Class 11 History Chapter 6 Displacing Indigenous Peoples Short Notes in English

The essence of this chapter for last-minute revision: definitions, key facts, dates and tables. The full notes, with the complete explanation, are available separately.

1 The chapter in one frame

Displacing Indigenous Peoples
North AmericaNatives from Asia over 30,000 years ago. Trade with Europeans, then treaties, the Trail of Tears, reservations, the end of the bison.
The frontierThe shifting western edge of settlement. Louisiana Purchase, Alaska, war with Mexico. Declared “ended” in 1892.
AustraliaAborigines from New Guinea over 40,000 years ago. British settlement from 1788, no treaties at all, and a very long road to an apology.

What the chapter is about. It recounts some aspects of the histories of the native peoples of America and Australia. Theme 8 dealt with the Spanish and Portuguese colonisation of South America, so this chapter does not repeat it. From the eighteenth century, more of South America, Central America, North America, South Africa, Australia and New Zealand came to be settled by immigrants from Europe, and many native peoples were pushed out into other areas.

Native names that survive. Ohio, Mississippi and Seattle in the USA; Saskatchewan in Canada; Wollongong and Parramatta in Australia. Tribal names are also given to unconnected things: Dakota an aeroplane, Cherokee a jeep, Pontiac a car, Mohawk a haircut.

How the natives got their history back. Till the mid-twentieth century, textbooks described how Europeans “discovered” the Americas and Australia and mentioned natives only as hostile. Anthropologists studied them from the 1840s. From the 1960s, natives were encouraged to write or dictate their own histories, which is oral history. Today there are historical works and fiction by native writers, galleries of native art, and the National Museum of the American Indian in the USA, curated by American Indians themselves.

North America in one paragraph. The continent extends from the Arctic Circle to the Tropic of Cancer and from the Pacific to the Atlantic. West of the Rocky Mountains is the desert of Arizona and Nevada, still further west the Sierra Nevada mountains; to the east are the Great Plains, the Great Lakes, the valleys of the Mississippi and the Ohio, and the Appalachian Mountains. Mexico is to the south. Forty per cent of Canada is forest, oil, gas and minerals explain the big industries, wheat, corn and fruit are grown extensively, and fishing is a major Canadian industry. Mining, industry and extensive agriculture were developed only in the last 200 years, by immigrants from Europe, Africa and China.

2 Definitions to learn by heart

All definitions in one place
ColonyA territory settled and controlled by people from another country. When its European inhabitants became independent of the European “mother-country”, it became a “state” or country.
NativeA person born in the place he or she lives in. Till the early twentieth century Europeans used the word for the inhabitants of countries they had colonised.
Oral historyHistory a community narrates or dictates from memory and tradition instead of writing it down itself.
SettlerThe word used for the Dutch in South Africa, the British in Ireland, New Zealand and Australia, and the Europeans in America: people who came to live on and farm the land, not only to trade or administer.
Wampum beltsBelts of coloured shells sewn together, exchanged by native tribes after a treaty was agreed to.
FrontierThe shifting western edge of settlement in the USA. As it moved, the natives beyond it were forced to move back.
ReservationA small area natives were locked off in, often land with which they had no earlier connection.
Trail of TearsThe forced removal of the Cherokees to the Great American Desert. Of 15,000 driven out, over a quarter died on the way.
AnthropologyThe subject, developed in France, introduced in North America from the 1840s out of curiosity about the differences between native “primitive” communities and the “civilised” communities of Europe.
DreamtimeThe Aboriginal Australian name for the deep past, in which the distinction between past and present is blurred.
Terra nulliusLatin for “belonging to nobody”, the Australian government’s own term for the land of Australia. Land belonging to nobody needed no treaty to take.
MulticulturalismOfficial Australian policy from 1974, giving equal respect to native cultures and to the cultures of immigrants from Europe and Asia.

3 Terms English uses for native peoples

Term Meaning
aborigine Native people of Australia. Latin ab means from, origine the beginning
Aboriginal An adjective, though often misused as a noun
American Indian / Amerind / Amerindian Native peoples of North and South America and the Caribbean
First Nations peoples Organised native groups recognised by the Canadian government. The Indians Act of 1876 said “bands”; “nations” has been used from the 1980s
indigenous people People belonging naturally to a place
native American The indigenous people of the Americas. The term now commonly used
“Red Indian” The brown-complexioned people whose land Columbus mistook for India
Torres Strait Islanders A large indigenous group in northern Australia. “Aborigine” is not used for them, as they are believed to have migrated from elsewhere and to belong to a different race

4 Numbers worth remembering

30,000+years ago the first people crossed from Asia into North America over the Bering Straits land-bridge
15,000Cherokees forced out on the Trail of Tears, over a quarter of whom died
90%of native Australians died in the 19th and 20th centuries from germs, loss of land and battles
Number What it counts
10,000 years ago The last Ice Age, when the natives moved further south in North America
11,000 years Age of the oldest artefact found in America, an arrow-point
5,000 years ago When the North American population began to increase, as the climate became more stable
100+ tongues Languages spoken in America “on the day before America”, in Macleish’s phrase
40 per cent Share of Canada covered with forests
200 years How recently mining, industry and extensive agriculture were developed in North America
100+ “New” names Place names in the Americas and Australia beginning with “New”, per the Geographical Dictionary
40,000+ years ago When the aborigines began arriving in Australia from New Guinea
350 to 750 Native communities in Australia in the late eighteenth century, each with its own language
200 Of those languages still spoken today
2.4 per cent Share of Australia’s population that native peoples formed in 2005
2 million Europeans who migrated to Australia between 1948 and 1975

Activity 2: population in millions. USA in 1820 against Spanish America in 1800.

USA, 1820 Spanish America, 1800
Natives 0.6 7.5
Whites 9.0 3.3
Mixed Europeans 0.1 5.3
Blacks 1.9 0.8
Total 11.6 16.9

5 Dates at a glance

Date What happened
Europeans reach North America
1497 John Cabot reaches Newfoundland
1507 Amerigo Vespucci’s Travels published, giving “America” its name
1534 / 1535 Jacques Cartier travels down the St Lawrence and meets natives; hears kanata, “village”, which becomes “Canada”
1607 / 1608 / 1620 British found Virginia; French found Quebec; British found Plymouth in Massachusetts
1701 / 1763 / 1774 / 1791 French treaty with the natives of Quebec; Quebec conquered by the British; Quebec Act; Canada Constitutional Act
1781 / 1783 Britain recognises the USA as an independent country; Britain gives the Mid-West to the USA
The USA and Canada, 1803 to 1892
1803 Louisiana purchased from France
1825-58 Natives in the USA moved to reserves
1832 Justice Marshall’s judgement on the Cherokees
1837 / 1840 French Canadian rebellion; Canadian Union of Upper and Lower Canada
1849 / 1859 American Gold Rush; Canada Gold Rush
1854 Chief Seattle’s letter to the President of the USA
1861-65 American Civil War, ending in the abolition of slavery
1865-90 American Indian Wars
1867 Confederation of Canada, settling the French settlers’ demand for autonomy
1869-85 Red River Rebellion by the Metis in Canada
1870 / 1885 Transcontinental railway completed in the USA; and in Canada, linking east and west coasts
1873 Barbed wire invented
1876 Canada Indians Act
1890 Bison almost exterminated; the USA the leading industrial power in the world
1892 “End” of the American frontier
Rights in the USA and Canada
1928 Lewis Meriam’s survey The Problem of Indian Administration published
1934 Indian Reorganisation Act: reservation natives may buy land and take loans
1954 Declaration of Indian Rights: US citizenship accepted, reservations and traditions to be left alone
1969 / 1982 Canada says it will “not recognise aboriginal rights”; the Constitution Act accepts existing aboriginal and treaty rights
Australia
1606 / 1642 Dutch travellers sight Australia; Tasman lands on the island later named Tasmania
1770 James Cook reaches Botany Bay and names it New South Wales
1788 British penal colony formed; Sydney founded
1850 Self-government granted to the Australian colonies
1851 / 1855 Chinese coolie immigration begins; stopped by law
1851-1961 Gold rushes
1901 Formation of the Federation of Australia, with six states
1911 Canberra established as capital, from kamberra, “meeting place”. New Delhi announced the same year
1948-75 Two million Europeans migrate to Australia
1968 W.E.H. Stanner’s lecture “The Great Australian Silence”
1974 “White Australia” policy ends and Asian immigrants are allowed entry; multiculturalism becomes official policy
1992 Mabo case: the High Court declares terra nullius legally invalid and recognises native claims to land from before 1770
1995 National Enquiry into the Separation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children from their Families
1999 (26 May) “A National Sorry Day”, apologising for the children “lost” from the 1820s to the 1970s

6 Two ways of seeing the same land

The native peoples The Europeans
Farming Crops for their own needs, no surplus, no extensive agriculture Crops for sale and profit, including rice and cotton that Europe could not grow
Land Thought it wrong to “own” land; content with the food and shelter it gave Private property protected by the constitution’s “right to property”
The forest Identified tracks invisible to Europeans Imagined the forest cut down and replaced by cornfields
Goods exchanged Gifts, given in friendship Commodities, to be sold for a profit in Europe at prices that varied with supply
Animals Killed only as many as they needed for food Slaughtered hundreds of beavers for fur; hunted wolves and mountain lions to extinction; bison almost exterminated by 1890
Time Believed time moved in cycles; the Australian “Dreamtime” blurs past and present Not described in the chapter; Henry Reynolds later condemned writing Australian history as though it had begun with Captain Cook’s “discovery”
Records Unwritten languages; Wampum belts, stories passed down the generations, the ability to “read the land” Written treaties, deeds and history books

What Europeans thought of natives. In the eighteenth century western Europeans defined “civilised” people by literacy, an organised religion and urbanism, so natives appeared “uncivilised”. Rousseau admired them as untouched by the corruptions of civilisation, the “noble savage”; Wordsworth wrote of them living “amid wilds”, though neither had met one. Thomas Jefferson spoke of them in words that the chapter says would cause a public outcry today. Washington Irving, who had met them, wrote that they were taciturn only with white men whose goodwill they distrusted, and that white men treated “the poor Indians as little better than animals”.

7 How the natives lost their land

1 . TreatiesNatives induced or forced to move after signing treaties selling their land. Prices very low, and Americans sometimes took more land or paid less than promised
↓
2 . Law ignoredGeorgia denies the Cherokees citizens’ rights. In 1832 Chief Justice John Marshall rules them “a distinct community, occupying its own territory in which the laws of Georgia had no force”
↓
3 . Trail of TearsPresident Andrew Jackson refuses to honour the judgment and sends the army. Of 15,000 driven to the Great American Desert, over a quarter die on the way
↓
4 . Moved againLand given “theirs in perpetuity” is taken back whenever lead, gold or oil is found. Tribes forced to share one tribe’s land, which sets them quarrelling
↓
5 . ReservationsLocked off in small areas, often land with no earlier connection to them. The US army crushes rebellions from 1865 to 1890; the Metis revolt in Canada from 1869 to 1885. After that they give up

The justification used at the time. Natives did not deserve land they did not use “to the maximum”; they were lazy because they did not use their craft skills to produce goods for the market; they had no interest in learning English or dressing “correctly”. They deserved to “die out”, it was argued, and a visiting Frenchman wrote that “primitive man will disappear with the primitive animal”.

Who came to settle, and why. The first Europeans were traders. Behind them, from the seventeenth century, came groups persecuted for belonging to a different sect of Christianity: Protestants living in predominantly Catholic countries, and Catholics in countries where Protestantism was the official religion. As long as there was vacant land this caused no trouble, but they gradually moved inland near native villages and used iron tools to cut down forests and lay out farms.

8 Rights, and who they were for

The “democratic spirit” that was the settlers’ rallying cry in the 1770s came to define the identity of the USA against the monarchies and aristocracies of the Old World, and the constitution guaranteed the individual’s “right to property”, which the state could not override. Both the democratic rights, the vote for representatives to Congress and for the President, and the right to property were for white men only.

Who said it What they said about the frontier and the natives
Karl Marx (1818-83) Described the American frontier as “the last positive capitalist utopia… the limitless nature and space to which the limitless thirst for profit adapts itself” (Grundrisse)
Daniel Paul (2000) A Canadian native who pointed out that Thomas Paine, the champion of democracy, “used the Indians as models of how society might be organized”, and argued that the native Americans by their example sowed the seeds for Europe’s own long movement towards democracy (We Were Not the Savages)
Howard Spodek “For the indigenous [people] the effects of the American Revolution were exactly opposite to those of the settlers: expansion became contraction, democracy became tyranny, prosperity became poverty, and liberty became confinement.”

The comparison Spodek’s quotation sits beside sets three groups side by side with the argument used to justify each: Indians under British rule, taxed arbitrarily and treated as not ready for representative government; natives in America and Australia, denied citizenship on the ground that they were “primitive”, with no settled agriculture, no provision for the future and no towns; and African slaves in America, denied personal liberty on the ground that “slavery is part of their own social system”.

9 Australia in one table

Question The chapter’s answer
Who was there first? The “aborigines”, a general name for a number of different societies, arriving over 40,000 years ago from New Guinea across a land-bridge. In their own tradition they did not come at all: they had always been there
Where do people live? Australia is sparsely populated and most towns are along the coast, where the British first arrived in 1770, because the central region is arid desert
Who settled it? Mostly convicts deported from England, free once their jail term ended on condition they did not return to Britain. The same practice had been used in the American colonies, and abandoned in Brazil after native reprisals against Portuguese convicts
What was the economy? Less varied than America’s: vast sheep farms and mining stations, then vineyards and wheat farming, which became the basis of the country’s prosperity
Who did the work? Some natives, “under conditions of work so harsh that it was little different from slavery”, and later Chinese immigrants as cheap labour, as in California
Why the immigration ban? Unease about depending on non-whites led both the USA and Australia to ban Chinese immigrants, and till 1974 Australia had a policy of keeping “non-white” people out
Why were there no treaties? Because the government had always termed the land terra nullius, belonging to nobody. The USA, Canada and New Zealand all had treaties, however unequal
What was the cost? Nearly 90 per cent of the native people died in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries from exposure to germs, from the loss of their lands and resources, and in battles against settlers

10 Five-minute recap

Quick Revision: read this the night before the exam
  • The chapter covers the native peoples of America and Australia. Their history was left out of textbooks till the mid-twentieth century, and oral history from the 1960s and native-curated museums restored their own voice.
  • After the seventeenth century France, Holland and England expanded, with control taking different forms: trading companies turning into rulers in South Asia, coastal trade and then partition in Africa, and “settler” colonies in America, Ireland, New Zealand and Australia.
  • North American natives lived in bands along river valleys, hunted bison, produced no surplus and therefore built no kingdoms, and felt no need to “own” land. Wampum belts recorded treaties in a society with no writing.
  • The first European traders came for fish and furs and were welcomed. They gave blankets, iron vessels, guns and alcohol, and alcohol, new to the natives, let them dictate the terms of trade. Europeans took away an addiction to tobacco.
  • Natives saw exchanged goods as gifts; Europeans saw them as commodities whose price moved with a market the natives could not see.
  • The frontier shifted west all through the nineteenth century, fed by the Louisiana Purchase, Alaska and war with Mexico, and the natives were pushed back each time. Nobody thought to ask their consent.
  • Marshall’s 1832 judgment protected Cherokee land; Jackson ignored it, and the Trail of Tears followed, 15,000 driven out and over a quarter dead. Land “in perpetuity” gave way to reservations, and resistance ended with the Indian Wars of 1865 to 1890 and the Metis revolts of 1869 to 1885.
  • The Gold Rush of the 1840s built the railways with Chinese labour, industry grew to make railway equipment and farm machinery, and the USA went from an undeveloped economy in 1860 to the world’s leading industrial power in 1890. By then the bison had almost gone, and by 1892 so had the frontier.
  • Rights came slowly: the Meriam survey of 1928, the Indian Reorganisation Act of 1934, the Declaration of Indian Rights of 1954, and Canada’s Constitution Act of 1982.
  • Australia’s aborigines arrived over 40,000 years ago. British settlement from 1788 killed nearly 90 per cent of them, and no treaty was ever made, because the land was called terra nullius. Stanner’s 1968 lecture broke the silence, multiculturalism became policy in 1974, the Mabo case overturned terra nullius in 1992, and National Sorry Day in 1999 apologised for the separated children.