Class 10 Social Science Chapter 18 Power-sharing Important Questions with Answers

Exam-useful questions from this chapter, grouped by marks, each with a full model answer. Try writing the answer yourself first, then check it against this one.

1 1-Mark Questions

Question 1 (1 mark)

Q. What is meant by ‘ethnic’?

Answer: Ethnic is a social division based on shared culture. People of the same ethnic group believe in their common descent because of similarities of physical type or culture, though they need not share the same religion or nationality.

Question 2 (1 mark)

Q. Define majoritarianism.

Answer: Majoritarianism is the belief that the majority community should be able to rule a country in whichever way it wants, by disregarding the wishes and needs of the minority.

Question 3 (1 mark)

Q. What is a civil war?

Answer: A civil war is a violent conflict between opposing groups within a country that becomes so intense that it appears like a war.

Question 4 (1 mark)

Q. What did Sri Lanka’s 1956 Act do?

Answer: It recognised Sinhala as the only official language of Sri Lanka, disregarding Tamil.

Question 5 (1 mark)

Q. Which community is Lebanon’s President required to belong to?

Answer: The Maronite sect of Catholic Christians.

Question 6 (1 mark)

Q. What does ‘prudential’ mean?

Answer: Prudential means based on prudence, or a careful calculation of gains and losses, as opposed to a decision based purely on moral considerations.

Question 7 (1 mark)

Q. What is Belgium’s ‘community government’?

Answer: A third layer of government, elected by people belonging to one language community (Dutch, French or German), regardless of where they live, with power over cultural, educational and language-related issues.

Question 8 (1 mark)

Q. What is meant by ‘horizontal distribution’ of power?

Answer: Power shared among different organs of government, such as the legislature, executive and judiciary, placed at the same level, each checking the others.

2 2-Mark Questions

Question 1 (2 marks)

Q. Describe Belgium’s linguistic composition in brief.

Answer: Belgium’s population is split by language: 59% live in the Flemish region and speak Dutch, 40% live in Wallonia and speak French, and the remaining 1% speak German. In the capital, Brussels, the split reverses: 80% speak French and only 20% speak Dutch.

Question 2 (2 marks)

Q. Why did Brussels present a ‘special problem’ for Belgium?

Answer: Dutch-speaking people were the national majority but only 20% of Brussels’ population, while French-speakers, the national minority, were 80% of Brussels. So the community that was the majority in the country was a minority in the capital, and both sides could claim control over Brussels.

Question 3 (2 marks)

Q. List two majoritarian measures adopted by Sri Lanka’s government after independence.

Answer: In 1956, an Act recognised Sinhala as the only official language, disregarding Tamil. The government also followed preferential policies favouring Sinhala applicants for university positions and government jobs.

Question 4 (2 marks)

Q. Why did Sri Lankan Tamils feel alienated from their government?

Answer: They felt that the constitution and government policies denied them equal political rights, discriminated against them in getting jobs and other opportunities, and ignored their interests, as one majoritarian measure followed another.

Question 5 (2 marks)

Q. State two elements of the Belgian model of power-sharing.

Answer: The Constitution requires an equal number of Dutch- and French-speaking ministers in the Central Government, and some special laws need the support of a majority of members from each linguistic group. Separately, many Central Government powers have been handed to the State Governments of the two regions, which are not subordinate to the Centre.

Question 6 (2 marks)

Q. Distinguish between the prudential and moral reasons for power sharing.

Answer: The prudential reason values power sharing for its better, more stable outcomes: it reduces conflict between social groups and prevents the instability that comes from imposing majority will. The moral reason values the very act of sharing power as the very spirit of democracy itself.

Question 7 (2 marks)

Q. What basic rule did Lebanon’s leaders agree upon after their civil war?

Answer: They fixed the country’s top offices by religious community: the President must be Maronite Catholic Christian, the Prime Minister Sunni Muslim, the Deputy Prime Minister Orthodox Christian, and the Speaker Shi’a Muslim. Christians also agreed not to seek French protection, and Muslims agreed not to seek unification with Syria.

Question 8 (2 marks)

Q. What is ‘vertical distribution’ of power, and give one Indian example of its two levels.

Answer: Vertical distribution is power shared among governments at different levels: one general government for the whole country and separate governments at the provincial or regional level. In India, these are called the Central (or Union) Government and the State Governments respectively.

3 4-Mark Questions

Question 1 (4 marks)

Q. Compare how Belgium and Sri Lanka each dealt with the question of power sharing, and the outcome each reached.

Answer: Both are democracies, yet they dealt with power sharing very differently. Belgium’s leaders realised that the country’s unity was possible only by respecting the feelings and interests of its different communities and regions; this realisation produced mutually acceptable power-sharing arrangements, amending the constitution four times between 1970 and 1993, and these helped the country avoid civic strife and a possible division on linguistic lines. (Brussels was also chosen as the headquarters of the European Union when many countries of Europe came together to form it.) Sri Lanka took the opposite path: its Sinhala-majority leadership adopted one majoritarian measure after another from 1956 onward, refusing Tamil demands for autonomy and equal opportunity. This shows that if a majority community forces its dominance over others and refuses to share power, it can undermine the unity of the country, exactly as happened in Sri Lanka’s decades-long civil war, which ended in 2009.

Question 2 (4 marks)

Q. Explain the four elements of the Belgian model of power sharing.

Answer: First, the Constitution requires an equal number of Dutch- and French-speaking ministers in the Central Government, and some laws need majority support from each linguistic group, so no single community can decide unilaterally. Second, many Central Government powers have been handed to the State Governments of Belgium’s two regions, which are not subordinate to the Centre. Third, Brussels has its own separate government with equal representation for both communities, a reciprocal arrangement: the French accepted equal representation in Brussels because the Dutch accepted equal representation centrally. Fourth, a third layer of government, the ‘community government’, is elected by people of one language community wherever they live, and controls cultural, educational and language-related matters.

Question 3 (4 marks)

Q. Explain, with examples, the two sets of reasons the chapter gives for why power sharing is desirable.

Answer: The prudential reason is that power sharing helps reduce the possibility of conflict between social groups: since social conflict often leads to violence and political instability, sharing power is a good way to keep political order stable. Imposing the majority’s will may look attractive in the short run, but it undermines national unity in the long run, and ‘tyranny of the majority’ often affects the majority adversely as well, not only the minority. Sri Lanka is the chapter’s example: its majoritarian measures from 1956 alienated the Tamils, and the distrust turned into a civil war in which thousands of people of both communities were killed. The moral reason is that power sharing is the very spirit of democracy: democratic rule means sharing power with everyone affected by its exercise, people have a right to be consulted on how they are governed, and a legitimate government is one where citizens, through participation, acquire a stake in the system. Belgium’s arrangements illustrate this: equal Dutch and French ministers, State Governments not subordinate to the Centre and a community government elected by each language community give every community a share in power.

Question 4 (4 marks)

Q. Name and briefly explain the four forms of power-sharing described in the chapter.

Answer: Horizontal distribution shares power among organs of government at the same level (legislature, executive, judiciary), each checking the others in a system of checks and balances. Vertical distribution shares power among governments at different levels, a general/federal government and provincial or state governments, extending further down to municipalities and panchayats. Power can also be shared among different social groups, such as religious or linguistic communities, as in Belgium’s community government or India’s reserved constituencies. Finally, power is shared through competition among political parties, pressure groups and movements, sometimes directly through coalition governments formed by allied parties.

Question 5 (4 marks)

Q. Describe Lebanon’s power-sharing pact and explain why Khalil is unhappy with it.

Answer: After Lebanon’s civil war, its leaders agreed to reserve the top offices by religious community: President for the Maronite Catholic Christian sect, Prime Minister for Sunni Muslims, Deputy Prime Minister for Orthodox Christians, and Speaker for Shi’a Muslims. Christians agreed not to seek French protection and Muslims agreed not to seek unification with Syria, and despite the population balance shifting to a Muslim majority since, both sides still respect the pact. Khalil, born to an Orthodox Christian father and a Sunni Muslim mother, does not like this system: he is a popular man with political ambition, but under the present system the top position is out of his reach. He practises neither his father’s nor his mother’s religion, and does not wish to be known by either.

Question 6 (4 marks)

Q. Trace how Sri Lanka’s majoritarian policies eventually led to a civil war.

Answer: After independence in 1948, Sinhala community leaders sought government dominance through their numerical majority, and from 1956 the elected government adopted one majoritarian measure after another: making Sinhala the sole official language, favouring Sinhala applicants for university positions and government jobs, and constitutionally protecting Buddhism. These measures deepened Sri Lankan Tamils’ sense of alienation, and their demands for regional autonomy and equal opportunity were repeatedly refused. By the 1980s, this had hardened into demands for an independent Tamil Eelam, and mutual distrust escalated into a full civil war that killed thousands, displaced many as refugees, and caused a terrible setback to the country’s social, cultural and economic life before ending in 2009.

4 6-Mark Questions

Question 1 (6 marks)

Q. Discuss, in detail, the different paths taken by Belgium and Sri Lanka on the question of power sharing, and what the chapter concludes from comparing them.

Answer: Belgium’s ethnic map is complex: 59% Flemish/Dutch-speakers, 40% Wallonia/French-speakers and 1% German-speakers nationally, with the split reversed in Brussels (80% French, 20% Dutch), which made the capital a special problem; the French-speaking minority was also relatively rich and powerful. Rather than let one community dominate, Belgian leaders recognised regional and cultural diversity and, between 1970 and 1993, amended their constitution four times to build a model resting on equal ministerial representation, devolved powers to State Governments that are not subordinate to the Centre, a power-sharing Brussels government, and a separate community government for cultural and linguistic matters. This complicated arrangement has worked well so far: it helped to avoid civic strife and a possible division on linguistic lines. Separately, Brussels was chosen as the headquarters of the European Union. Sri Lanka, with a Sinhala-speaking majority (74%) and Tamil-speaking minority (18%), took the opposite route after its 1948 independence: a series of majoritarian measures from 1956 onward, from the Sinhala-only Act to preferential job and education policies to constitutional protection for Buddhism, steadily alienated the Tamil community, whose demands for autonomy and equal opportunity were repeatedly denied. The result was decades of distrust hardening into open civil war, ending in 2009 after enormous human and economic cost. The chapter’s own conclusion is that both are democracies, yet they dealt with power sharing differently: in Belgium the leaders realised that the unity of the country is possible only by respecting the feelings and interests of different communities and regions, whereas Sri Lanka shows that if a majority community wants to force its dominance over others and refuses to share power, it can undermine the unity of the country.

Question 2 (6 marks)

Q. Explain fully why power sharing is considered desirable for democracies, illustrating your answer with examples from the chapter.

Answer: Two separate sets of reasons make power sharing desirable. The prudential reason treats power sharing as good policy: social conflict between groups often leads to violence and political instability, so distributing power reduces that risk and keeps the political order stable; imposing a majority’s will might look convenient in the short run, but the chapter warns it undermines national unity over time, and that the ‘tyranny of the majority’ can end up harming the majority community itself, not only the minority it dominates. The moral reason treats power sharing as valuable for its own sake: democratic rule involves sharing power with everyone affected by its exercise and who must live with its consequences, so people have a right to be consulted on how they are governed, and a legitimate government is one where citizens, through participation, acquire a stake in the system. India’s own reserved constituencies for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes illustrate the principle in practice: the book says such arrangements give space in the government and administration to diverse social groups who otherwise would feel alienated from the government. The chapter’s four forms of power-sharing, horizontal, vertical, among social groups, and through political parties, are the common arrangements through which democracies put this idea into practice.

Question 3 (6 marks)

Q. Explain the four forms of power-sharing described in the chapter, matching each to the real-world example the chapter itself gives.

Answer: Horizontal distribution shares power among the legislature, executive and judiciary at the same level, so that no organ can act with unlimited power: the chapter’s own example is the Bombay High Court ordering the Maharashtra State Government to improve conditions at Mumbai’s children’s homes, the judiciary checking the executive exactly as the ‘checks and balances’ idea describes. Vertical distribution shares power between a general government for the whole country and provincial or regional governments, going further down to municipalities and panchayats: the chapter’s example is Nigeria’s state finance ministers demanding that the federal government declare its income sources and revenue-sharing formula, a dispute between levels of government. Power shared among social groups, such as religious or linguistic communities, is illustrated by Belgium’s community government, and by the government of Ontario in Canada settling a land-claim dispute with the aboriginal community, giving a distinct social group a direct say in decisions that affect it. Finally, power shared through political parties and pressure groups is illustrated by Russia’s Union of Right Forces and Liberal Yabloko Movement agreeing to unite their organisations into a strong right-wing coalition, with a common list of candidates for the next parliamentary elections, exactly the kind of party competition and alliance-building the chapter describes as the fourth form.

Question 4 (6 marks)

Q. Using Khalil’s dilemma, discuss both the strengths and the limitations of Lebanon’s power-sharing system.

Answer: Lebanon’s pact, agreed at the end of a bitter civil war in which one of Khalil’s uncles was killed, reserves the President’s office for Maronite Catholic Christians, the Prime Minister’s for Sunni Muslims, the Deputy Prime Minister’s for Orthodox Christians, and the Speaker’s for Shi’a Muslims, with Christians giving up any claim to French protection and Muslims giving up any claim to unification with Syria. Its clearest strength is durability: even though the population balance has shifted from near-equality to a clear Muslim majority since the pact was struck, both communities have continued to honour it rather than renegotiate it by force, which fits the chapter’s prudential argument that power sharing helps ensure the stability of political order. Its clearest limitation is rigidity: a system built entirely around fixed religious identities leaves no room for someone like Khalil, who identifies with neither his father’s nor his mother’s religion, however capable or popular he might be as a leader, since the country’s highest offices are assigned by birth-community rather than by merit or public support. The chapter leaves the story unfinished, so it does not settle whether Khalil’s ‘normal democracy’ alternative, where whoever wins the most votes governs regardless of community, would actually improve on the present system or simply reopen the very conflict the pact was designed to prevent, a genuine unresolved tension between fairness to individuals and stability for the whole country.

5 Case Studies

Case Study
The chapter describes how, in Belgium, the minority French-speaking community was relatively rich and powerful, which was resented by the Dutch-speaking community once they too gained access to economic development and education, much later. This led to rising tension between the two communities through the 1950s and 1960s, felt most acutely in Brussels, where Dutch-speakers are a small minority (20%) even though they are the national majority (59%). Belgian leaders eventually recognised regional and cultural diversity rather than letting either side dominate, and amended their constitution four times between 1970 and 1993 to work out an arrangement that would let everyone live together within the same country.

(A) 1 mark What share of Brussels’ population is Dutch-speaking, according to the passage?
Answer: 20 per cent.

(B) 2 marks Why was Brussels described as presenting ‘a special problem’ for Belgium?
Answer: Because the national pattern reversed there: Dutch-speakers, who are the majority nationally (59%), form only a 20% minority in Brussels, while French-speakers, the national minority, form an 80% majority in the capital, so the community that was the majority in the country was a minority in the capital.

(C) 3 marks What lesson does Belgium’s response to this tension teach about preventing conflict in a diverse country?
Answer: It teaches that recognising and respecting regional and cultural diversity, rather than letting either community impose its will, is what preserves a country’s unity. Belgium’s leaders chose negotiation over domination, reshaping their constitution four times over 23 years to build genuinely shared power (equal ministers, devolved state powers, a shared Brussels government, and a community government), and this deliberate accommodation is exactly what avoided the civic strife and possible linguistic partition that a majoritarian approach, as Sri Lanka’s case shows, can instead produce.

Case Study
The chapter explains that for a long time it was believed all of a government’s power must reside in one person or group at one place, since dispersed power was thought to prevent quick decisions. This belief changed with the emergence of democracy, whose basic principle is that people are the source of all political power and rule themselves through institutions of self-government. Modern democracies therefore share power in several ways: among organs of government at the same level, among governments at different levels, among social groups, and through competing political parties and pressure groups.

(A) 1 mark According to the passage, what was the old belief about where government power should reside?
Answer: That all of a government’s power must reside in one person or group of persons located at one place.

(B) 2 marks Why, according to the passage, did democracy change this old belief?
Answer: Because democracy’s basic principle is that people are the source of all political power, and people rule themselves through institutions of self-government, so power could no longer be treated as something that belongs to just one person or place.

(C) 3 marks Using the Bombay High Court/Maharashtra Government example from the chapter, explain which form of power-sharing this represents and why.
Answer: This is horizontal distribution of power: the judiciary (the Bombay High Court) checking the executive (the Maharashtra State Government) by ordering it to act and improve the living conditions of children in Mumbai’s homes. It represents exactly the ‘checks and balances’ idea the passage describes, where one organ of government, placed at the same level as another, can check that other organ’s exercise of power rather than power residing unchecked in a single place.