Class 10 English First Flight Chapter 9 The Proposal Notes in English

What you will learn in this chapter
  • What a farce is, and what the headnote says the play is really about
  • The three characters, their pet names, their illnesses and their tempers
  • The full plot: the proposal, the Oxen Meadows quarrel, the reconciliation, the Guess and Squeezer quarrel, the faint and the engagement
  • Every insult and accusation, with the right speaker
  • Humour, irony, themes and key lines for extract questions
  • Short answers to “Thinking about the Play” and the language exercises, including Reported Speech
Anton Chekhovone-act farceChubukovNatalya StepanovnaIvan LomovOxen MeadowsBurnt MarshGuessSqueezerpalpitationsChampagne!

1Getting Ready for the Play

1.1 The Playwright and the Headnote

The headnote calls the writer Anton Chekhov, a Russian short story writer and dramatist (the contents page prints the name as “Chekov”). He wrote this play in 1888-89. Its original title was “A Marriage Proposal”. It is a one-act play and a farce.

Learn by heartDefinition 1: Farce

A comedy that makes us laugh through silly situations, exaggerated characters and absurd quarrels rather than through real events. The Proposal is a farce: three adults nearly ruin a marriage over a small field and two hunting dogs.

What the headnote says the play is about

Rich families like to link themselves with other rich families, so that their estates grow. Such marriages “make good economic sense”. Lomov, a wealthy neighbour, comes to ask for the hand of Chubukov’s daughter Natalya, who is twenty-five. All three are quarrelsome and fight over petty issues, so the proposal almost gets lost. In the end economic good sense wins and the proposal is made, but the quarrelling probably goes on.

1.2 Before You Read

The first activity gives three meanings of “proposal”: (i) a suggestion or plan for doing something, (ii) an offer for a possible plan or action, (iii) asking for someone’s hand in marriage. The play is about the third meaning.

A short article describes a Russian wedding. Its main points:

Stage Russian custom described in the book
Planning Simple: rings, the bride’s dress, cars and a reception. Earlier the bride’s family paid for the reception; today both families usually share the cost.
Length Two days; some weddings go on for a week.
Fetching the bride The groom climbs the stairs of her apartment block. At each landing her friends ask him a question or riddle (for example, picking out his bride from photos of baby girls). A wrong guess means paying cash to move on.
After registration The couple tour the city sights for two or three hours, then reach the reception.
Reception Toasts by close friends or relatives; everyone drinks at the same moment. Later the groom’s friends “steal” the bride and the bride’s friends steal her shoe; the groom pays for both.

Activity 2 asks you to list customs that are similar to Indian ones (procession, games at the bride’s home, the shoe-stealing fun, families sharing the celebration) and customs that are different (registration followed by a city tour, toasts with wine).

1.3 The Characters and the Setting

Character (as the book lists them) Who he or she is
Stepan Stepanovitch Chubukov A landowner; Natalya’s father
Natalya Stepanovna (called Natasha by her father) His daughter, twenty-five years old
Ivan Vassilevitch Lomov Chubukov’s neighbour, “a large and hearty, but very suspicious, landowner”; he says he is 35

Setting: the whole play happens in one place, the drawing-room of Chubukov’s house.

2The Plot at a Glance

The play keeps swinging between sweetness and fury. This figure shows how the temperature in the room rises and falls.

The rise and fall of tempers in The Proposal: two big quarrels, a near "death", an engagement and a fresh quarrel at the curtain.
The rise and fall of tempers in The Proposal: two big quarrels, a near “death”, an engagement and a fresh quarrel at the curtain.
Stage 1: Lomov arrives in evening dressChubukov thinks he wants a loan; Lomov asks for Natalya’s hand; Chubukov is overjoyed.
↓
Stage 2: Lomov aloneHe lists his reasons for marrying and all his ailments.
↓
Stage 3: Quarrel 1, Oxen MeadowsBefore he can propose, Lomov mentions “my Oxen Meadows”. Natalya, then Chubukov, claim the land. Family insults follow and Lomov staggers out.
↓
Stage 4: The truth comes outChubukov reveals that Lomov came to propose. Natalya has hysterics and demands he be brought back.
↓
Stage 5: Peace, then Quarrel 2Natalya gives in on the Meadows; talk turns to hunting, and a new fight starts over the dogs Guess and Squeezer.
↓
Stage 6: Lomov collapsesNatalya thinks he is dead; he comes round; Chubukov joins their hands and the two are engaged.
↓
Stage 7: The curtainSeconds later they argue about the dogs again while Chubukov shouts for champagne.

3The Play Scene by Scene

3.1 Lomov Arrives: A Loan or a Proposal?

Lomov walks in wearing a dress-jacket and white gloves. Chubukov greets him with a flood of pet names: my darling, my angel, my treasure, my precious, my beauty. He teases Lomov for being so formally dressed, “As if you’re paying a New Year’s Eve visit!”

Lomov is so nervous that he stumbles over Chubukov’s name (“Honoured Stepanitch… I beg pardon Stepan Honouritch”) and has to drink water. Meanwhile Chubukov says to himself:

Chubukov’s aside (first suspicion)

CHUBUKOV: “He’s come to borrow money. Shan’t give him any!”

Right after this he says aloud, “What is it, my beauty?” The gap between what he thinks and what he says is the first joke of the play.

Learn by heartDefinition 2: Aside

Words a character speaks to himself or to the audience, which the other characters on stage are not supposed to hear. The book marks them [aside].

Chubukov loses patience (“Spit it out!”), and Lomov finally says he has come to ask for the hand of Natalya Stepanovna. Chubukov’s mood flips at once. He hugs and kisses Lomov, sheds a tear, says he has hoped for this a long time, and claims, “I’ve always loved you, my angel, as if you were my own son.” He admits he is “off my balance with joy”. When Lomov asks whether Natalya will agree, Chubukov is sure of it: “She’s in love; egad, she’s like a lovesick cat”. He goes to fetch “Natasha”.

3.2 Lomov’s Speech to Himself

Left alone, Lomov shivers (“It’s cold… I’m trembling all over”) as if facing an examination. He reasons that a man who waits for an ideal or for real love will never marry, so he must decide at once.

Why he wants to marry Natalya

  • She is “an excellent housekeeper, not bad-looking, well-educated”
  • He is already 35, which he calls “a critical age”
  • He needs “a quiet and regular life”
  • Love is never mentioned

The ailments he lists

  • Palpitations (a racing, pounding heart)
  • Excitable, always getting upset
  • Trembling lips, a twitch in his right eyebrow, noise in his ears
  • Worst of all, his sleep: a “pull” in his left side reaches his shoulder and head, he jumps up “like a lunatic”, and this may happen twenty times a night

3.3 Natalya Enters

Natalya comes in and says her papa told her a merchant had come for his goods. She apologises for her apron and neglige (a loose house dress) because they are shelling peas for drying. She offers lunch and a smoke, then chats about the farm: yesterday’s rain stopped the workmen, and she had a whole field of hay cut and now fears it may rot. She notices his evening dress and asks if he is going to a ball.

Lomov starts a long, roundabout introduction. He has known her family since childhood. He inherited his land from his late aunt and her husband, who greatly respected her father and her late mother. The Lomovs and the Chubukovs have always been friendly. Then comes the fatal sentence: “my Oxen Meadows touch your birchwoods.”

3.4 Quarrel 1: Who Owns Oxen Meadows?

Natalya stops him at once: the Meadows are “ours, not yours!” The land in question lies between her birchwoods and the Burnt Marsh.

Lomov’s argument Natalya’s argument
He has documents. Long ago a grandmother on his aunt’s side let the peasants belonging to Natalya’s great-grandfather use the land free, in perpetuity, and they paid her back by making bricks. Her grandfather and great-grandfather both reckoned their land stretched to the Burnt Marsh, so the Meadows were theirs.
The peasants used the land for forty years and began to treat it as their own. Her family has held the land for nearly three hundred years.
He does not want the Meadows; he acts “on principle” and even offers them to her as a present. The Meadows are only five dessiatins, worth perhaps 300 roubles, but “I can’t stand unfairness.”

Natalya finds his offer insulting: how can he give her her own land? She reminds him that last year they lent him their threshing-machine and had to put off their own threshing till November, yet he treats them “as if we were gypsies”. She calls his behaviour impudent (rude, cheeky). Lomov asks if she thinks him a “landgrabber”. She threatens to send her mowers to the Meadows that very day; he says he will “give it to them in the neck”. The scene ends in a shouting match: “Ours!” “Mine!”

Chubukov joins the fight

Chubukov enters and, in his usual sweet tone, tells Lomov, “Darling, the Meadows are ours!” His point is that the peasants never paid the grandmother because the land was in dispute, and he tells Lomov, “you haven’t seen the plan.” He adds that he would sooner give the Meadows to the peasants than to Lomov, and reminds the “young man” that he is twice his age.

Lomov calls him “a grabber” and threatens to go to court. From here the quarrel turns personal:

Speaker Accusation
Chubukov Lomov is a pettifogger (one who loves going to court over trifles); all his people were like that
Lomov Chubukov’s grandfather was tried for embezzlement (stealing money he was trusted with)
Chubukov There is lunacy in the Lomov family; Lomov’s grandfather was a drunkard; his younger aunt, Nastasya Mihailovna, ran away with an architect
Lomov Chubukov’s mother was hump-backed
Chubukov Lomov’s father was “a guzzling gambler”
Natalya Few backbiters equal Lomov’s aunt
Chubukov Lomov is an intriguer, hints at a bribe before the last elections, and calls him a “malicious, doublefaced intriguer”

Lomov, clutching his heart and complaining of a numb foot, staggers out. Chubukov shouts, “don’t set foot in my house again!” and Natalya adds, “Take it to court! We’ll see!”

3.5 The Secret Comes Out

Father and daughter keep abusing the absent Lomov: rascal, villain, scarecrow, monster. Chubukov then lets slip that this “blind hen”, this “turnip-ghost”, had the cheek to come with a proposal. Natalya is stunned: “To propose? To me? Why didn’t you tell me so before?” She falls into an easy-chair, wails and has hysterics (wild, uncontrolled crying), screaming “Bring him back!”

Chubukov panics, says he will shoot or hang himself, and complains, “what a burden, Lord, to be the father of a grown-up daughter!” Each blames the other for driving Lomov away. Chubukov runs out and fetches him back.

3.6 Peace, and then Quarrel 2: Guess or Squeezer?

Natalya apologises: “we were all a little heated”, the Meadows “really are yours”, “We were wrong.” Lomov says he acted on principle and starts re-explaining his evidence; she quickly cuts him short. Aside, she wishes she knew how to get him started on the proposal, and aloud she asks about his shooting plans. He means to go after blackcock after the harvest, and then mentions his sorrow: his dog Guess has gone lame.

Point Guess (Lomov’s dog) Squeezer (Chubukov’s dog)
Price 125 roubles, bought from Mironov; Natalya: “too much”; Lomov: “very cheap” 85 roubles
Natalya’s view “old and as ugly as a worn-out cab-horse”; no known pedigree A thoroughbred, son of Harness and Chisels, better than anything Volchanetsky has
Lomov’s view Worth more than five Squeezers Overshot: lower jaw shorter than the upper, so a bad hunter; worth about 25 roubles
Chubukov’s view Purebred, firm on his feet, well-sprung ribs, but old and short in the muzzle “the best dog in the district”
The Marusinsky hunt Ran neck-and-neck with the Count’s dog Left a whole verst behind; Chubukov blames the Count’s whipper-in for hitting him; Lomov says Squeezer was worrying a sheep

Natalya accuses Lomov of a “demon of contradition” (the book’s spelling) and says, “those hunters argue most who know least.” Father and daughter both mock his health, copying his cry of “My heart!” Natalya says he should lie on the kitchen oven catching black beetles instead of hunting foxes. Chubukov says he only goes hunting to argue.

The insults climb again. Lomov: Chubukov hunts only to get in with the Count and to intrigue. Chubukov: “Boy! Pup!” Lomov: “Old rat! Jesuit!” Chubukov threatens to “shoot you like a partridge”. Lomov says Chubukov’s late wife used to beat him; Chubukov retorts that Lomov is “under the slipper of your house-keeper”. Lomov falls into an armchair, crying for a doctor.

3.7 The “Death” and the Engagement

Natalya screams that Lomov is dead and has hysterics again. Chubukov tries to make him drink water and, thinking him dead, asks for a knife and a pistol. Then Lomov moves and mutters, “I see stars… mist… where am I?”

Chubukov seizes the chance. He puts Lomov’s hand in his daughter’s: “She’s willing!”, “Kiss and be damned to you!” Natalya agrees, they kiss, and both say they are happy. Chubukov sighs, “What a weight off my shoulders”. But Natalya immediately asks Lomov to admit that Guess is worse than Squeezer. “Better!” “Worse!” Chubukov calls this “a way to start your family bliss” and tries to drown them out by shouting “Champagne! Champagne!” as the curtain falls.

4The Two Quarrels Side by Side

4.1 Same Pattern, Twice

Quarrel 1: Oxen Meadows

  • Starts when Lomov says “my Oxen Meadows”
  • Natalya first, then Chubukov joins
  • Grows into insults about grandparents, aunts and parents
  • Ends with Lomov thrown out
  • Natalya gives in only after she learns of the proposal

Quarrel 2: Guess and Squeezer

  • Starts when Lomov mentions his lame dog
  • Natalya first, then Chubukov joins
  • Grows into insults about hunting, wives and housekeepers
  • Ends with Lomov fainting
  • Never settled: it restarts after the engagement

5The Characters

5.1 The Three Quarrellers

1

Ivan Lomov

Nervous and fussy about his health (palpitations, numb foot, twitching eyebrows). Suspicious and touchy: he takes small points as matters of “principle”. He proposes for practical reasons, not love. Quick to shout, quick to faint.

2

Natalya Stepanovna

A capable farm manager (hay, threshing, peas). Proud, stubborn and hot-tempered; she “can’t stand unfairness” but will not listen. She wants to marry: the word “proposal” changes her in a second. Even after the engagement she must win the dog argument.

3

Stepan Chubukov

A shrewd, money-minded landowner: his first thought is that Lomov wants a loan. Sugary pet names turn into crude insults the moment his land is touched. He is eager to marry off his grown-up daughter and hurries the engagement through.

5.2 Five Words for Each Character (Thinking about the Play, Q3 ii)

Lomov Natalya Chubukov
nervous, hypersensitive, suspicious, argumentative, practical quarrelsome, proud, outspoken, possessive, hasty selfish, two-faced, hot-tempered, calculating, theatrical

6Humour and Irony

6.1 Where the Laughs Come From

Learn by heartDefinition 3: Irony

A gap between what is expected or said and what actually happens or is meant. In this play a man who comes to propose ends up being thrown out, and a family that wants him as a son-in-law calls him a “stuffed sausage”.

Source of humour Example from the play
Sweet words, sour thoughts Chubukov calls Lomov “my beauty” while thinking he wants money
Petty causes, huge fights A field worth about 300 roubles; two hunting dogs
Sudden change of mood Chubukov goes from “my angel” to “pettifogger”; Natalya from “monster” to “Bring him back!”
Exaggerated illness Lomov’s heart, eyebrows, foot and shoulder; “Where is my shoulder?”
Hypocrisy Natalya says the land is not worth much to her, yet fights for it furiously
Comic ending An engaged couple quarrel at once while the father shouts “Champagne!”

6.2 Russian-Sounding Expressions (Language I.1)

An older man calling a grown man my darling, my angel, my treasure, my precious, my beauty, my beloved sounds Russian, as do oaths like “egad” and “Tfoo!” and “so to speak”. Idiomatic modern English also appears: “Spit it out!”, “Don’t go round and round it”, “Shut up!”, “want to have me on”, “a weight off my shoulders”.

7Themes and Message

7.1 Four Big Ideas

1

Marriage as a business deal

Lomov chooses a good housekeeper; Chubukov wants his daughter settled. Land and money matter more than love.

2

Greed for property

Each family clings to what it owns: “I don’t want anything of yours and I don’t want to give anything of mine.”

3

Anger over trifles

Small issues grow into family insults. The speaking activity on anger management grows out of this.

4

Pretence of the rich

Polite manners hide selfishness; good neighbours turn into “grabbers” in seconds.

Message: through laughter the play shows how foolish it is to let ego, greed and temper spoil relationships, and how hollow a marriage can be when it rests on property alone.

8Key Lines with Speakers

Speaker Line What it shows
Chubukov (aside) “He’s come to borrow money. Shan’t give him any!” His selfishness and suspicion
Chubukov “She’s in love; egad, she’s like a lovesick cat” He is eager to marry her off
Lomov He is “already 35”, which he calls “a critical age, so to speak” Practical reason for marrying
Natalya “I can’t stand unfairness.” Her pride and stubbornness
Lomov “I don’t want the Meadows, but I am acting on principle.” Ego dressed up as principle
Chubukov “I, young man, am twice your age” He pulls rank
Natalya “I’ve noticed that those hunters argue most who know least.” Her sharp tongue
Chubukov “Well, that’s a way to start your family bliss!” Irony: the quarrels will go on

9Textbook Questions: Short Answers

9.1 Thinking about the Play and Phrases

Thinking about the Play
  1. Chubukov’s first suspicion and his sincerity: He suspects Lomov has come to borrow money. He is not sincere when he says he has loved Lomov “as if you were my own son”: a moment earlier he was refusing a loan in his mind, and soon he is calling Lomov a pettifogger and an intriguer. His joy comes from getting a rich husband for his daughter.
  2. Is Natalya “like a lovesick cat”? Partly. She does not know of the proposal and fights Lomov, so she is not openly in love. But once she hears the word “proposal” she wails and demands he be fetched, and she gives up the Meadows. She is eager to be married, though her love of winning remains.
  3. Words and insults (i): see the accusations table in Section 3.4 and the lines in 3.5 to 3.7 (pettifogger, blind hen, turnip-ghost, stuffed sausage, wizen-faced frump, Boy! Pup!, Old rat! Jesuit!, milksop). Kind words: Lomov’s “excellent housekeeper, not bad-looking, well-educated” and Chubukov’s pet names. (ii) See the five-word table in Section 5. (iii) They might next quarrel over the wedding costs, the dowry of land, whose house to live in, or Lomov’s illnesses.
Thinking about Language: phrases (I.3)
  • You may take it that = you can be sure that. You may take it that the results will be out on Monday.
  • He seems to be coming round = he is regaining consciousness. After a splash of water, the fainted boy seemed to be coming round.
  • My foot’s gone to sleep = my foot has gone numb. I sat cross-legged so long that my foot went to sleep.

9.2 Reported Speech (Language II): the Rules Filled In

Rule Answer
1. To report a question we use asked
2. To report a statement we use said (or declared, told)
3. The adverb of place here changes to there
4. Present tense in direct speech becomes past tense
5. Present continuous becomes past continuous; am getting becomes was getting
6. A word of respect in direct speech adds the adverb respectfully
7. I, me, our, mine change to he/she, him/her, their, his/hers

Exercise III asks you to put the 2006 newspaper excerpt about actor A. K. Hangal into reported speech using these rules. The speaking tasks cover anger management, a script from Tagore’s The Home and the World, the qualities to look for in a marriage partner, and scenes from romantic comedies.

10Words to Know

The play’s pages carry no margin glossary, so these are general meanings that fit the play.

Word Meaning here
dessiatin an old Russian measure of land area
rouble Russian money
verst an old Russian measure of distance
in perpetuity for ever
overshot (of a dog) having the upper jaw longer than the lower
pettifogger a person who argues or goes to court over trivial matters
embezzlement stealing money one has been trusted to look after
intriguer a person who makes secret plans to gain something
whipper-in a hunt servant who keeps the hounds together with a whip
impudent rude and disrespectful
hysterics a fit of wild crying or screaming
milksop a weak, timid man
All definitions in one place
FarceA comedy built on silly situations, exaggerated characters and absurd quarrels
AsideWords spoken to oneself or the audience that other characters do not hear
IronyA gap between what is expected or said and what really happens or is meant
Quick Revision: read this the night before the exam
  • Anton Chekhov (contents: Chekov); 1888-89; first called “A Marriage Proposal”; one-act farce
  • Theme in the headnote: rich families marry to enlarge estates; petty quarrels nearly kill the proposal
  • Chubukov (landowner), Natalya (25), Lomov (35, suspicious); Chubukov’s drawing-room
  • Evening dress, white gloves; Chubukov’s aside: he has come to borrow money
  • Lomov’s reasons: housekeeper, not bad-looking, well-educated; 35; quiet regular life
  • Ailments: palpitations, twitch in right eyebrow, pull in left side, wakes twenty times
  • Oxen Meadows: between birchwoods and Burnt Marsh; five dessiatins; 300 roubles; bricks; forty years; nearly 300 years
  • Threshing-machine lent, own threshing put off till November
  • Insults: pettifogger, embezzlement, lunacy, Nastasya Mihailovna and the architect, hump-backed mother, guzzling gambler
  • Proposal revealed; Natalya’s hysterics; “Bring him back!”
  • Guess (125 roubles, Mironov) vs Squeezer (85 roubles, overshot); Marusinsky hunt; a verst behind
  • Lomov faints; Chubukov joins hands; kiss; dogs again; “Champagne! Champagne!”
Check yourself before the exam
  • Can I say why the play is called a farce?
  • Can I explain Chubukov’s first suspicion and why his affection is not sincere?
  • Can I give both sides of the Oxen Meadows argument?
  • Can I match each insult to the right speaker?
  • Can I compare Guess and Squeezer with prices and faults?
  • Can I describe each character in five adjectives?
  • Can I explain the irony of the ending?
  • Can I fill in the seven Reported Speech rules?
More for this chapter