Exam-useful questions from this chapter, grouped by marks, each with a full model answer. Try writing the answer yourself first, then check it against this one.
1 1-Mark Questions
Q. Who is the poet of “A Photograph”?
Answer: Shirley Toulson.
Q. What does “the cardboard” stand for in the poem?
Answer: It stands for the old photograph, which is mounted on card.
Q. Who took the photograph?
Answer: “the uncle with the camera” (the poem does not say which relation he is to the girls).
Q. How old was the poet’s mother in the photograph?
Answer: About twelve: “some twelve years or so”.
Q. What were the two girl cousins doing in the photograph?
Answer: They were paddling in the shallow water at the edge of the sea.
Q. Name the two cousins who appear in the photograph with the mother.
Answer: Betty and Dolly.
Q. What does “this circumstance” refer to?
Answer: The mother’s death.
Q. How many stanzas does the poem have, and how many lines are in each?
Answer: Three stanzas, of 9, 6 and 4 lines.
2 2-Mark Questions
Q. What has the camera captured?
Answer: The camera has captured a moment from the mother’s childhood: the mother, about twelve, paddling at the beach with her two cousins, Betty and Dolly, each holding one of her hands, all three standing still to smile “through their hair” at “the uncle with the camera”.
Q. What has not changed over the years? What does this suggest?
Answer: The sea has not changed, or rather it “appears to have changed less”. This suggests that nature lasts while human life is short; the girls in the photo grew up and, in the mother’s case, died.
Q. Why does the poet call the girls’ feet “terribly transient”?
Answer: Transient means lasting a short time. The sea, which “appears to have changed less”, is set beside the girls’ feet, so the contrast shows how brief human life is. “Terribly” shows how painful this brevity feels to the poet.
Q. What does the line “Some twenty — thirty — years later” show?
Answer: It marks the move from the photo to a later time, when the grown-up mother laughs at it. The dashes between “twenty” and “thirty” slow the line and can suggest a hesitant count back; either way, the phrase stresses how much time has passed.
Q. Explain: “The sea holiday / Was her past, mine is her laughter.”
Answer: The sea holiday was a memory for the mother, which she laughed at years later. Now the mother’s laughter is a memory for the poet. The same photograph holds two layers of memory, one for each of them.
Q. What does the line “Its silence silences” mean?
Answer: The mother’s death has left a silence that nothing can fill. That silence makes the poet silent too: her grief is too deep to put into words.
Q. Why does the poet say her mother’s “sweet face” in the photo was from “before I was born”?
Answer: The photo shows her mother at about twelve, years before the poet was born. The poet knows this young, sweet face only through the photograph, never in real life.
Q. Identify the poetic device in “the laboured ease of loss” and explain it.
Answer: “laboured ease” is an oxymoron: “laboured” means done with effort and “ease” means without effort. It shows that the calm with which the loss is remembered only looks easy; it takes effort and hides pain.
3 3-Mark Questions
Q. What is the meaning of the line “Both wry / With the laboured ease of loss”?
Answer: “Both” means the mother’s memory of the sea holiday and the poet’s memory of her mother’s laughter. Each is “wry”: amused, but mixed with sadness. The poem does not say what each has lost; one reading is that the mother laughed at a childhood that was gone, and the poet smiles at the memory of a mother who is gone. In both cases the ease is “laboured”: the calm takes effort, because of loss.
Q. The three stanzas depict three different phases. What are they?
Answer: Stanza 1: the mother’s childhood, caught in the photograph, when she was about twelve and paddling with her cousins. Stanza 2: the mother as a grown woman, twenty or thirty years later, laughing at the photo, a laugh the poet now remembers. Stanza 3: the present, when the mother has been dead nearly as many years as that girl lived (roughly twelve) and the poet is left with silence.
Q. What is the significance of the sea in the poem?
Answer: The sea is the one thing in the photo that “appears to have changed less”. It stands for the permanence of nature. Set beside the girls’ “terribly transient feet”, it shows how short human life is: the people have grown up and, in the mother’s case, died while the sea goes on.
Q. What does the word “cardboard” denote in the poem? Why has this word been used?
Answer: “Cardboard” denotes the photograph, which is mounted on card. Using the word for the material rather than saying “photograph” stresses that the photo is old, and that the card is the only picture of the young mother.
Q. How does the poem use contrast to bring out its theme?
Answer: The poem sets the lasting sea against the girls’ “terribly transient feet”. It also sets the mother’s easy laughter against the “laboured ease of loss”, and the talk of stanza 2 against the silence of stanza 3. These contrasts show how time changes everything human.
Q. What did the mother’s laugh at the snapshot indicate?
Answer: Her laugh showed amusement at how she and her cousins had been dressed for the beach. The poet calls it “wry”, so it also carried a touch of sadness. One reading is that it showed nostalgia: she was fondly remembering a childhood that was gone.
Q. Comment on the title “A Photograph”.
Answer: The title is apt because the whole poem grows out of one old photograph. The photo records the mother’s childhood, makes the mother laugh years later, and now reminds the poet of her mother’s death. It is one of the things that outlast the people in it, along with the sea.
4 5-Mark Questions
Q. “A Photograph” is a poem about the passage of time and the transience of human life. Discuss.
Answer: The poem moves through three times, one in each stanza. In stanza 1 the mother, about twelve, paddles at the beach with her cousins Betty and Dolly while an uncle photographs them. The sea “appears to have changed less”, but the girls have “terribly transient feet”: nature lasts, human life passes.
In stanza 2, “Some twenty — thirty — years later”, the grown-up mother laughs at the snapshot and the clothes they wore. The holiday was her past, and her laughter is now the poet’s memory (“mine is her laughter”). Both memories are “wry / With the laboured ease of loss”.
In stanza 3 the mother has been dead nearly as many years as that girl lived. There is “nothing to say at all”, and “Its silence silences.”
The stanzas shrink from nine lines to four as the mother passes from life into memory. The photograph and the sea remain, and so does the poet’s memory of her mother’s laughter.
Q. Trace how the poet’s feelings change across the three stanzas of the poem.
Answer: In stanza 1 the poet looks at the photo with tender interest. She sees her mother’s “sweet face” from “before I was born” and notices, with a hint of sadness, how “transient” the girls’ lives are beside the unchanging sea.
In stanza 2 her feeling is warm, fond nostalgia. She remembers her mother laughing at the snapshot and naming Betty and Dolly, and realises that the holiday was her mother’s past while the laughter is hers. Both memories are “wry”, amused but sad.
In stanza 3 the feeling becomes grief. Her mother has been dead nearly as many years as that girl lived. The poet finds there is “nothing to say at all”, and the poem ends in silence: “Its silence silences.”
So the poem moves from gentle curiosity, through nostalgia, to a loss too deep for words.
Q. The book places “A Photograph” after “The Portrait of a Lady” because of the thematic relation between the two. Bring out this relation.
Answer: Both texts look at an older family member across time and end in loss.
In “The Portrait of a Lady”, the narrator cannot imagine his grandmother ever being young; the grandfather is known only through a portrait above the mantelpiece. In “A Photograph”, the poet sees her mother young only in a photo, a “sweet face” from “before I was born”.
Both show time changing a relationship: the narrator and his grandmother grow apart over the years, while the poet’s memory moves from her mother’s childhood, to her mother laughing at the snapshot, to the present.
Both end with a death, the grandmother’s and the mother’s, and with a silence: the sparrows sit silently in the prose, and “Its silence silences” in the poem.
Together they show that time takes away the people we love and leaves us pictures and memories.
Q. How does one photograph connect the mother’s past with the poet’s present in the poem?
Answer: The photograph is the thread that runs through all three stanzas.
First, it holds the mother’s past: “The cardboard shows me how it was”, the mother at about twelve, paddling with Betty and Dolly, smiling at the uncle with the camera.
Second, it becomes part of a later memory. Twenty or thirty years on, the mother laughs at it and the clothes they wore. “The sea holiday / Was her past, mine is her laughter”: the photo now carries the poet’s own memory too.
Third, in the present, the same photo reminds the poet that her mother has been dead nearly as many years as that girl lived. It brings back a loss about which there is “nothing to say at all”.
So a piece of card links three times, and shows that while people are transient, the photograph, like the sea, remains.
Q. Photographs help us hold on to people and moments that time takes away. Taking “A Photograph” as your starting point, write about the value of photographs and memories in our lives.
Answer: In “A Photograph”, an old picture keeps the poet’s mother young for ever: a girl of about twelve, paddling and smiling at the uncle with the camera. Long after that day, the photo still makes the mother laugh, and after her death it still lets the poet see her.
Photographs do this for all of us. They hold faces and moments that time changes or takes away: grandparents when they were young, a family holiday, a friend who has moved away. Looking at them, we remember not only the event but the people who shared it with us.
Memories also help us bear loss. The poet cannot speak about her mother’s death, yet the photo and the memory of her mother’s laughter keep a link with her.
At the same time, the poem shows the limits of a photograph: it can show “how it was”, but it cannot bring the person back. So we should value our people while they are with us, and treasure the pictures and memories they leave.
5 Case Studies
When the two girl cousins went paddling,
Each one holding one of my mother’s hands,
And she the big girl — some twelve years or so.
All three stood still to smile through their hair
At the uncle with the camera. A sweet face,
My mother’s, that was before I was born.
And the sea, which appears to have changed less,
Washed their terribly transient feet.
(A) 1 mark Who are the three people in the photograph?
Answer: The poet’s mother and her two girl cousins.
(B) 1 mark Identify the poetic device in “terribly transient feet”.
Answer: Transferred epithet: “transient” really describes the girls’ lives, not their feet (there is also alliteration in “terribly transient”).
(C) 2 marks Explain “the sea, which appears to have changed less, / Washed their terribly transient feet.”
Answer: The sea appears to have changed less since the photo was taken, but the girls have grown up and, in the mother’s case, died. Their “transient” feet show how brief human life is compared with lasting nature.
She’d laugh at the snapshot. “See Betty
And Dolly,” she’d say, “and look how they
Dressed us for the beach.” The sea holiday
Was her past, mine is her laughter. Both wry
With the laboured ease of loss.
(A) 1 mark When did the mother laugh at the snapshot?
Answer: Some twenty or thirty years after it was taken.
(B) 1 mark Name the poetic device in “laboured ease”.
Answer: Oxymoron: “laboured” (effortful) and “ease” (effortless) are opposites placed together.
(C) 2 marks Explain “Both wry / With the laboured ease of loss.”
Answer: The mother’s memory of the holiday and the poet’s memory of her laughter are both amused but sad. Each looks back calmly at something lost, and that calm is “laboured”: forced, hiding pain.
As that girl lived. And of this circumstance
There is nothing to say at all.
Its silence silences.
(A) 1 mark Who does “that girl” refer to?
Answer: The poet’s mother as a girl of about twelve, in the photograph.
(B) 1 mark Name one poetic device in “Its silence silences.”
Answer: Personification (silence silences the poet); it also has alliteration.
(C) 2 marks Why does the poet feel there is “nothing to say at all” about “this circumstance”?
Answer: “This circumstance” is her mother’s death. The photo once gave her mother something to laugh and talk about, but death leaves only a silence that no words can fill.