Complete NCERT solutions for Class 11 English, Woven Words Book 3, Chapter 21: “My Watch” by Mark Twain. Every exercise below, including the in-text word box, is reproduced from NCERT (with the book’s typos “seemd” and “Williams'” corrected), with a full model answer underneath.
1In-text Question
Q. Look for these expressions and words in the text and guess the meaning from the context: bodings, human cabbage, vicious happiness, prised, brained him.
Answer:
bodings: feelings that something bad is going to happen; the narrator “commanded my bodings and superstitions to depart” after the watch ran down.
human cabbage: a dull person who cannot think beyond one idea; the jeweller who could see only that the watch “was four minutes slow”.
vicious happiness: a cruel delight; the watchmaker’s “look of vicious happiness” when he hears the watch has never been repaired.
prised: forced open with a tool (the text prints “pried the watch open”).
brained him: struck him hard on the head; a comic exaggeration of the narrator’s anger at the last repairer.
2Understanding the Text
Q. What was the importance of the watch to the author?
Answer: The watch was extremely important to the narrator, he calls it his “beautiful new watch” and had come to trust it completely. It had run for eighteen months “without losing or gaining”, and without breaking any part of its machinery or stopping. Because of this flawless record, the narrator had begun to believe the watch was infallible, that it could never be wrong about the time and could never break. He treated it almost like a living thing whose “constitution” and “anatomy” were imperishable, which is why, when he let it run down one night, he grieved about it “as if it were a recognised messenger and forerunner of calamity”.
Q. What were the attempts made by the author to get his watch repaired?
Answer: After the chief jeweller first pushed up the regulator (believing the watch was four minutes slow), the watch began gaining time badly, and the narrator made six separate attempts to have it corrected: (1) a watchmaker cleaned, oiled and regulated it, which instead made it run far too slow; (2) another watchmaker found the barrel “swelled” and reduced it, after which the watch kept “a fair and square average” but raced for half the day and slowed for the rest; (3) another watchmaker diagnosed a broken “king-bolt”, after which the watch ran in stop-start fits and “kicked back like a musket” every time it went off; (4) another picked it all to pieces, turned “the ruin” over under his glass and said there “appeared to be fresh start”, after which the hands shut together like a pair of scissors at ten minutes to ten every time; (5) another straightened a bent crystal and a crooked mainspring, after which the watch “performed unexceptionably”, except that now and then, after nearly eight hours, its hands suddenly spun out of control; and (6) a sixth watchmaker, who turned out to be an old acquaintance, “a steam-boat engineer of other days and not a good engineer, either”, gave the most absurd diagnosis of all, applying steam-engine language to a watch.
Q. Why did the author finally give up on his watch?
Answer: The narrator did not so much “give up” on the watch as lose his patience with its repairers. By the last visit he felt “this thing was getting serious”: the watch “had cost two hundred dollars originally”, and he “seemed to have paid out two or three thousand for repairs”. After five different watchmakers had each left the watch broken in a new and stranger way, a sixth watchmaker, an old acquaintance who used to be a steam-boat engineer, examined it “just as the other watchmakers had done” and gave his verdict “with the same confidence of manner” and gave a diagnosis that made no sense at all for a watch (“she makes too much steam… hang the monkey-wrench on the safety-valve”). This final, most ridiculous misdiagnosis was the last straw: the narrator’s frustration, built up over five earlier failures, finally broke, and he reacted with the deadpan, wildly exaggerated line “I brained him on the spot and had him buried at my own expense.”
Q. What was Uncle William’s comment on the ‘tinkerers’ of the world?
Answer: Uncle William used to say that “a good horse was a good horse until it had run away once, and that a good watch was a good watch until the repairers got a chance at it.” He also used to wonder what became of all the unsuccessful tinkers, gunsmiths, shoe-makers, engineers and blacksmiths, but, as the essay’s last line says, “nobody could ever tell him”.
3Explain these Lines
Q. “I seemed to detect in myself a sort of sneaking fellow-feeling for the mummy in the museum, and a desire to swap news with him.”
Answer: By this point in the story, a watchmaker’s repair has made the watch run so slow that the narrator keeps missing appointments and drifting further and further behind in time, first a day behind, then a week, until he feels he is stuck in “week before last” while the rest of the world has moved on. He humorously compares this feeling to that of an ancient mummy in a museum, something completely out of touch with the present, and jokes that he now feels enough kinship with it to want to “swap news”. The line is a comic exaggeration of just how far out of step with real time his watch (and therefore he himself) has fallen.
Q. “Within a week it sickened to a raging fever and its pulse went up to a hundred and fifty in the shade.”
Answer: This line describes what happened after the chief jeweller pushed up the regulator, believing the watch was slow. Instead of correcting it, this made the watch run faster and faster with every passing day. Twain describes this purely mechanical fault through the language of human illness, the watch “sickened” to a “raging fever” and its “pulse” raced, personifying it as a sick patient. This comic exaggeration turns a simple timekeeping fault into something that sounds like a medical emergency, which is exactly the kind of humour the essay is built on.
Q. “She makes too much steam — you want to hang the monkey-wrench on the safety-valve!”
Answer: This is the verdict of the sixth and final repairer, whom the narrator recognises as an old acquaintance, “a steam-boat engineer of other days and not a good engineer, either”. His diagnosis borrows the vocabulary of a steam engine, “steam” and a “safety-valve”, and applies it, absurdly, to a watch, which obviously has neither. The line is funny because it is delivered “with the same confidence of manner” as every watchmaker’s diagnosis before it, suggesting that his authority was not based on knowledge of watches (the book implies this but does not state it). It marks the essay’s comic climax, provoking the narrator’s final, deadpan overreaction.
4Talking about the Text
Discuss in pairs or groups of four:
Q. Replacing old machines with new is better than getting them repaired.
Answer (model discussion points): The essay can be used to support this view, since each repair in the story leaves the watch with some new fault: even the barrel repair gives only “a fair and square average”, and the crystal and mainspring repair leaves it running “unexceptionably, save that now and then” it spins out of control. The watch ran well on its own and broke down once professionals began “correcting” it. One can argue that repeated, unnecessary tinkering (rather than the watch’s own age or design) can cause breakdowns, and that sometimes buying new is simpler and safer than repeatedly repairing something that already works. On the other hand, one could also argue the opposite: not every “old” machine is actually faulty, as here, where the watch had no real problem until it was interfered with, so the real lesson may not be “replace, don’t repair” but rather “do not fix what isn’t broken”, and repair only when genuinely necessary and only by someone who can be trusted.
Q. It is difficult to part with personal items like a watch which have a sentimental value attached to them.
Answer (model discussion points): The narrator’s persistence through six repairers shows exactly this attachment: despite each visit leaving the watch with some new fault, he keeps trying to save it rather than simply replacing it, suggesting the watch means more to him than its function alone. Personal items often carry memories or associations (how they were acquired, how long they have been used) that make them feel irreplaceable even when a purely practical person would have given up much earlier. At the same time, the essay’s humour also gently pokes fun at this very attachment, the narrator’s persistence, taken to its extreme, becomes part of the joke, suggesting that sentimental attachment can sometimes make us tolerate far more trouble than an object is really worth.
5Appreciation
Q. How is humour employed to comment on the pains that the author took to get his watch set right?
Answer: Twain builds humour through several techniques working together. He personifies the watch as a living, ailing body, it gets a “raging fever”, a racing “pulse”, and every time it went off it “kicked back like a musket”, turning ordinary mechanical faults into comic medical symptoms. He uses hyperbole again and again, exaggerating outcomes to absurd extremes (the watch ends up “thirteen days ahead of the almanac” in two months; its hands later look like “a delicate spider’s web”). The plot itself is built on irony: every visit to a repairer is meant to fix the watch, yet each one leaves it with a new, different fault instead. And the essay’s tone stays deliberately calm and matter-of-fact even at its most extreme moment, the “braining” of the sixth repairer, which is what turns an outrageous event into comedy rather than something to be taken seriously. Together, these techniques turn the narrator’s genuine frustration into an escalating, and increasingly ridiculous, comic sequence.
Q. ‘The author’s treatment of the subject matter makes the readers identify themselves with the experience.’ Comment on this statement.
Answer: Most readers have, at some point, taken something to be repaired only to have it come back with a new problem, or have dealt with a person who sounds confident but turns out to be wrong, which is exactly the frustration Twain dramatises here, just pushed to a comic extreme. Because the narrator tells the story in the first person, sharing his growing exasperation directly with the reader, and because each repairer’s over-confident jargon will feel familiar to anyone who has dealt with an unhelpful “expert”, readers can easily recognise their own experience inside the exaggerated comedy. The essay works precisely because it takes a very ordinary, relatable annoyance and stretches it, through hyperbole and repetition, into something absurd, the reader laughs partly because they, too, have felt exactly this kind of frustration, even if never to this extent.
Q. Identify some of the improbable images the author has used to effect greater humour.
Answer: Several images in the essay are deliberately improbable for comic effect: the watch’s “pulse” going up to “a hundred and fifty in the shade” as though it were a fevered patient; the watch ending up “thirteen days ahead of the almanac” within just two months; the spinning hands becoming “a delicate spider’s web” over the watch’s face as it reels off twenty-four hours in six or seven minutes; the watch that “kicked back like a musket” every time it went off; and, most improbable of all, the narrator calmly saying he “brained” the sixth repairer and “had him buried” at his own expense, an absurdly extreme, almost cartoonish image told in a completely flat, matter-of-fact tone.
6Language Work
Q. Make a list of the expressions that imbue the watch with human attributes.
Answer: Expressions that personify the watch as a living, human (or animal) body include: the watch has a “constitution” and an “anatomy”, which are called “imperishable”; it “sickened to a raging fever”; its “pulse went up to a hundred and fifty in the shade”; it later “kicked back like a musket” each time it restarted; it would “go like the very mischief” with “such a barking and wheezing and whooping and sneezing and snorting” that the narrator could not hear himself think; it ran and stopped “using its own discretion about the intervals”; and the narrator had believed it “infallible in its judgments about the time of day”. Even the closing verdict, “She makes too much steam”, continues to address the watch as if it were a living, working body rather than a machine.
NCERT recommends two further readings by the same author for anyone who enjoyed this essay’s humour: The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Mysterious Stranger and Other Stories, both by Mark Twain.