A condensed summary of Class 11 English Woven Words, Book 3, Poetry Item 8, “For Elkana” by Nissim Ezekiel (with the NCERT note on “The Limerick”), for last-minute revision: movement-wise gist, poetic devices, theme, key quotes and all definitions in one place. The full notes are available separately for detailed reading.
This chapter is in the NCERT book but is not in the CBSE 2026-27 English Elective syllabus, so it is not assessed in the CBSE board paper this year. Study it for other boards that use the NCERT book, or for practice.
1 The Poem, Movement by Movement, at a Glance
| Movement | Gist |
|---|---|
| 1 | Idyllic April evening on the lawn; wife comments on a broken window-pane |
| 2 | Wife’s mild criticism; narrator’s wry aside and private withdrawal |
| 3 | Seven-year-old son demands dinner; parents silently agree “Children Must be Disciplined” |
| 4 | Wife’s ruling: “Wait. In five minutes I’ll serve you dinner.” |
| 5 | Son refuses, arguing he “won’t be hungry any more” in five minutes |
| 6 | Father sides with the boy, calling him “a logician” |
| 7 | Wife’s laughter holds the family together; they go into the house |
2 Poetic Devices at a Glance
Understatement
“This argument appeals to me.”
Asides
“except of course the man she loves / who happened to be me.”
Juxtaposition
Idyllic lawn evening set against a broken window-pane and a dinner-time squabble
Irony
“Unusual rapport” that stays unspoken: “She looks at me. I look away.”
Capitalisation
“Children Must be Disciplined” reads like a mock-formal rule
Simile
“crescent-moon-like chin uplifted”
Free verse
No fixed rhyme scheme; stanzas of very different lengths (the longest has 14 lines)
3 Theme
Theme (one reading; the book does not state a theme): An ordinary family evening, a small dinner-time disagreement with a seven-year-old son, observed with warmth and gentle irony. The poem studies how a family communicates through private asides, an unspoken parental agreement the parents do not act on together, and a dispute that ends in shared laughter rather than discipline.
“My wife’s delightful laughter / holds the three of us together.”
The poem’s closing lines
4 Key Facts Worth Memorising
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Poet | Nissim Ezekiel (1924-2004), born Mumbai; educated Wilson College Bombay, Birbeck College London |
| Career | Professor of American Literature, Bombay University; critic; playwright |
| Verse form | Free verse, 55 lines in stanzas of very different lengths, studied here as 7 movements |
| Son’s age | Seven years old |
| Boy’s reasoning | “in five minutes I won’t be hungry any more”: answers NCERT Q6 |
| Title dedication | “For Elkana”; NCERT text never explains who Elkana is, so do not assert this as fact |
| Suggested reading | The Night of the Scorpion and Other Poems by Nissim Ezekiel |
| Limerick form | 5-line comic poem, rhyme scheme aabba (lines 1,2,5 / lines 3,4), punch or joke usually in the last line |
- Written by Nissim Ezekiel (1924-2004), “perhaps the best known Indian poet to have written in English” (book’s own words)
- A wife’s mild criticism, a son’s dinner demand, and the family’s dispute ending in laughter
- Key devices: understatement, asides, juxtaposition, irony, capitalisation for mock-formality, simile, free verse
- “Children Must be Disciplined” is a silent, ironic agreement that the poem never carries through: “She looks at me. I look away.”
- The boy’s demand feels logical because he reasons “I won’t be hungry any more” in five minutes
- Ending: connection, not correction, “delightful laughter… holds the three of us together”
- The Limerick: five lines, rhyme scheme aabba, punch or joke usually in the last line, compared to slapstick comedy