Class 11 English Book 1 Chapter 16 Childhood NCERT Solutions in English

Complete solutions to every question NCERT Hornbill sets on the poem “Childhood” by Markus Natten (Unit 4, page 42). The book’s apparatus for this poem is the four “Think it out” questions answered below; there is no “Before you read” box, no glossary and no other exercise for this poem. Try each answer yourself first, then check.

1 Think It Out

Question 1

Q. Identify the stanza that talks of each of the following.
individuality    rationalism    hypocrisy

Answer:

Idea Stanza Proof from the poem
Individuality Stanza 3 “Was it when I found my mind was really mine, / To use whichever way I choose, / Producing thoughts that were not those of other people / But my own, and mine alone”
Rationalism Stanza 1 “Was it the time I realised that Hell and Heaven, / Could not be found in Geography, / And therefore could not be,”
Hypocrisy Stanza 2 “Was it the time I realised that adults were not / all they seemed to be, / They talked of love and preached of love, / But did not act so lovingly,”

In Stanza 1 the speaker tests a belief against evidence (rationalism). In Stanza 2 he sees that adults preach one thing and do another (hypocrisy). In Stanza 3 he discovers that he can think for himself (individuality).

Question 2

Q. What according to the poem is involved in the process of growing up?

Answer: According to the poem, growing up is not a single event but a series of changes in the way a person thinks and sees the world. The speaker suggests several moments:

  • Getting older: perhaps it was “the day I ceased to be eleven”, when he turned twelve.
  • Learning to reason: he realised that Hell and Heaven “Could not be found in Geography, / And therefore could not be”. He stopped accepting things on belief alone and began to test them by reason.
  • Seeing through adults: he noticed that adults “talked of love and preached of love, / But did not act so lovingly”. He lost his childish trust in grown-ups.
  • Thinking independently: he found that his “mind was really mine”, producing thoughts that were “my own, and mine alone”.

Each of these brings a gain in maturity but costs some of a child’s innocence. In the end that innocence is hidden “in an infant’s face”. So growing up involves reasoning, disillusionment with adults and the growth of individuality, together with the loss of innocence.

Question 3

Q. What is the poet’s feeling towards childhood?

Answer: The poet looks back on childhood with nostalgia, a fond and slightly sad longing for something that is gone. He asks “When did my childhood go?” again and again because he misses it and cannot find the moment it slipped away. In the last stanza he says it went to “some forgotten place, / That’s hidden in an infant’s face”: he can no longer reach that innocence himself and sees it in a baby’s face. He ends with the quiet, honest line “That’s all I know.” He does not reject growing up, but he clearly feels what he has lost, so his feeling is one of tender, wistful regret for the innocence of childhood.

Question 4

Q. Which do you think are the most poetic lines? Why?

Answer: This question asks for your own choice backed by reasons. A strong choice is the closing stanza:

Lines chosen
Where did my childhood go?
It went to some forgotten place,
That’s hidden in an infant’s face,
That’s all I know.

These lines are the most poetic for four reasons:

  • A change in the question: after three stanzas asking “When”, the speaker asks “Where”, showing he has stopped searching for a date and accepted that childhood has gone.
  • Personification: childhood “went” somewhere, as if it were a person who quietly walked away.
  • Imagery: “an infant’s face” gives us a picture of pure innocence, the very thing the speaker has lost through reason, disillusionment and independence.
  • Sound and ending: the soft rhymes “go / know” and “place / face” make the stanza musical, and “That’s all I know.” ends the poem on a gentle, honest note of uncertainty.

(Another acceptable choice is “They talked of love and preached of love, / But did not act so lovingly”, because the repetition of “love” and the sharp contrast with “did not act” expose adult hypocrisy in very few words. Any reasoned choice is acceptable if you quote the lines exactly and give clear reasons.)