Complete solutions to the NCERT Woven Words textbook’s own questions on Poetry Item 8, “For Elkana” by Nissim Ezekiel. This is a short unit: the book gives six “Understanding the Poem” questions and one reflective activity (“Try This Out”). Try answering each one yourself first, then check.
This chapter is in the NCERT book but is not in the CBSE 2026-27 English Elective syllabus, so it is not assessed in the CBSE board paper this year. Study it for other boards that use the NCERT book, or for practice.
1 Understanding the Poem
Q. Comment on the subtlety with which the poet captures the general pattern of communication within a family.
Answer: Much of the family’s real communication in the poem happens without speech. The narrator avoids arguing with his wife by silently withdrawing into his own thoughts rather than disagreeing aloud. The parents agree completely on “Children Must be Disciplined” but only as an “unspoken thought,” and then do not act on it together: after “She looks at me. I look away.” the wife alone delivers the verdict “Wait.” The father privately notices that “the boy is like his father” without saying so to anyone in the poem. The one moment the family shares openly is the wife’s “delightful laughter” that “holds the three of us together.” Ezekiel shows, subtly and without any big dramatic scene, that a family often communicates as much through silence, private thought and shared unspoken understanding as through actual conversation.
Q. Poetic effect is achieved in the poem through understatement and asides. Discuss this with examples.
Answer: Understatement appears when the father, having been completely won over by his son’s argument, responds with the deliberately mild “This argument appeals to me,” instead of showing open delight or pride at his son’s cleverness. Asides appear when the narrator breaks into the narration with a private, self-mocking comment the other characters never hear, such as “except of course the man she loves / who happened to be me.” Both devices let the reader share a quiet joke with the poet that the other characters inside the poem are never let in on, which is exactly what gives the poem its gentle, conspiratorial humour.
Q. How is the idyllic juxtaposed with the pedestrian in the poem?
Answer: The poem opens on an idyllic scene: a “warm April evening,” “breezes / sauntering across the lawn,” and a family sitting outside in comfortable silence. Directly against this, Ezekiel places pedestrian, ordinary domestic details: a “broken window-pane,” a demanding seven-year-old, a mother who “wags a finger” and “delivers verdict.” The pleasant natural setting and the ordinary, mildly comic household scene sit side by side throughout the poem, and it is exactly this contrast that gives the poem its warmth: nothing dramatic happens, only real family life unfolding inside a pleasant evening.
Q. Explain the undertones in the statement: ‘Wife and husband in unusual rapport / State one unspoken thought’:
Answer: Calling the agreement “unusual rapport” hints that the couple do not usually agree so completely, so this rare moment of unity is treated almost as a small event worth noting. That the thought is “unspoken” adds a further undertone: real agreement exists between them, but it is never actually voiced, and, as the very next line shows (“She looks at me. I look away.”), it is not acted on by both parents together; the wife then delivers the verdict “Wait.” The undertone is gently ironic: the agreement is unspoken, and the parents do not act on it together.
Q. Comment on the capitalisation of all the words in the line: ‘Children Must be Disciplined’.
Answer: Capitalising every word turns a private parental thought into something that reads like a printed rule, a law, or a proverb. This is deliberately comic: it exaggerates the seriousness with which the parents privately hold this belief, especially since the very next line, “She looks at me. I look away.”, shows both parents hesitating, and the wife’s ruling is only “Wait.” One reading is that the capitalisation gently mocks how grand parents make their own everyday convictions sound.
Q. What makes the urgency of the child’s demand seem logical?
Answer: The boy does not only repeat his demand; he gives an actual reason: “in five minutes I won’t be hungry any more.” This is a real, if child-sized, piece of logic, since it argues that waiting would defeat the very purpose of eating. It is precisely this reasoning, not mere impatience, that makes his urgency feel logical, and it is why the father says, “This argument appeals to me. / Such a logician deserves his dinner straightaway.”
2 Try This Out (Reflective Activity)
Q. Paraphrase the poem and notice the change in effect. Comment on the deft touch with which the poet transforms ordinary events into evocative poetry.
Answer: This is a personal writing activity with no single fixed answer. A short model paraphrase: “One warm evening, my wife and I sit on the lawn. She points out a broken window and hints I should have fixed it. I ignore her and think about something else instead. Our seven-year-old son suddenly demands his dinner. We both silently agree he should be disciplined, but we do not act on it together. His mother tells him to wait five minutes; he refuses, arguing that in five minutes he won’t be hungry any more. I find his logic convincing and take his side. His mother laughs, and the argument ends happily as we all go inside.” Notice how paraphrasing keeps every event but loses the poem’s wit, timing and irony, the private asides, the mock-formal “delivers verdict,” the capitalised “Children Must be Disciplined”, which is exactly the “deft touch” this activity asks you to notice: Ezekiel’s skill lies less in WHAT happens than in HOW he tells it.