Class 11 English Book 3 Chapter 18 Felling of the Banyan Tree Notes in English

What you will learn in this chapter
  • Who Dilip Chitre was, and which of his own books this poem is taken from
  • The complete poem, exactly as the book prints it, explained movement by movement
  • Every poetic device the poem actually uses, with the exact line that proves it
  • What the banyan tree is often read as symbolising, and why its felling can be read as standing for something larger than one tree
  • The usual reading of the poem’s theme: the destruction of nature and tradition, and the loss of roots that follows
  • How to answer an extract-based or line-based question from this poem, with a worked example
Dilip ChitreTravelling in a Cagesymbolismsimilepersonificationmetaphorironyfree verseraw mythologymassacred
CBSE 2026-27

This chapter is in the NCERT book but is not in the CBSE 2026-27 English Elective syllabus, so it is not assessed in the CBSE board paper this year. Study it for other boards that use the NCERT book, or for practice.

1Meet the Poet

1.1 About Dilip Chitre

Dilip Chitre (1938-2009) was born in Baroda. The book’s own note tells us he wrote poetry in both Marathi and English. This poem is taken from his collection Travelling in a Cage, published in 1980. Besides poetry, Chitre also wrote short stories and critical essays, and An Anthology of Marathi Poetry 1945-1965 is named as one of his most important works of translation. The book adds that he “sees poetry as an expression of the spirit,” and closes by saying he “lives and works in Mumbai,” the book’s own present-tense wording, even though Chitre passed away in 2009; it is kept here exactly as the textbook prints it.

1938-2009Dilip Chitre’s life span
1980year Travelling in a Cage was published
Marathi + Englishthe two languages he wrote poetry in
Exam Tip

If asked “from which collection is this poem taken?”, the answer is Travelling in a Cage (1980). If asked about his translation work, the answer is An Anthology of Marathi Poetry 1945-1965: note that this is a work of translation, not a collection of his own poems.

2The Poem, in Full

The poem is printed by NCERT in three stanzas, with almost no internal punctuation, only a handful of commas, so that it reads as one continuous, unbroken recollection. Reproduced below exactly as the book gives it.

Felling of the Banyan Tree · Dilip Chitre

My father told the tenants to leave
Who lived on the houses surrounding our house on the hill
One by one the structures were demolished
Only our own house remained and the trees
Trees are sacred my grandmother used to say
Felling them is a crime but he massacred them all
The sheoga, the oudumber, the neem were all cut down
But the huge banyan tree stood like a problem
Whose roots lay deeper than all our lives
My father ordered it to be removed

The banyan tree was three times as tall as our house
Its trunk had a circumference of fifty feet
Its scraggy aerial roots fell to the ground
From thirty feet or more so first they cut the branches
Sawing them off for seven days and the heap was huge
Insects and birds began to leave the tree

And then they came to its massive trunk
Fifty men with axes chopped and chopped
The great tree revealed its rings of two hundred years
We watched in terror and fascination this slaughter
As a raw mythology revealed to us its age
Soon afterwards we left Baroda for Bombay
Where there are no trees except the one
Which grows and seethes in one’s dreams, its aerial roots
Looking for the ground to strike.

3Understanding the Poem, Movement by Movement

The poem has no titles for its three stanzas, but it moves through four clear stages. Reading it this way is the fastest way to hold the whole poem in your head for the exam.

Movement 1 · Stanza 1The poet’s father tells the tenants around the family’s hillside house to leave; their houses are demolished one by one, leaving only the family’s own house and its trees. The grandmother’s belief that “trees are sacred” is set against the father, who “massacred them all”: the sheoga, the oudumber, the neem; the poem adds that felling them “is a crime”. Only the huge banyan tree, which “stood like a problem” with roots “deeper than all our lives,” is singled out: the father orders it removed too.
↓
Movement 2 · Stanza 2The poet now describes the tree itself: three times as tall as the house, a trunk fifty feet around, and “scraggy aerial roots” that “fell to the ground / From thirty feet or more“. So the workers begin with the branches, sawing them off for seven days until the heap is huge; insects and birds begin to leave the tree.
↓
Movement 3 · Stanza 3, lines 1-5Then they come to the massive trunk: “Fifty men with axes chopped and chopped”. “The great tree revealed its rings of two hundred years“. The family watches this “slaughter” in “terror and fascination”, “As a raw mythology revealed to us its age”.
↓
Movement 4 · Stanza 3, lines 6-9Soon after, the family leaves Baroda for Bombay, a city with “no trees except the one / Which grows and seethes in one’s dreams”, its aerial roots “Looking for the ground to strike.” One reading is that the tree cut down in real life lives on, restlessly, in the poet’s imagination.
One reading (not from the NCERT text)Definition 1: What the Poem Is About (Theme)

The book does not state a theme. A common reading is that the poem is about the destruction of nature and of inherited tradition by the father’s order to clear the land of trees, including the banyan, and the lasting sense of loss this leaves behind. The poem tells this through one banyan tree: trees are “sacred”, as the grandmother “used to say”; the father “ordered it to be removed”; and once cut down, it still “grows and seethes in one’s dreams”, its aerial roots “Looking for the ground to strike.”

4The Banyan Tree as a Symbol

The banyan tree can be read as more than just a tree in this poem. The book does not say what it stands for, so the points below are a reading, supported by the poem’s own lines.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 2: Symbolism

Symbolism is when an object in a poem stands for an idea beyond itself. The banyan tree is often read as a symbol of tradition, ancestry and continuity: it is older than any living member of the family (“Whose roots lay deeper than all our lives”), and its age, shown by its “rings of two hundred years”, is spoken of as “a raw mythology”. On this reading, cutting it down stands for the destruction of an inherited past.

Common Mistake

Do not say the poem is only about environmental destruction. It is about that, but many readers also see the banyan tree as a symbol of family history and tradition: the grandmother’s saying that “Trees are sacred”, and roots that “lay deeper than all our lives”, support a reading of the poem as being about a family (and a wider society) losing its roots.

5Poetic Devices Used

Every device below is tied to its exact line in the poem, so learn each device together with its example. The book does not name these devices; the definitions are standard literary terms.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 3: Simile

A simile is a comparison between two unlike things using “like” or “as”. This poem uses one clear simile: “the huge banyan tree stood like a problem”, comparing the ancient tree to an obstacle that stands in the way of something the father wants done.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 4: Metaphor

A metaphor is a comparison that does not use “like” or “as”: one thing is spoken of directly as another. “a raw mythology” is a metaphor: the tree, with its “rings of two hundred years”, is spoken of directly as an ancient body of myth. The line reads “As a raw mythology revealed to us its age”, but here “As” means “while”: it joins the line to “We watched in terror and fascination this slaughter”, so it is not a simile. “Whose roots lay deeper than all our lives” is also a metaphor, using the tree’s physical roots to stand for a tradition and history deeper than any living person’s memory.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 5: Personification

Personification gives a human action to something non-human. In the poem’s final image, the dream-tree’s aerial roots are “looking for the ground to strike,” as if the roots themselves were searching, the way a person searches for solid ground to stand on.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 6: Irony and Contrast

Irony is a gap between what is said or believed and what actually happens. The grandmother “used to say” “Trees are sacred”, and the poem adds “Felling them is a crime”; yet the father “massacred them all” (the sheoga, the oudumber, the neem) and then ordered the banyan “to be removed”. The word “massacred”, normally used for the mass killing of people, applied here to trees, sharpens this contrast and can be read as showing the poet’s critical judgement of his father’s act.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 7: Repetition

Repetition is saying the same word more than once for effect. “Fifty men with axes chopped and chopped” repeats “chopped” to capture the relentless, mechanical, unending violence of the felling, blow after blow with no pause.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 8: Imagery

Imagery is language that creates a picture in the reader’s mind by appealing to the senses. The poem is built almost entirely out of strong visual imagery: the huge heap of sawn branches, insects and birds leaving the tree, fifty men chopping at the massive trunk, the rings of two hundred years suddenly exposed, and the aerial roots that appear again “in one’s dreams.”

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 9: Free Verse and Enjambment

Free verse is poetry with no fixed rhyme scheme and no regular metre. This poem is written in free verse, and almost every line runs on into the next without stopping (enjambment): for example, “But the huge banyan tree stood like a problem / Whose roots lay deeper than all our lives” is one continuous thought split only by the line break, not by punctuation. The poem also has almost no internal punctuation at all, which makes it read as a single unbroken memory rather than a set of separate, punctuated statements.

6The Poem at a Glance

Point Detail
Poet Dilip Chitre (1938-2009)
Collection Travelling in a Cage (1980)
Form Free verse, three stanzas, almost no internal punctuation
Rhyme scheme None (free verse)
Narrator / voice First person: the poet (“we”, “our house”), recalling the felling of the family’s banyan tree
Setting The family’s house on a hill in Baroda; later, a move to Bombay
Central theme (one reading) Destruction of nature and tradition by the father’s order to fell the trees, and the roots that are lost with it
Key symbol (one reading) The banyan tree: tradition, ancestry, continuity
Key contrast The grandmother’s saying that trees are sacred against the father, who “massacred them all” and ordered the banyan removed
Tone Critical of the father, mixed with the family’s own “terror and fascination” while watching
Closing image The tree survives only in dreams, its roots still “looking for the ground to strike”
Figure 1 The banyan tree's scale, as the poem's own numbers describe it: three times the house's height, a fifty-foot trunk circumference, and aerial roots that "fell to the ground / From thirty feet or more".
Figure 1 The banyan tree’s scale, as the poem’s own numbers describe it: three times the house’s height, a fifty-foot trunk circumference, and aerial roots that “fell to the ground / From thirty feet or more”.

7Why “Felling of the Banyan Tree”?

The title names the poem’s central event directly: “felling” is the plain word for cutting a tree down, and in the poem it is an act the father orders (“My father ordered it to be removed”), not an accident. Naming the banyan specifically, rather than just “a tree,” points to the one tree the poem singles out from the sheoga, the oudumber and the neem: the tree “Whose roots lay deeper than all our lives” and whose rings showed “two hundred years”. One reading is that this is what makes its felling feel like the loss of something that should have outlived the whole family.

Exam Tip

If asked to “Comment on the contemporary concern that the poem echoes” (the book’s own eighth question), connect the poem to the wider, real-world pattern of old trees being cut down for construction, roads or private convenience: the same conflict between short-term human decisions and long-lived nature that the poem dramatises through one family’s banyan tree.

8Words to Know

Word / Phrase Meaning
scraggy thin, rough and untidy-looking (the book asks you to guess this word’s meaning from the context; it describes the tree’s aerial roots)
massacred killed on a large, brutal scale; used here for the mass destruction of trees, not people
circumference the distance around the outside of something round, here the trunk
aerial roots roots that grow above the ground, hanging down from the branches, typical of a banyan tree
mythology a body of old, half-legendary stories or beliefs; in the poem, the tree that revealed its age is spoken of as “a raw mythology”
seethes moves or churns restlessly, as if boiling with contained energy
tenants people who live in a house or building that belongs to someone else

9Answering Extract-Based and Line-Based Questions

An extract-based question gives a short extract from the poem and asks two or three questions on it. The method below works for any lines from this poem.

Solved Example

Extract: “But the huge banyan tree stood like a problem / Whose roots lay deeper than all our lives / My father ordered it to be removed”

Q. Identify the poetic device in “stood like a problem,” and explain what the line suggests about the banyan tree.

Step 1: Spot the comparing word “like”, which signals a simile.
Step 2: Identify the two things being compared: the tree, and a “problem” that stands in someone’s way.
Step 3: Connect it to the poem’s theme: the tree is not really a problem in itself, it only becomes one because it stands between the father and what he wants done with the land, which shows the poem’s critical view of the father’s decision.
Answer: The device is a simile. It compares the huge banyan tree to “a problem,” suggesting that, for the father’s plan to clear the land, the deeply rooted tree was in the way, an obstacle to be removed rather than something sacred to be preserved. The poem’s critical tone towards the felling (“massacred”, “slaughter”) suggests the poet does not share that view.

Exam Tip

Always name the device first, then quote the exact words that show it, then explain the effect in your own words. A one-word answer like “simile” with no explanation is incomplete.

Three of the book’s questions, in brief

Q2 (the father’s nature): the words “told the tenants to leave”, “massacred them all” and “ordered it to be removed” show a man who acts with authority and without hesitation, unmoved by the view that trees are sacred.

Q4 (“grows and seethes”): “grows” keeps the felled tree alive in the poet’s dreams; “seethes” suggests churning, restless energy, so the tree does not rest in memory as a calm picture but stays stirred up and unsettled.

Q7 (“Whose roots lay deeper than our lives”): the line reflects how people can destroy, by one quick decision, something far older than any human life, with roots that go deeper than anyone living. The full answers to all eight questions are in this chapter’s NCERT Solutions.

All definitions in one place
ThemeOne reading: destruction of nature and tradition by the father’s order to fell the trees, and the roots that are lost with it
SymbolismOne reading: the banyan tree stands for tradition, ancestry and continuity: “roots lay deeper than all our lives”
SimileA comparison using “like” or “as”: “the huge banyan tree stood like a problem”
MetaphorA direct comparison with no “like”/”as”: “a raw mythology”; “roots lay deeper than all our lives”
PersonificationA human action given to something non-human: aerial roots “looking for the ground to strike”
Irony / ContrastThe grandmother’s “Trees are sacred” against the father, who “massacred them all” and ordered the banyan removed
RepetitionA word repeated for effect: “chopped and chopped”
ImageryLanguage that creates a picture for the senses: the heap of branches, the axes, the exposed rings
Free verse / EnjambmentNo fixed rhyme or metre; lines run on without stopping, almost no internal punctuation
Quick Revision: read this the night before the exam
  • Poet: Dilip Chitre (1938-2009), from the collection Travelling in a Cage (1980)
  • The father tells the tenants to leave; their houses are demolished one by one; the grandmother used to say trees are sacred, but the father “massacred” all of them, including the sheoga, oudumber and neem
  • The banyan tree alone is singled out: it “stood like a problem” whose “roots lay deeper than all our lives”; the father orders it removed too
  • The tree’s size: three times the house’s height, fifty-foot circumference; its aerial roots “fell to the ground / From thirty feet or more”
  • The felling: branches sawn for seven days; fifty men with axes “chopped and chopped”; the trunk’s rings show two hundred years, “a raw mythology”
  • The family watches in “terror and fascination,” then moves from Baroda to Bombay
  • Closing image: no trees in Bombay except the one that survives in dreams, its roots still “looking for the ground to strike”
  • Central theme (one reading): destruction of nature and inherited tradition, and the lasting sense of lost roots
Check yourself before the exam
  • Can I recite or summarise the poem’s four movements in the correct order?
  • Can I explain why the banyan tree can be read as a symbol, not just a tree?
  • Can I name and quote the poem’s simile, at least two metaphors, and its one clear personification?
  • Can I explain the irony between the grandmother’s belief and the father’s action?
  • Can I give the tree’s physical details (height, circumference, root length, age) from memory?
  • Can I explain what the closing dream-image of the tree suggests?
  • Can I answer all 8 of the book’s own “Understanding the Poem” questions in full sentences?