Class 11 English Book 2 Chapter 4 Birth Notes in English

What you will learn in this chapter
  • The full story of the night Andrew Manson delivers Joe and Susan Morgan’s first child, in the order it happens
  • Who Andrew Manson, Joe, Susan, the grandmother and the midwife (whom the book also calls “the nurse”) are, and what each one shows about the story
  • The themes of dedication, hope over despair, and the value of even the smallest human life
  • The literary techniques that build the story’s tension, and how to point to the exact line each one appears in
  • Every glossary word the book itself explains, plus other hard words from the chapter
  • How to answer the chapter’s own three discussion questions, and practice questions built on them
Andrew MansonThe CitadelBlaenellyasphyxia pallidaresuscitationdedication

1 About the Chapter

“Birth” is not a complete story on its own. It is an excerpt from A.J. Cronin’s 1937 novel The Citadel, printed here as a self-contained excerpt covering a single night. NCERT gives its own framing note at the start of the chapter, and it is worth reading closely because every character it names is named again in the story:

“In this excerpt from The Citadel, Andrew Manson, newly out of medical school, has just begun his medical practice as an assistant to Dr Edward Page in the small Welsh mining town of Blaenelly. As he is returning from a disappointing evening with Christine, the girl he loves, he is met by Joe Morgan. Joe and his wife, who have been married nearly twenty years, are expecting their first child.”

NCERT’s own framing note, printed before the story begins

Background (not in the NCERT text)

A.J. Cronin (1896-1981) was a Scottish physician who became a novelist. The Citadel draws on his own early years as a doctor in a Welsh mining community. The book does not give this background, and the rest of the novel’s plot is not part of this chapter, so study the chapter itself and do not bring the novel into an answer.

Figure 1: A period illustration of a coal works near Neath in Glamorganshire, south Wales (John Hassell, 1798, public domain). The book sets the story in "the small Welsh mining town of Blaenelly".
Figure 1: A period illustration of a coal works near Neath in Glamorganshire, south Wales (John Hassell, 1798, public domain). The book sets the story in “the small Welsh mining town of Blaenelly”.

2 The Story, Stage by Stage

The chapter covers roughly five hours of one night, told in order. Reading it as five stages makes the shape of the story, and its single dramatic turn, easy to hold in your head.

1 · The callNearly midnight. Andrew, tired and lost in his own thoughts, is met by an anxious Joe Morgan outside the surgery: Susan’s baby is coming, and early.
↓
2 · The waitAt Number 12 Blaina Terrace, Andrew waits through the night with Susan’s mother and the midwife, deciding to stay until it is over.
↓
3 · The birthAt dawn, after an hour’s hard labour, the child is born lifeless. Andrew must choose, in an instant, between the baby and the collapsing Susan.
↓
4 · The fightWith Susan safe, Andrew turns to the “stillborn” child and refuses to give up on it, working on for more than half an hour.
↓
5 · The cryThe child breathes, then cries. Andrew walks out at dawn among the first of the night-shift miners, feeling he has done “something real at last”.

2.1 Midnight: the call to Bryngower

Andrew is returning to Bryngower, worn out and preoccupied, after a disappointing evening with Christine. He finds Joe Morgan pacing outside the surgery, “back and forward… this last hour.” Joe’s wife Susan, married to him nearly twenty years, wants the doctor now, “before time, too” (the baby is arriving early). Andrew fetches his bag and the two men walk to Number 12 Blaina Terrace in silence.

Cronin tells us that Andrew feels “dull and listless” and has “no premonition that this night call would prove unusual, still less that it would influence his whole future in Blaenelly.” So Andrew expects nothing, but the same sentence warns the reader that this night will matter (one reading: this builds suspense from the very start). At the door, Joe will not come in: “I’ll not come in… But, man, I know ye’ll do well for us.”

2.2 The long wait

Upstairs, the room is small and poorly furnished, lit only by an oil lamp. Susan’s mother, a tall, grey-haired woman of nearly seventy, and a stout, elderly midwife are already there. The grandmother offers Andrew tea, afraid that he would leave the case, saying he would return later; he reassures her, “Don’t fret, mother, I’ll not run away.” He knows he “could not snatch even an hour’s sleep” if he went home, and that the case “would demand all his attention”, so he decides “to remain until everything was over.”

Waiting by the kitchen fire, Andrew’s thoughts are “heavy, muddled.” “The episode he had witnessed at Cardiff station still obsessed him morbidly.” His mind drifts to marriages he knows: Bramwell, “foolishly devoted to a woman who deceived him sordidly”; his own employer Edward Page, “bound to the shrewish Blodwen”; and Denny, “living unhappily, apart from his wife.” “His reason told him that all these marriages were dismal failures,” yet with the image of Christine before him he wishes “to consider marriage as an idyllic state.” The book sums it up: “It was the conflict between his level, doubting mind and his overflowing heart which left him resentful and confused.” This quiet, self-absorbed worrying is what the rest of the night interrupts.

The grandmother breaks his thoughts with a small, human detail: Susan does not want chloroform if it might harm the baby, “she’s awful set upon this child, Doctor, bach,” and, after a pause, “Ay, we all are, I fancy.” Andrew reassures her that the anaesthetic will do no harm.

2.3 Dawn: a lifeless birth

At half-past three the nurse calls Andrew up. What follows is “a long, harsh struggle.” As the first light of dawn shows through the blind, the child is born, lifeless. Andrew feels “a shiver of horror”: after everything he had promised the family, the baby is not breathing.

He is caught in an immediate dilemma: try to revive the child, or turn to Susan, who now lies “collapsed, almost pulseless,” still not fully out of the ether. There is no time to weigh the choice consciously. He hands the baby to the nurse and works on Susan first, in “a frantic race against her ebbing strength,” smashing open a glass ampule and injecting medicine with a hypodermic syringe. Her heart strengthens; only once he is sure she is safe does he turn back to the child.

Learn by heartMedical detail 1

The book calls Andrew’s choice a dilemma: he is “torn between his desire to attempt to resuscitate the child, and his obligation towards the mother, who was herself in a desperate state.” “The dilemma was so urgent he did not solve it consciously.” “Blindly, instinctively,” he gives the child to the nurse and turns to Susan first, then returns to fight for the child. The book gives no reason for the choice.

2.4 “Where’s the child?”: the diagnosis

Only once Susan is safe does Andrew ask, “Where’s the child?” The midwife, frightened, admits she had placed it beneath the bed. Andrew pulls the baby out from among sodden newspapers: “A boy, perfectly formed,” but limp, “white and soft as tallow,” its cord “hastily slashed,” its head lolling, its limbs seemingly boneless.

Andrew recognises the condition at once: asphyxia pallida, and his mind races back to a similar case he had once seen treated at “the Samaritan” (a hospital). Recognising the diagnosis from memory, and recalling the treatment for it, is what lets him act immediately instead of guessing.

Learn by heartDefinition 1: Asphyxia Pallida

Asphyxia pallida (the book’s own footnote): “suffocation or unconscious condition caused by lack of oxygen and excess of carbon dioxide in the blood, accompanied by paleness of the skin, weak pulse, and loss of reflexes.” This is exactly the state Andrew finds the newborn child in.

2.5 The resuscitation

Andrew calls urgently for hot water, cold water and basins. When the nurse hesitates, seeing the pallid body, he shouts “Quick!” His method, as the book describes it, is to work “like some crazy juggler,” plunging the child alternately into an icy basin and one as hot as his hand can bear.

Fifteen minutesSweat runs into Andrew’s eyes; his sleeve hangs dripping; still no breath from the child.
Soon afterThe midwife, watching in “stark consternation,” whimpers, “For mercy’s sake, Doctor … It’s stillborn.” Andrew does not heed her.
Half an hourBeaten and despairing, Andrew still persists: rubbing the child with a rough towel, “crushing and releasing the little chest with both his hands.”
The turning pointThe chest gives “a short, convulsive heave, another… and another.” Life is returning.

Through this stretch the grandmother stands “pressed back against the wall,” her hand at her throat, watching in silence. Andrew remembers “her longing for a grandchild, as great as had been her daughter’s longing for this child.” The floor becomes a “draggled mess,” and Andrew, stumbling over a wet towel, nearly drops the child, now “wet and slippery in his hands, like a strange, white fish.” These small, physical details are what make the scene feel real rather than simply described.

2.6 The cry, and the walk at dawn

After the first convulsive heaves, a bubble of mucus appears at one nostril; the limbs are no longer boneless, the head no longer lolls, the blanched skin slowly turns pink, and then, “exquisitely, came the child’s cry.” The nurse sobs, “Dear Father in heaven… It’s come — it’s come alive.” Andrew hands her the baby, feeling “weak and dazed,” while around him the room lies in a “shuddering litter” of blankets, towels, basins and soiled instruments. The grandmother, hands together, is praying silently, without a sound.

Andrew dresses, tells the nurse he will fetch his bag later, and goes down through the kitchen to the scullery for a drink of water. Outside, he tells the waiting Joe, simply, “All right, Joe… Both all right.” It is nearly five o’clock and quite light; the first miners of the night shift are already in the streets. Walking among them, “spent and slow,” Andrew thinks, “oblivious to all other work he had done in Blaenelly”: “I’ve done something; oh, God! I’ve done something real at last.”

Exam Tip

The final line is the chapter’s closing line, and Discussion Question 1 asks about it. Be ready to explain why Andrew says it (he has just fought for and saved two lives against real odds, with his own hands, after the midwife had called the child stillborn) and what it means. The book says he thinks it “oblivious to all other work he had done in Blaenelly”; one reading is that this night, not his ordinary work, feels to him like the “real” work his profession is for.

3 Characters

Character Role and key trait
Andrew Manson The protagonist; a young doctor, newly out of medical school, assistant to Dr Page. Begins the night self-absorbed and torn about marriage; ends it, after fighting for and winning two lives against the odds, feeling he has “done something real at last”
Joe Morgan Susan’s husband, a burly driller. Anxious but trusting (“I know ye’ll do well for us”); waits outside rather than come in; his relief at the end (“Both all right”) is the story’s quiet release
Susan Morgan Joe’s wife and the patient. Married nearly twenty years, “awful set upon this child”; collapses after the birth and is “not yet out of the ether”; she “dreamed her way quietly through the anaesthetic” while her baby was revived
The grandmother Susan’s mother, nearly seventy. Watches the resuscitation in silence, “uttering no sound”, voices the family’s longing for the child (“Ay, we all are, I fancy”), and prays silently once the child cries; the story’s emotional witness
The midwife (also called “the nurse”) Stout and elderly; the one woman helping Andrew (the book calls her both “the midwife” and “the nurse”). Places the lifeless baby beneath the bed, hesitates at his orders, whimpers “It’s stillborn”, then sobs “It’s come alive”

Four more names are mentioned but never appear in the room: Christine, the girl Andrew loves; Dr Edward Page, Andrew’s employer, unhappily married to “the shrewish Blodwen”; and Bramwell and Denny, whose unhappy marriages occupy Andrew’s thoughts earlier in the night. All four belong to the frame of Andrew’s personal life that this one night interrupts.

Andrew at midnight

  • Tired, “dull and listless”
  • Thoughts “so filled with Christine” after a disappointing evening
  • Torn between his “level, doubting mind” about marriage and his “overflowing heart”, so “resentful and confused”
  • Has “no premonition” the night will matter

Andrew at dawn

  • Alert, decisive, physically spent from real effort
  • “Oblivious to all other work he had done in Blaenelly”
  • Has just fought, with his own hands, for a life
  • Feels he has finally “done something real”

4 Themes

1

Dedication

Andrew’s refusal to stop working on the child, even after half an hour of failure and the midwife’s verdict that it is stillborn, can be read as a picture of what medical dedication looks like: physical, exhausting, and unwilling to accept that it is too late until it truly is.

2

Hope over despair

The story repeatedly shows despair as the reasonable response, and hope as the choice that wins anyway: Andrew is “beaten, despairing,” and persists regardless. The child’s first “convulsive heave” arrives exactly when giving up would have seemed justified.

3

The value of life

The enormous effort spent on one small, newly born life, by everyone in the room, can be read as saying that a life is worth this much trouble, even at its very first minute.

4

Textbook medicine vs real practice

Nothing in the chapter is a calm, orderly procedure. Andrew must choose between two patients in an instant, improvise with a kettle and basins, and keep working past the point a textbook case study would call it over. This is Discussion Question 2 in narrative form.

5

Self-discovery

Andrew begins the night thinking about his own romantic disappointment and his doubts about marriage. He ends it “oblivious to all other work he had done in Blaenelly”, feeling that he has “done something real at last”. One reading is that he has found what his training was for.

6

Quiet strength around a crisis

Nobody in the room is a doctor except Andrew, yet everyone plays a part: the grandmother’s silent faith, the midwife’s practical (if mistaken) judgement, her obedience to his orders and her hysterical sobs when the child comes alive, and Joe’s patient trust outside the door.

The chapter’s three discussion questions

  • Question 1 (“I have done something; oh, God! I’ve done something real at last.”): see the Exam Tip in section 2.6.
  • Question 2 (textbook medicine and the world of a practising physician): see Theme 4 above.
  • Question 3 (someone brought back to life from the brink of death; organ transplant and organ regeneration): Andrew’s night is itself one such incident. A child born lifeless is brought back to breathing through hot and cold water baths, towel-rubbing and chest compression. For your own answer, name a real incident only if you can state it accurately, and explain the two procedures the question names: an organ transplant replaces a failing organ (such as a kidney, liver or heart) with a healthy one from a donor, and organ regeneration uses the body’s own power to regrow or repair tissue (the liver, for example, can regrow part of itself).

5 Literary Devices and Technique

Learn by heartDefinition 2: Narration

“Birth” is told in the third person, closely following Andrew’s thoughts and physical sensations throughout (“Andrew felt…”, “his mind… raced back…”). This is different from a first-person narrator telling their own story in their own voice.

Learn by heartDefinition 3: Suspense

Suspense is tension built by delaying the answer to a question the reader urgently wants answered. Cronin builds it here with exact, ticking time markers: “nearly midnight,” “half-past three,” “Fifteen minutes passed,” “having laboured in vain for half an hour,” “Nearly five o’clock.” The later ones measure how long the child has gone without breathing.

Learn by heartDefinition 4: Symbolism

Symbolism is using a concrete detail to stand for a larger idea. The alternating icy and hot water baths are literal medical treatment. Reading them as a symbol of the child’s struggle between life and death is an interpretation; the book does not say so.

Learn by heartDefinition 5: Irony

Irony is when the outcome is the opposite of what was expected. The book says Andrew had “no premonition that this night call would prove unusual, still less that it would influence his whole future in Blaenelly.” One reading: the call he expects to be ordinary is the one that matters most.

Beyond the four terms above, notice two more technique points:

  • Vivid, near-clinical imagery makes the child’s condition feel physically real rather than merely stated: “white and soft as tallow,” later “wet and slippery… like a strange, white fish.”
  • A shift in rhythm at the climax: short, broken clauses build up to the child’s cry (“another… and another… Andrew turned giddy”), then the prose relaxes into plain, calm sentences for the walk at dawn. The sentence rhythm itself performs the release of tension.

6 Glossary

The book itself explains three words with footnotes. Use these exact definitions, since they are the book’s own footnotes:

Word Meaning (book’s own footnote)
tallow the hard fat of animals melted and used to make soap, candles etc.
asphyxia pallida suffocation or unconscious condition caused by lack of oxygen and excess of carbon dioxide in the blood, accompanied by paleness of the skin, weak pulse, and loss of reflexes
scullery a room for washing dishes and for similar work

The chapter also uses these harder words. Simple meanings, in the sense the chapter uses them:

Word Meaning as used here
burly big and strong-bodied (used for Joe, the driller)
premonition a feeling that something is about to happen, before it does
dilemma a situation with two difficult choices and no easy answer
ebbing steadily going away or growing weaker, like a tide going out
flaccid limp, without firmness
ampule a small sealed glass container holding one dose of medicine
hypodermic syringe the needle-and-tube instrument used to inject medicine
haggard looking exhausted and worn from strain
pallid / blanched unnaturally pale, drained of colour
consternation a feeling of sudden anxiety or dismay
draggled wet and messy, dragged through dirt or spilled water
convulsive happening in sudden, uncontrolled jerks
iridescent showing shifting rainbow-like colours
exquisite extremely intense and finely felt; here the returning sense of life is so strong it almost makes Andrew faint

7 Lines to Remember

“I’ve done something; oh, God! I’ve done something real at last.”

Andrew Manson, the chapter’s closing line

“For mercy’s sake, Doctor … It’s stillborn.”

The midwife, the verdict Andrew refuses to accept

“Dear Father in heaven … It’s come — it’s come alive.”

The midwife (called “the nurse” here), the moment of release

All definitions in one place
TallowThe hard fat of animals melted and used to make soap, candles etc.
Asphyxia pallidaSuffocation caused by lack of oxygen and excess carbon dioxide, with pale skin, weak pulse and loss of reflexes
SculleryA room for washing dishes and similar work
Third-person narrationA story told about a character (“he”, “she”) rather than by that character in their own voice
SuspenseTension built by delaying the answer to a question the reader urgently wants answered
SymbolismUsing a concrete detail to stand for a larger idea
IronyAn outcome that is the opposite of what was expected
20years (nearly) Joe and Susan had been married
30minutes Andrew fought on for the “stillborn” child
1937year The Citadel, the novel this chapter comes from, was published
Quick Revision: read this the night before the exam
  • Andrew Manson, newly out of medical school, delivers Joe and Susan Morgan’s first child on a night call to Blaenelly
  • The baby is born lifeless at dawn; Andrew, acting “blindly, instinctively”, turns to the collapsing Susan first
  • He diagnoses asphyxia pallida, and fights for half an hour with hot-and-cold water baths and chest compression despite the midwife’s “It’s stillborn”
  • The child cries at last; Andrew tells Joe, “Both all right,” and walks out among the night-shift miners
  • Final line: “I’ve done something real at last.” He is “oblivious to all other work he had done in Blaenelly”
  • Themes: dedication, hope over despair, the value of life, textbook medicine vs real practice, self-discovery
  • Devices: third-person narration, suspense through real-time markers; readings: hot/cold symbolism, irony of the “ordinary” night call
Practice Questions
  1. 1 markWhat condition had the newborn child developed, in the doctor’s own diagnosis?
  2. 2 marksWhy does Andrew attend to Susan before the child, even though the child is not breathing?
  3. 3 marksDescribe the method Andrew uses to try to revive the child.
  4. 4 marksHow does Andrew’s state of mind at the end of the chapter differ from his state of mind at the start?
  5. 6 marks“There lies a great difference between textbook medicine and the world of a practising physician.” Discuss this with reference to the chapter.