Full answers to all 9 exercise questions of NCERT Understanding Society (Class 11, Book 2), Chapter 5 “Indian Sociologists” (Reprint 2026-27). The questions are given exactly as printed in the English edition. Each answer uses the chapter’s own terms, names and examples.
1 Iyer and Roy
Q. “How did Ananthakrishna Iyer and Sarat Chandra Roy come to practice social anthropology?”
Answer: Both became anthropologists by accident: the book calls them ‘accidental anthropologists’, and their work was done on an ‘amateur’ basis. They were true pioneers: in the early 1900s they practised a discipline that did not yet exist in India and had no institutions to promote it.
- L.K. Ananthakrishna Iyer (1861-1937): began as a clerk, then became a school teacher and a college teacher in Cochin state (present day Kerala). In 1902 the Dewan of Cochin asked him to assist with an ethnographic survey of the state, part of the British plan for such surveys in all princely states and presidency areas. He did it purely voluntarily: teaching at the Maharajah’s College, Ernakulam during the week and working as the unpaid Superintendent of Ethnography at weekends. His work was praised by British anthropologists and administrators, and he was invited to a similar survey in Mysore state. He became probably the first self-taught anthropologist to win national and international recognition: Reader at the University of Calcutta (1917-1932), where he helped set up India’s first post-graduate anthropology department.
- Sarat Chandra Roy (1871-1942): held degrees in English and law (Ripon College, Calcutta). In 1898 he went to Ranchi as an English teacher at a Christian missionary school, then practised law in the Ranchi courts and was appointed official interpreter in the court. His professional need to interpret tribal customs and laws to the court made him deeply interested in tribal society. He travelled widely among tribal communities and did intensive fieldwork on an ‘amateur’ basis, publishing over a hundred articles and monographs on the Oraon, the Mundas and the Kharias. He founded Man in India (1922).
2 The tribal debate
Q. “What were the main arguments on either side of the debate about how to relate to tribal communities?”
Answer: In the 1930s and 1940s there was much debate on the place of tribal societies within India and how the state should respond to them.
- The protectionists (many British administrator-anthropologists): tribes were primitive peoples with a distinctive culture far from mainstream Hinduism. The innocent and simple tribals would suffer exploitation and cultural degradation through contact with Hindu society. So the state had a duty to protect them and help sustain their way of life against the pressure to assimilate; assimilation would mean severe exploitation and cultural extinction.
- The nationalists (G.S. Ghurye the best-known exponent, in his debate with Verrier Elwin): they believed in the unity of India and in modernising Indian society. Preserving tribal culture was misguided and kept tribals backward as ‘museums’ of primitive culture; like parts of Hinduism, tribes too needed to develop. Ghurye called the tribes ‘backward Hindus’, citing evidence of their long interaction with Hinduism: they were simply further behind in the same process of assimilation. The ill-effects of assimilation were common to all the backward and downtrodden sections of society: inevitable difficulties on the road to development.
- Common ground: both sides accepted that Indian tribals were hardly ever isolated primitive communities; they differed on how to evaluate the impact of mainstream culture.
3 Risley and Ghurye on race and caste
Q. “Outline the positions of Herbert Risley and G.S. Ghurye on the relationship between race and caste in India.”
Answer:
- Herbert Risley (British colonial official): humans can be divided into distinct races by physical features such as the circumference of the skull, the length of the nose and the volume of the cranium. India was a unique ‘laboratory’ for studying racial types because caste had strictly prohibited inter-marriage for centuries. Higher castes approximated Indo-Aryan traits, lower castes non-Aryan aboriginal, Mongoloid or other groups. So caste must have originated in race, and the lower castes were the original inhabitants, subjugated by Aryans who came from elsewhere.
- G.S. Ghurye (Caste and Race in India, 1932): he did not disagree with the basic argument but found it only partially correct. Using averages alone ignored the variation within each community. Risley’s pattern was broadly true only for northern India; elsewhere inter-group differences in measurements were not large or systematic, so racial groups had long been mixing, except in the Indo-Gangetic plain. ‘Racial purity’ was preserved by the ban on inter-marriage only in ‘Hindustan proper’; in the rest of India endogamy may have been introduced into groups already racially varied.
The racial theory of caste is no longer believed today, but it was considered true in the first half of the 20th century.
4 The definition of caste
Q. “Summarise the social anthropological definition of caste.”
Answer: G.S. Ghurye’s comprehensive definition emphasises six features:
- Segmental division: caste society is divided into closed, mutually exclusive segments; caste is decided by birth and can neither be avoided nor changed.
- Hierarchical division: every caste is either higher or lower than every other; in theory no two castes are equal.
- Restrictions on social interaction: specially on sharing food, governed by ideas of purity and pollution; most dramatically, untouchability.
- Differential rights and duties for different castes, in religious practice and in the secular world.
- Restricted choice of occupation: hereditary, so caste is a rigid form of the division of labour.
- Restrictions on marriage: caste endogamy, with rules of exogamy, which help reproduce the caste system.
The definition made the study of caste more systematic. It was a conceptual definition based on what the classical texts prescribed; in practice many features were changing, though all exist in some form.
5 Living tradition
Q. “What does D.P. Mukerji mean by a ‘living tradition’? Why did he insist that Indian sociologists be rooted in this tradition?”
Answer: A living tradition maintains its links with the past by retaining something from it, while adapting to the present and incorporating new things, so that it evolves over time. Tradition (from ‘to transmit’; parampara, aitihya) is kept alive by retelling stories and myths, but this link with the past does not rule out change; it shows adaptation.
Why sociologists must be rooted in it:
- India’s crucial distinctive feature was its social system: “India had had society, and very little else.” So the first duty of the Indian sociologist was to study and know its social traditions.
- “It is not enough for the Indian sociologist to be a sociologist. He must be an Indian first”, sharing in the folk-ways, mores, customs and traditions, to understand his social system and what lies beneath and beyond it.
- So sociologists should know ‘high’ and ‘low’ languages and cultures: Sanskrit, Persian or Arabic, and also local dialects.
- In the same spirit D.P. criticised unthinking borrowing from western intellectual traditions: tradition was neither to be worshipped nor ignored, and modernity was needed but not to be blindly adopted.
6 Indian culture and change
Q. “What are the specificities of Indian culture and society, and how do they affect the pattern of change?”
Answer: Following D.P. Mukerji:
- Society over-developed: history, politics and economics were less developed than in the west, but the social dimension was ‘over-developed’.
- Not individualistic: the average Indian’s desires are fixed by his socio-cultural group; the system is oriented to group, sect or caste-action, not voluntaristic individual action.
- Strong traditions: rooted in the past through stories and myths, yet adapting.
Effect on change:
- The economy, the commonest internal source of change in the west, has not been as effective in India; class conflict has been “smoothed and covered by caste traditions”. So one of the first tasks is to explain the internal, non-economic causes of change.
- Of the three principles, shruti, smriti and anubhava, generalised anubhava (the collective experience of groups) is the main agent of change: the bhakti movement, and the Sufis in Indian Islam, challenged the high traditions. Anubhava and prem (experience and love), not buddhi-vichar (discursive reason), drive change.
- Because tradition is resilient, conflict produces change without breaking tradition: orthodoxy is challenged by popular revolts, transformed, and the revolts are reabsorbed into the transformed tradition. This is typical of a caste society, where class formation and class consciousness are inhibited.
7 The welfare state
Q. “What is a welfare state? Why is A.R. Desai critical of the claims made on its behalf?”
Answer: In his essay “The myth of the welfare state”, A.R. Desai identifies three features of the welfare state:
- A positive state: unlike the ‘laissez faire’ state, it does not do only the minimum for law and order; it actively designs and implements social policies for the betterment of society.
- A democratic state: democracy, specially multi-party elections, is an essential condition; hence liberal thinkers excluded socialist and communist states.
- A mixed economy: private capitalist and public enterprises co-exist; the state concentrates on basic goods and social infrastructure, private industry on consumer goods.
Why he is critical: from a Marxist perspective, he tested welfare states against five criteria: freedom from poverty, discrimination and insecurity for all; reduction of income inequality; making the profit motive subservient to community needs; stable development free from booms and depressions; employment for all. Examining Britain, the USA and much of Europe, he found their claims greatly exaggerated: they fail to give minimum economic and social security, cannot reduce inequality and often encourage it, cannot ensure stable development free from market fluctuations, and suffer excess economic capacity and high unemployment. So the welfare state is “something of a myth”.
8 The village debate
Q. “What arguments were given for and against the village as a subject of sociological research by M.N. Srinivas and Louis Dumont?”
Answer:
- Against (Louis Dumont): social institutions like caste are more important than the village, which is only a collection of people living in a particular place. Villages may live or die and people may move, but their institutions, like caste or religion, go with them wherever they go. So it would be misleading to give much importance to the village as a category.
- For (M.N. Srinivas): the village is a relevant social entity. Historical evidence shows villages served as a unifying identity and village unity was significant in rural life. He also rejected the British administrator anthropologists’ picture of the village as unchanging, self-sufficient “little republics”: villages had changed considerably, were never self-sufficient, and had economic, social and political relationships at the regional level.
9 Village studies and Srinivas
Q. “What is the significance of village studies in the history of Indian sociology? What role did M.N. Srinivas play in promoting village studies?”
Significance:
- They showed the importance of ethnographic research methods.
- They gave eye-witness accounts of rapid social change in the countryside as the newly independent nation began planned development.
- Urban Indians and policy makers valued these vivid descriptions of the heartland of India.
- They gave sociology a new role in an independent nation: not restricted to ‘primitive’ peoples, it became relevant to a modernising society.
Srinivas’ role: the village was his life-long focus; a year of fieldwork in a village near Mysore was decisive for him. He encouraged and coordinated a major collective effort at ethnographic accounts of villages in the 1950s and 1960s and, with S.C. Dube and D.N. Majumdar, made village studies the dominant field in Indian sociology. He wrote both ethnographic accounts and historical-conceptual discussions of the village, arguing for it as a unit of study in his debate with Louis Dumont.