Class 11 English Book 2 Chapter 4 Birth NCERT Solutions in English

Complete solutions to every exercise question of NCERT Snapshots, Book 2 Chapter 4, “Birth,” with each question in the book’s own wording and a full model answer under each. Write your own answer first, then compare. Unlike some other Snapshots chapters, “Birth” carries only these three questions in the book itself, with no separate “Understanding the Text” style grouping.

1 Chapter Questions

Question 1

Q. “I have done something; oh, God! I’ve done something real at last.” Why does Andrew say this? What does it mean?

Answer: Andrew says this at the very end of a night in which he has fought, with his own hands and skill, to save both Susan Morgan and her newborn child, who is born lifeless and is revived only after more than half an hour of desperate effort. He says it because he feels he has achieved something of true, hard-won value “at last”: not a routine visit or an ordinary prescription, but a victory over death, won by refusing to give up even after the midwife whimpered, “It’s stillborn.”
It means that Andrew now measures the worth of his profession differently. Earlier in the same night his thoughts had been “so filled with Christine”, and he had been “resentful and confused” by the conflict between his “level, doubting mind” about marriage and his “overflowing heart”. By the end, the book says, he is “oblivious to all other work he had done in Blaenelly”, feeling that he has “done something real at last”. One reading is that he now sees the “real” purpose of being a doctor in exactly this kind of desperate, life-saving effort, not in his ordinary daily rounds.

Question 2

Q. There lies a great difference between textbook medicine and the world of a practising physician. Discuss.

Answer: Textbook medicine presents cases as clear, ordered problems: a diagnosis is stated, a standard treatment is listed, and the outcome usually follows in a predictable, calm sequence. This chapter shows how different real practice actually is. Andrew has no time to think: within a single instant he must choose between two patients who both need him at the same time, the newborn child and the collapsing Susan. The book says, “The dilemma was so urgent he did not solve it consciously”; he acts “blindly, instinctively” rather than by working through the choice step by step.
Once he turns to the child, he has only what is at hand in the Morgans’ small bedroom: “The basins arrived, the ewer, the big iron kettle,” and he uses hot and cold water and a rough towel. He also draws on memory, recalling “a case he once had seen in the Samaritan” and the treatment used there. He also continues working long after a textbook case would consider the outcome settled, refusing to accept the midwife’s verdict that the child is stillborn, and persisting physically, by hand, after half an hour of failure. This shows that a practising physician needs not only medical knowledge but also swift judgement under pressure, the ability to improvise with whatever is at hand, physical stamina, and the will to keep trying past the point where giving up would seem reasonable, none of which a textbook case study can fully teach in advance.

Question 3

Q. Do you know of any incident when someone has been brought back to life from the brink of death through medical help. Discuss medical procedures such as organ transplant and organ regeneration that are used to save human life.

Answer: This is an open discussion question inviting students to connect the chapter’s theme to real, modern medicine, so answers will vary; one acceptable model follows. The chapter itself gives one such incident: a child born lifeless is brought back to breathing by Andrew’s hot and cold water baths, towel-rubbing and chest compression. In real life, a common example is a person whose heart has stopped being revived with cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), which keeps blood moving through chest compressions and rescue breaths, together with a defibrillator, which can restart the heart with an electric shock. Rescuers keep going even when the person shows no immediate response, in the same spirit of persistence Andrew shows, though not every patient survives.
Beyond emergency resuscitation, modern medicine has developed further ways of saving lives that would once have been considered lost. In an organ transplant, a damaged or failing organ, such as a kidney, liver or heart, is surgically replaced with a healthy one from a donor, allowing a patient to survive an illness that would otherwise be fatal. In organ regeneration, doctors and researchers use the body’s own capacity to heal, for example the liver’s ability to regrow part of itself after injury or surgery, or newer techniques such as stem-cell therapy, which aim to help damaged tissue repair or regenerate rather than be replaced entirely. Both of these, like Andrew’s night with the Morgans, show medicine at its most dramatic: an active, hands-on fight to preserve a life that might otherwise have been lost.