Class 9 English Chapter 7 Carrier of Words NCERT Solutions in English

Complete solutions to every exercise of NCERT Kaveri, Unit 7: the documentary article “Carrier of Words” and the poem “Words” by Charles Swain, in the order the book prints them. Each question is given in the book’s words, followed by a model answer. The listening answers follow the transcripts printed in the book (pages 272-274). Speaking, discussion and project tasks get a short model response you can adapt.

1 Carrier of Words: Reflect and Respond

Reflect and Respond I

Q. Look at the pictures given below of persons engaged in the same profession. Discuss in pairs and share your answers with your classmates and teacher.
1. Which profession do they belong to?
2. Do they face any difficulties while doing their duty?
3. How does their profession affect the people they meet?

Answer: 1. They are postmen, people who carry and deliver mail.
2. Yes. They walk or ride long distances in heat, rain and cold, carry heavy bags, and often have to reach remote places with poor roads.
3. They connect people with their families and the outside world. They bring letters, news and money, so people depend on them and trust them.

Reflect and Respond II

Q. Discuss in groups.
1. How can ‘words’ be ‘carried’?
2. Who could be a carrier of words?
3. What are the means for people to stay connected?

Answer: 1. Words are carried when they are written down and sent to someone: in letters, postcards, telegrams and money order messages, and today through phone calls, messages and emails.
2. A postman is the best-known carrier of words. A messenger, a phone or the internet can also carry words.
3. Letters and postcards, phone calls, text messages, emails, video calls and social media.

Reflect and Respond III

Q. Read the words given in the box below and place them in their appropriate context in the following passage. (slumped, dunes, defying, hamlets, signals, devoid)

Answer: 1. signals · 2. dunes · 3. hamlets · 4. defying · 5. slumped · 6. devoid
Completed: Immediately, our body sent signals that our decision to visit the sand dunes in the afternoon was insane. We had passed a few hamlets on our way to the desert. We could not find even a single soul outdoors, defying the blazing sun. Even the camels were slumped in the little shade offered by the khejri trees. … as the area was devoid of any other network service.

2 Check Your Understanding (after Part I)

Check Your Understanding I

Q. Khetaram needs to submit information about himself for getting an identity card. While reading the text, fill up the following information sheet for Khetaram.

Name Khetaram
Position Gramin Dak Sewak (the sole postman of his branch post office)
Employer India Post
Official address Somarad Branch Post Office, Rajasthan
Mode of transport used On foot, carrying the mailbag on his shoulders (the sand is so soft that even bicycles can’t ply); the BSF gives him a lift (“the BSF always gives me a lift”)
Key responsibilities (1) Deliver mail to the far-flung dhaanis near the Indo-Pakistan border
(2) Carry the mailbag, which may weigh up to 28 kilos
(3) Deliver the mail within 24 hours of its dispatch from Jodhpur
(4) Be the link between the villagers and their faraway families
Check Your Understanding II

Q. Discuss with your teacher.
1. Why do you think Khetaram has taken up this challenging job?
2. How do you think Khetaram would feel about taking up this challenging task every day?

Answer: 1. He needs the job to support his family. As Part II tells us, famine is “a way of life” in his area, and one crop of bajra cannot feed his family of five. The job also lets him serve the people of his area, who depend on him.
2. He would feel tired, especially in the summer heat, but also proud and satisfied, because he knows people are waiting for his letters and trust him. He later says he is grateful he “can serve the people even after 60”.

3 Check Your Understanding (after Part II)

Check Your Understanding I

Q. Complete the table given below with the situations given in Column 1 and the reasons in Column 2.

Column 1 (Situation) Column 2 (Reason)
The temperature is recorded as 49.9 degrees celsius even when it has crossed 50, and Khetaram keeps delivering. When the temperature is recorded as 50 degrees celsius and above, a state holiday has to be declared.
Khetaram can dwell on any threshold. The villagers trust him. He reads out their letters and writes their replies, so he is warmly received in every home.
BSF always gave Khetaram a lift. People are kind to him, and he delivers the BSF’s dak since their camp came to the area.
Check Your Understanding II

Q. Why was a piece of jaggery offered in the village when he brought news of a birth or weddings?

Answer: The villagers live in a poor, famine-hit area, so “a piece of jaggery is all that can be offered” when he brings news of a birth or weddings.

Check Your Understanding III

Q. How would phone lines help Khetaram in his job?

Answer: The phone lines are now only 50 km away. When they arrive, Khetaram might become a Gramin Sanchar Sewak and carry a cell phone along with the post from home to home.

4 Critical Reflection I: Extracts

Extract 1

Q. “Akaal or famine is a way of life here. In a good year, I get one crop of bajra. That cannot feed my family of five. We would starve without this job,” he says. And for each family which resides in this arid land, survival is partly dependent on money orders remitted by a relative.
(i) Complete the sentence given below with an appropriate reason. One crop of bajra makes a little difference for people like Khetaram because ____.
(ii) Why did Khetaram term famine as ‘a way of life’?
(iii) Give one reason why Khetaram had to take up a job to help his family to survive.
(iv) Complete the analogy given below with a word from the extract. Other families: Money orders:: Khetaram: ____
(v) What would ‘a good year’ signify?

Answer: (i) One crop of bajra makes a little difference for people like Khetaram because it cannot feed a family of five for the whole year.
(ii) Famine comes so often in this dry desert land that people have learnt to live with it as a normal part of their lives.
(iii) Even in a good year his land gives only one crop of bajra, which cannot feed his family of five; without the job they “would starve”.
(iv) job
(v) A good year is one in which Khetaram gets one crop of bajra, instead of a year of famine.

Extract 2

Q. There is one letter delivery he dreads. The envelope with the right corner torn off, which signifies that the missive bears news of death. “Ashubh Samachar cannot be carried into the house,” says Khetaram. So, he stands outside, reads out the letter twice, then tears it to bits. “Bad news must be destroyed,” he mutters philosophically.
(i) Choose the correct option for the following question. Who could have torn the right corner of the envelope? A. Khetaram B. Sender of the letter C. Receiver of the letter D. The postmaster
(ii) Complete the sentence with an appropriate reason. The most likely reason for Khetaram reading the letter twice is because ____.
(iii) What was Khetaram’s philosophy regarding bad news, and how did he act upon it?
(iv) State whether the following sentence is true or false. Khetaram’s action of tearing the letter differed from his beliefs.
(v) Mention any one aspect of Khetaram’s temperament which is revealed through this extract.

Answer: (i) B. Sender of the letter. The torn corner “signifies that the missive bears news of death”, so it is most likely torn by the person who sends that news.
(ii) The most likely reason for Khetaram reading the letter twice is because he will not take it into the house and will tear it up, so he wants the family to hear the sad news clearly before he destroys it.
(iii) His philosophy was that “Bad news must be destroyed” and that “Ashubh Samachar cannot be carried into the house”. So he stood outside the house, read the letter out twice and then tore it to bits.
(iv) False. His action matched his belief: he believed bad news must be destroyed, and he destroyed the letter.
(v) He is sensitive and respectful of the villagers’ beliefs, and calm and philosophical in the face of sorrow.

5 Critical Reflection II

Question 1

Q. Justify the statement made by Postmaster-General, Rajasthan Western Region stating that the role of GDS is ‘invaluable’.

Answer: The role of the GDS is invaluable because, as he says, “they deliver in interior areas that are often inaccessible by any means besides foot.” Khetaram, for example, walks to dhaanis some 120 km beyond the last railhead and 10 km beyond where the road ends in sand. The GDS also serve Ladakh, Lakshadweep and the northeast, and they make up more than 50 per cent of India Post’s workforce. Without them, people in these remote places would have no link with their families, and India Post could not reach its rural depositors.

Question 2

Q. How was the purpose of India Post different from that of the British postal system?

Answer: The British postal system was set up “to relay company dak between administrative centres”, that is, to carry official mail between offices. After independence, the mandate of India Post was “to bring the entire population within the mailing ambit”, to serve every citizen. That is why the number of post offices grew from 25,000 in 1947 to more than a lakh and a half today.

Question 3

Q. People trusted Gramin Dak Sewaks. Support this statement with any two instances from the text.

Answer: (1) When a scheme to scrap the GDS and give their job to patwaris was proposed, it was “summarily rejected”. Budh Singh, a village elder, said, “We knew they would not be able to do the job.”
(2) Khetaram “can dwell on any threshold”. Everyone feels comfortable asking him to read their letters and draft their replies.
(Also: rural depositors entrust their monthly savings to the post office through the GDS.)

Question 4

Q. Infer the most likely reason that Khetaram was grateful to continue as GDS, even after the age of 60.

Answer: The job is his family’s lifeline. In his famine-hit area one crop of bajra cannot feed his family of five, and he says they “would starve without this job”. Since a GDS may serve till 65, he can keep earning an assured income and keep serving the people who depend on him.

Question 5

Q. Explain why the author pays tribute to people like Khetaram.

Answer: People like Khetaram work in the harshest conditions, heat above 50 degrees celsius, sandstorms and heavy loads, to keep remote villages connected with their families. They carry news, money and trust, and help people read and write their letters. The author calls them “a part and parcel of our social fabric” and “a great support”, and so salutes them.

6 Vocabulary and Structures in Context

Vocabulary I

Q. Study the phrases given in Column 1 and match them with their meanings in Column 2. Now, use the phrases from Column 1 in sentences of your own.
1. crumbles into sand 2. give a new lease of life 3. turn into a trickle before drying out 4. bearing words across this desolate geography

Answer: 1-(iii) disappears in the desert · 2-(i) get a chance to continue living · 3-(iv) lessen gradually and then finally stop · 4-(ii) carrying letters to less populated areas
Sentences:
1. The village road crumbles into sand a few kilometres before the dunes.
2. The new job gave my uncle a new lease of life.
3. In May, the little stream turns into a trickle before drying out.
4. The postman has spent years bearing words across this desolate geography.
Note: phrase 3 is not used in the reading passage, so it is matched from its meaning.

Vocabulary II

Q. Identify examples of alliteration and metaphor in the extract given below. Khetaram’s khaki turban and uniform are his only protection against the desert’s furies, the scorching summer winds and swirling sandstorms which turn him into a walking sandman.

Answer: Alliteration: “Khetaram’s khaki” (repeated ‘k’ sound); “scorching summer” and “swirling sandstorms” (repeated ‘s’ sound).
Metaphor: “a walking sandman”: the sand covers him so completely that he is described as a man made of sand. “the desert’s furies” also presents the harsh weather as the anger of the desert.

Vocabulary III

Q. Match the words in Column 1 to what they suggest in Column 2 in the context of the chapter. Now, use the words from Column 1 in sentences of your own.
1. arid 2. concessional 3. gaunt 4. remote 5. desolate

Answer: 1-(iii) farmland without much yield · 2-(i) interest rate for the farmers · 3-(v) farmer waiting for the rains · 4-(ii) corner of the world · 5-(iv) desert stretching far and wide
Sentences:
1. Very little grows on the arid land of the Thar.
2. The bank gave the farmers a loan at a concessional rate.
3. The gaunt farmer looked at the dry sky and waited for the rains.
4. The GDS deliver letters to the most remote villages.
5. The postman walked alone across the desolate desert.
Note: “concessional” and “gaunt” are not used in the reading passage, so they are matched from their meanings.

Vocabulary IV: Present perfect

Q. Now, fill in the blanks by using the present perfect form of the verbs given in the brackets to complete the following paragraph.

Answer: 1. I have just got a collection of postage stamps from my grandfather. He 2. has collected these stamps over a period of 20 years. I 3. have studied most of the stamps in his collection and loved all of them. I 4. have begun my own collection of postage stamps. Grandfather 5. has truly inspired me.
(Rule: has/have + past participle.)

Vocabulary V: Passive voice

Q. Now, complete the following paragraph about the advice given by Khetaram. One example has been done for you.

Answer: To begin with, a lot of stamina will be needed for this job. Next, reading clearly A. must be practised, as you B. will be expected to read out the letters by some of the villagers. Words C. must be written neatly as you D. will be asked to draft replies by some villagers. Full sleeved-shirts and trousers E. must be worn to protect yourself from the heat.
(“should be practised / written / worn” is equally correct.)

7 Carrier of Words: Listen and Respond

Listen and Respond I

Q. You will listen to a girl talking about an event. As you listen, fill in the blank with the suitable word from the brackets. The speaker concluded her talk with a ____. (suggestion/request/advice)

Answer: request. (In the transcript, Bhavna of Grade 9 B ends: “I request all the students to actively participate and make this event a grand success.”)

Listen and Respond II

Q. You will listen to the girl talking about the event again. As you listen, choose the correct option for the following questions.
1. What was the occasion that the speaker was talking about? (i) Letter writing carnival (ii) Philately day (iii) Indian Postal Day
2. India Post is famous for having the most extensive network ____. (i) in India (ii) in the world (iii) among design institutes
3. Letter writing is being revived as this art form has been ____. (i) celebrated (ii) appreciated (iii) forgotten
4. Which of the following will be a part of the letter writing carnival? (i) calligraphy and graphology (ii) origami and designing (iii) letter posting and philately
5. What will the postal department add to the event? (i) interactive demonstrations (ii) theatre and dance (iii) workshop for letter writing

Answer: 1. (iii) Indian Postal Day (celebrated on 10 October)
2. (ii) in the world (the talk calls India Post “the most widely functioning government postal service in the world”)
3. (iii) forgotten (“letter writing, a forgotten art form”)
4. (i) calligraphy and graphology
5. (i) interactive demonstrations

8 Carrier of Words: Speaking Activity

Speaking Activity I

Q. The postcard, inland letter, envelope, and money order form were engaged in a discussion on who the most important one was. In groups of four, select one each and reason with each other logically. You may use the points for discussion given in Column 1 and the cues given in Column 2 to express your opinion.
Column 1 (Points for discussion): utility · cost effective · privacy · space to write · possibility of enclosures
Column 2 (Verbal cues to present opinion): It seems to me that… · Some people say that… · I would like to point out that… · I totally agree that… · That’s one way to look at it but…

Model response: Postcard: “It seems to me that I am the most cost effective of all. A short message reaches anyone for very little money.”
Inland letter: “That’s one way to look at it but I give more space to write, and I fold into my own cover, so the message stays private.”
Envelope: “I would like to point out that only I can carry enclosures, such as photographs or documents, and I give the most privacy.”
Money order form: “Some people say that words are enough, but I carry money to families in remote villages. For many of them, survival depends on me.”
Conclusion: “I totally agree that each of us is useful in a different way.”

9 Carrier of Words: Writing Task

Writing Task I

Q. Now, on behalf of your parents draft an imaginary condolence message for your aunt on the recent passing away of her father.

Answer: 18 September 20XX

Dear Meena,

We are deeply saddened to hear about the passing away of your father. Please accept our heartfelt condolences. We will always remember his kindness and the warmth with which he welcomed our family. We extend our deepest sympathy to you and your family in this hour of grief. May God give eternal peace to the departed soul and strength to all of you to bear this loss.

Yours sincerely,
Rakesh and Sunita

Format checklist: date, salutation, words of sorrow and condolence, a kind memory, prayer for peace and strength, closing and names. Keep it short and gentle.

10 Carrier of Words: Learning Beyond the Text

Learning Beyond the Text I

Q. The unique ‘Daakroom’ carnival was conceptualised by the Ministry of Culture to re-introduce children and larger audiences to letter writing in innovative, creative, and engaging ways.

Note: This is a reading item. Remember: Daakroom was supported by India Post, the Ministry of Culture and Gandhi Smriti and Darshan Samiti, hosted competitions and workshops around writing and post, and aimed at a “digital detox” to revive letter writing.

Learning Beyond the Text II

Q. 1. Study the postage stamps given below and discuss who or what they depict.
2. Work in groups of five. Find information about stamps on the following categories (personalities, celebrations, centenaries, nature, our heritage) and note details as directed. Now, prepare a class board on “Philately–Upholding Our Heritage” with your findings.

Answer: 1. The five stamps, as named on them, show: Sarojini Naidu (poet and freedom fighter; the stamp prints 1879-1949); Kishore Kumar (singer and actor); Teej (a festival); the Painted Stork (a bird); and the Sun Temple, Konark (a monument).
2. Approach: each member takes one category, finds two or three stamps in it, and notes the name and significance (for a personality, the field they belong to). Stick the pictures and notes under five headings on the board, with a title strip “Philately–Upholding Our Heritage”.

Learning Beyond the Text III

Q. In the past, telegram was a mode of fast communication, commonly used to quickly send short and specific messages, such as greetings and condolences. Its pricing structure was based on the number of words to be transmitted, and therefore, needed to be precise. The following form was used for sending such telegrams.

Model: The book prints no separate question here. As practice, a condolence telegram from Sawant Singh would use very few words, for example: DEEPLY GRIEVED KUNWAR UNCLE’S DEMISE. HEARTFELT CONDOLENCES. SAWANT. Every word costs money, so articles and extra words are dropped.

11 Words: Reflect and Respond

Reflect and Respond I

Q. Why are words important? Can we communicate without words? How? Share your answers with your classmates and teacher.

Answer: Words help us share thoughts, feelings and information clearly, and they keep people connected. Yes, we can communicate without words, through facial expressions, gestures, body language, sign language, pictures and emojis. A smile, a hug or a nod often says a lot.

Reflect and Respond II

Q. Use the given sentences as clues to find words from the grid and fill the blanks. One example has been done for you. (My mother summoned me to introduce her friends.)
Horizontal: 1. We eat food to ____ our hunger. 2. The train will ____ from the station at 5.00 p.m. 3. The gardener was removing the ____ to clean the flower beds.
Vertical: 4. The view from the top of the hill was ____ the difficult climb. 5. The herbs and spices ____ flavour to food. 6. Flowers ____ in spring. 7. We enjoyed a delicious ____ after the ceremony.

Answer: Horizontal: 1. satisfy · 2. depart · 3. weeds
Vertical: 4. worth · 5. impart · 6. blossom · 7. feast
(All of these words come from the poem. Note: the printed grid does not show “impart” in one straight line; the answer is clear from the clue and from the poem’s line “Can deeper joy impart”.)

12 Words: Check Your Understanding

Check Your Understanding I

Q. Fill in the blanks with one word from the poem. One example has been done for you.
In this poem, the poet reflects that words fail to truly satisfy what the heart wants to convey. Words are compared to summer birds who 1. ____, leaving nothing behind. The heart, is equated to a 2. ____ who finds that words are as worthless as 3. ____ when needed. He feels that a few sincere words can bring more 4. ____ than many meaningless ones. He adds that a voice that brings happiness to a 5. ____ place does not say much, but the few words it does, are very precious. Moreover, if words could satisfy us, the 6. ____ would celebrate but words often fail to do that. The poem ends on the note that empty words may look impressive with lots of flowers, but they cannot produce anything valuable, like a 7. ____.

Answer: 1. depart · 2. pilgrim · 3. weeds · 4. joy · 5. lonely · 6. world · 7. fruit

Check Your Understanding II.1

Q. Read the poem again. Find any four sets of rhyming words and also write the rhyme scheme of the poem.

Answer: Rhyming sets: heart/depart, needs/weeds, way/say, chest/test (also care/air, earth/worth, said/head, cheer/dear, feast/least, show/grow, root/fruit).
Rhyme scheme: every stanza rhymes abab.

Check Your Understanding II.2

Q. Read the following phrases and sentences taken from the poem. Identify the poetic device in each of them and explain what the poet wants to communicate through their usage.

Line Device What it communicates
(i) But words, like summer birds, depart… Simile Words do not stay; like birds that leave after summer, they vanish and leave nothing behind.
(ii) heart, a pilgrim upon earth… Metaphor The heart is on a long journey through life, always searching for comfort and meaning.
(iii) words are of as little worth / As just so many weeds Simile Empty words are as plentiful and as useless as weeds.
(iv) If words could satisfy the chest … Oft satisfy the least! Antithesis (a contrast between what words could do and what they actually do) Words seem to promise comfort, but when they are really needed they give the least.
(v) The world might hold a feast… Hyperbole The whole world would celebrate if words alone could fill our hearts, which shows how rarely they do.
(vi) Like plants that make a gaudy show / All blossom to the root Simile Showy words are like plants covered in flowers: impressive to look at.
(vii) But whose poor nature cannot grow / One particle of fruit! Simile (completing the plant comparison), with exaggeration in “One particle” “whose” refers to the plants of the same comparison: showy words, like these plants, produce no result at all.
Check Your Understanding II.3

Q. Which words are repeated in the poem? Why does the poet use repetition?

Answer: “words” is repeated the most; “heart” and “satisfy” also recur, and the phrase “If words could satisfy” opens both stanza 1 and stanza 5. The repetition keeps the poem’s two subjects, words and the heart, in focus, stresses the central idea that words often fail the heart, and gives the poem a musical, memorable quality.

Check Your Understanding II.4

Q. The stanzas 4, 5, and 6 end with exclamation marks. Choose the option that displays the emotions being expressed through them.
(i) 4. disillusionment 5. admiration and 6. frustration
(ii) 4. frustration 5. admiration and 6. disillusionment
(iii) 4. admiration 5. frustration and 6. disillusionment
(iv) 4. frustration 5. disillusionment and 6. admiration

Answer: (iii) 4. admiration 5. frustration and 6. disillusionment. Stanza 4 admires the few dear words (“But, oh! those few, how dear!”), stanza 5 is frustrated that words “Oft satisfy the least!”, and stanza 6 shows disillusionment with showy words that bear no fruit.

Check Your Understanding III: Hyperbole

Q. Identify examples of hyperbole from the given lines. If words could satisfy the chest, The world might hold a feast. Work in pairs. Complete the sentences given below with hyperboles.

Answer: Hyperbole: “The world might hold a feast” (the whole world celebrating is an exaggeration).
1. I have tonnes of things to do on this weekend.
2. The player missed the basket by a mile.
3. My mother is so tired that she can sleep for a decade.
4. I will be back in two seconds.

Check Your Understanding IV: Rhythm and metre

Q. Now, listen to the teacher read the poem. As you listen, underline the syllables that are stressed in all the lines of the poem. Share your answers with the teacher.

Answer: Read each line aloud and mark the beats. In every stanza the beat falls on every second syllable: four beats in lines 1 and 3, three in lines 2 and 4. The stressed syllables are shown here in capitals (underline these in your book).
Stanza 1: If WORDS could SA-tis-FY the HEART, / The HEART might FIND less CARE; / But WORDS, like SUM-mer BIRDS, de-PART, / And LEAVE but EMP-ty AIR.
Stanza 3: A LIT-tle SAID, and TRU-ly SAID, / Can DEEP-er JOY im-PART / Than HOSTS of WORDS, which REACH the HEAD, / But NEV-er TOUCH the HEART.
Mark stanzas 2, 4, 5 and 6 the same way as your teacher reads them.

13 Words: Critical Reflection

Extract 1

Q. The heart, a pilgrim upon earth, / Finds often, when it needs, / That words are of as little worth / As just so many weeds.
(i) Why has the poet referred to the heart as ‘a pilgrim’?
(ii) When would a heart ‘need’ words?
(iii) Complete the sentence with an appropriate reason. The words are like weeds because ____.
(iv) Mention two emotions the heart might be experiencing when it finds words to be of ‘little worth’.
(v) What do these lines suggest about the nature of communication?

Answer: (i) Like a pilgrim on a long journey, the heart travels through life searching for comfort, love and meaning.
(ii) A heart needs words in times of sorrow, loneliness or trouble, when it wants comfort and support.
(iii) The words are like weeds because they grow in plenty but are useless when real help is needed.
(iv) Disappointment and loneliness (or sadness).
(v) Real communication needs sincerity. Many empty words do not help anyone; only words that come from the heart can comfort another heart.

Extract 2

Q. If words could satisfy the chest, / The world might hold a feast; / But words, when summoned to the test, / Oft satisfy the least!
(i) How can words ‘satisfy the chest’?
(ii) How can words be ‘summoned to the test’?
(iii) What does ‘the world’ holding ‘a feast’ imply?
(iv) Complete the sentence with an appropriate reason. The poet mentions that words satisfy the least because ____.
(v) Select the word that does not mean the same as ‘oft’. A. always B. usually C. frequently D. often

Answer: (i) Words can satisfy the chest (the heart and its feelings) only when they are sincere and meet a person’s real emotional need.
(ii) Words are summoned to the test when we depend on them in a real situation, such as grief or need, and they must prove their worth.
(iii) It implies great joy and celebration everywhere, because every heart would be content. It is an exaggeration (hyperbole) showing how rarely words alone satisfy.
(iv) The poet mentions that words satisfy the least because, when put to the test, they are often empty and cannot give the heart what it needs.
(v) A. always

Critical Reflection II.1

Q. What is the comparison that the poet draws between words and ’empty air’?

Answer: The poet says words, “like summer birds, depart, / And leave but empty air.” Just as birds fly away after the season and leave the air empty, words pass away quickly and leave nothing behind. They cannot satisfy the heart.

Critical Reflection II.2

Q. According to the poet meaningful words are more precious than a lot of them. Explain.

Answer: The poet says “A little said, and truly said, / Can deeper joy impart / Than hosts of words, which reach the head, / But never touch the heart.” Many words may make sense to the mind, but only a few sincere words reach our feelings. The voice that cheers a lonely home “Hath oft the fewest words to say”, yet “those few” are “dear”. So a few meaningful words are worth more than many.

Critical Reflection II.3

Q. Do you agree that the poet presents contrasting ideas related to ‘words’ in the poem? If yes, why? If no, why not?

Answer: Yes. The poet contrasts two kinds of words. Empty words are like summer birds that depart, like weeds, and like gaudy plants without fruit; they “reach the head” but “never touch the heart”. Sincere words, “A little said, and truly said”, give “deeper joy” and are “dear”. The contrast shows that the value of words depends on the sincerity behind them, not on how many are spoken.

Critical Reflection II.4

Q. The theme of loneliness hovers over the poem. Support this statement with examples from the text.

Answer: The heart is “a pilgrim upon earth”, a lonely traveller searching for comfort. When it needs words, it finds them worthless, which leaves it alone with its feelings. Words “leave but empty air”, an image of emptiness. The poet speaks of “A lonely home” that needs a cheerful voice. These images show a heart that longs for true company and comfort.

Critical Reflection II.5

Q. How does the poet convey the superficial nature of words? What ought to be done to address this?

Answer: The poet shows words as shallow through comparisons: they depart like summer birds, are worth as little as weeds, reach the head but not the heart, and are like plants that “make a gaudy show” but cannot grow “One particle of fruit”. To address this, we should speak less but sincerely, mean what we say, and back our words with feeling and action, because “A little said, and truly said” gives deeper joy.

14 Words: Vocabulary in Context

Vocabulary I

Q. The poet has used some figurative phrases. Match the phrases in Column 1 with their correct meanings in Column 2. Use each phrase in a sentence of your own.

Answer: 1. satisfy the heart: (iv) makes one happy
2. depart and leave but empty air: (vi) makes no impact
3. hosts of words: (i) many words
4. never touch the heart: (v) does not appeal to our emotions
5. wins its sunny way: (ii) cheers up a person
6. plants that cannot grow fruit: (iii) there is no outcome
Sentences:
1. Only a sincere apology can satisfy the heart of a hurt friend.
2. His promises departed and left but empty air.
3. The speaker used hosts of words but said very little.
4. Speeches full of big words often never touch the heart.
5. Her cheerful greeting always wins its sunny way into the room.
6. Plans that are never acted upon are like plants that cannot grow fruit.

Vocabulary II: Word maps

Q. Create a ‘Word Map’ for each of the words from the poem given in the box. (depart, pilgrim, cheer, word, sunny, satisfy, heart; ‘cheer’ is done in the book.)

Word Meaning Synonym Antonym Sentence Sketch
depart to go away, to leave leave arrive The train will depart at 5 p.m. a bird flying away
pilgrim a person who travels to a holy place devotee, traveller no exact antonym (a stay-at-home) The pilgrim walked for days to reach the temple. a walker with a stick and bag
word a single unit of language that has a meaning term silence (in the sense of no words) Choose every word with care. a speech bubble
sunny bright with sunshine; cheerful bright, cheerful gloomy She has a sunny smile. a shining sun
satisfy to fulfil a need or wish please, fulfil disappoint A glass of water can satisfy your thirst. a full plate
heart the organ that pumps blood; the centre of feelings soul, core mind (as in head versus heart) Her kind words touched my heart. a heart shape

15 Words: Listen and Respond

Listen and Respond I

Q. You will listen to a conversation between a girl and a boy. As you listen, mark four statements from 1-6 that are true.
1. The girl was excited to participate in the declamation contest.
2. The boy was doubtful about the suitability of the topic chosen for the contest.
3. The girl explained that people prefer to keep their personal experiences to themselves.
4. The boy was unaware of the role played by body language in reflecting the speaker’s confidence.
5. According to the girl, body language had an insignificant role to play in communication.
6. The girl had issued the book on body language earlier from the library.

Answer: True: 1, 2 and 4.
1. True: asked if she is participating, Sonali says “Of course, I am. I was among the first few students to register for the contest.”
2. True: Vivek asks, “Do you think it is a topic that can lead to an engaging talk?”
4. True: when she mentions body language, he asks, “Body language? How?”
3. False: she says we want to “share information with others or express ideas and relate our experiences with them.”
5. False: she says communication “takes place not only with words but also with gestures and postures”.
6. Not said in the conversation: Sonali only tells Vivek that he will find books on body language “in the reference section” and may “request the librarian to issue it.”

16 Words: Speaking Activity

Speaking Activity I

Q. Read the following quotations and select the one you like the most. Explain the quotation and share the reason for your choice with your classmates and teacher. You may talk about a connected personal experience too.

Model response: I chose “Saying nothing… sometimes says the most.” by Emily Dickinson because it matches the poem “Words”. It means that silence can express feelings better than a flood of words. When my friend lost her grandmother, I did not know what to say, so I simply sat with her and held her hand. Later she told me that my silent company comforted her more than any words.

The quotations and their speakers, as printed: Gautama Buddha (“Whatever words we utter…”), Swami Vivekananda (“We are what our thoughts have made us…”), Mahatma Gandhi (“It is better in prayer…”), Martin Luther King, Jr. (“In the End, we will remember…”), Kalpana Chawla (“The path from dreams to success does exist…”), Homer (“Words empty as the wind…”), Emily Dickinson (“Saying nothing…”), Walt Whitman (“The words of my book nothing…”).

17 Words: Writing Task

Writing Task I

Q. Write an essay on any one quotation from speaking activity. Follow the guidelines given below while drafting the essay. (Introduction; Body of the essay, paragraphs 2 and 3; Counterargument; Conclusion)

Model essay: Choosing Our Words with Care

Introduction: Gautama Buddha said, “Whatever words we utter should be chosen with care for people will hear them and be influenced by them for good or ill.” This quotation appeals to me because I have seen how a single sentence can lift someone up or hurt them deeply. In this essay I will explain why our words need care.

Body 1: Words shape how people feel. A teacher’s kind remark can give a shy student the courage to speak in class. For instance, when my teacher told me my handwriting had improved, I began to enjoy writing.

Body 2: In addition to feelings, words shape actions. Rumours spread by careless talk can break friendships, while an honest word of advice can stop someone from making a mistake. However, once a hurtful word is spoken, it cannot be taken back.

Counterargument: Some people say that choosing words too carefully makes us hide the truth. This criticism does not hold, because the Buddha does not ask us to lie; he asks us to speak the truth kindly and at the right time.

Conclusion: Words can heal or harm. Consequently, we should think before we speak and choose words that do good. Finally, as the poet Charles Swain reminds us, a few words said truly are worth more than many said carelessly.

18 Words: Learning Beyond the Text

Learning Beyond the Text I

Q. In groups of six, follow the instructions to play the ‘Non-verbal’ game.

Approach: Each student writes or draws an emoji with an expression on one slip and a gesture on the other. Jumble the slips and keep them upside down. In turns, pick a slip and act it out in 30 seconds without speaking. The first person to identify the expression or gesture gets 10 points. Play two rounds and find the Non-verbal Champion. The game is like Dumb Charades, and it shows that we can communicate without words.

Learning Beyond the Text II

Q. Do you know? The French priest Charles-Michel de l’Épée (1712-89) is recognised as ‘The Father of Sign Language and Deaf Education’.

Note: A fact to remember. Sign language lets people communicate through hand signs, which links to Reflect and Respond I: we can communicate without spoken words.

Learning Beyond the Text III

Q. You must have read poems and songs in English and in your own language. Now, read and enjoy the poem given below. (“Weigh Your Words” by E. F. Hayward)

Note: The poem advises us to “weigh” our words and speak only what we mean. Idle words and careless promises can make a heart ache, and a word once “written on a heart” can never be erased. Its message matches “Words”: fewer, sincere words mean “a whole lot more”.