Class 11 English Book 1 Chapter 15 The Voice of the Rain NCERT Solutions in English

Complete solutions to every exercise printed with NCERT Hornbill’s poem “The Voice of the Rain” by Walt Whitman (page 34, “Think it out”, sections I, II and III), with each question exactly as the book prints it and a full model answer under it. Write your own answer first, then compare.

1 Think it out: Section I

Question I.1

Q. There are two voices in the poem. Who do they belong to? Which lines indicate this?

Answer: The two voices belong to the poet and the rain.

  • The poet speaks in the first two lines. The words “said I” show this: “And who art thou? said I to the soft-falling shower, / Which, strange to tell, gave me an answer, as here translated:”
  • The rain speaks from the third line onwards. The words “said the voice of the rain” show this: “I am the Poem of Earth, said the voice of the rain,”. No new speech tag follows, and the lines after it are in the rain’s first person: “Eternal I rise”, “I descend”, “I give back life to my own origin”.
Question I.2

Q. What does the phrase “strange to tell” mean?

Answer: “Strange to tell” means “surprising to say”, or “it may sound strange, but it is true”. The poet uses it because the rain gave him an answer. Rain does not normally speak, so the poet admits that what he is reporting is wonderful and hard to believe.

Question I.3

Q. There is a parallel drawn between rain and music. Which words indicate this? Explain the similarity between the two.

Answer: The poem makes the comparison with a song in the bracketed last two lines: “song”, “issuing from its birth-place”, “after fulfilment”, “wandering”, “Reck’d or unreck’d” and “duly with love returns”. “Poem of Earth” (line 3) is a related idea, not a word about music.

The similarity: Both move in a cycle, going out from where they began and coming back to it.

  • Rain rises from the land and the sea (its origin), takes shape in the sky as clouds (“vaguely form’d”), falls to wash the earth and bring seeds to life, and so gives life back to its own origin.
  • A song comes out of its birth-place (one reading: the heart of the poet or singer), wanders, reaches its “fulfilment”, and whether it is noticed or not (“Reck’d or unreck’d”) it returns with love to where it began.

One reading is that rain is the music, the poetry, of the earth: like a song it comes from a source, serves others and returns to that source.

Question I.4

Q. How is the cyclic movement of rain brought out in the poem? Compare it with what you have learnt in science.

Answer: The rain describes its own journey as a circle that never ends.

The poem’s words What happens Science stage
“Eternal I rise impalpable out of the land and the bottomless sea, / Upward to heaven” Water rises from land and sea as vapour that cannot be touched Evaporation
“whence, vaguely form’d, altogether changed, and yet the same” In the sky it takes a vague shape (clouds), changed in form but still water Condensation
“I descend to lave the droughts, atomies, dust-layers of the globe” It falls as rain and washes the dry, dusty earth Precipitation
“I give back life to my own origin, / And make pure and beautify it” The water returns to the land and sea it came from, bringing seeds to life Collection, and the cycle begins again

The words “Eternal” and “forever, by day and night” show that the cycle never stops. This matches the water cycle we study in science: evaporation, condensation, precipitation and collection. The poem describes the same scientific process in poetic language, and adds a feeling of love and purpose: the rain repays the earth that gave it birth.

Question I.5

Q. Why are the last two lines put within brackets?

Answer: The poem does not say why, so this is one reading. Up to line 9 the rain describes its own journey. The bracketed lines do not add another stage to that journey; they compare it with a song, which also issues from its birth-place, wanders, reaches “fulfilment”, and “duly with love returns”, whether noticed (“Reck’d”) or not. The brackets can be read as setting this comparison apart, like an aside, from the rain’s own account of its journey. In this way the poem links the cycle of nature with the journey of a song.

Question I.6

Q. List the pairs of opposites found in the poem.

Answer:

  • rise / descend: “Eternal I rise” (line 4) and “I descend” (line 6)
  • heaven / earth: “Upward to heaven” (line 5) and “Poem of Earth” (line 3), “the globe” (line 6)
  • day / night: “by day and night” (line 8)
  • Reck’d / unreck’d: “Reck’d or unreck’d” (line 11), meaning heeded or unheeded
  • altogether changed / yet the same: “altogether changed, and yet the same” (line 5)

These opposites show the two-way, circular movement of the rain: up and down, sky and earth, all the time.

2 Think it out: Section II (Sentence Patterns)

Question II

Q. Notice the following sentence patterns.
1. And who art thou? said I to the soft-falling shower.
2. I am the Poem of Earth, said the voice of the rain.
3. Eternal I rise
4. For song … duly with love returns
Rewrite the above sentences in prose.

Answer: In each sentence the poet has used inversion (unusual word order) or old forms (“art thou”). In prose the normal order is restored:

  1. I asked the soft-falling shower who it was.
  2. The voice of the rain said that it was the Poem of Earth.
  3. I rise eternally. (I rise forever.)
  4. A song, which comes out of its birthplace and wanders, duly returns with love after it has fulfilled its purpose, whether it is heeded or not.

3 Think it out: Section III

Question III

Q. Look for some more poems on the rain and see how this one is different from them.

Answer (model): The book names no other rain poems; this is an activity. Rain poems can be read and compared on three points: who speaks, what is described, and what the rain means. On these points, “The Voice of the Rain” stands out in three ways:

  • The rain itself speaks. The poem is a dialogue, and the rain describes itself in the first person: “I am the Poem of Earth”.
  • It describes the whole cycle of water, rising, taking shape as clouds, falling and giving back life to its origin, in a way that matches science.
  • It gives the rain a deeper meaning. The rain gives life and returns to its origin, and the bracketed lines compare this with a song that “duly with love returns”. One reading is that it is a poem about nature and about poetry at the same time.

(This is an activity: read two or three rain poems from your library or textbook, and compare them on these three points: who speaks, what is described, and what the rain means.)

Exam Tip

The book’s glossary gives these meanings: impalpable: something that cannot be touched; lave: wash; bathe; atomies: tiny particles; latent: hidden. Write them in exactly these words.