Exam-useful questions from this chapter, grouped by marks, each with a full model answer. Try writing the answer yourself first, then check it against this one.
1 1-Mark Questions
Q. Who is the poet of “The Tale of Melon City”?
Answer: Vikram Seth.
Q. From which collection is the poem taken, and in what year was it published?
Answer: It is taken from Mappings, published in 1981, and is included in the Collected Poems by Vikram Seth.
Q. What does the King order to be built, and why?
Answer: A triumphal arch across the city’s main thoroughfare, “To edify spectators there” (to impress and instruct the onlookers) as he rode past.
Q. Why is the King’s crown knocked off?
Answer: Because the arch was built too low.
Q. Who is first blamed for the mishap?
Answer: The chief of builders.
Q. When the masons are questioned, whom do they blame?
Answer: They blame the architect.
Q. What is the wisest man’s verdict?
Answer: That the arch itself is guilty and must be hanged, since it knocked the crown off the King’s head.
Q. What does the idiot answer when the guards ask him who should be King?
Answer: “A melon,” which was simply his standard answer to every question.
2 2-Mark Questions
Q. Why does the King order the arch built, according to the poem?
Answer: The King, described as “just and placid,” wants a triumphal arch built across the main road “To edify spectators there,” that is, to impress the people who watch him ride beneath it. The poem gives this one purpose only; it does not discuss any practical or defensive use.
Q. How does the chief of builders escape being hanged?
Answer: Just as he is about to be hanged, he shouts to the King, “O King, it was the workmen’s fault.” The King halts the execution and, still believing himself to be acting justly, turns his anger on the workmen instead.
Q. How does the architect defend himself before the King?
Answer: When the King orders him hanged, the architect reminds the King, “You made certain amendments to / The plans when I showed them to you.” This traces the real fault for the low arch back to the King’s own changes, ending the chain of blame at the very top.
Q. What is unusual about the wisest man the King summons, and why is calling him “wise” ironic?
Answer: He is so old that he “could not walk and could not see,” and has to be carried to the court. Calling him wise “therefore,” simply because of his age, is ironic, since his actual verdict, that a lifeless arch should be hanged, is one of the most foolish judgements in the whole poem.
Q. How does the Councillor save the arch from being hanged?
Answer: Just as the arch is being led to the scaffold, the Councillor objects, “How can we hang so shamefully / What touched your head, Your Majesty?” “True,” muses the King, and the arch is not hanged.
Q. Why does the King finally decide to have “someone” hanged immediately, regardless of guilt?
Answer: The crowd has grown restless and is muttering aloud; the King “perceived their mood and trembled” and says that “the nation / Wants a hanging.” He postpones “consideration / Of finer points like guilt” and orders that someone, anyone, be hanged at once, to satisfy the mob.
Q. How do the Ministers arrange for the next King to be chosen, and why?
Answer: They send out heralds to proclaim that whoever next passes the City Gate will choose the ruler of the state, “As is our custom,” to be “Enforced with due ceremony.” Being “practical-minded men,” they need a quick way to name a successor after the King’s sudden death, and the old custom gives them one.
Q. Why does the idiot answer “a melon” when asked who should be King?
Answer: The poem explains this plainly: “A melon” was simply “his standard answer to / All questions” (“He liked melons”). He is not making a political statement; the Ministers alone turn his careless habit into a coronation.
3 4-Mark Questions
Q. Trace the complete chain of blame in the poem, from the chief of builders to the King himself.
Answer: The King first blames the chief of builders for the low arch and orders him hanged.
The chief of builders escapes by blaming the workmen, who built the arch.
The workmen escape by blaming the bricks, which they say “were made of the wrong size”; the King then summons the masons.
The masons, “quivering,” escape by blaming the architect.
The architect escapes by reminding the King, “You made certain amendments to / The plans when I showed them to you,” tracing the fault back to the King, who the architect says amended the plans.
Q. Explain the central irony of the poem’s ending, when the King himself is hanged.
Answer: The King had decreed that “someone” must be hanged immediately, regardless of who was actually guilty, once he saw the restless crowd’s mood.
When every man is measured against the noose that had been set up, only one man turns out to be tall enough to fit it: the King himself.
He is therefore hanged “by Royal Decree,” meaning his own law, made to punish someone else, ends up killing him.
This is the poem’s sharpest irony: a King so concerned with the appearance of justice destroys himself through his own careless idea of it.
Q. What impression do you form of the King’s sense of “justice” over the course of the poem?
Answer: The King is introduced as “just and placid,” suggesting fairness and calm.
But his idea of justice, in practice, is simply to find someone to hang for every mishap, rather than to establish who is truly at fault.
He changes his mind repeatedly, from the chief of builders, to the workmen, to the architect, to the arch itself, showing that his “justice” is really just a search for a convenient scapegoat.
When the crowd grows restless, he postpones “consideration / Of finer points like guilt”, ordering an immediate hanging of “someone” because “The nation / Wants a hanging”, which suggests that his justice was never based on real guilt.
Q. Describe the roles of the wisest man and the Councillor, and how their actions together decide the arch’s fate.
Answer: The wisest man is summoned specifically to give an authoritative, fair verdict on who is guilty.
His actual verdict, that the arch itself must be hanged since it “banged the crown off,” is absurd, since an arch cannot be guilty of anything.
The Councillor then intervenes with an equally strange but effective argument: hanging the arch would be shameful, since it once touched the King’s own head.
Between them, the two men decide the arch’s fate: the wisest man condemns it, and the Councillor, with an argument about the King’s head, saves it. Neither decision rests on real justice, which one reading takes as the poem’s running joke that reasoned judgement plays almost no part in any of these decisions.
Q. Explain how the poem uses humour to make a serious point about injustice.
Answer: The poem describes absurd events, such as masons “quivering” with fear, an arch being formally led to a scaffold, and a melon crowned and “reverently set” on the throne, in a calm, matter-of-fact tone, which is what makes them funny.
This humour never hides the poem’s real subject: a chain of officials who value only the appearance of following a procedure, never actual guilt or fairness.
Because the reader laughs at each absurd step, the poem’s real criticism, of blind, procedure-obsessed “justice,” lands more sharply than a serious complaint would.
The biggest joke, the King hanged by his own decree, is also the poem’s most serious point: careless power can destroy the very person who wields it.
Q. How does the poem end, and what does its final couplet suggest about “laissez faire” as a form of government?
Answer: An idiot passing the City Gate answers “a melon” when the guards ask who is to be King, and the Ministers crown a melon King.
Years later, the people explain this as simple “customary choice,” saying a melon-king is “OK” with them “as long as he / Leaves us in Peace and Liberty.”
The poem’s final couplet states, “The principles of laissez faire / Seem to be well-established there”: the people are left free from interference, since their King is a melon.
One reading is that the suggestion is gently satirical: after a King who interferes constantly and unjustly, a ruler who does nothing may leave the people freer. The poem does not say whether this is good or bad.
4 6-Mark Questions
Q. “The Tale of Melon City” is a satire on rulers who confuse the form of justice with its substance. Discuss with reference to the poem.
Answer: Introduction: the poem’s King is called “just and placid,” yet his actions repeatedly show a hollow, procedural idea of justice rather than a fair one.
The pattern: at every stage, from the chief of builders to the architect, the King simply orders a hanging without ever pausing to check who is genuinely responsible.
The wisest man’s episode: even the person specially summoned for wisdom gives a verdict that a lifeless arch is guilty, showing that the poem doubts whether “wise” judgement is being exercised by anyone at all.
The crowd’s role: once the crowd grows restless, the King says outright that “The nation / Wants a hanging,” with guilt set aside as one of the “finer points” whose consideration is to be postponed.
The climax: the King’s own decree, made carelessly and for someone else, ends up hanging the King himself, the sharpest possible illustration of how empty and dangerous his notion of justice has been.
Conclusion: by building an absurd, escalating chain of scapegoating that finally consumes the King who started it, the poem satirises rulers and officials everywhere who prize the appearance of procedure over the substance of fairness.
Q. Trace the complete sequence of events in the poem from the building of the arch to the crowning of the melon, showing how each event causes the next.
Answer: The “just and placid” King orders a triumphal arch built “To edify spectators there,” to impress the people who will watch him ride beneath it.
The arch, built too low, knocks off his crown as he rides under it, which the King calls “a disgrace.”
This starts a chain of blame: the chief of builders blames the workmen; the workmen blame the bricks, which they say were made of the wrong size; the King summons the masons, who blame the architect; each escapes punishment in turn.
The architect reveals that the King himself amended the plans, so the King, calling it “a tricky thing,” summons “the wisest man in this country” for a verdict.
The wisest man, old and carried in because he cannot walk or see, rules that the arch itself must be hanged, but a Councillor saves it by objecting that it would be shameful to hang what touched the King’s head.
With the crowd now restless and muttering, the King says “The nation / Wants a hanging”; every man is measured for the noose, only the King is tall enough, and he is hanged “by Royal Decree.”
The relieved Ministers, who say the “unruly town” might have turned against the Crown had they found no one to hang, and being “practical-minded men,” send out heralds to proclaim, “As is our custom,” that whoever next passes the City Gate will choose the ruler.
An idiot happens to pass first, and answers “a melon” purely out of habit, so the Ministers crown a melon and carry it to the throne, where they “reverently set it down.”
Q. Discuss the poem’s use of irony and humour, quoting the exact lines that show each device.
Answer: Central irony: the King’s own decree, “Hanged must be / Someone, and that immediately,” ends up hanging the King himself, since “He was the King. His Majesty / Was therefore hanged by Royal Decree.”
A second irony: the Ministers cry, “‘Long live the King!’ the Ministers said. / ‘Long live the King! The King is dead,'” wishing long life to a King in the very same breath as announcing his death.
Humour from absurd solemnity: the masons “stood there quivering” in fear over bricks, and the arch is “led” to the scaffold as though it were a condemned prisoner.
Humour from the wisest man: he is chosen “so old (and therefore wise) was he” though he “could not walk and could not see,” and his verdict is that the arch must be hanged.
Humour from the ending: a melon is crowned and “reverently set… down” on the throne, treated exactly like a real monarch.
One reading: together, these devices let the poem’s serious criticism of blind, procedural “justice” land as sharp comedy rather than as a solemn lecture.
Q. What impression would you form of a state where the King was “just and placid”? Discuss with reference to the poem’s events, and explain how peace and liberty are eventually maintained in “Melon City.”
Answer: On the surface, “just and placid” suggests a fair, calm ruler, exactly the impression the poem invites the reader to question from its very first framing note.
In practice, this King’s justice consists only of finding someone, anyone, to hang for each mishap, moving the blame from the chief of builders down through the workmen, masons and architect, and even to the arch itself.
His “placid” calm gives way when the crowd grows restless (“The King perceived their mood and trembled”), and he sets aside even this pretence of justice by postponing “consideration / Of finer points like guilt” and ordering an immediate hanging.
The irony is complete when this same King is hanged by his own decree, showing that a state run this way is not truly just at all, only unpredictable and finally self-destructive.
Peace and liberty are eventually maintained not through wise rule but through the accident of a melon becoming King: with a melon as King, the people say they are left in “Peace and Liberty.”
The poem’s closing couplet on “laissez faire” suggests, half-seriously, that a ruler who does nothing at all can leave a state more peaceful and freer than one who “rules” actively but unjustly.
5 Case Studies
(A) 1 mark Why was the wisest man carried rather than made to walk to the court?
Answer: Because he was so old that he could not walk at all.
(B) 2 marks What does the poem mean by “so old (and therefore wise) was he”?
Answer: It humorously suggests that old age alone, not any real proof of wisdom, is treated as the qualification for being called “wisest,” gently mocking how such judgements are actually made.
(C) 3 marks What is ironic about the wisest man’s own verdict here?
Answer: The man chosen specifically for his wisdom delivers the single most absurd verdict in the entire poem, that a lifeless arch is guilty and must be hanged. One reading is that this is the poem’s joke about how little real wisdom or reason actually goes into deciding “justice” in this kingdom, whatever title is given to the person delivering it.
(A) 1 mark Who does “someone” refer to in this passage?
Answer: It refers to the King himself, who turned out to be the only man tall enough to fit the noose, which had been “set up somewhat high”.
(B) 2 marks Why are the Ministers relieved rather than grieving at the King’s death?
Answer: They are relieved because someone has been found to hang, and they say that if they had not found someone, the “unruly town” might have rebelled against the Crown itself.
(C) 3 marks Explain the irony in the Ministers’ own words, “Long live the King! The King is dead.”
Answer: “Long live the King” is traditionally a wish for a ruler’s long life and continued reign, but here the Ministers say it in the very same breath as announcing his death. One reading is that this shows how empty and automatic their loyalty and their ceremony have become, and that following the correct words and the correct procedure matters more to these officials than the real substance of what has actually happened.