Quick-revision summary of Chapter 4: Introducing Western Sociologists (Understanding Society, Class 11, Book 2). For full explanations, read the complete notes.
1 Key definitions
Key definitions
Enlightenment18th century Europe: philosophers rejected the supremacy of religious doctrines, made reason the means to truth and the human being the sole bearer of reason
AlienationIn capitalism, human beings are distanced from nature, other humans, their work and its product, and their own self
Mode of productionA long-lasting system of material production, marked by its means and its relations of production
Social factCollective patterns of behaviour and belief, not created by individuals, that press on them and shape behaviour
Social actionWeber: all meaningful human behaviour
Value neutralityRecord others’ values without being affected by one’s own opinions
Ideal typeA logically consistent model highlighting the most significant features of a social phenomenon
OfficeA public post of impersonal, formal authority that exists apart from the person holding it
2 The context of sociology
- Sociology: child of the ‘age of revolution’, born in 19th century Western Europe.
- Enlightenment (late 17th and 18th c.): human being at the centre, reason, the ‘knowing subject’; secular, scientific and humanistic attitudes.
- French Revolution (1789): sovereignty of individuals and nation-states; Declaration of Human Rights; serfs freed; public vs private (education public, religion and family private); liberty, equality, fraternity.
- Industrial Revolution (Britain, late 18th and early 19th c.): science and technology in production (Spinning Jenny, steam engine) + new organisation of labour and markets; factories, cities, slums; state’s need for knowledge; sociology the ‘science of the new industrial society’.
3 Karl Marx (1818-1883)
- Germany; exile in Britain; met Engels 1844; Communist Manifesto (with Engels); Eighteenth Brumaire 1852; Critique of Political Economy 1859; Capital Vol. I 1867; Highgate Cemetery 1883.
- Scientific socialism; stages: primitive communism → slavery → feudalism → capitalism → socialism.
- Alienation: from nature, from each other, from the fruits of labour and the work process, from oneself.
- Capitalism: exploitative, yet a necessary and progressive stage.
- Base = productive forces (land, labour, technology, energy) + production relations (labour organisation, property relations). Superstructure = religion, art, law, literature, ideas. Material life shapes ideas.
4 Class struggle
1Same position in production → a class
↓
2Class consciousness, through political mobilisation
↓
3Class conflict → overthrow of the ruling class = revolution
- ‘The history of all hitherto existing societies is the history of class struggle’.
- Bourgeoisie own the means of production; workers sell their labour for wages.
- Dominant ideology justifies rule (‘fate’); rival ideologies challenge it. Economic processes generally tend to generate class conflicts, though this also depends on political and social conditions.
5 Emile Durkheim (1858-1917)
- Epinal, France; first Professor of Sociology in Paris (1913); Division of Labour in Society 1893, Rules of Sociological Method 1895, Suicide 1897, The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life 1912.
- Society = a moral community over and above the individual; moral facts can be observed, described, classified (Durkheim 1964: 32).
- Sociology studies the ’emergent’ level (a team is more than eleven persons) and is empirical: social facts are seen indirectly through patterns, e.g. the suicide rate.
- Social facts: like things, external, constraining, collective representations, general.
| Mechanical solidarity | Organic solidarity |
|---|---|
| Primitive society; similarity; small population | Modern society; heterogeneity; large population |
| Self-sufficient groups; personal ties | Interdependence; impersonal ties and institutions |
| Repressive law (collective revenge) | Restitutive law (repair the wrong) |
| Individual submerged in the collectivity | Individual has some autonomy, many identities |
6 Max Weber (1864-1920)
- Erfurt, Germany; The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism 1904; most works published after his death (Economy and Society, The Religion of India).
- Interpretive understanding of social action (meaningful behaviour), unlike the natural sciences’ ‘laws of nature’.
- Empathetic understanding: ‘feeling with’ (empathy), not ‘feeling for’ (sympathy).
- Value neutrality: describe, not judge; needs an ‘iron will’.
- Ideal type: a tool for analysis, not an exact copy of reality; judged by usefulness. Weber suggested that the ethics of certain Protestant sects had a deep influence on capitalism in Europe.
- Authority: traditional (custom and precedence), charismatic (‘gift of grace’), rational-legal (law; bureaucracy).
7 Bureaucracy: five features
- Functioning of officials: official jurisdiction, fixed duties, qualified staff, positions outlast occupants.
- Hierarchical ordering of positions: higher supervise lower; scope of appeal.
- Reliance on written document: files kept as records.
- Office management: trained and skilled personnel.
- Conduct in office: exhaustive rules; legal recognition makes officials accountable.
Bureaucracy separates the public from the domestic world and restricts officials’ power.
More for this chapter