Class 11 English Book 1 Chapter 13 A Photograph NCERT Solutions in English

Complete solutions to every exercise the NCERT Hornbill book prints with the poem “A Photograph” by Shirley Toulson: the word-meaning task and all seven “Think it out” questions, worded exactly as in the book, with a full model answer under each. Write your own answer first, then compare.

1 Infer the Meanings

Word Task

Q. Infer the meanings of the following words from the context.
paddling
transient
Now look up the dictionary to see if your inference is right.

Answer:
• paddling: In “the two girl cousins went paddling”, the girls are at the beach with their feet in the sea, so the word means walking about in shallow water at the edge of the sea. The dictionary agrees: to paddle is to walk with bare feet in shallow water.
• transient: In “Washed their terribly transient feet”, the girls’ feet are set against the sea, which “appears to have changed less”. So “transient” must mean the opposite of lasting: short-lived, passing. The dictionary gives “lasting only for a short time”.

2 Think It Out

Question 1

Q. What does the word ‘cardboard’ denote in the poem? Why has this word been used?

Answer: “Cardboard” denotes the old photograph, which is printed and mounted on stiff card. The poet names the material instead of saying “photograph” to show how old the picture is, and to stress that this card is the only picture of her mother as a young girl.

Question 2

Q. What has the camera captured?

Answer: The camera has captured a moment from the mother’s childhood. The mother, about twelve, stands paddling in the sea with her two girl cousins, Betty and Dolly, each holding one of her hands. All three have stood still to smile “through their hair” at “the uncle with the camera”.

Question 3

Q. What has not changed over the years? Does this suggest something to you?

Answer: The sea has not changed, or rather it “appears to have changed less” than the people in the photograph. Yes, this suggests that nature is lasting while human life is short. The girls whose feet the sea washed have grown up, and the poet’s mother has died, but the sea goes on. The sea, which appears to have changed less, sets the girls’ brief lives in contrast, and that contrast brings out the poet’s word “transient”.

Question 4

Q. The poet’s mother laughed at the snapshot. What did this laugh indicate?

Answer: The laugh showed that the mother was amused at the way she and her cousins had been dressed for the beach: “look how they / Dressed us for the beach”. The poet calls it “wry”, so the laugh also carried a touch of sadness. One reading is that it showed nostalgia: she was fondly remembering a childhood that could never come back.

Question 5

Q. What is the meaning of the line “Both wry with the laboured ease of loss.”

Answer: “Both” refers to two memories: the sea holiday, which was the mother’s past, and the mother’s laughter, which is now the poet’s past. Both are “wry”, amused but mixed with sadness. The poem does not say what each has lost; one reading is that the mother laughed at a childhood that was gone, and the poet now smiles at the memory of a mother who is gone. In both cases the ease is “laboured”: the calm takes effort, because of loss.

Question 6

Q. What does “this circumstance” refer to?

Answer: “This circumstance” refers to the death of the poet’s mother, who has now been dead “nearly as many years / As that girl lived”, that is, roughly twelve years. The poet feels there is “nothing to say at all” about it.

Question 7

Q. The three stanzas depict three different phases. What are they?

Answer:
• Stanza 1, the mother’s childhood: the photograph shows her at about twelve, paddling at the beach with her two cousins, photographed by an uncle.
• Stanza 2, the mother’s adult years: twenty or thirty years later, the mother laughs at the snapshot and recalls Betty and Dolly and their beach clothes.
• Stanza 3, the present: the mother has been dead nearly as many years as that girl lived, roughly twelve; the poet finds nothing to say about her death, and “Its silence silences.”

Exam Tip

These eight items are everything the book prints with this poem: there is no “Notice the poetic devices” or “Try this out” section for “A Photograph”. The book’s note for teachers adds one point: the poem is placed after “The Portrait of a Lady” “because of the thematic relation between the two”. The book does not name the theme; one reading is that both look at an older family member across time and end in death and silence.