a vegetable market are not fixed by any single person; they emerge from the interaction of demand (how much buyers want and can pay) and supply (how much sellers have brought to sell that day), with individual vendors adjusting their asking price based on how quickly their stock is selling and what nearby sellers are charging. (b) A vegetable’s price runs unusually high when supply is short relative to demand, for example after a poor harvest, bad weather, or transport delays, and unusually low when supply is unusually large relative to demand, for example during a bumper harvest or when a vegetable is in peak season and every farmer brings a large stock to market at once. (c) Yes, you may notice this; the chapter itself opens by asking why vegetables are expensive in the morning but cheaper in the evening. Use the chapter’s rule: when supply is less than demand, prices rise; when supply exceeds demand, prices fall. In the morning many buyers come looking for fresh tomatoes, so demand is high. By evening fewer buyers are left, and vendors still holding tomatoes that may spoil overnight have more stock than buyers want, so they lower prices to clear it. To comment on your own market, record the morning and evening prices, how much stock vendors have left and how many buyers there are, and explain the change using those facts.
Q. Categorise the following combination of goods into substitute goods and complementary goods. a. Movie ticket in the cinema hall and popcorn b. Eraser and pencil c. Laptop and computer d. Air Conditioner and cooler e. Notebook and pen f. Apple and banana g. Mobile and earphones.
Answer: Complementary goods (used together): (a) movie ticket and popcorn, (b) eraser and pencil, (e) notebook and pen, (g) mobile and earphones. Substitute goods (can replace each other): (d) Air Conditioner and cooler (both cool a room, so a buyer may choose one instead of the other), (f) apple and banana (both are fruit choices that can replace each other). (c) Laptop and computer: substitute goods, since a laptop is a type of computer and one can replace the other for most tasks (a buyer usually chooses one or the other).
Q. Fig. 9.8 shows the demand curve DD’ and Supply curve SS’. Based on the figure, answer the following questions: a. What does point E represent in this market? b. What is the equilibrium price and equilibrium quantity at point E? c. Point A lies on DD’. Point B lies on SS’. What do the points A and B indicate about demand and supply? What does the gap between A and B (both on the upper dashed price line) represent? d. Point F lies on DD’. Point C lies on SS’. What do the points F and C indicate about demand and supply? What does the gap between C and F (both on the lower dashed price line) represent? e. If the price stays at the lower dashed line, what could happen next in a free market?
Answer: (a) Point E is the point where the demand curve DD’ and the supply curve SS’ intersect, so it represents the market equilibrium, the one point where quantity demanded exactly equals quantity supplied. (b) Reading the figure, point E lies directly above the 30 kg mark on the quantity axis, at a price roughly midway between the ₹200 and ₹300 lines, so the equilibrium price is about ₹250 and the equilibrium quantity is 30 kg. (c) The upper dashed line is drawn at the ₹300 price level. Point A, where this line meets DD’, shows the (smaller) quantity demanded at ₹300, roughly 23 kg; point B, where it meets SS’, shows the (larger) quantity supplied at ₹300, roughly 37 kg. Since B lies to the right of A, quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded at this price, and the gap between A and B represents excess supply, or a surplus, of roughly 14 kg. (d) The lower dashed line is drawn at a price below ₹200, roughly ₹150-160. Point C, where this line meets SS’, shows the (smaller) quantity supplied at that price, roughly 17 kg; point F, where it meets DD’, shows the (larger) quantity demanded at that same price, roughly 43 kg. Since F lies to the right of C, quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied at this price, and the gap between C and F represents excess demand, or a shortage, of roughly 26 kg. (e) If the price stays at the lower dashed line, this shortage persists: more buyers want the good than sellers are willing to supply at that price, so in a free market, competition among buyers for the limited quantity available would push the price back up, moving the market back toward the equilibrium price at point E.
Q. Draw a market equilibrium graph using the following demand schedule. (Price (₹): 10, 20, 30, 40, 50; Q.D. (kg): 5, 10, 15, 20, 25; Q.S. (kg): 25, 20, 15, 10, 5.) a. Plot the demand and supply curve using the above data. b. Identify the equilibrium price and quantity. c. Observe the above data and analyse what happens if the price is set at ₹20 or ₹40.
Answer: (a) Plot price (₹) on the Y-axis and quantity (kg) on the X-axis. Mark the Q.D. points from the table, (5 kg, ₹10), (10 kg, ₹20), (15 kg, ₹30), (20 kg, ₹40) and (25 kg, ₹50), and join them as the demand line; mark the Q.S. points, (25 kg, ₹10), (20 kg, ₹20), (15 kg, ₹30), (10 kg, ₹40) and (5 kg, ₹50), and join them as the supply line. The two lines cross at 15 kg and ₹30; label this point E. (b) The equilibrium price is ₹30 and the equilibrium quantity is 15 kg: ₹30 is the only price at which Q.D. equals Q.S. (15 kg each). (c) At ₹20, Q.D. is 10 kg and Q.S. is 20 kg. Quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded, so there is a surplus (excess supply) of 10 kg. At ₹40, Q.D. is 20 kg and Q.S. is 10 kg. Quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied, so there is a shortage (excess demand) of 10 kg. At both prices the market is 10 kg away from balance; only ₹30 clears it.
2 In-text questions: The Big Questions, Think About It, Let’s Explore and other boxes
Besides the end-of-chapter questions, the chapter prints question boxes inside the text: “Think About It”, “Let’s Explore”, “Let’s Analyse” and “Let’s Recall”. Every one of them is answered below, in the order it appears in the book. The chapter’s opening “The Big Questions” box is answered first.
Q. 1. What are the factors that influence the demand for and supply of goods and services in a market? 2. How are prices of goods and services determined through demand and supply interactions? 3. What is market equilibrium, and does it exist in the real world? 4. How and why does the government intervene in the market?
Answer:
- Demand depends on the price of the good (the law of demand: as price rises, quantity demanded falls), the prices of related goods (substitutes and complements), the consumer’s income, tastes and preferences, seasonality and expectations about future prices. Supply depends on the price of the good (the law of supply: as price rises, quantity supplied rises), the prices of related goods the seller could produce instead, the number of sellers, technology, the cost of inputs, and future expectations.
- Prices are set by the interaction of buyers and sellers. If the price is too low, demand exceeds supply (a shortage), so the price is pushed up; if it is too high, supply exceeds demand (a surplus), so the price falls. The price settles where the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied.
- Market equilibrium is the point where demand equals supply, so there is neither a shortage nor a surplus (in Table 9.3, ₹100 per kg and 12 kg of mangoes). In the real world, equilibrium is never fixed: technology, wages, wars, pandemics, weather and disasters keep shifting demand and supply, so markets are always adjusting to a new equilibrium, as the price of face masks rose and then fell during and after COVID-19.
- The government intervenes to protect consumers and producers and to provide what markets do not: it sets price ceilings (maximum prices, as for essential medicines) and price floors (such as the minimum wage); it regulates monopolies by keeping prices and quantity supplied in check; it used the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 to cap sanitiser prices when hoarding and black-marketing appeared during COVID-19; and regulators such as the RBI, SEBI, TRAI and the Central Consumer Protection Authority ensure transparency in the market; and it provides public goods such as roads, parks and streetlights. Intervention must be careful, because too much of it can distort prices and reduce producers’ incentives.
Q. What happens when you consume the first mango? It tastes delicious, right? The second one is good? The third one and so on? You are barely interested in eating mangoes by this point. Why do you think this happens?
Answer: Because of the diminishing marginal utility principle. The extra satisfaction (utility) from each additional mango falls as we eat more: the first mango satisfies our hunger and craving most, the second gives less extra satisfaction, and by the third or fourth we are full and get very little extra pleasure. Since the utility of each further mango falls, our willingness to pay for more mangoes also falls, so the quantity we demand at a given price falls.
Q. (1) Create your own demand schedule for buying notebooks at different prices. At what price would you buy the most? At what price would you stop buying altogether? What could be the reason behind your choices? (2) Ask your family members if they postponed or advanced buying any product because of future expectations of changes in price?
Answer (1): A sample demand schedule for one term:
| Price per notebook (₹) | Notebooks I would buy |
|---|---|
| 20 | 10 |
| 30 | 8 |
| 40 | 6 |
| 60 | 3 |
| 80 | 0 |
I would buy the most (10) at the lowest price, ₹20, and stop buying at ₹80. Reasons: my budget is limited, so at a higher price I can afford fewer; at ₹80 I would switch to cheaper substitutes, such as loose sheets or using both sides of old notebooks; and I need only a certain number anyway. This follows the law of demand: as price rises, quantity demanded falls.
Answer (2): Sample responses: my parents bought gold jewellery before a wedding season because they expected its price to rise further; an uncle postponed buying a new phone until the festive sale, expecting the price to fall; families stock up on onions or cooking oil when they hear that prices are going to rise. This shows that expectations about future prices change demand today.
Q. What happens to the supply of a product in case of a change in the cost of inputs, discovery of an alternate input, depletion of resources, change in weather, disaster, etc.? Discuss in class using examples of diverse goods and services.
Answer:
| Change | Effect on supply | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of inputs rises | Supply falls (less is offered at each price) | When diesel or fertiliser prices rise, farmers and transporters supply less at the old price; bus and taxi services raise fares. |
| Cost of inputs falls, or an alternate cheaper input is found | Supply rises | Cheaper solar panels have increased the supply of electricity from solar power; LED bulbs became cheaper to make and their supply grew. |
| Depletion of resources | Supply falls | Overfishing reduces the catch of some fish; falling groundwater reduces the supply of crops that need a lot of water. |
| Change in weather | Good weather raises supply; bad weather lowers it | Unseasonal rain or a heatwave damages tomatoes and onions, so their supply falls and prices shoot up; a good monsoon brings a bumper harvest. |
| Disaster | Supply falls suddenly | A flood or cyclone cuts roads and damages crops and factories; during COVID-19, lockdowns disrupted the supply of many goods. |
Q. Using data from Table 9.3, plot the demand and supply curve at the three prices, i.e., ₹40, ₹100, and ₹150. Identify and mark excess demand and supply on the graph. Think about how equilibrium could be reached in these scenarios.
Answer: Take quantity of mangoes (kg) on the X-axis and price (₹) on the Y-axis, and plot:
| Price (₹) | Demand point (Qd) | Supply point (Qs) | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 | (38 kg, ₹40) | (6 kg, ₹40) | Excess demand = 38 − 6 = 32 kg |
| 100 | (12 kg, ₹100) | (12 kg, ₹100) | Equilibrium |
| 150 | (8 kg, ₹150) | (43 kg, ₹150) | Excess supply = 43 − 8 = 35 kg |
Join the three demand points to get a downward-sloping demand curve, and the three supply points to get an upward-sloping supply curve. They cross at ₹100 and 12 kg, the equilibrium point E. Mark the horizontal gap between the curves at ₹40 as excess demand (shortage) of 32 kg, and the gap at ₹150 as excess supply (surplus) of 35 kg.
Reaching equilibrium: at ₹40 buyers want far more than sellers offer, so buyers compete and the price is pushed up; as it rises, quantity demanded falls and quantity supplied rises until they meet at ₹100. At ₹150 sellers cannot sell all their mangoes, so they cut the price; as it falls, quantity demanded rises and quantity supplied falls until they meet at ₹100.
Q. Can you think of another real-life example (other than hotels) where prices change frequently? Explain why the prices keep changing. Our choices today affect future resources. For example, high demand for fast fashion, overfishing and overuse of groundwater can harm future supply. So, should we focus only on short-term gains, or also think about long-term sustainability? How could this affect the market equilibrium?
Answer: Examples: air tickets cost more as the travel date comes closer or during holidays, because many people want to fly then and seats are limited; app-based cab fares rise (“surge”) when it rains or at office hours, because demand jumps while the number of drivers is limited; vegetable prices in the mandi change daily with how much produce arrives and how many buyers come. In each case prices keep changing because demand and supply keep changing.
Sustainability: we should also think about the long term. If we overuse a resource today, its future supply falls; the supply curve then shifts to the left, the equilibrium price rises, and less of the good is available to future buyers, as when fish stocks or groundwater run low. Sensible use today, such as buying fewer fast-fashion clothes, fishing within limits and saving water, keeps future supply steady, so prices stay stable and the resource lasts.
Q. Have you ever seen or heard of the government fixing prices or wages (for example, bus fares, medicines, or minimum wages)? Share an example and why you think it was done.
Answer: Examples:
- Ceiling prices of essential medicines: the government fixes the maximum price of essential medicines, and in 2017 it capped the price of heart stents, so that patients are not overcharged for life-saving treatment.
- Minimum Support Price (MSP): the government announces a minimum price for crops such as wheat and paddy, so that farmers get a fair price even when market prices fall.
- Minimum wages: fixed so that workers are not paid too little to live on.
- Bus fares and electricity tariffs: fixed by the State government or a regulator, so that essential services stay affordable for everyone.
Such controls are used to protect consumers, workers or producers when the market price would be unfair, especially for essential goods and services. (The chapter itself names medicines and minimum wages; the stent, MSP and fare examples are general knowledge, not from the chapter.)
Q. From your surroundings, list two goods or services that are provided by the government (for example: roads, streetlights, parks, police, and so on.). Choose one of the goods you listed and answer: Who does benefit from it? Why would it be difficult for a private company to provide this service on its own? Imagine the government stops providing this good or service, what problems might people in your area face?
Answer: Two goods/services: streetlights and a public park. Taking streetlights:
- Who benefits: everyone who uses the street at night: walkers, cyclists, drivers, shopkeepers and residents.
- Why a private company would find it difficult: it cannot charge each person who walks under a light, and it cannot stop those who do not pay from using the light. So it earns no direct profit, and many people would think “others will pay, I can use it free”, as in the chapter’s park example. That is why such public goods are provided by the government from taxes.
- If the government stopped: dark streets would mean more accidents, more theft and crime, and women, children and the elderly would feel unsafe going out after dark; shops would close early and the local economy would suffer.
Q. In the chapter ‘Democracy’, you have read that a democratic government is accountable to the people and is expected to act in their interest. According to you, how should a democratic government decide when and how much it should intervene in markets to protect people’s welfare? Whose voices should a democratic government consider while making such decisions: consumers, producers, workers, or others? Why?
Answer: When and how much: the government should intervene when the market clearly fails people: when essential goods (medicines, food grains) become unaffordable, when there is hoarding, black marketing or adulteration, when workers are exploited, or when public goods are not provided. It should intervene only as much as needed, for a clear purpose, based on reliable data and expert advice, and review its decision regularly, because excessive control can cause shortages, black markets and lower production.
Whose voices: all of them: consumers (who pay the prices), producers and farmers (who need fair returns to keep producing), workers (whose wages and jobs are affected), and also the poor and marginalised, experts and future generations (for resources such as water). In a democracy the government represents everyone, so it must balance these interests through consultation, debate in the legislature and public feedback, instead of serving only one group.