All the questions the NCERT textbook Exploration, Chapter 6, “How Forces Affect Motion”, asks inside the chapter (Think It Over, What if, all ten Pause and Ponder questions, Think as a Scientist and Activities 6.1 to 6.7), then all sixteen exercise questions of “Revise, Reflect, Refine” exactly as they are printed in the book, and finally The Journey Beyond, with a model answer under each question. Write your own answer first, then compare.
1 Think It Over
Q. (a) Why does a canoe move forward when the canoeist pushes water backwards with their paddle and why does it move faster when they push harder? (b) Suppose the same canoeist uses the same paddle force in two different canoes, one empty and one carrying another passenger. In which case will the canoe move faster?
Answer: (a) When the canoeist pushes the water backwards with the paddle, the water pushes the paddle forward with an equal force (Newton’s third law). The two forces act on different objects, so they do not cancel; the forward force on the paddle moves the paddle and the canoe forward. Pushing harder makes this forward force larger, so the canoe’s velocity increases more.
(b) The empty canoe moves faster. For the same force, acceleration is inversely proportional to mass (a = F/m, Newton’s second law). The canoe carrying a passenger has more mass, so it gets a smaller acceleration.
2 Pause and Ponder 1 and 2: Balanced or unbalanced?
Q. A weightlifter lifts a barbell (Fig. 6.8). List two forces that are acting on the barbell. Are these forces balanced if the weightlifter keeps the barbell steady?
Answer: The two forces are (i) the gravitational force (weight) of the barbell, acting downwards, and (ii) the force applied by the weightlifter, acting upwards. If she keeps the barbell steady, it is at rest and does not move, so yes, the two forces are balanced: they are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction, and the net force is zero.
Q. Two players R and S are participating in an arm-wrestling match (Fig. 6.9). At the instant, when the arms tilt to the front direction (out of the page towards you), are the forces exerted by the players balanced? If not, which player exerted the larger force?
Answer: No, the forces are not balanced. If they were balanced, the clasped hands would not move. The hands move towards the front, so the net force on them acts towards the front, and the player whose push on the hands is directed towards the front (out of the page) exerted the larger force. To name that player, see from the arm positions in Fig. 6.9 which of R and S is pushing the clasped hands in that direction.
3 What if the force of friction disappears?
Q. What if the force of friction disappears in the world? How will the motion of objects be impacted?
Answer: An object once set moving would never slow down by itself: with no friction and no other opposing force, it would keep moving with a constant velocity (Newton’s first law). At the same time, many everyday motions would become impossible. We could not walk or run, because the forward push on our feet comes from friction with the ground; our feet would simply slip backwards. Vehicles could not start, turn or stop, since their tyres would only spin or slide. Nobody could climb a tree, and objects could not be held in the hand, because all of these depend on friction.
4 Activity 6.1: A stack of coins on different surfaces
Q. A stack of four coins is pushed back against a stretched rubber band to the mark C and released, first on a wooden table top, then on a laminated table top, then on a polished marble or tiled floor. After losing contact with the rubber band, does the velocity of the stack decrease gradually until it comes to rest? Does it travel a larger distance on the laminated table top than on the wooden table top, and does its velocity decrease more slowly? Does it travel an even larger distance on the polished marble or tile floor? What conclusion do you draw from your observations?
Answer (expected result): Yes. Once the stack leaves the rubber band, its velocity decreases gradually and it stops after some distance, because the force of friction acts on it opposite to its motion. It travels a larger distance on the laminated table top than on the wooden one, and an even larger distance on the polished marble or tile floor, with its velocity decreasing more slowly each time.
Conclusion: the rubber band is stretched by the same amount every time, yet the distance changes, so the force of friction is different on different surfaces. Where the force of friction is smaller, the velocity decreases more slowly and the stack travels a larger distance before coming to rest.
5 Activity 6.2: Measuring friction with a spring balance
Q. A wooden block attached to a spring balance is pulled with gradually increasing force, and the reading is noted when the block just starts moving. What does this reading indicate? If the velocity of the block is neither increasing nor decreasing, what can you say about the net force acting on the block? Does the reading of the spring balance indicate the magnitude of the force of friction? Compare the readings for all four surfaces: are they different? Is the reading smallest for the surface on which the stack of coins travelled the largest distance, and largest for the surface on which the distance was smallest?
Answer: Only two forces act on the block along the surface: the force applied by the spring and the force of friction. If the block’s velocity is neither increasing nor decreasing, the net force on it is zero, so the spring’s force is equal to the force of friction. The reading of the spring balance therefore gives an approximate measure of the force of friction between the block and the surface.
The readings are different for different surfaces. The reading is smallest on the polished marble or tile floor, where the coins travelled the largest distance, and largest on the surface where they travelled the smallest distance. A smaller reading means a smaller force of friction.
6 Think as a Scientist: A thought experiment with no friction
Q. Suppose you find an object and a horizontal floor having such smooth surfaces that the force of friction between them is zero. Imagine, what will happen if you repeat steps 3 and 4 of Activity 6.1 with such an object and a horizontal floor? Will the velocity of the object decrease? Will the object ever come to rest or continue moving forever?
Answer: Once the object leaves the rubber band, no force acts on it along the floor (there is no friction), so the net force on it is zero. Its velocity will not decrease, and it will never come to rest: it will continue moving forever with a constant velocity. This is exactly what Galileo argued through his thought experiments, and it is the idea behind Newton’s first law of motion.
7 Pause and Ponder 3 to 5: Zero net force
Q. An object is moving with a constant velocity. Is there a net force acting upon it?
Answer: No. Constant velocity means zero acceleration, so by Newton’s first law (and the second law, F = ma) the net force on the object is zero. Forces may act on it, but they balance each other.
Q. Suppose, no net force is acting on an object. Which of the following situations are possible?
(i) Object remains at rest if at rest.
(ii) Object keeps moving with a constant velocity if already moving.
(iii) Object is moving with a constant acceleration.
Answer: Situations (i) and (ii) are possible. Situation (iii) is not possible: an object with no net force acting on it has zero acceleration, so it cannot be accelerating.
Q. In the real world, it is difficult to find a situation where no forces are acting on an object. But by applying additional forces, a condition can be achieved where the net force on the object is zero. Explain with the help of an example.
Answer: A box moving on the floor slows down and stops because the force of friction acts on it. If a person pushes the moving box forward with a force exactly equal to the force of friction, the two forces are equal and opposite and balance each other. The net force on the box becomes zero, and the box keeps moving with a constant velocity. Other examples: a weightlifter holding a barbell steady (her upward force balances its weight), or two teams in a tug of war pulling with equal force.
8 Activity 6.3 and Think as a Scientist: More force, more acceleration
Q. Based on your experiences, you can make a hypothesis: for the same object, a larger force results in larger acceleration. How can you test your hypothesis? (In Activity 6.3 a cart is pulled across a table by a thread passing over a pipe to a cup holding objects. The time T1 to cover the table is recorded; the mass in the cup is then doubled and the time T2 is recorded.) What do you find?
Answer: The hypothesis is tested by applying forces of different magnitudes on the same object on the same surface and finding the acceleration in each case. The weight of the cup and the objects in it pulls the cart with a constant force, and doubling the mass in the cup doubles this force.
The cart starts from rest and covers the same distance s both times, so s = ½a1T12 = ½a2T22, which gives a1/a2 = T22/T12. With the larger force the cart takes less time (T2 is smaller than T1), so a2 is larger than a1.
Conclusion: the acceleration of an object of fixed mass increases as the net force on it increases. Doubling the force should double the acceleration; in practice the increase is a little less than two times, because of measurement errors and the friction between the cart’s wheels and the surface.
9 Activity 6.4 and Think as a Scientist: More mass, less acceleration
Q. Apart from force, does acceleration depend on any other factor? For the same force, a smaller mass has a larger acceleration: how can you test this second hypothesis? (In Activity 6.4 the mass in the cup is kept constant and the mass of the cart is doubled.) Using the values of time measured, find the ratio of acceleration for these two cases. Do you find that for the same force, when you increased the mass of the cart, the acceleration decreased?
Answer: Yes, acceleration also depends on the mass of the object. The hypothesis is tested by keeping the force the same (same cup and objects) and changing only the mass of the cart. Here let a1 and T1 be for the original cart, and a2 and T2 for the cart with doubled mass. The heavier cart takes a longer time to cover the same distance (T2 is larger than T1), so the ratio a1/a2 = T22/T12 comes out greater than 1: the acceleration decreased. Ideally it should be halved; the measured value is slightly different because of measurement errors and friction. So, for a given force, the acceleration produced is inversely related to the mass of the object.
10 Pause and Ponder 6 to 8: Using the second law
Q. A toy car of mass 100 g is moving with a constant velocity of 0.5 m s−1. What is the net force acting on the toy car?
Answer: The velocity is constant, so the acceleration is zero. Net force F = ma = 0.1 kg × 0 = 0 N. The mass and the value of the velocity do not matter here.
Q. Two children of different masses are sitting on identical swings. To impart identical initial acceleration, for which child would you require to apply a larger force? Explain why.
Answer: A larger force is needed for the child with the larger mass. By Newton’s second law, F = ma: for the same acceleration a, the force needed is proportional to the mass m, so the heavier child needs a larger force.
Q. How are glass items packed for transportation using a bubble wrap or hay protected from damage?
Answer: During transport, a jerk or a fall can bring a glass item’s motion to a sudden stop. Bubble wrap or hay is soft and compressible, so it increases the time over which the item’s velocity changes. A longer time means a smaller acceleration, and so a smaller force acts on the glass (F = ma). The smaller force does not break the glass, just as a fielder pulls the hands back while catching a ball, or an airbag cushions a passenger.
11 Activity 6.5: Pushing and pulling a table from a chair with wheels
Q. Sitting on a chair with wheels with your legs raised, push a heavy table away from you. What happens to you? Does the chair move in the opposite direction? Now pull the table towards you: in which direction does your chair move now? What conclusion can you draw from this activity?
Answer: When you push the table away, you and the chair move backwards, in the direction opposite to your push. When you pull the table towards you, you and the chair move towards the table.
Conclusion: each time you applied a force on the table, the table applied a force on you in the opposite direction. Forces always come in pairs acting on two different objects, which is Newton’s third law of motion.
12 Activity 6.6: Two spring balances pulling each other
Q. Two identical spring balances are connected by their hooks; one is held fixed and the free end of the other is pulled. Predict what will be the readings of their scales if the spring balances are stationary. Is your observation the same as your prediction? The readings of the two spring balances are the same every time: what does it indicate?
Answer: Prediction: both balances will show the same reading. The observation agrees with the prediction every time, whatever force is applied. This indicates that the forces the two spring balances apply on each other, in opposite directions, are equal in magnitude, as Newton’s third law states.
13 Activity 6.7: The balloon on a thread
Q. An inflated balloon with a straw stuck on it hangs on a taut thread passing through the straw. The thread tied at the neck of the balloon is removed. Observe in which direction the straw and the balloon move.
Answer: The balloon and the straw move along the thread in the direction opposite to the direction in which the air rushes out of the neck. The stretched material of the balloon pushes the air out as it shrinks; the air rushing out exerts an equal and opposite force on the balloon (Newton’s third law), and this force moves the balloon. A rocket moves in the same way, by expelling gas.
14 Pause and Ponder 9 and 10: The third law at work
Q. Why does a fireperson sometimes struggle when holding the pipe issuing water?
Answer: The pipe pushes a large amount of water forward at high speed. By Newton’s third law, the water pushes back on the pipe with an equal and opposite force, so the pipe is pushed backwards. The fireperson has to apply a large force to hold the pipe steady against this backward force, which is why it is a struggle.
Q. Suppose a spacecraft is moving in a region of space where the gravitational force acting upon it is negligible. Suggest how can it change its velocity.
Answer: It can fire its engine to expel gas. By Newton’s third law, the expelled gas pushes the spacecraft in the opposite direction. To speed up, it expels gas backwards (opposite to its motion); to slow down, it fires the engine in the direction of its motion, as the Vikram lander of Chandrayaan-3 did before landing on the Moon; to change direction, it expels gas sideways.
15 Friction on a table pushed at constant velocity
Q. Using a horizontal force F, a table is moved across the floor at a constant velocity. How much is the frictional force exerted by the floor on the table?
Answer: Since the table moves at a constant velocity, its acceleration is zero. By Newton’s first law (equivalently, the second law with a = 0), the net force acting on it must also be zero. The only other horizontal force on the table besides the applied push F is friction from the floor, so friction must be equal in magnitude to F and act in the opposite direction, opposing the table’s motion.
16 A ball on a frictionless surface
Q. For a ball moving on a smooth frictionless surface, choose the appropriate option that will make the following statements physically correct.
(i) If no net force is applied on the ball, the velocity of the ball will remain the same/increase/decrease.
(ii) If a net force is applied on the ball in the direction of its motion, the magnitude of the velocity of the ball will remain the same/increase/decrease.
(iii) If a net force is applied on the ball in a direction opposite to the direction of its motion, the magnitude of the velocity of the ball will remain the same/increase/decrease.
Answer:
(i) remain the same. With no net force acting and no friction on this surface, Newton’s first law says the ball keeps moving at its existing, constant velocity.
(ii) increase. A net force in the direction of motion accelerates the ball in that same direction, so its speed increases.
(iii) decrease. A net force opposite to the motion decelerates the ball, so its speed decreases.
17 Blocks P and Q
Q. Two blocks P and Q on a smooth horizontal surface are shown in Fig. 6.36a and Fig. 6.36b. Two forces of magnitudes 4 N and 5 N are acting in opposite directions on block P, while block Q is moving with a constant velocity. Which of the following statement is correct?
(i) P experiences a net force and Q does not experience a net force.
(ii) P does not experience a net force and Q experiences a net force.
(iii) Both P and Q experience a net force.
(iv) Neither P nor Q experiences a net force.
Answer: Statement (i) is correct. The two forces on P (4 N and 5 N, opposite directions) are unequal, so they do not cancel; P experiences a net force of 1 N in the direction of the 5 N force. Q moves at a constant velocity, which by Newton’s first law means the net force acting on it is zero.
18 The snake boat race
Q. While practising for the snake boat race (Vallum kalli in Kerala), 100 oarsmen are rowing a boat together. Out of these, 95 row backwards to propel the boat forward. But by mistake, 5 oarsmen row in the opposite direction. If each oarsman applies a horizontal force of 200 N, what is the net force on the snake boat? (Ignore drag forces, air friction, etc.)
Answer: The 95 correctly-rowing oarsmen push the boat forward with a total force of 95 × 200 N = 19,000 N. The 5 oarsmen rowing the wrong way push with a total of 5 × 200 N = 1,000 N in the opposite direction. The net force is the difference of these two: 19,000 N − 1,000 N = 18,000 N, in the forward direction.
19 Direction and proportionality of acceleration
Q. When a net force acts on an object, we observe that the object accelerates:
(i) opposite to the direction of force, with acceleration proportional to the force acting on the object.
(ii) opposite to the direction of force, with acceleration proportional to the mass of the object.
(iii) in the direction of force, with acceleration inversely proportional to the force acting on the object.
(iv) in the direction of force, with acceleration proportional to the force acting on the object.
Answer: Option (iv) is correct. Newton’s second law states that an object accelerates in the direction of the net force acting on it, and that this acceleration is directly proportional to the force (and inversely proportional to the object’s mass, though that part is not what this option asks about).
20 Position-time graphs of four objects
Q. The position-time graph for four objects A, B, C and D moving along a straight line are given in Fig. 6.37. A net force acts on: (i) Object A (ii) Object B (iii) Object C (iv) Object D
Answer: A net force acts only on Object C. Object A’s graph is a straight line with a constant positive slope (constant velocity, zero net force). Object B’s graph is a flat horizontal line (the object stays at rest, zero net force). Object C’s graph is a curve that gets steeper with time (its slope, the velocity, keeps increasing, which means it is accelerating, so a net force must be acting on it). Object D’s graph is a straight line with a constant negative slope (constant velocity in the negative direction, zero net force).
21 The sailor jumping from the boat
Q. A sailor jumps out from a small boat to the shore (Fig. 6.38). As the sailor jumps forward, will the boat move? If yes, in which direction and why.
Answer: Yes, the boat will move, backward (away from the shore, opposite to the sailor’s jump). To jump forward, the sailor pushes backward against the boat with their feet. By Newton’s third law, the boat exerts an equal and opposite force on the sailor, pushing them forward; at the same time, the sailor’s backward push on the boat sends the boat moving backward.
22 The high jump landing mat
Q. During a high jump event, a landing mat or sand bed is placed for the athlete to fall upon (Fig. 6.39). Explain the reason behind it.
Answer: The mat or sand bed increases the time over which the athlete’s fall is brought to a stop. The athlete’s velocity has to drop to zero either way, but over a longer time the magnitude of the acceleration is smaller, so by Newton’s second law (F = ma) a smaller force acts on the athlete’s body. This lowers the risk of injury, for the same reason a fielder pulls the hands back while catching a fast ball.
23 Colliding hand carts
Q. A hand cart loaded with vegetables collides with an identical but empty hand cart. During the collision:
(i) the loaded cart exerts a force of larger magnitude on the empty cart.
(ii) the empty cart exerts a force of larger magnitude on the loaded cart.
(iii) neither cart exerts a force on the other.
(iv) the loaded cart and the empty cart, both exert an equal magnitude of force on each other.
Answer: Option (iv) is correct. By Newton’s third law, whenever one cart exerts a force on the other during the collision, the second cart exerts an equal and opposite force on the first, regardless of how loaded either cart is. (The two carts’ accelerations will still differ, since the loaded cart has more mass, but the forces themselves are equal.)
24 Plotting the force-mass graph
Q. The acceleration-mass graph for the acceleration produced by a force on objects of different masses is plotted in Fig. 6.40. Plot the force-mass graph for this case.
Answer: Fig. 6.40 shows a curve falling from about 10 m/s² at 1 kg to about 2 m/s² at 5 kg, which is the shape a = F/m takes for a constant force. Reading the force from the 1 kg point: F = ma = 1 × 10 = 10 N, and this is confirmed by the other points on the curve (for example, at 4 kg the graph shows a = 2.5 m/s², and 4 × 2.5 = 10 N again). Since the same force of 10 N was used to produce every point on the acceleration-mass graph, the force-mass graph is a horizontal straight line at F = 10 N, for every mass value from 1 kg to 5 kg: force does not depend on mass here, only acceleration does.
25 Force from a velocity-time graph
Q. The velocity-time graph of an object of mass 10 kg moving along a straight line is shown in Fig. 6.41. Calculate the force acting on the object by using the graph.
Answer: Fig. 6.41 is a straight line rising from 10 m/s at t = 0 s to 30 m/s at t = 8 s. The acceleration is the graph’s slope: a = (30 − 10)/8 = 20/8 = 2.5 m/s². The force is then F = ma = 10 × 2.5 = 25 N, acting in the direction of motion.
26 The bullet and the wooden block
Q. A bullet of mass 50 g moving with a speed of 100 m/s enters a heavy stationary wooden block and stops after penetrating a distance of 50 cm. Estimate the stopping force acting on the bullet (assume that the bullet undergoes constant acceleration within the block).
Answer: Given: mass m = 50 g = 0.05 kg, initial speed u = 100 m/s, final speed v = 0, distance s = 50 cm = 0.5 m.
Using v² = u² + 2as: 0 = (100)² + 2 × a × 0.5, so 0 = 10,000 + a, giving a = −10,000 m/s² (a deceleration).
Magnitude of the stopping force: F = ma = 0.05 × 10,000 = 500 N, acting opposite to the bullet’s motion.
27 The footballer’s penalty kick
Q. An ace footballer converted a penalty shot by kicking the football with a speed of 108 km/h. The estimated force they imparted was 800 N. The mass of the football was 0.4 kg. Calculate the time of contact between their foot and the ball.
Answer: First convert the speed: 108 km/h = 108 × 1000/3600 = 30 m/s. The ball starts at rest (u = 0) and reaches v = 30 m/s.
Acceleration produced by the force: a = F/m = 800/0.4 = 2000 m/s².
Time of contact: using v = u + at, 30 = 0 + 2000 × t, so t = 30/2000 = 0.015 s (15 milliseconds).
28 Distance travelled in a rough patch
Q. An object of mass 2 kg moving with a constant velocity of 10 m/s encounters a rough patch where the force of friction on the object is 7 N. At the same time, an additional constant force of 3 N opposing the motion is applied on the object. After entering the rough patch, how much distance does the object travel before coming to rest?
Answer: Both the 7 N friction and the 3 N applied force oppose the object’s motion, so the total opposing force = 7 + 3 = 10 N.
Deceleration: a = F/m = 10/2 = 5 m/s² (taking the direction of motion as positive, a = −5 m/s²).
Using v² = u² + 2as with u = 10 m/s and v = 0: 0 = (10)² − 2 × 5 × s, so 0 = 100 − 10s, giving s = 10 m.
29 The tractor, the harrow and the trolley
Q. A tractor pulls a harrow (a ploughing tool) of mass m1 with a net force F resulting in an acceleration of a1. The same tractor pulls a trolley of mass m2 with a force F producing an acceleration of a2. If the tractor now pulls the trolley with the harrow placed on it (with the same force F), then obtain an expression for the resulting acceleration in terms of a1 and a2. Ignore friction.
Answer: From Newton’s second law applied separately: F = m1a1, so m1 = F/a1. Also F = m2a2, so m2 = F/a2.
With the harrow placed on the trolley, the same force F now pulls the combined mass (m1 + m2), so the new acceleration a is:
a = F / (m1 + m2) = F / (F/a1 + F/a2) = 1 / (1/a1 + 1/a2)
a = (a1 × a2) / (a1 + a2)
30 The bar magnet and the compass needle
Q. When the pole of a bar magnet is brought close to a magnetic compass, the bar magnet and the compass needle (which is also a magnet) exert a magnetic force on each other. As per Newton’s third law of motion, both the forces are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction. However, the compass needle moves, whereas the bar magnet does not move (Fig. 6.42). Explain why.
Answer: Equal forces do not produce equal accelerations unless the masses are also equal (Newton’s second law, a = F/m). The compass needle is a small, light magnet that can turn freely, so the force gives it a large, easily visible acceleration (it swings around). A bar magnet usually has a much larger mass than the needle, so the same force gives it an acceleration (a = F/m) too small to notice, and it does not appear to move. (The book gives no masses for these magnets; this is the reasoning, not a measured result.)
31 The Journey Beyond
Q. (a) Does the force of friction also depend on how hard the surfaces press each other? Is the friction acting on an object that is about to move larger than the friction after motion begins? Is the friction which acts on a rolling object less than that on a sliding object? (b) Two toy cars of equal mass, each carrying a bar magnet, are placed with like poles touching and released. Did the cars travel equal distances in opposite directions? What happens when equal masses are added to both cars?
Answer: (a) Yes to all three. The harder the two surfaces press against each other, the larger the force of friction. The friction on an object that is just about to move is larger than the friction once it is sliding, which is why it is harder to start pushing a heavy box than to keep it moving. The friction on a rolling object is much less than on a sliding one, which is why the invention of the wheel was such a major milestone.
(b) The two magnets push each other with equal and opposite forces (Newton’s third law). Since the cars have equal masses, they get equal accelerations and travel equal distances in opposite directions. Expected result: when equal masses are added to both cars, the same forces produce smaller accelerations, so each car travels a smaller distance and the graph of distance travelled against mass slopes downwards. Record your own readings to check this.
Q. (c) Wrap a rope once around a rough tree branch or post, attach a heavy bucket to one end and try to hold it by the other end (Fig. 6.43). Now add one more turn of the rope and repeat. What do you find?
Answer: Each extra turn increases the ‘grip’ between the rope and the branch. This increases the friction and reduces the force required, so it becomes much easier to hold the same load. The reduction in effort is much larger than you might expect from adding just one turn: friction does not increase in a simple linear way, and small changes in contact can lead to large changes in force. In the same way, friction between a rope and a post allows large ships to be held safely at a pier.
(d) The book also suggests reading excerpts from Newton’s original work, the Principia, to see how he formulated the laws of motion; the original text and commentaries are available online. This is a reading suggestion, not a question.