Class 11 History Chapter 6 Displacing Indigenous Peoples NCERT Solutions in English

All six exercise questions from the NCERT textbook Themes in World History, Theme 6, “Displacing Indigenous Peoples”, exactly as the English edition prints them, with a full model answer for each. The first four come under the book’s heading Answer in Brief and the last two under Answer in a Short Essay. They are followed by the in-text questions: two from the Section IV introduction and timeline printed with this chapter, and the theme’s four Activities. Write your own answer first, then check it against this one.

1 South American and North American natives compared

Question 1

Q. Comment on any points of difference between the native peoples of South and North America.

Answer: The chapter itself sets the two apart at several points. Any two or three of the differences below make a complete answer.

Point of difference North America South and Central America
Agriculture No extensive agriculture was attempted, so no surplus was produced. Agriculture produced a surplus, which is what made larger states possible.
Political organisation People lived in bands, in villages along river valleys. No kingdoms or empires developed. Kingdoms and empires developed, which is why the chapter uses them as the contrast.
Control of land There were occasional quarrels between tribes over territory, but by and large control of land was not an issue, and they felt no need to “own” the land. Settled kingdoms rested on the control of territory and of the people who farmed it.
Who colonised them, and when France, Holland and England came from the seventeenth century, first to trade in fish and furs. Spain and Portugal came earlier, and their American empires stopped expanding after the seventeenth century. The Spanish were “overcome by the abundance of gold”.
What the first traders wanted Fish and furs, for which the natives’ hunting expertise was useful, so the first encounters were friendly. Gold above all, which is the reason the chapter gives for how differently the Spanish behaved.
How many survived In the USA in 1820 there were 0.6 million natives against 9.0 million whites, in a total of 11.6 million. In Spanish America in 1800 there were 7.5 million natives against 3.3 million whites, in a total of 16.9 million.
Mixed populations Mixed Europeans numbered only 0.1 million in the USA in 1820. Mixed Europeans numbered 5.3 million in Spanish America in 1800, a far larger share of the population.

The point to end on. The population figures are the sharpest difference of all, and they follow from the rest. In the north the natives were displaced by a settler population that wanted the land itself, so their numbers collapsed and they were pushed onto reservations. In Spanish America the natives remained the largest single group and a large mixed population grew up alongside them.

2 English economic and social life in nineteenth-century USA

Question 2

Q. Other than the use of English, what other features of English economic and social life do you notice in nineteenth-century USA?

Answer: Several habits and institutions the settlers carried with them are visible in the chapter.

1. Private ownership of land, and inheritance by the eldest son. Some of the migrants from Britain and France were younger sons who would not inherit their fathers’ property, and were therefore eager to own land in America. They brought with them the idea that land is property an individual owns outright. That is the exact opposite of the native view, and it is what made the “right to property” so central to the US constitution.

2. Farming for the market rather than for use. Settlers introduced crops such as rice and cotton which could not be grown in Europe and could therefore be sold there for profit. Growing a crop in order to sell it in a distant market is commercial agriculture of the English kind, and Jefferson’s “dream” of a country of small European-owned farms belongs to the same picture.

3. The plantation, and slave labour. In the southern states, large plantations growing crops for sale were worked by slaves bought in Africa. The southern climate was too hot for Europeans to work outdoors, and enslaved natives had died in large numbers in South America, so plantation owners bought slaves in Africa.

4. Industry and the machine. Industrial towns grew and factories multiplied. The chapter is careful to note that the reason was different from England’s: there, small peasants losing land to big farmers moved into factory jobs, whereas in North America industry grew to make railway equipment and large-scale farming machinery. The form is English, the cause is not.

5. Enclosure of the land. Wolves and mountain lions were hunted to extinction to protect the huge farms, and settlers felt totally secure only with the invention of barbed wire in 1873. A landscape divided by fences into private holdings is an English landscape.

6. English law and representative government. The “democratic spirit” of the 1770s settlers, the vote for representatives to Congress, and a written guarantee of the individual’s right to property all grew out of English political argument, even though they were used against the English king. Both these rights, however, were for white men only.

7. Convict settlement. The British used the American colonies as a place to send convicts until those colonies became independent, and only then moved the practice to Australia. That too was an English institution planted on American soil.

3 What the “frontier” meant to the Americans

Question 3

Q. What did the “frontier” mean to the Americans?

Answer: “Americans” in this chapter is a term used to mean the European people of the USA, and to them the word carried four meanings at once.

1. A line that moved. Canada and the USA came into existence at the end of the eighteenth century, occupying only a fraction of the land they now cover. The western “frontier” of the USA was a shifting one, and as it moved, the natives were forced to move back with it. It was never a border between two states in the ordinary sense.

2. Land that could be had. Large areas were acquired by purchase, the Louisiana Purchase from France and Alaska from Russia, and by war, much of southern USA being won from Mexico. Beyond the line lay land that a poor European could buy cheaply and own, which is why the frontier drew younger sons from Britain and France, families from Germany, Sweden and Italy who had lost their land to big farmers, and Poles who found the prairie grasslands like the steppes of home.

3. A licence to ignore whoever lived there. It did not occur to anyone that the consent of the natives living in these areas should have been asked. The frontier was imagined as empty, and the people already on it were treated as an obstacle rather than as owners.

4. A national idea. Karl Marx described the American frontier as “the last positive capitalist utopia… the limitless nature and space to which the limitless thirst for profit adapts itself”. The frontier stood for a future that had no limit, and the “democratic spirit” of the settlers grew alongside it.

How it ended, and why that mattered. In 1892 the USA’s continental expansion was complete. The area between the Pacific and the Atlantic was divided into states and there no longer remained a frontier to pull European settlers west. Within a few years the USA was setting up colonies in Hawaii and the Philippines: it had become an imperial power. The frontier had not so much closed as moved overseas.

4 Why Australian native history was left out

Question 4

Q. Why was the history of the Australian native peoples left out of history books?

Answer:

1. History was made to begin with Captain Cook. Till the middle of the twentieth century, Australian history textbooks described how Europeans had “discovered” Australia, and hardly mentioned the native peoples except to suggest that they were hostile to Europeans. Henry Reynolds later condemned exactly this in his book Why Weren’t We Told?, which attacked the practice of writing Australian history as though it had begun with Cook’s “discovery”.

2. The natives were studied as specimens, not as people with a past. Anthropology had been introduced out of a curiosity to compare native “primitive” communities with the “civilised” communities of Europe, and some anthropologists argued that the American and Australian natives would simply “die out”, just as no “primitive” people remained in Europe. A people expected to disappear was not thought to have a history worth writing.

3. There was no written record of the kind historians accepted. Their past was not kept in documents. It survived in “vast bodies of stories”, in textile, painting and carving skills, and in the idea of the “Dreamtime”, in which the distinction between past and present is blurred. Historians who wrote the country’s history from the settlers’ side did not draw on any of it.

4. Silence was convenient. Australia, unlike the USA, Canada and New Zealand, had no treaties with the natives formalising the European takeover of land, because the government had always termed the land terra nullius, belonging to nobody. Writing the natives into the history of the country would have raised the question of how their land was taken, and of the children of mixed blood who had been forcibly separated from their relatives.

5. When the silence broke. In 1968 people were electrified by a lecture by the anthropologist W.E.H. Stanner called “The Great Australian Silence”, which was precisely about the silence of historians on the aborigines. From the 1970s, as in North America, there was an eagerness to understand natives as communities with distinct cultures and their own ways of understanding nature and climate. University departments were set up to study native cultures, galleries of native art were added, museums were enlarged with dioramas and rooms explaining native culture, and natives began writing their own life histories. The chapter calls this “a wonderful effort” and notes that it came at a critical time, because much of these cultures would otherwise have been forgotten.

5 How satisfactory is a museum gallery display?

Question 5

Q. How satisfactory is a museum gallery display in explaining the culture of a people? Give examples from your own experience of a museum.

Answer: This question asks for your own opinion, so the examiner is looking for a balanced answer with reasons on both sides and at least one example you have actually seen. Below is a model you can adapt.

What a museum gallery does well. It puts the real object in front of you, and an object carries information that no description does: the weight of a stone tool, the closeness of the weave in a textile, the colours of shells in a belt. The chapter says the natives of North America were skilled craftspeople who wove beautiful textiles, and a single case of their weaving makes that sentence real. A gallery also arranges things so you can compare them, and it can bring together objects that were never in one place. In Australia, museums were enlarged to incorporate dioramas and imaginatively designed rooms explaining native culture, and university departments were set up to study those cultures, so the display can carry serious scholarship behind it.

Where it falls short. A gallery shows objects, and a culture is mostly not made of objects. Wampum belts can be displayed, but the treaty ceremony they recorded cannot. The natives’ belief that time moved in cycles, their accounts of their own origins passed from one generation to the next, the ability to “read the land” the way a literate person reads a text, the “Dreamtime” in which past and present are not separate: none of these can be put in a case. A display also freezes a people at one moment, so the visitor comes away thinking of a culture that stopped rather than one that is still alive. And it is arranged by somebody, so it carries that person’s idea of what matters.

What the chapter says about the difference the curator makes. The new National Museum of the American Indian in the USA has been curated by American Indians themselves. That is exactly the point: the same objects arranged by the people whose objects they are tell a different story from the same objects arranged by outsiders who once described those people only as hostile.

An example from my own experience. In the tribal gallery of a state museum I have visited, the bows, fishing traps, drums and woven baskets were laid out beautifully and each had a small label giving the name of the community. What the gallery did well was to show how much skill went into ordinary things. What it could not show was who made them, when, for what occasion, or what songs went with the drums, and there was nothing written by anyone from those communities. I left knowing what the objects looked like and almost nothing about the people.

Conclusion. A museum gallery is a good beginning and a poor ending. It is most satisfactory when the people concerned have curated it themselves, when oral history and life writing are displayed beside the objects, and when the visitor is told that the community still exists. On its own, it explains the products of a culture rather than the culture.

6 An encounter in California, about 1880

Question 6

Q. Imagine an encounter in California in about 1880 between four people: a former African slave, a Chinese labourer, a German who had come out in the Gold Rush, and a native of the Hopi tribe, and narrate their conversation.

Answer: The imagination here has to be built out of what the chapter actually says. Each of the four is in California for a reason the chapter gives, and each has lost or gained something the chapter names. Here is one such conversation.

A railway camp near the edge of the desert, evening, about 1880. Four men sit by a fire.

The German (Klaus): I came in the Gold Rush. In the forties they found traces of gold here in California and word reached my village, and thousands of us hurried across hoping for a quick fortune. I never found any gold. But then the railways began, and there was work for anyone who could hold a hammer.

The Chinese labourer (Wang): There was work for us because they needed thousands of us. They brought us in to lay the lines across the whole continent. It was finished in 1870 here, and the Canadian one in 1885. We were cheap, and that was the whole of our value. Now there is talk in the newspapers of stopping any more of us coming. In Australia they have already made a law about it, they tell me.

Klaus: They say it is because a country should not depend on people who are not white.

The former slave (Samuel): I have heard that argument all my life. I was born a slave on a cotton plantation in the south. The trade in slaves was banned long before I was born, but that changed nothing for those of us already there, or for our children. Then in 1861 the war came, the states that wanted to keep slavery against the states that wanted it ended, and in 1865 the ones who wanted it ended won. I am a free man. But free is not the same as equal. My children still cannot sit in the same schoolroom or the same railway carriage as his.

Wang: And you, friend? You have said nothing.

The Hopi (Honani): My people were here before the word California existed. Our stone tablets said that brothers and sisters would come back to us as turtles across the land, and one morning we looked out across the desert and saw men in armour, and we thought the tablets had come true. We put out our hands for a handshake. Into the hand they dropped a trinket.

Klaus: That was the Spanish, long ago.

Honani: It was the beginning. Now there are treaties instead of trinkets, which is a smaller thing dressed in bigger words. Land was sold for prices no one could call prices. In Georgia a Chief Justice ruled in 1832 that the Cherokee were a distinct community with their own territory, and the President sent the army anyway, and of the fifteen thousand driven out, more than a quarter died on the road. They call it the Trail of Tears. Land was given to others of us “in perpetuity”, which means until lead or gold or oil is found under it.

Samuel: They say your people do not use the land.

Honani: They say we do not use it to the maximum. We took what we needed and no more. We killed as many animals as we could eat. Now go and look at the plains: the bison are almost gone, and with them the life my grandfathers led. Your railway carried the hunters, friend Wang.

Wang: I laid the track. I did not choose what ran on it.

Honani: No. None of us chose. You were brought for your cheapness, he was brought in chains, and Klaus came for gold that was never there. I am the only one of the four who was already here, and I am the only one with nowhere to go back to.

Klaus: There is a word for this country in the newspapers. They call it a frontier.

Honani: A frontier is a line that moves. Every time it moves, we move. In a few years there will be no line left, and then you will see what they do with all that thirst.

What the examiner is looking for. Four voices, each carrying a fact from the chapter: the Gold Rush of the 1840s and the disappointment that followed it; Chinese labour on the transcontinental railways, completed in 1870 and 1885, and the ban that followed in both the USA and Australia; slavery, the war of 1861 to 1865 and segregation that lasted into the twentieth century; and the natives’ loss of land through treaties, the Trail of Tears, the reservations and the near extermination of the bison by 1890. Ending on the frontier ties the four stories to the chapter’s central idea.

7 In-text questions (Section IV introduction and Activities)

The chapter’s PDF opens with the introduction and timeline of Section IV, “Towards Modernisation”, which ask two questions of their own, and the theme then asks four more in its Activity boxes. They are answered here in the order they appear in the book.

In-text 1 · Section IV introduction

Q. One might wonder what is meant by “mainstream”. How does economic and political power influence the making of “mainstream cultures”?

Answer: The “mainstream” is the way of life that a country’s government, schools, laws and markets treat as normal, the culture everyone else is expected to join. It is not simply the culture of the most people: in America and Australia it was the culture of the European settlers, who were not the first inhabitants at all.

1. Economic power decides what counts as “using” the land. The settlers bought and sold everything, including land and water, so a people who did not commodify land were called lazy and said not to deserve it, because they did not use it “to the maximum”.
2. Political power writes the rules. Treaties, Georgia’s state laws, reservations, the Indians Act and the idea of terra nullius were all made by settler governments. Rights such as the vote and the right to property were for white men only.
3. Power controls schools and history books. Till the middle of the twentieth century, textbooks told the story of European “discovery” and left the natives out.
4. Power can try to absorb the rest. In the 1950s and 1960s the US and Canadian governments wanted natives to “join the mainstream”, that is, adopt European culture, while Australian authorities tried simply to ignore native traditions.

So the “mainstream” is shaped by whoever holds economic and political power. The chapter shows the other side too: the natives did not allow the European deluge to wipe out their cultures, and with the 1954 Declaration of Indian Rights, Canada’s Constitution Act of 1982 and Australian multiculturalism from 1974, the definition of the mainstream itself began to change.

In-text 2 · Timeline IV · Activity

Q. If you compare the four timelines given in the book, you will find that the chronological reference periods in the left-hand column differ. Can you think of the reasons for this? Try and design a timeline of your own, giving reasons for your selections.

Answer: How the columns differ. Timeline I (6 MYA to 1 BCE) moves in huge steps, from “6 mya-500,000 BP” to “500,000-150,000 BP” and later in thousands and hundreds of years. Timeline II (c. 100 BCE to 1300 CE) moves in steps of fifty years (“100-50 BCE”, “50-1”, “1-50 CE”). Timeline IV (c. 1700 to 2000) moves decade by decade (“1720-30”, “1730-40”). The nearer a timeline comes to the present, the shorter its periods.

Reasons. 1. The length of time covered. Timeline I spans about six million years; Timeline IV only three centuries. A column of decades for Timeline I would run to thousands of rows.
2. The kind of evidence. For the remote past we have fossils, tools and remains that can be dated only roughly, so a long span is the most honest unit. For the last three centuries we have written records dated to the year.
3. The pace and number of events. Recorded events crowd much more closely together in recent centuries, so smaller divisions are needed to show them.
4. What each timeline is about. Timeline I traces slow processes such as the emergence of humans and the domestication of plants and animals; Timeline II kingdoms and empires; Timeline IV the slave trade, nation states, colonisation, democratic and anti-colonial movements and modern inventions. Processes are harder to date than events such as wars, so they need broader periods.

A timeline of my own. For example, a timeline of my own town or of the railways in India could use periods of 25 years before 1900, when only a few dates are known, and decades after 1900, when many more are recorded. I would select dates that show change in ordinary life (the first school, the arrival of the railway, electricity, the first hospital) as well as political events, because, as the book says, processes through which ordinary women and men shaped history matter as much as events, and the dates I choose show what I think is important.

In-text 3 · Mutual Perceptions · Activity 1

Q. Discuss the different images that Europeans and native Americans had of each other, and the different ways in which they saw nature.

Answer: How Europeans saw the natives. Eighteenth-century western Europeans defined “civilised” people by literacy, an organised religion and urbanism, so the natives appeared “uncivilised”. Rousseau admired them as untouched by the corruptions of civilisation, “the noble savage”; Wordsworth thought people living close to nature had only limited powers of imagination and emotion, though neither had met a native American. Thomas Jefferson spoke of “this unfortunate race” as having “justified extermination”. Washington Irving, who had actually met them, found them taciturn only with white men and great mimics among themselves, and wrote that white men treated “the poor Indians as little better than animals”.

How natives saw the Europeans. Many native folk tales mocked Europeans as greedy and deceitful. The natives were saddened by the Europeans’ greed and uneasy that the hundreds of beavers they slaughtered for fur would take revenge. They were puzzled that traders gave them a lot one year and very little the next, since they had no sense of a “market” in faraway Europe. The Hopi memory of holding out a hand for a handshake and receiving a trinket shows how they felt they were treated.

How each saw nature. To the natives, goods exchanged were gifts given in friendship and land was not something to “own”; they took from it only what they needed and killed only as many animals as they needed for food. Looking at a forest, they saw tracks invisible to Europeans. To the Europeans, fish and furs were commodities to be sold for profit, and a forest was land to be cut down and replaced by cornfields. Jefferson’s “dream” was a country of small European-owned farms, and in his view the natives’ refusal to own land made them “uncivilised”.

In-text 4 · The Native Peoples Lose their Land · Activity 2

Q. Comment on these two sets of population data. (USA, 1820: natives 0.6 million, whites 9.0 million, mixed Europeans 0.1 million, blacks 1.9 million, total 11.6 million. Spanish America, 1800: natives 7.5 million, whites 3.3 million, mixed Europeans 5.3 million, blacks 0.8 million, total 16.9 million.)

Answer: 1. Natives. In the USA natives were only 0.6 of 11.6 million, about one in twenty. In Spanish America they were 7.5 of 16.9 million, the largest single group, close to half the population. In the north the natives had been pushed out and their numbers had collapsed; in Spanish America they remained the largest group.
2. Whites. Whites were 9.0 million in the USA, nearly four-fifths of the total, which shows that the USA was a settler society. In Spanish America they were only 3.3 million, a ruling minority.
3. Mixed Europeans. Only 0.1 million in the USA against 5.3 million in Spanish America. In the north settlers and natives lived apart, with natives driven westward and later onto reservations; in Spanish America the two populations mixed on a large scale.
4. Blacks. 1.9 million in the USA against 0.8 million in Spanish America. Southern plantation owners in the USA bought slaves in Africa because the climate was too hot for Europeans to work outdoors and enslaved natives had died in large numbers.
The conclusion. The two sets of figures show two different kinds of colonisation: in the USA the land was taken and filled by settlers and African slaves, while in Spanish America a small European ruling group lived among a large native and mixed population.

In-text 5 · The Winds of Change · Activity 3

Q. Comment on the following statement by the American historian Howard Spodek: “For the indigenous [people] the effects of the American Revolution were exactly opposite to those of the settlers: expansion became contraction, democracy became tyranny, prosperity became poverty, and liberty became confinement.”

Answer: The statement is borne out by the chapter, point by point.

1. Expansion became contraction. For the settlers the new USA grew through the Louisiana Purchase, Alaska and war with Mexico, and the frontier moved west. For the natives every move of the frontier meant being pushed back, until they were locked into small reservations.
2. Democracy became tyranny. The settlers’ “democratic spirit” gave them the vote, but both democratic rights and the right to property were for white men only. Chief Justice Marshall’s judgment in favour of the Cherokees was overridden by President Jackson, who sent the army to drive them out on the Trail of Tears.
3. Prosperity became poverty. By 1890 the USA was the world’s leading industrial power, but the bison on which the natives lived had almost been exterminated, and the 1928 Meriam survey found terribly poor health and education facilities on reservations.
4. Liberty became confinement. The settlers won independence from Britain; the natives lost the freedom to move over their own land and were confined to reservations, often on land with which they had no connection.

The table beside the statement in the book shows this was a pattern: Indians under British rule, natives in America and Australia, and African slaves in America were all treated as not equal, with a “rationalisation” each time (“not ready” for representative government, “primitive”, “slavery is part of their own social system”). The natives themselves were not passive, however: they fought until 1890, and from the 1920s they slowly won back rights.

In-text 6 · Australia · Activity 4

Q. In 1911, it was announced that New Delhi and Canberra would be built as the capital cities of British India and of the Commonwealth of Australia. Compare and contrast the political situations of the native people in these countries at that time.

Answer: Similarities. In both countries the native people were ruled by the British and had no real share in power. Both new capitals were decisions taken by the colonial rulers, not by the native people. And in both, the rulers justified their position by calling the natives unequal: Indians were seen as not ready for the responsibility of representative government, Australian aborigines as “primitive”.

Differences. 1. Numbers. In India the natives were the vast majority and the British a small ruling group. In Australia, after the nineteenth century, nearly 90 per cent of the natives had died from germs, loss of land and battles with settlers, and the settlers had become the majority.
2. Land. In India people kept their land, and the British collected taxes from landowners through the older administrative system. In Australia the land had been taken outright as terra nullius, with no treaty at all.
3. Government. Australia’s six states had formed a Federation in 1901 and governed themselves, but it was a government of the white settlers, with a policy of keeping “non-white” people out; the natives had no place in it. In India, the people were colonial subjects of a British government, taxed arbitrarily, but they were already organising: the Indian National Congress had been founded in 1885.
4. Future. Indians would win independence in 1947. Australian aborigines remained a small minority whose rights were recognised only much later, with the Mabo judgment of 1992 and National Sorry Day in 1999.

The name itself. Canberra was named from a native word, kamberra (“meeting place”), even though the natives had no voice in the government that would sit there.