Class 11 English Book 1 Chapter 5 The Adventure NCERT Solutions in English

Complete solutions to every exercise of NCERT Hornbill, Prose Chapter 5, “The Adventure,” exactly as printed in the book, starting with the “Notice these expressions” box at the head of the chapter, with a full model answer under each. Write your own answer first, then compare.

1 Before You Read: Notice These Expressions

Pre-reading box

Q. Notice these expressions in the text. Infer their meaning from the context.
blow-by-blow account · de facto · morale booster · astute · relegated to · doctored accounts · political acumen · gave vent to

Answer:

  • blow-by-blow account: a detailed description of every stage of an event, in the order it happened. The history book Gangadharpant reads “did not go into a blow-by-blow account of the battle itself”; instead it described the battle’s consequences.
  • de facto: a Latin phrase meaning “in fact” or “in reality”, as opposed to officially. The Peshwas kept the puppet Mughal regime alive in Delhi, but they were “these de facto rulers from Pune”, the real holders of power.
  • morale booster: something that raises people’s confidence and spirits. The Maratha victory at Panipat “was not only a great morale booster to the Marathas but it also established their supremacy in northern India.”
  • astute: clever and quick to see what will be to one’s advantage. The Peshwas “were astute enough to recognise the importance of the technological age dawning in Europe” and set up their own centres for science and technology.
  • relegated to: moved to a lower, less important position. “The trouble-maker, Dadasaheb, was relegated to the background and he eventually retired from state politics.”
  • doctored accounts: accounts that have been changed or falsified, so they cannot be fully trusted. Gangadharpant seldom relied on the Bakhars, but “buried in the graphic but doctored accounts, he could spot the germ of truth.”
  • political acumen: sharp judgement and skill in political matters. Vishwasrao and his brother Madhavrao “combined political acumen with valour” and expanded Maratha influence all over India.
  • gave vent to: expressed freely and forcefully. At the Azad Maidan lecture, when the audience shouted at him to vacate the presidential chair, “Professor Gaitonde went to the mike and gave vent to his views”: an unchaired lecture, he said, is like Hamlet without the Prince of Denmark.

2 Understanding the Text

I. Tick the statements that are true.

Q.
1. The story is an account of real events.
2. The story hinges on a particular historical event.
3. Rajendra Deshpande was a historian.
4. The places mentioned in the story are all imaginary.
5. The story tries to relate history to science.

Answer:
1. False, the story is a work of science fiction, not an account of real events.
2. True, the whole story hinges on the Battle of Panipat.
3. False, Rajendra Deshpande is a scientist, not a historian; Gaitonde is the historian.
4. False, real places are named throughout: Pune, Bombay, Lonavala, Karjat, Kalyan, Victoria Terminus, the Azad Maidan, and more.
5. True, the story explains a historical “what if” using catastrophe theory and quantum theory.

II. Briefly explain the following statements from the text.

Q. 1. “You neither travelled to the past nor the future. You were in the present experiencing a different world.”

Answer: Rajendra says this to correct the idea that Gaitonde time-travelled. His theory is that history branched into two worlds at the Battle of Panipat, and Gaitonde briefly experienced the other branch, which exists in the same present, not in an earlier or later time.

Q. 2. “You have passed through a fantastic experience: or more correctly, a catastrophic experience.”

Answer: Rajendra corrects his own word choice here. “Fantastic” makes it sound imaginary, but he means it precisely: Gaitonde’s experience is best explained by catastrophe theory, where a small change at a critical moment (the bullet narrowly missing Vishwasrao) produced a completely different outcome.

Q. 3. Gangadharpant could not help comparing the country he knew with what he was witnessing around him.

Answer: Seeing an India that “had not been subjected to slavery for the white man” and “had learnt to stand on its feet and knew what self-respect was,” where the British keep only Bombay as their sole outpost, Gaitonde cannot help contrasting it with the India of his own history, which was ruled by the British for a long period.

Q. 4. “The lack of determinism in quantum theory!”

Answer: Gaitonde says this once he understands Rajendra’s point: unlike a bullet fired from a gun, whose position can be calculated exactly, the behaviour of a quantum particle like an electron “cannot be predicted definitively”: one can at best quote odds for where it will be found. This “lack of determinism” is the scientific idea Rajendra uses to explain how more than one outcome could exist.

Q. 5. “You need some interaction to cause a transition.”

Answer: Rajendra means that a jump between two “worlds” (or between two states, as with an electron) does not happen on its own; something has to trigger it. He guesses that the trigger was in Gaitonde’s own mind: at the time of the collision he was thinking about catastrophe theory and its role in wars, and perhaps about the Battle of Panipat, and “the neurons in your brain acted as a trigger.” Rajendra admits this is only a guess, since why the transition happened is one of the “many unsolved questions in science”.

3 Talking about the Text

Question 1

Q. Discuss the following statements in groups of two pairs, each pair in a group taking opposite points of view.
(i) A single event may change the course of the history of a nation.
(ii) Reality is what is directly experienced through the senses.
(iii) The methods of inquiry of history, science and philosophy are similar.

Answer: This is a discussion exercise with no single correct answer; students are expected to argue both sides. Sample points for each:
(i) For: The story itself shows a single bullet’s path changing India’s entire future. Many historians argue that key battles, assassinations or decisions have redirected a nation’s path.
(i) Against: Long-term social, economic and geographic forces usually shape history more than any one event; even a different outcome at Panipat might only have delayed, not prevented, similar later developments.
(ii) For: We only know the world through sight, hearing, touch and the other senses, so what we sense is effectively what is real to us.
(ii) Against: Science shows that much of reality (electrons, radio waves, gravity) exists and can be measured even though it cannot be directly sensed, so reality is broader than direct sense-experience.
(iii) For: All three fields build a hypothesis, test it against evidence or logic, and revise their conclusions accordingly.
(iii) Against: Science relies on repeatable experiments and controlled variables, while history studies unrepeatable past events and philosophy often reasons without any physical experiment at all, so their methods differ significantly even if their spirit of inquiry is similar.

Question 2

Q. (i) The story is called ‘The Adventure’. Compare it with the adventure described in ‘We’re Not Afraid to Die…’.
(ii) Why do you think Professor Gaitonde decided never to preside over meetings again?

Answer:
(i) Both stories are called adventures, but of very different kinds. “We’re Not Afraid to Die…” describes a real, physical adventure at sea: a family’s boat, Wavewalker, is hit by a huge wave in a storm and is near capsizing, and they must survive real physical danger through courage and skill. “The Adventure” is an intellectual and scientific adventure: Gaitonde’s danger is not physical but conceptual, discovering that history itself could have branched differently, and finding proof of another version of reality. One is an adventure of survival; the other is an adventure of ideas.
(ii) Gaitonde tells Rajendra that his thousandth address “was made on the Azad Maidan” when he was “so rudely interrupted.” In that world the custom of a presiding chair had been abolished, and his attempt to defend the chair ended with the audience pelting him and swarming the stage to eject him. He therefore declares that “the Professor Gaitonde who disappeared while defending his chair on the platform will now never be seen presiding at another meeting,” and sends his regrets to the organisers of the Panipat seminar. The humiliation, and the discovery that the custom he valued could simply be abolished, may have made him feel that his days of presiding were over; it also gives the story a gently comic ending.

4 Thinking about Language

Question 1

Q. In which language do you think Gangadharpant and Khan Sahib talked to each other? Which language did Gangadharpant use to talk to the English receptionist?

Answer: Gangadharpant and Khan Sahib most likely spoke to each other in Hindi or Hindustani, a common link language between a Maharashtrian historian and a businessman travelling across northern India to Peshawar. With the English receptionist at Forbes Building, Gaitonde would have spoken in English, since that is the language of a British firm in this British-run Bombay.

Question 2

Q. In which language do you think Bhausahebanchi Bakhar was written?

Answer: It would have been written in Marathi, since Bakhars are a traditional form of Marathi historical chronicle, and “Bhausahebanchi Bakhar” itself is an account concerning Sadashivrao Bhau, a Maratha commander.

Question 3

Q. There is mention of three communities in the story: the Marathas, the Mughals, the Anglo-Indians. Which language do you think they used within their communities and while speaking to the other groups?

Answer: Within their own communities, the Marathas would have spoken Marathi, the Mughals Persian or Urdu, and the Anglo-Indians English. While speaking to each other, they would likely have used a shared link language: Hindustani was commonly used between Marathas and Mughals, while English or a simplified Hindustani would have been used for communication with Anglo-Indian officials, since English was the language of British administration.

Question 4

Q. Do you think that the ruled always adopt the language of the ruler?

Answer: Not always. Rulers often try to impose their language for administration and education, but the ruled do not always fully adopt it. The story does not show language imposition; it shows British institutions, such as the East India House and the permit checks near Bombay. Many communities keep their own language alive at home and in cultural life even while learning the ruler’s language for administration, trade or education, exactly as happened in India under British rule, where local languages survived and flourished alongside English.

5 Working with Words

I. Tick the item that is closest in meaning to the following phrases.

Answer:
1. to take issue with → (iii) to disagree.
2. to give vent to → (i) to express.
3. to stand on one’s feet → (ii) to be independent.
4. to be wound up → (ii) to stop operating.
5. to meet one’s match → (iii) to meet someone who is equally able as oneself.

II. Distinguish between the following pairs of sentences.

Answer:
1. (i) “He was visibly moved” means his emotion could clearly be seen by others.
(ii) “He was visually impaired” means he had a problem with his eyesight.
2. (i) “Green and black stripes were used alternately” means the two colours took turns, one after another, in a repeating pattern.
(ii) “Green stripes could be used or alternatively black ones” means one colour or the other could be chosen instead, as an alternative option.
3. (i) “The team played the two matches successfully” means the team achieved its aim in both matches.
(ii) “The team played two matches successively” means the two matches were played one right after the other, in immediate succession.
4. (i) “The librarian spoke respectfully to the learned scholar” means the librarian showed the scholar respect while speaking.
(ii) “You will find the historian and the scientist in the archaeology and natural science sections of the museum respectively” means the historian is linked to the first section named (archaeology) and the scientist to the second (natural science), each in the same order as they were listed.

6 Noticing Form

Task

Q. The story deals with unreal and hypothetical conditions. Some of the sentences used to express this notion are given below. Notice that in an unreal condition, it is clearly expected that the condition will not be fulfilled.
1. If I fire a bullet from a gun in a given direction at a given speed, I know where it will be at a later time.
2. If I knew the answer I would solve a great problem.
3. If he himself were dead in this world, what guarantee had he that his son would be alive.
4. What course would history have taken if the battle had gone the other way?

Answer: Sentence 1 is a real, factual condition: firing a bullet in a known direction and speed genuinely does let you calculate its position, so this condition can be, and is, fulfilled. Sentences 2, 3 and 4, however, are unreal or hypothetical conditions: Rajendra does not actually know the answer (2), Gaitonde is not actually dead in this world (3), and the battle did not actually go the other way in Gaitonde’s own history (4). Each of these describes a condition that is understood, from the way it is phrased (“If I knew,” “If he himself were dead,” “if the battle had gone the other way”), to be contrary to fact, which is exactly the grammatical shape of an unreal or hypothetical condition. The book groups sentence 1 with the others, but it is a real, open condition, which is why it contrasts with sentences 2 to 4.

7 Things to Do

I. Read the passage on the Catastrophe Theory

Q. Read the following passage on the Catastrophe Theory downloaded from the Internet, and note what it says.

Answer: The passage credits French mathematician René Thom with originating catastrophe theory in the 1960s, as a branch of dynamical systems theory that classifies sudden shifts in behaviour arising from small changes in circumstances, what it calls “bifurcations between different equilibria, or fixed point attractors.” It sorts these by how many control parameters change together: two controls produce the most common type, the “cusp” catastrophe, while beyond five controls no classification exists. As real-world examples, it lists ships capsizing at sea, bridges collapsing, and, less convincingly, animal fight-or-flight responses and prison riots. This is exactly the theory Rajendra uses in the story to explain how one small event, the bullet narrowly missing or hitting Vishwasrao, could tip the entire outcome of the Battle of Panipat.

II. Look up information on the following theories

Q. Look up the Internet or an encyclopedia for information on: (i) Quantum theory (ii) Theory of relativity (iii) Big Bang theory (iv) Theory of evolution.

Answer:
(i) Quantum theory describes the behaviour of matter and energy at the smallest scales (atoms and subatomic particles). It shows that the behaviour of such particles cannot be predicted definitively: only odds can be given for where they will be found, which is the “lack of determinism” Rajendra refers to in the story.
(ii) Theory of relativity, developed by Albert Einstein, has two parts: special relativity, which shows that measurements of space and time depend on the observer’s speed, and general relativity, which explains gravity as the bending of space and time by mass.
(iii) Big Bang theory is the leading scientific explanation for the origin of the universe: about 13.8 billion years ago, the universe began expanding rapidly from an extremely hot, dense state, and has continued expanding and cooling ever since.
(iv) Theory of evolution, proposed by Charles Darwin, explains how species of living things change over long periods of time through natural selection, in which individuals with traits better suited to their environment are more likely to survive and pass those traits on to their offspring.