Complete solutions to every exercise question of NCERT Snapshots, Chapter 3, “Mother’s Day,” with every question in the book’s own wording. Unlike a prose chapter, this play carries only five numbered questions, with no lettered sub-headings such as “Understanding the Text.” Write your own answer first, then compare.
Q. This play, written in the 1950s, is a humorous and satirical depiction of the status of the mother in the family.
(i) What are the issues it raises?
(ii) Do you think it caricatures these issues or do you think that the problems it raises are genuine? How does the play resolve the issues? Do you agree with the resolution?
Answer (i): The play raises the issue of a mother’s unpaid, unthanked labour being taken completely for granted by her husband and children. Every family member expects meals, ironing and attention on demand, while, as “Mrs Pearson” tells Doris during the swap, the mother puts in “twice the hours you do” and gets “no wages nor thanks for it”; she also says, “I could do with a change.” The play also raises the connected issue of self-respect: Mrs Pearson knows all this is unfair, yet cannot bring herself to say so directly, which is itself part of the problem the play examines.
Answer (ii): This has no single correct answer and is meant for discussion, but a balanced answer should engage with both possibilities. The personality-swap device, the exaggerated club nickname, and the neat, fast happy ending are clearly comic exaggerations, no real family reforms itself in one afternoon, and no real neighbour has a genuine magical trick. In that sense, the play does caricature its issues for comic effect. At the same time, the underlying pattern it satirises, a mother’s care becoming invisible until she withholds it, and a family that only notices her the moment she stops being convenient, is a genuine and recognisable problem, which is exactly why the exaggeration is funny rather than simply strange. The play resolves the issues by having the family, frightened and humbled by a single day of firm treatment, agree at once to “a nice family game of rummy”, with the children getting the supper ready. Whether one agrees with this resolution is again a matter of opinion: it is a satisfying, hopeful ending for a short comic play, but it can be questioned because the family never learns the real reason for the change, so nothing guarantees the new behaviour lasts. A student may reasonably argue either that the ending is convincing because attitudes visibly shift once behaviour is confronted, or that it is too neat because real change usually needs understanding, not just a single shock.
Q. If you were to write about these issues today what are some of the incidents, examples and problems that you would think of as relevant?
Answer: This is an open discussion question, and answers will vary, but relevant modern examples could include: a working mother who is still expected to do all the housework and cooking after her paid job, sometimes called the “double burden” or “second shift” (terms from sociology; the book does not use them); a family WhatsApp group where only the mother is expected to organise everyone’s schedules, appointments and reminders; unequal division of chores between siblings, where a daughter is asked to help in the kitchen while a son is not; or a mother’s own hobbies, friendships and rest time being treated as less important than everyone else’s plans. A good answer should connect at least one such modern example back to the play, for example to the reading that unpaid, unnoticed work at home is still work, and deserves the same respect as work done outside it.
Q. Is drama a good medium for conveying a social message? Discuss.
Answer: Yes, drama is a strong medium for conveying a social message, and “Mother’s Day” itself is a good example of why. Because a play is seen and heard rather than only read, an audience experiences the unfairness towards Mrs Pearson directly, through action and dialogue, rather than being told about it in an essay, which tends to make the message land more immediately and emotionally. Comedy in particular, as this play shows, lets an audience laugh at a fault before they can become defensive about it, so the criticism goes in more easily than a direct lecture would. Drama also compresses a message into a short, memorable shape, a single afternoon, five characters, one small set, which makes the point easy to remember and retell. A balanced answer might add that drama’s message depends heavily on performance and interpretation, so a poorly staged or misunderstood play can also blunt its own message, but overall drama, especially satirical drama like this play, is a genuinely effective way to raise a social issue.
Q. Read the play out in parts. Enact the play on a suitable occasion.
Answer: This is a classroom performance activity with no written “answer” as such. Students should be assigned the five roles, Mrs Pearson, George, Doris, Cyril and Mrs Fitzgerald, and should pay close attention to the stage directions in brackets (such as “coolly,” “aggressively,” “dubiously”) when reading their lines aloud, since these directions carry much of the play’s comedy and characterisation. The personality-swap scenes work best when the two actresses playing Mrs Pearson and Mrs Fitzgerald clearly change their voice and manner the moment the chant is spoken, exactly as the stage direction instructs.
Q. Discuss in groups plays or films with a strong message of social reform that you have watched.
Answer: This is an open discussion activity and answers will vary by student. A group might discuss any play or film they have seen that raises a social issue through its story, for example a film about the unequal treatment of a family member, a school play about honesty or bullying, or a television drama about respecting elders or the environment. In discussion, students should be encouraged to identify what specific social message the play or film conveys, and by what technique it does so (comedy, tragedy, a twist ending, a narrator’s commentary), so the discussion connects back to how “Mother’s Day” uses comedy and a fantastical device to make its own point.