Exam-useful questions from this chapter, grouped by marks, each with a full model answer. Try writing the answer yourself first, then check it against this one.
This chapter is in the NCERT book but is not in the CBSE 2026-27 English Core syllabus, so it is not assessed in the CBSE board paper this year. Study it for other boards that use the NCERT book, or for practice.
1 1-Mark Questions
Q. Who wrote ‘The Ailing Planet: the Green Movement’s Role’, and where was it first published?
Answer: It was written by Nani Palkhivala and first published in The Indian Express on 24 November 1994.
Q. In which year and country was the world’s first nationwide Green party founded?
Answer: It was founded in 1972, in New Zealand.
Q. What are the earth’s four principal biological systems, according to Lester R. Brown?
Answer: Fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands.
Q. What does the notice ‘The world’s most dangerous animal’ at the Lusaka zoo actually show the visitor?
Answer: A mirror, so the visitor sees themselves.
Q. According to reliable data, as cited in the essay, at what rate is India losing its forests?
Answer: 3.7 million acres a year.
Q. According to the essay, who declared himself Du Pont’s ‘Chief Environmental Officer’?
Answer: Mr Edgar S. Woolard, the Chairman of Du Pont.
Q. What figure does the essay give for the world’s population in 1994?
Answer: 5.7 billion.
Q. Name the Article of the Indian Constitution quoted in the essay on protecting the environment.
Answer: Article 48A.
2 2-Mark Questions
Q. What is ‘sustainable development’, as defined in the essay?
Answer: As defined by the World Commission on Environment and Development in 1987 and quoted in the essay, it is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs.
Q. Why does Palkhivala compare the shift to a holistic worldview with the Copernican revolution?
Answer: Because he calls it “a shift in human perceptions as revolutionary as” the one Copernicus introduced when he taught that the earth and the other planets revolved round the sun: humans are moving from the mechanistic view to a holistic and ecological view that sees the earth as a living organism of which we are parts.
Q. What reasons does the essay give for the destruction of forests in poor countries?
Answer: In poor countries, local forests are being decimated in order to procure firewood for cooking. In some places firewood has become so expensive that, in the essay’s words, ‘what goes under the pot now costs more than what goes inside it.’
Q. How are the earth’s principal biological systems being depleted, according to the essay?
Answer: In large areas of the world, human claims on these systems are reaching an unsustainable level where their productivity is impaired; then fisheries collapse, forests disappear, grasslands are converted into barren wastelands and croplands deteriorate. Over-fishing is common every day, and in poor countries local forests are decimated for firewood.
Q. What does Palkhivala mean by calling development ‘the best contraceptive’?
Answer: He means that as incomes rise, education spreads and health improves, fertility falls, so development is the best contraceptive; he adds that development itself may not be possible if the present increase in numbers continues.
Q. Why, according to Palkhivala, does the failure to enforce laws matter for the environment?
Answer: Article 48A of the Constitution provides that ‘the State shall endeavour to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests and wildlife of the country’, but Palkhivala argues that laws are never respected nor enforced in India, so the constitutional protection exists on paper without stopping the actual destruction.
Q. What solution does Palkhivala propose for population growth, and what does he explicitly reject?
Answer: He proposes voluntary family planning without any element of coercion, and explicitly rejects treating human beings ‘like cattle’ through compulsory sterilisation.
Q. Explain the significance of the title ‘The Ailing Planet.’
Answer: One way to read the title is as a metaphor of the earth as a sick patient whose ‘vital signs reveal a patient in declining health,’ whose ‘metabolic needs’ must be respected, and for whom humans must act as responsible ‘stewards’ and ‘trustees.’
Q. What does the essay mean by describing fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands as forming ‘the foundation of the global economic system’?
Answer: It means that these four systems supply our food and virtually all the raw materials for industry, except minerals and petroleum-derived synthetics, so their decline threatens not just the environment but the economic system built on them.
Q. According to the essay, what specific claim does the First Brandt Report make, and who from India was connected to it?
Answer: The First Brandt Report asks, ‘Are we to leave our successors a scorched planet of advancing deserts, impoverished landscapes and ailing environment?’ Mr L.K. Jha, a distinguished Indian, was a member of the Brandt Commission that produced this report.
Q. Explain what Palkhivala means when he writes, ‘what goes under the pot now costs more than what goes inside it.’
Answer: He means that in some places, as local forests are decimated for firewood, firewood used for cooking has become so expensive that the cost of the fuel itself now exceeds the cost of the food being cooked over it.
3 4-Mark Questions
Q. Describe, in your own words, the shift in human perception that Palkhivala says the Green Movement has brought about.
Answer: Palkhivala describes a shift from a mechanistic view of the world, which sees the world as ‘a dissociated collection of parts’, to a holistic and ecological view, which sees the earth as one living, connected organism. He calls it a shift in human perceptions as revolutionary as that introduced by Copernicus, who taught that the earth and the other planets revolved round the sun. For the first time, he says, there is a worldwide consciousness that the earth is a living being of which humans are parts, and that they have ethical obligations as its stewards and as trustees of its legacy for future generations.
Q. Explain, with examples from the essay, how Palkhivala uses statistics and named authorities to make his argument convincing.
Answer: Palkhivala builds his case largely on quoted experts and precise numbers rather than personal opinion. He cites Lester R. Brown’s book on the earth’s four biological systems, Dr Myers calling the tropical forest ‘the powerhouse of evolution,’ the World Bank’s estimate of a fivefold increase needed in forest planting, and James Speth of the World Resources Institute on the rate of forest loss. He also gives exact figures: 1.4 million catalogued species, 40 to 50 million acres of forest lost a year worldwide, and India’s population at 920 million. This combination of expert authority (ethos) and hard statistics (logos) makes the crisis feel documented and undeniable rather than a matter of opinion.
Q. How does the essay present India’s own environmental record, and what does Palkhivala suggest is the real problem?
Answer: The essay notes that Article 48A of the Constitution provides that the State ‘shall endeavour to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests and wildlife of the country’, but Palkhivala argues the real problem is enforcement, not law: laws in India are ‘never respected nor enforced.’ He points to Parliament’s Estimates Committee report of ‘near catastrophic depletion’ of India’s forests over four decades, with a loss of 3.7 million acres a year according to reliable data, while the actual loss is estimated to be about eight times the rate indicated by government statistics. He adds that large areas officially designated as forest land ‘are already virtually treeless’.
Q. Trace the growth of world population as described in the essay, and explain why Palkhivala calls it one of the strongest factors distorting humanity’s future.
Answer: The essay traces population from the first billion, reached only after more than a million years, around 1800, to a second billion by 1900, with a further 3.7 billion added during the twentieth century alone, bringing the total to an estimated 5.7 billion by 1994, rising by one million every four days. Palkhivala calls this one of the strongest distorting factors because, in his words, ‘the rich get richer, and the poor beget children which condemns them to remain poor,’ trapping the poorest in a cycle. He adds that development itself may not be possible if the present increase in numbers continues, and that ‘the choice is really between control of population and perpetuation of poverty.’
Q. What role does the essay assign to industry in addressing the environmental crisis, and how is this illustrated?
Answer: Palkhivala says industry has ‘a most crucial role to play’ in the new ‘Era of Responsibility,’ and wishes more businessmen shared the view of Du Pont’s Chairman. He illustrates this with Mr Edgar S. Woolard, Chairman of Du Pont, who declared himself the company’s ‘Chief Environmental Officer’ and stated that the company’s continued existence as a leading manufacturer required it to excel in environmental performance, showing that industry has ‘a most crucial role to play’ in the Era of Responsibility.
Q. Identify and explain three rhetorical devices Palkhivala uses in this essay, with an example of each.
Answer: First, an extended metaphor runs throughout, comparing the earth to a sick patient, as in ‘the earth’s vital signs reveal a patient in declining health.’ Second, he uses irony, as in the Lusaka zoo cage labelled ‘the world’s most dangerous animal’ that actually holds only a mirror, showing the visitor is the danger. Third, he uses antithesis, contrasting opposing ideas for effect, as in Margaret Thatcher’s quoted line, “No generation has a freehold on this earth. All we have is a life tenancy — with a full repairing lease.”
4 6-Mark Questions
Q. “For the first time in human history we see a transcending concern — the survival not just of the people but of the planet.” Discuss this statement with reference to the essay’s overall argument.
Answer: This statement can be read as the essay’s turning point: the shift “from the mechanistic view to a holistic and ecological view of the world”, in which the survival of the planet, not just of the people, becomes the concern. Palkhivala builds toward this idea across the whole essay. He opens with the worldview shift he compares to the Copernican revolution, then documents in detail how the earth’s systems, its species, forests, grasslands and croplands, are being depleted, and how the growth of world population is “one of the strongest factors distorting the future of human society”. Rather than ending in despair, he presents this new ‘transcending concern’ as the foundation of what he calls the ‘Era of Responsibility’: a holistic view that sees the world ‘as an integrated whole rather than a dissociated collection of parts.’ He backs this with real examples of the shift already underway, such as Edgar Woolard of Du Pont naming himself ‘Chief Environmental Officer,’ and closes with Margaret Thatcher’s and Lester Brown’s quotations reminding readers that no generation has “a freehold on this earth” and that we have “borrowed it from our children”. Read this way, the statement sums up the essay’s argument: that human survival now depends on caring for the planet’s survival too.
Q. Palkhivala uses a wide range of facts, statistics and expert quotations rather than simply stating his opinions. Evaluate how effective this technique is in making the essay persuasive, using at least four examples from the text.
Answer: Palkhivala’s technique of building his argument largely from named authorities and precise statistics, rather than personal opinion, is highly effective for a persuasive essay because it gives his claims the weight of documented evidence rather than one man’s alarm. For example, he does not simply say forests are disappearing; he cites the World Bank’s estimate that a fivefold increase in forest planting is needed to cope with the expected fuelwood demand in the year 2000, and quotes James Speth, President of the World Resources Institute, on the rate reaching ‘an acre-and-a-half to a second.’ He does not simply say species are being lost; he gives the precise figure of 1.4 million catalogued species against an estimated three to a hundred million uncatalogued ones, and quotes Dr Myers calling the tropical forest ‘the powerhouse of evolution.’ On India specifically, he cites Parliament’s own Estimates Committee report and the Constitution’s Article 48A, turning his argument about enforcement into a documented, official failure rather than a personal complaint. Finally, closing quotations from Margaret Thatcher and Lester Brown lend the essay the authority of world-recognised voices at its most memorable moment. Taken together, this technique makes the essay convincing because a reader cannot dismiss it as one person’s opinion, every major claim is anchored to a name, a report, or a number that the reader could, in principle, check.
5 Case Studies
(A) 1 mark Who popularised the concept of sustainable development, and in which year?
Answer: The World Commission on Environment and Development popularised it in 1987.
(B) 2 marks In your own words, explain what ‘without stripping the natural world of resources future generations would need’ means.
Answer: It means that present-day growth should not use up or destroy natural resources, such as forests, water, or biodiversity, to the point where future generations no longer have enough of them to meet their own needs.
(C) 3 marks Why is this definition important to the overall argument of the essay?
Answer: One way to see it: this definition gives the essay’s idea of responsible development a precise, quotable form from an international commission. It grounds Palkhivala’s later arguments about forests, species and population in a single accepted standard: development is only acceptable if it does not compromise the future, which is exactly the standard he shows humanity failing to meet throughout the rest of the essay.
(A) 1 mark According to the passage, at what rate does reliable data say India is losing its forests?
Answer: 3.7 million acres a year.
(B) 2 marks What does the passage mean by land that is ‘officially designated as forest land’ but ‘already virtually treeless’?
Answer: It means that government records still classify certain large areas as forest land, but in reality those areas have already lost almost all their trees, which suggests that official forest-cover figures overstate how much forest actually still exists.
(C) 3 marks What does this passage suggest about the reliability of official government statistics on environmental issues?
Answer: It suggests that official statistics can significantly understate the real scale of environmental damage: the passage says the actual loss of forests is estimated to be about eight times the rate indicated by government statistics. This fits Palkhivala’s argument, just before the passage, that laws are ‘never respected nor enforced’ in India.