Model answers to every exercise question of NCERT Snapshots, Chapter 5, “The Tale of Melon City.” The five questions are reproduced exactly as printed in the book; the answers are written for this site, not taken from NCERT. This chapter has no separate “Exercises” heading in the NCERT text: the 5 questions below are printed directly after the poem, with the same numbering as the book itself. Write your own answer first, then compare.
1 Questions
Q. Narrate ‘The Tale of Melon City’ in your own words.
Answer: A “just and placid” King orders a triumphal arch built across the city’s main road “To edify spectators there,” that is, to impress the people who will watch him ride beneath it. When the arch turns out to be too low, it knocks off his crown as he rides under it. A frown appears on his “placid face”, he calls it “a disgrace”, and he orders the chief of builders hanged.
The chief of builders escapes by blaming the workmen; the workmen blame the bricks, which they say were made of the wrong size; the King then summons the masons, who blame the architect. The architect, in turn, reminds the King that the King himself made changes to the plans, so the fault traces back to the King himself.
Calling this “a tricky thing” and asking for counsel, the King calls for “the wisest man in this country.” This man, so old that he can neither walk nor see, is carried in and rules that the arch itself must be hanged, since it knocked off the crown. As the arch is led to the scaffold, a Councillor objects that it would be shameful to hang something that touched the King’s own head. “True,” muses the King, and the arch is not hanged.
By now the crowd has grown restless and is muttering aloud. The King perceives their mood and trembles; he postpones “consideration / Of finer points like guilt,” says “The nation / Wants a hanging,” and orders that “someone” be hanged immediately. Every man is measured against the noose that has been set up, and only one man is found tall enough to fit it: the King himself. He is hanged “by Royal Decree,” his own law used to punish him.
The Ministers, relieved rather than grieving, say that if they had not found someone, “the unruly town / Might well have turned against the Crown.” They say, “Long live the King! The King is dead,” and, “Being practical-minded men,” send out heralds to proclaim, “As is our custom,” that whoever next passes the City Gate will choose the ruler. An idiot happens to pass first, and answers “A melon” when the guards ask who is to be King, simply because that was his standard answer to every question. The Ministers take him literally, crown a melon and set it on the throne.
Years later, when asked how a melon became King, the people explain it as “customary choice,” saying a melon-king is “OK” with them as long as he leaves them in “Peace and Liberty.” The poem ends by noting that “The principles of laissez faire / Seem to be well-established there.”
Q. What impression would you form of a state where the King was ‘just and placid’?
Answer: On the surface, calling the King “just and placid” suggests a fair-minded, calm ruler, and this is exactly the impression the poem’s own opening note invites the reader to question. In practice, the King’s “justice” turns out to mean nothing more than finding someone to hang after every mishap, without ever pausing to find out who is truly responsible: his sentence moves from the chief of builders, to the workmen, to the architect, and even orders a lifeless arch hanged on the wisest man’s advice.
His “placid” calm also proves hollow: the moment the crowd grows restless, he trembles, postpones “consideration / Of finer points like guilt” and orders an immediate hanging simply to satisfy the mob. A state ruled this way would feel deeply unpredictable and unsafe for its people, since punishment depends on who is available to blame rather than who is actually guilty. The final irony, the King being hanged by his own careless decree, confirms that his “justice” was never grounded in fairness at all, only in the appearance of following a procedure.
Q. How, according to you, can peace and liberty be maintained in a state?
Answer: This is an open question inviting the student’s own view, connected to the poem’s own suggestion. In the poem, peace and liberty are maintained almost by accident, once a melon, which cannot command, judge or punish anyone, becomes King: with no active ruler interfering in their lives, the people say they have their “Peace and Liberty,” and the closing couplet says “The principles of laissez faire / Seem to be well-established there.” The poem’s satirical tone leaves open whether this is a good way to run a state.
Beyond the poem, peace and liberty in a real state are better maintained through fair and consistent laws applied equally to everyone, governance that listens to reasoned argument rather than the loudest crowd, freedom for citizens to live and speak without unnecessary interference, and rulers or institutions who are themselves accountable for their mistakes rather than passing the blame onto others, unlike almost every official in this poem.
Q. Suggest a few instances in the poem which highlight humour and irony.
Answer: Irony: the King’s own decree, meant to punish someone else, ends up hanging the King himself: “He was the King. His Majesty / Was therefore hanged by Royal Decree.” A second irony is the Ministers crying, “‘Long live the King!’ the Ministers said. / ‘Long live the King! The King is dead.'” wishing the King long life in the very same breath as announcing his death.
Humour: the masons “stood there quivering” with fear over the bricks; the wisest man is chosen for his supposed wisdom even though “he could not walk and could not see,” simply because he was “so old (and therefore wise)”; the arch itself is treated as a guilty prisoner and “led” toward the scaffold; and, at the very end, a melon is crowned and “reverently set… down” on the throne, exactly as if it were a real monarch.
Q. ‘The Tale of Melon City’ has been narrated in a verse form. This is a unique style which lends extra charm to an ancient tale. Find similar examples in your language. Share them in the class.
Answer: This is a classroom activity asking students to find examples in their own language, so individual answers will vary. The general point to make is that many languages have a long tradition of telling old, often moral or humorous, stories in rhyming verse rather than prose, for example, ballads, folk songs and verse fables passed down orally, since a rhythm and a rhyme scheme make a story easier to remember, recite and pass on to the next generation, exactly the effect Vikram Seth achieves in this poem by retelling an old tale credited to Idries Shah in short rhyming couplets.
A student answering this in class should name one or two verse narratives they actually know in their own mother tongue or a language they study (for instance, traditional Hindi or regional-language ballads, verse folk tales, or well-known rhyming fables), and briefly say what story each one tells, rather than leaving the question unanswered for want of an English example.