Full answers to all 6 exercise questions of NCERT Understanding Society (Class 11, Book 2), Chapter 1 “Social Structure, Stratification and Social Processes in Society” (Reprint 2026-27). The questions are given exactly as printed in the English edition. Each answer uses the chapter’s own terms, names and examples. Exam status: CBSE does not examine this chapter in 2026-27; UP Board (10 marks), Rajasthan Board (10) and MP Board (8) do.
1 Tasks that demand cooperation
Q. “Discuss the different tasks that demand cooperation with reference to agricultural or industrial operations.”
Answer: Both Durkheim and Marx presume that human beings have to cooperate to meet their basic needs and to produce and reproduce their world. Farming and industry show this clearly.
Agricultural operations:
- Irrigation: in T.K. Oommen’s study, a Charas, an indigenous device for well irrigation, needs 2 pairs of bullocks and four men. An ordinary peasant cannot afford four bullocks, and a household may not have enough men, so families borrow bullocks and men from kin, neighbours and friends, promising similar services in return.
- Division of labour on the farm: all societies have at least some rudimentary division of labour, especially between the tasks allocated to men and those performed by women.
- Effect of technology: when the Charas is replaced by a Rehat (Persian wheel), which needs heavier capital but only one pair of bullocks and one person, the need for cooperation falls. So the level of technology may determine the need for cooperation between men and groups.
Industrial operations:
- Industry rests on a complex division of labour. Specialised workers in a garment or car factory cannot survive without many other specialised workers supplying their needs. This is Durkheim’s organic solidarity: cohesion through interdependence.
- The factory owner and the factory worker cooperate in everyday work, though a conflict of interests defines their relationship (the conflict view).
- A worker whose only task is to pull a lever or press a button all day cooperates in production, but Marx would call this cooperation enforced, since the worker is alienated from the work and its products.
Conclusion: agriculture with simple technology needs cooperation between households; industry needs cooperation between many specialised workers, though that cooperation may not be voluntary.
2 Voluntary or enforced cooperation
Q. “Is cooperation always voluntary or is it enforced? If enforced, is it sanctions or is the strength of norms that ensure cooperation? Discuss with examples.”
Answer: Cooperation is not always voluntary. The chapter shows that cooperation can be enforced and can serve to conceal conflict.
- Voluntary cooperation: in simple societies with no surplus, people cooperated without class, caste or race divisions. Durkheim saw altruism and solidarity, the moral force of society, behind cooperation.
- Enforced by the structure of work: for Marx, cooperation is not voluntary in a class society. The productive power of cooperation appears to workers as an alien force outside them. A factory worker pulling a lever all day has lost control over his work and its products (alienation), so his cooperation is enforced.
- Enforced by sanctions: dominant groups sustain an unequal order by cultural norms and often coercion or even violence. In Oommen’s land conflict, the Patel was taken to the police station and forced to agree to return the land to Ganpat, a police constable: here cooperation came through force.
- Enforced by the strength of norms: norms and socialisation often keep an order going even when it serves one section. In a study, women (41.7 per cent spoke of a daughter’s love) would not claim their share of natal property because they feared souring relations with brothers and losing their welcome at home; a claimant is called “hak lene wali”. No one punished them; the norm of male inheritance did the work.
- In the household: Amartya Sen notes enforced cooperation: family activities must look overtly cooperative even when substantial conflicts exist, and conflict is treated as deviant. Kabeer shows women subscribing to son-preference for longer-term security.
Conclusion: cooperation may be voluntary, but often it is ensured by sanctions (force, police, violence) or, more quietly, by the strength of norms. Functionalists call the second kind accommodation; the conflict view sees it as hidden conflict.
3 Conflict in Indian society
Q. “Can you find illustrative examples of conflict drawn from Indian society? Discuss the causes that led to conflict in each instance.”
Answer: Conflict means a clash of interests. Conflict theorists hold that scarcity of resources produces conflict as groups struggle for access to and control over them. The bases vary: class or caste, tribe or gender, ethnicity or religious community.
| Example from the chapter | Cause of the conflict |
|---|---|
| Land conflict (Oommen): Ganpat forcefully cultivated land mortgaged by Harbaksh to Nathu Ahir, the Patel | Control over land, a scarce resource; an informal deal not in revenue records; Ganpat’s power as a police constable |
| Peasant movements | Deep-rooted conflict over land resources, expressed openly |
| Women and natal property | The norm of male inheritance against women’s property rights; the conflict stays hidden under cooperation |
| Conflict within households (Sen, Kabeer) | Unequal distribution by age and gender; son-preference; patriarchal risk |
| Debate on reservation (Activity 6: 27 per cent for OBCs, 10 per cent for economically weaker sections among upper castes) | Competition for education and jobs between castes; lower caste students drop out while upper castes dominate higher institutions |
General knowledge: you can add examples from your own surroundings, such as a dispute over water between two villages, and find the cause in the same way: which scarce resource, power or status is being contested, and by which groups.
Note: conflicts are not new. Greater assertion of democratic rights by disadvantaged groups only makes them more visible.
4 How conflicts get resolved
Q. “Write an essay based on examples to show how conflicts get resolved.”
Answer:
Introduction. Conflict, a clash of interests, has always been part of every society. The functionalist perspective holds that in most cases competition and conflict tend to get resolved without too much distress, and may even help society. The conflict perspective asks whose interests the resolution serves.
Resolution through power and force. In Oommen’s land-conflict case, Ganpat could not go to court because the mortgage was not in the revenue records. He used violence to cultivate the land and, as a police constable, got the police to force the Patel to agree. A meeting of the villagers was then convened, the money was given to the Patel and Ganpat received the land back. The conflict was settled through power and access to resources rather than through a court.
Resolution through accommodation. When women give up their claim on natal property to keep their brothers’ affection, the conflict is settled by compromise. Functionalists call this accommodation: an effort to compromise and co-exist despite conflict. But the conflict is only hidden, not ended.
Resolution by treating conflict as deviant. In families, Sen notes, conflicts are moulded into a format of cooperation and treated as aberrations. Women resolve their disadvantage covertly, through secret lending and borrowing or trusted allies (Kabeer).
Resolution through change in technology. When the Rehat replaced the Charas, households no longer needed to borrow bullocks and men from one another, so the need for cooperation fell.
General knowledge: resolution through the state. Governments also try to address conflicts over access to education and jobs through public policies; the reservation decisions in Activity 6 are one such case, and they are themselves widely debated.
Conclusion. Conflicts get resolved by law, compromise, force, social change or new technology. But the chapter warns that the absence of an open clash does not mean conflict has ended: covert conflict and overt cooperation are common.
5 A society without competition
Q. “Imagine a society where there is no competition. Is it possible? If not, why not?”
Answer: Sociology does not accept that competition is natural or universal. It sees competition as a social entity that emerged and became dominant at a particular historical point. So a society with little or no competition is possible:
- In the chapter’s anecdote, a teacher in a remote area of Africa offered a chocolate to the winner of a race. The children felt anxiety and distress: for them fun was a cooperative and collective experience, not one where rewards exclude some.
- In simple societies with no surplus, people cooperated without being divided on class, caste or race lines.
- Under mechanical solidarity, people live similar lives bound by shared beliefs.
But in a modern capitalist society it is very hard to imagine, because competition is built into how such a society works:
- Durkheim and Marx noted the growth of individualism and competition in modern societies; capitalism stresses efficiency and profit maximisation.
- Its assumptions are expansion of trade, division of labour, specialisation and hence rising productivity, driven by rational individuals in free competition in the marketplace.
- The ideology of competition is the dominant ideology of capitalism: firms, students and workers compete for the greatest material rewards.
Conclusion: a society without competition is possible in principle, as the anecdote shows, but not in a modern capitalist society, where competition is a guiding force. And even there, competition is not equal: children who drop out of school remain out of it entirely.
6 Is modern society more competitive or conflict ridden?
Q. “Talk to your parents and elders, grandparents and their contemporaries and discuss whether modern society is really more competitive or conflict ridden than it used to be before. And if you think it is, how would you explain this sociologically?”
Answer: Elders usually say that competition today is far sharper (for school admissions, college seats and jobs) and that conflicts seem to be everywhere. A sociological answer accepts part of this and questions part of it.
More competitive: yes, and here is why.
- Competition as a desirable value flourished with the onset of capitalism. Modern society stresses efficiency and profit; the ideology of competition is its dominant ideology.
- Durkheim and Marx noted the growth of individualism and competition in modern societies. As the division of labour grows (organic solidarity), people become more specialised and dependent on one another.
- Competition starts at admission to school and continues through life (Activity 8).
More conflict ridden: not necessarily.
- Common sense says conflicts are new, but sociologists show they have always been part of every society; only their nature and form change.
- Conflicts look more frequent because social change and the greater assertion of democratic rights by disadvantaged and discriminated groups make them more visible.
- M.N. Srinivas reminds us that the “good old peaceful days” are a matter of nostalgia: the old order was not conflict-free and perpetrated inhuman cruelties on vast sections of the population.
- Much past conflict was covert, hidden under enforced cooperation, as with women in households or women giving up natal property.
Conclusion: modern society is more openly competitive because of capitalism and individualism. It is not necessarily more conflict ridden; conflict is simply more openly expressed today.