Full answers to all 20 exercise questions of NCERT Indian Economic Development, Chapter 4 “Human Capital Formation in India” (Reprint 2026-27). The questions are given exactly as printed in the English edition. Answers are in points, so you can write as many points as the marks need.
1 Two major sources of human capital
Q. What are the two major sources of human capital in a country?
Answer: The two major sources of human capital in a country are:
- Investment in education: individuals spend on education to increase their future income, just as companies spend on capital goods to increase future profits. An educated person has more labour skill.
- Investment in health: spending on vaccination, medical care, spread of health literacy and clean drinking water directly increases the supply of healthy labour force. A sick labourer has to stay away from work and productivity is lost.
2 Indicators of educational achievement
Q. What are the indicators of educational achievement in a country?
Answer: Educational achievements in a country are generally indicated by three measures:
- Adult literacy rate: the per cent of people aged 15 and above who are literate. In India in 2017-18: male 82%, female 66%.
- Primary education completion rate: the per cent of the relevant age group completing primary education. In 2017-18: male 93%, female 96%.
- Youth literacy rate: the per cent of people aged 15 to 24 who are literate. In 2017-18: male 93%, female 90%.
3 Regional differences in educational attainment
Q. Why do we observe regional differences in educational attainment in India?
Answer:
- India is a federal country; education spending is done by the union, state and local governments, so each state spends a different amount.
- In 2020-21 the per capita public expenditure on elementary education ranged from as high as ₹96,968 in Sikkim to as low as ₹10,710 in Bihar, a difference of about 9 times.
- This difference in spending leads to differences in educational opportunities and attainments across states.
4 Human capital vs human development
Q. Bring out the differences between human capital and human development.
Answer:
| Basis | Human capital | Human development |
|---|---|---|
| View of education and health | Means to increase labour productivity | Integral to human well-being |
| Human beings | A means to an end (productivity) | Ends in themselves |
| When investment is productive | Only if output of goods and services rises | Even if productivity does not rise, welfare should increase |
| Basic education and health | Valued for their contribution to productivity | Important in themselves; every individual’s right |
5 Why human development is broader
Q. How is human development a broader term as compared to human capital?
Answer:
- Human capital looks at education and health only as means of increasing labour productivity; any investment that does not raise output is unproductive in this view.
- Human development holds that education and health are integral to human well-being; only when people can read and write and lead a long and healthy life can they make other choices they value.
- Here human beings are ends in themselves, so investment in education and health should be made even if it does not raise labour productivity.
- It treats basic education and health as every individual’s right. So human development covers productivity as well as well-being and rights, which makes it the broader term.
6 Factors in human capital formation
Q. What factors contribute to human capital formation?
Answer: Five factors contribute to human capital formation:
- Expenditure on education: investment made to raise future income; the main source of human capital.
- Expenditure on health: preventive medicine (vaccination), curative medicine (medical intervention during illness), social medicine (spread of health literacy), clean drinking water and good sanitation; these increase the healthy labour force.
- On-the-job training: the firm trains workers at its own cost, inside the firm or off-campus; the return in higher productivity exceeds the cost.
- Migration: moving for higher salaries, to cities or abroad; enhanced earnings outweigh the cost of transport, higher cost of living and psychic costs.
- Expenditure on information: about the labour, education and health markets; needed for investment decisions and efficient use of human capital.
7 Government organisations, schools and hospitals
Q. How government organisations facilitate the functioning of schools and hospitals in India?
Answer:
- Education: ministries of education at the union and state level, departments of education, and organisations like the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), University Grants Commission (UGC) and All India Council of Technical Education (AICTE) facilitate institutions in the education sector.
- Health: ministries of health at the union and state level, departments of health, and organisations like the National Medical Commission and Indian Council for Medical Research (ICMR) facilitate institutions in the health sector.
- All three tiers spend: union, state and local governments (Municipal Corporations, Municipalities, Village Panchayats) spend on education and health simultaneously.
- Standards and price: the government ensures that private providers follow its standards and charge the correct price.
- Free services: the government provides education and health services free to deserving citizens and the socially oppressed classes; the 2009 Act made free education a right for children aged 6-14.
8 Education as an input for development
Q. Education is considered to be an important input for the development of a nation. How?
Answer:
- An educated person has more labour skill, earns more income and contributes more to economic growth.
- Education stimulates innovations and creates the ability to adapt to new technologies.
- It gives knowledge to understand changes in society and scientific advances, and helps people make better choices and gain better social standing.
- It has external benefits: an educated person takes part effectively in the democratic process and contributes to the socio-economic progress of the nation.
- Women’s education improves economic independence and social status of women, and has a favourable impact on the fertility rate and on the health care of women and children.
9 Health infrastructure and expenditure on migration
Q. Discuss the following as a source of human capital formation (i) Health infrastructure (ii) Expenditure on migration.
Answer:
(i) Health infrastructure:
- Like education, health is an important input for the development of a nation and an individual.
- A sick labourer without access to medical facilities has to stay away from work, and productivity is lost.
- Spending on preventive medicine (vaccination), curative medicine (medical intervention during illness), social medicine (spread of health literacy), and clean drinking water and good sanitation are the forms of health expenditure.
- This spending directly increases the supply of healthy labour force, so it is a source of human capital formation.
(ii) Expenditure on migration:
- People migrate for jobs with higher salaries than in their native places; unemployment drives rural-urban migration in India, and engineers and doctors migrate abroad for higher salaries.
- Migration involves the cost of transport, higher cost of living in the new place and psychic costs of living in a strange socio-cultural setup.
- The enhanced earnings in the new place outweigh these costs, so expenditure on migration is a source of human capital formation.
10 Need for information on health and education expenditure
Q. Establish the need for acquiring information relating to health and education expenditure for the effective utilisation of human resources.
Answer:
- People spend to acquire information about the labour market and other markets such as education and health.
- They want to know the salaries of various jobs, whether educational institutions provide the right type of employable skills, and at what cost.
- This information decides where to invest in education or health, that is, the decisions on investment in human capital.
- It is also needed for the efficient utilisation of the human capital stock already acquired.
- Since this information is necessary for investment decisions and for efficient use of human capital, expenditure on information is also a source of human capital formation.
11 Investment in human capital and growth
Q. How does investment in human capital contribute to growth?
Answer: Economic growth means the increase in real national income of a country. Investment in human capital helps it in these ways:
- An educated person has more labour skill and generates more income.
- A healthy person can supply labour without interruption for a longer time.
- Education, health, on-the-job training, job market information and migration raise a person’s income generating capacity.
- Human capital raises labour productivity, stimulates innovations and creates the ability to absorb new technologies.
- Table 4.1 shows that from 1951 to 2018-22 the literacy rate rose from 16.67% to 78%, infant mortality fell from 146 to 28, and real per capita income rose from ₹7,651 to ₹94,054; these sectors grew together.
12 Education levels and inequality
Q. ‘There is a downward trend in inequality world-wide with a rise in the average education levels’. Comment.
Answer:
- Education raises a person’s income generating capacity. When education spreads to all rather than a few, more people can do higher-paying work.
- Income then spreads more widely instead of being concentrated, so income inequality falls.
- The book’s conclusion makes the same point: education and health services should reach all sections of society so that economic growth and equity are attained together.
- In India too, the spread of education has reduced gender inequality: the male-female gap in youth literacy fell from 22.4 points in 1990 to 3 points in 2017-18 (Table 4.2).
- But this does not happen on its own; the gap in state spending (Sikkim ₹96,968, Bihar ₹10,710) shows that public spending must also be spread evenly.
13 Role of education in economic development
Q. Examine the role of education in the economic development of a nation.
Answer:
- Productivity and income: educated workers have more skill and income; they contribute more to national income.
- Technology and innovation: education helps people understand scientific advances, facilitates inventions and innovations, and an educated labour force adapts to new technologies.
- Social benefits: educated people take part effectively in democracy and make better life choices.
- Human development: the ability to read and write is part of well-being itself and the basis for making other choices.
- Knowledge economy: the National Education Policy 2020 says the age of machine learning and artificial intelligence will need a skilled, multidisciplinary workforce; human capital formation will take India to a higher, knowledge-based growth trajectory.
- The Seventh Five Year Plan said a large population, trained and educated on sound lines, can itself become an asset in accelerating economic growth.
14 Investment in education and economic growth
Q. Explain how investment in education stimulates economic growth.
Answer:
- Investment in education turns human resources into human capital, just as investment turns physical resources into physical capital.
- It raises labour skill and labour productivity, which raises output and real national income, that is, economic growth.
- It stimulates innovations and creates the ability to absorb new technologies.
- An educated labour force facilitates the adaptation of new technologies.
- The book adds a caution: the effect is hard to measure, since years of schooling, teacher-pupil ratio and enrolment rates may not reflect quality, and higher income also causes higher human capital, so causality runs both ways.
15 Need for on-the-job training
Q. Bring out the need for on-the-job-training for a person.
Answer:
- On-the-job training raises a worker’s skill and labour productivity, and so the worker’s income generating capacity.
- It is given in two forms: inside the firm under the supervision of a skilled worker, or by sending workers for off-campus training.
- The firm bears the cost in both cases, so it insists that the worker stays for a specific period to recover the benefit of the enhanced productivity.
- The return in enhanced labour productivity is more than its cost, so it is a source of human capital formation.
16 Human capital and economic growth
Q. Trace the relationship between human capital and economic growth.
Answer:
- From human capital to growth: education and health raise labour productivity, stimulate innovations and create the ability to absorb new technologies; this raises real national income.
- From growth to human capital: higher income lets people and governments spend more on education and health, which builds a higher level of human capital. Causality runs in both directions.
- Evidence is nebulous: because of measurement problems this is hard to prove; comparing developing and developed countries shows convergence in the measures of human capital but none in per capita real income.
- India’s experience: Table 4.1 shows education, health and income growing together, each probably reinforcing the others. India recognised this importance long ago in the Seventh Five Year Plan.
17 Promoting women’s education
Q. Discuss the need for promoting women’s education in India.
Answer:
- The male-female literacy gap is narrowing, a positive development in gender equity; still, female adult literacy in 2017-18 was 66%, 16 points below males (82%).
- Women’s education improves women’s economic independence.
- It improves the social status of women.
- It has a favourable impact on the fertility rate.
- It improves the health care of women and children.
- So we cannot be complacent about rising literacy rates; there are miles to go before cent per cent adult literacy.
18 Government intervention in education and health
Q. Argue in favour of the need for different forms of government intervention in education and health sectors.
Answer:
- Private and social benefits: these services create both, which is why private and public institutions both exist; a public role is needed.
- Long-term, irreversible impact: if a child is admitted to a school or health centre without the required services, much damage is done before the decision to shift the child is taken.
- Incomplete information and monopoly: consumers lack complete information on quality and cost, so providers gain monopoly power and exploit; the government ensures standards and the correct price (regulation).
- Poverty: a large section below the poverty line cannot afford basic education and health care, and a substantial section cannot afford super specialty health care and higher education.
- Rights: basic education and health are rights of citizens, so the government should provide them free to deserving citizens and the socially oppressed classes (direct provision), as under the 2009 Right to Education Act.
- Finance: the government levies a 2% education cess, sanctions outlays for higher education and runs loan schemes for students.
19 Main problems of human capital formation
Q. What are the main problems of human capital formation in India?
Answer:
- Inadequate spending: education spending is a little over 4% of GDP, against at least 6% recommended by the Education Commission (1964-66).
- Regional disparity: per capita public expenditure on elementary education in 2020-21 was ₹96,968 in Sikkim and ₹10,710 in Bihar.
- Education for All unfinished: the number of illiterates equals India’s population at independence; the 10-year goal of the 1950 Directive Principles was not met.
- Gender inequality: female adult literacy (66%) is well below male (82%) in 2017-18.
- Few reach higher education: the education pyramid is steep.
- Educated unemployment: in 2011-12, 16-30% of graduate youth were unemployed against only 3-6% of primary-educated youth.
- Poverty: a large section cannot afford basic education and health.
20 Regulating fees
Q. In your view, is it essential for the government to regulate the fee structure in education and health care institutions? If so, why?
Answer: Yes, the government should regulate the fee structure, because:
- Individual consumers do not have complete information about the quality and cost of these services.
- So education and health institutions acquire monopoly power and exploit consumers with high fees.
- The effects of these services are long-term and cannot be easily reversed, so a wrong choice is costly.
- A large section of India’s population lives below the poverty line; unregulated high fees would keep them out of basic education and health care.
- The book says the government’s role is to ensure that private providers follow standards and charge the correct price. This helps education and health reach everyone, so growth and equity come together.