Covers T.R. Jain & V.K. Ohri (2026-27) ch 8. Based on NCERT Indian Economic Development, Chapter 8 (Reprint 2026-27) and the CBSE curriculum 2026-27. Every table is the book’s own.
Board note: CBSE teaches this book in Class 12; UP, Bihar, Rajasthan and MP Boards teach it in Class 11.
- Why countries form regional and global groupings, and why they study their neighbours’ development
- The development policies China and Pakistan followed from their founding, with dates
- How India, China and Pakistan compare on demography, GDP, sectoral shares and human development, from the book’s tables
- What liberty indicators are and why the Human Development Index is incomplete without them
- Why China grew fast, and why Pakistan’s growth slowed and its poverty rose again
1 Introduction: why compare neighbours?
The chapter opens with John F. Kennedy’s line: “Geography has made us neighbours. History has made us friends.” In the earlier units we studied India’s development experience and its policies. This chapter compares India with its two largest neighbouring economies, Pakistan and China.
1.1 Why countries form regional and global groupings
- Over the last two decades or so, the economic transformation taking place across the world, partly because of globalisation,
- This change has both short-term and long-term implications for each country, including India
- So nations are trying various means to strengthen their own domestic economies
- To this effect they form regional and global economic groupings such as SAARC, the European Union, ASEAN, G-8, G-20 and BRICS
1.2 Why understanding a neighbour’s development matters
Own strengths and weaknesses
Studying a neighbour’s development process lets a country better comprehend its own strengths and weaknesses.
Two-way competition
Developing countries face competition not only from developed nations but also amongst themselves.
Limited economic space
They share the relatively limited economic space that the developing world enjoys in world markets.
Shared environment
All major common economic activities in the region affect overall human development in a shared environment.
1.3 Three very different political set-ups
All three are endowed with vast natural resources, but there is little similarity in their political power set-ups.
| India | Pakistan | China |
|---|---|---|
| The largest democracy in the world | Militarist political power structure | Command economy |
| Wedded to a secular and deeply liberal Constitution for more than half a century | Militarist rule, unlike India’s democracy | One-party rule; only recently started moving towards a democratic system and more liberal economic restructuring |
2 Developmental path: a snapshot view
India, Pakistan and China have many similarities in their development strategies. All three started on their development path at about the same time.
- Jawaharlal Nehru said at the time that the new and revolutionary changes in China and India, even though they differ in content, symbolise the new spirit and vitality of Asia
- All three began planning their development in similar ways, through Five Year Plans
| Country | First Five Year Plan | Later position |
|---|---|---|
| India | 1951-56 | Followed the Five Year Plan model until March 2017 |
| China | 1953 | Now on the 14th Five Year Plan (2021-25) |
| Pakistan | 1956 (now called the Medium Term Development Plan) | Since 2018, the 12th Five Year Development Plan (2018-23) |
The Medium Term Development Plan is what Pakistan’s first five year plan (1956) is now called.
Strategies common to India and Pakistan:
- Creating a large public sector
- Raising public expenditure on social development
2.1 China’s path
- After the People’s Republic of China was established under one-party rule (1949), all critical sectors of the economy, enterprises and lands owned and operated by individuals were brought under government control
- Then, in 1958, came the Great Leap Forward
The Great Leap Forward (GLF) was a campaign launched in China in 1958 to industrialise the country on a massive scale. People were encouraged to set up industries in their backyards.
Under the commune system, people in rural areas cultivated land collectively. In 1958 there were 26,000 communes, covering almost all the farm population.
Problems the GLF ran into:
Severe drought
A severe drought caused havoc, killing about 30 million people.
Conflict with Russia
When Russia had conflicts with China, it withdrew the professionals it had sent to help industrialise the country.
The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution (1966-76), introduced by Mao in 1965, sent students and professionals to work and learn from the countryside.
The 1978 reforms: China’s present fast industrial growth can be traced back to the reforms of 1978. They came in phases:
Township and village enterprises were enterprises owned and operated by local collectives.
Dual pricing means fixing prices in two ways: farmers and industrial units bought and sold fixed quantities of inputs and outputs at prices fixed by the government, and the rest at market prices.
- As production increased over the years, the proportion of goods and inputs transacted in the market also increased
Special economic zones (SEZs) were set up by China, as part of its reforms, to attract foreign investors.
In 1978 commune land was given to households for use (cultivation), not for ownership. Collective ownership of land stayed.
2.2 Pakistan’s path
- Like India, Pakistan follows the mixed economy model, with public and private sectors existing side by side
- In the late 1950s and 1960s, Pakistan introduced a regulated policy framework for import substitution-based industrialisation
- It combined tariff protection for manufacturing consumer goods with direct import controls on competing imports
- The Green Revolution brought mechanisation and more public investment in infrastructure in select areas
- This raised foodgrain production and changed the agrarian structure dramatically
- In the 1970s, capital goods industries were nationalised
- Then, in the late 1970s and 1980s, the policy shifted: the thrust areas became denationalisation and encouragement of the private sector
- In this period Pakistan also received financial support from western nations and remittances from a growing outflow of emigrants to the Middle-east
- This stimulated growth; the government offered more incentives to the private sector, creating a good climate for new investment
- In 1988, reforms were initiated
- The Wagah Border (the book’s Fig. 8.1) is not only a tourist place but is also used for trade between India and Pakistan
Import substitution-based industrialisation protects domestic industry with tariffs and import controls so that goods earlier imported are made at home.
Remittances are money sent home by workers employed abroad, such as Pakistani workers in the Middle-east.
For chronology questions, hold Pakistan’s order: nationalisation (1970s), then denationalisation (late 1970s-1980s), then reforms (1988).
3 Demographic indicators
- Of every six persons in the world, one is an Indian and another a Chinese
- Pakistan’s population is very small; the book puts it at roughly about one-tenth of China or India
- China is the largest nation and has the largest area, yet its density is the lowest
| Table 8.1: Select Demographic Indicators, 2021-23 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Country | Estimated population (million) | Annual growth of population (%) | Density (per sq. km) | Sex ratio | Fertility rate | Urbanisation (%) |
| India | 1428 | 0.81 | 473 | 930 | 2.0 | 36 |
| China | 1411 | -0.10 | 150 | 898 | 1.2 | 65 |
| Pakistan | 240 | 1.96 | 300 | 948 | 3.4 | 38 |
Source: World Development Indicators 2024.
Sex ratio is the proportion of females per 1000 males.
What Table 8.1 shows:
- Population growth is highest in Pakistan (1.96%), then India (0.81%), then China (-0.10%)
- The sex ratio is low and biased against females in all three countries; it is lowest in China (898)
- Scholars cite son preference in all three countries as the reason; all three are now adopting measures to improve the situation
- Fertility is low in China (1.2) and very high in Pakistan (3.4)
- Urbanisation is highest in China (65%); 36% of India’s people live in urban areas
The one-child norm was introduced in China in the late 1970s, allowing a couple only one child.
Writing “China has the most people, so it has the highest density” is wrong. China has the largest area, so its density is the lowest (150 per sq. km). India’s is the highest (473).
4 Gross Domestic Product and sectors
4.1 Size of GDP
- According to the book, China’s GDP (PPP) is 35 trillion dollars, the second largest in the world
- India’s GDP (PPP) is 15 trillion dollars, about 42 per cent of China’s
- Pakistan’s GDP is 1.5 trillion dollars, roughly 10 per cent of India’s

4.2 GDP growth
| Table 8.2: Annual Growth of Gross Domestic Product (%), 1980-2024 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Country | 1980-90 | 2015-2017 | 2024 |
| India | 5.7 | 7.3 | 6.5 |
| China | 10.3 | 6.8 | 5.0 |
| Pakistan | 6.3 | 5.3 | 3.1 |
Source: Key Indicators for Asia and Pacific 2025, Asian Development Bank; World Development Indicators 2024.
- When many developed countries could not keep up even 5 per cent growth, China maintained near double-digit growth (10.3%) in the 1980s
- In the 1980s Pakistan (6.3%) was ahead of India (5.7%), and India was at the bottom
- In 2015-17 and 2024, growth declined in Pakistan and China, while India saw a moderate increase
- Some scholars blame Pakistan’s falling growth on its reform processes and long political instability
4.3 Agriculture in China
- China and Pakistan have a larger share of urban population than India
- Because of topography and climate, the area suitable for cultivation in China is small, only about 10 per cent of its land
- China’s total cultivable area is 40 per cent of India’s
- Until the 1980s, more than 80 per cent of China’s people depended on farming as their sole livelihood
- The government then encouraged people to leave their fields for handicrafts, commerce and transport
- In 2021, with 23 per cent of its workforce in agriculture, China’s agriculture contributed only 8 per cent of GVA
In the book’s words, Gross Domestic Product is now called Gross Value Added (GVA).
| Sector | Contribution to GVA (%) | Distribution of workforce (%) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| India | China | Pakistan | India | China | Pakistan | |
| Agriculture | 18 | 8 | 24 | 43 | 23 | 36 |
| Industry | 28 | 38 | 21 | 26 | 32 | 26 |
| Services | 54 | 54 | 55 | 31 | 45 | 38 |
| Total | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
Table 8.3: Sectoral Share of Employment and GDP (%) in 2022. Source: World Development Indicators Database 2024; Key Indicators of Asia and Pacific 2025.
- Agriculture: agriculture contributes 18 and 24 per cent of GVA in India and Pakistan, but a larger share of the workforce works in it in India (India 43%, Pakistan 36%)
- Industry: 26% of Pakistan’s workforce is in industry but produces 21% of GVA; in India 26% of the workforce produces 28%; in China industry employs 32% and contributes 38%
- Services: in all three countries the service sector contributes the highest share of GDP (54, 54, 55 per cent)
Agriculture: many workers, small output (2022):
4.5 Structural change: China versus India and Pakistan
- In the normal course of development, countries first shift employment and output from agriculture to industry, and then to services
- This is what is happening in China (Table 8.3)
- In India and Pakistan the share of the workforce in industry is low (26 per cent) and industry’s contribution to GDP is also low (India 28%, Pakistan 21%)
- So in these countries the shift is taking place directly from agriculture to the service sector
- Thus in all three the service sector is emerging as a major player of development: it contributes more to GDP and is a prospective employer

Share of the workforce in services (%): in the 1980s, Pakistan was shifting its workforce to services faster than India and China.
| Country | 1980s | 2022 |
|---|---|---|
| India | 17 | 31 |
| China | 12 | 45 |
| Pakistan | 27 | 38 |
4.6 Growth of output by sector
| Table 8.4: Trends in Output Growth in Different Sectors (%), 1980-2018 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Country | 1980-90 | 2014-18 | ||||
| Agriculture | Industry | Service | Agriculture | Industry | Service | |
| India | 3.1 | 7.4 | 6.9 | 3.1 | 6.9 | 7.6 |
| China | 5.9 | 10.8 | 13.5 | 3.1 | 5.3 | 7.1 |
| Pakistan | 4 | 7.7 | 6.8 | 1.7 | 4.8 | 5.0 |
- Agriculture: over five decades the growth of agriculture, which employs the largest proportion of the workforce in all three, has declined; in the table China fell from 5.9 to 3.1 and Pakistan from 4 to 1.7, while India stayed at 3.1
- Industry: China kept near double-digit growth (10.8%) in the 1980s but has declined recently (5.3%); India (7.4 to 6.9) and Pakistan (7.7 to 4.8) also declined
- Services: China’s service growth was high in 1980-90 (13.5%), while India’s service output grew at a positive and increasing rate (6.9 to 7.6)
- So China’s growth comes from the manufacturing and service sectors, India’s from the service sector
- In this period Pakistan decelerated in all three sectors
Table 8.3 gives shares (%) and Table 8.4 gives growth rates (%). “Services are 54% of India’s GVA” and “India’s services grew 7.6%” are two different statements; do not mix them in an answer.
5 Indicators of human development
| Table 8.5: Some Selected Indicators of Human Development, 2017-2023 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Item | India | China | Pakistan |
| Human Development Index (value) | 0.685 | 0.797 | 0.544 |
| Rank (based on HDI) | 130 | 78 | 168 |
| Life expectancy at birth (years) | 72.0 | 78.0 | 67.6 |
| Mean years of schooling (aged 15 and above) | 6.9 | 8.0 | 4.3 |
| Gross National Income per capita (PPP, US dollars) | 9,047 | 22,029 | 5,501 |
| People living below poverty line (%) (national) | 21.9 (2019-21) | 0.0 (2023) | 21.9 (2023) |
| Infant mortality rate (per 1000 live births) | 25.5 | 4.8 | 51 |
| Maternal mortality rate (per 1 lakh births) | 103 | 23 | 154 |
| People using at least basic sanitation (% of population) | 78 | 96 | 71 |
| People using at least basic drinking water source (% of population) | 93 | 98 | 91 |
| Prevalence of undernourishment (% of population) | 17 | 3 | 19 |
Sources: Human Development Report 2025; World Development Indicators Metadata 2024.
What Table 8.5 shows:
- China is moving ahead of India and Pakistan on many indicators: income, the share below the poverty line, and health indicators such as mortality rates, access to sanitation, literacy, life expectancy and malnourishment
- On the HDI, China (0.797, rank 78) leads, then India (0.685, rank 130), then Pakistan (0.544, rank 168)
- The book says China and Pakistan are ahead of India in reducing the proportion of people below the poverty line; China has the smallest share of poor among the three
- China leads on sanitation (96%)
- India and Pakistan have not been able to save women from maternal mortality: in China only 23 women die per one lakh births, against 103 in India and 154 in Pakistan
- Surprisingly, all three report improved drinking water sources for most of their population (93, 98, 91 per cent)

Given: GNI per capita (PPP): China 22,029; India 9,047 US dollars.
Formula: Ratio = China’s per capita income ÷ India’s per capita income
Substitution: 22,029 ÷ 9,047 = 2.43
Result: China’s per capita income is about 2.4 times India’s.
Interpretation: China’s industrial growth has taken its per capita income far ahead of India’s.
5.1 The limit of these indicators: liberty indicators
- When judging such questions, note one problem: these indicators are extremely important, but not sufficient
- Along with them we also need what may be called liberty indicators
Liberty indicators are measures of the extent of people’s freedom, such as the extent of democratic participation in social and political decision-making.
Added, but given no extra weight
- The extent of democratic participation in social and political decision-making
Not yet introduced at all
- The extent of constitutional protection given to rights of citizens
- The extent of constitutional protection of the independence of the judiciary and the Rule of Law
Without including these (and perhaps some more) and giving them overriding importance in the list, the construction of a human development index may be said to be incomplete and its usefulness limited.
the book, section 8.5
6 Development strategies: an appraisal
- Countries often take another country’s development strategy as a model for lessons and guidance, especially since reforms began in different parts of the world
- To learn from neighbours we need the roots of their successes and failures, and the different phases of their strategies
- The start of reforms is taken as the point of reference
6.1 Why China introduced structural reforms in 1978
- China had no compulsion from the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund to reform, unlike India and Pakistan
- The new leadership was not happy with the slow pace of growth and the lack of modernisation under Maoist rule
- It felt that the Maoist vision, based on decentralisation, self-sufficiency and shunning foreign technology, goods and capital, had failed
- Despite extensive land reforms, collectivisation, the Great Leap Forward and other initiatives, per capita grain output in 1978 was the same as in the mid-1950s
China’s reforms
- Began in 1978
- On its own initiative, with no outside compulsion
- Trigger: failure of the Maoist vision
India’s and Pakistan’s reforms
- India 1991, Pakistan 1988
- Forced upon them by international agencies such as the World Bank and IMF
- India borrowed from the IMF and World Bank to set right its balance of payments crisis
6.2 Factors behind China’s rapid growth
The pre-reform base
Infrastructure in education and health, land reforms, long decentralised planning and small enterprises improved social and income indicators after the reforms.
Rural health services
Before the reforms there had already been a massive extension of basic health services in rural areas.
Equitable distribution
The commune system gave a more equitable distribution of foodgrains.
Small-scale experiments first
Each reform was tried at a smaller level, then extended on a massive scale. Experiments under decentralised government let the economic, social and political costs of success or failure be assessed.
6.3 Pakistan: slow growth and the re-emergence of poverty
- Scholars argue that in Pakistan the reform process worsened all the economic indicators; compared with the 1980s, GDP growth and its sectoral parts have not yet improved
- Data on the international poverty line look healthy for Pakistan, but scholars using Pakistan’s official data indicate rising poverty
Reasons for slow growth and returning poverty (as scholars put it):
Dependence on good harvests
Agricultural growth and food supply were based on good harvests, not on an institutionalised process of technical change. Good harvest, good economy; otherwise stagnation or negative trends.
Unstable foreign exchange
Most foreign exchange came from remittances of Pakistani workers in the Middle-east and from highly volatile agricultural exports.
Foreign loans
Dependence on foreign loans grew, and so did the difficulty of paying them back.
Foreign exchange is essential for every country. A country that earns it through sustainable export of manufactured goods need not worry. Pakistan’s weakness was that its foreign exchange rested on remittances and volatile farm exports.
The recent recovery:
- In the last few years Pakistan has recovered its economic growth and sustained it
- The Annual Plan 2019-20 reports that GDP grew 5.5 per cent in 2017-18, the highest of the previous decade
- Agriculture’s growth was far from satisfactory, while industry and services grew at 4.9 and 6.2 per cent; many macroeconomic indicators began to show stable and positive trends
6.4 India’s trade with its neighbours (the book’s “Work These Out”)
| Country | Exports from India (Rs crore) | Imports to India (Rs crore) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2004-05 | 2024-25 | Compound rate of growth (%) | 2004-05 | 2024-25 | Compound rate of growth (%) | |
| Pakistan | 2,341 | 4,720 | 3.6 | 427 | 4 | -20.8 |
| China | 25,232 | 1,20,617 | 8.1 | 31,892 | 9,59,666 | 18.5 |
Formula: Exports as % of imports = (Exports ÷ Imports) × 100
China, 2004-05: (25,232 ÷ 31,892) × 100 = 79.1%
China, 2024-25: (1,20,617 ÷ 9,59,666) × 100 = 12.6%
Pakistan, 2004-05: (2,341 ÷ 427) × 100 = 548.2%
Pakistan, 2024-25: (4,720 ÷ 4) × 100 = 1,18,000%
Interpretation: India’s trade deficit with China has grown sharply: in 2024-25 India exports to China only about one-eighth of what it imports from China (deficit ₹8,39,049 crore). Imports from Pakistan have almost stopped (₹4 crore), so exports there are many times imports.
The divisor is imports, not exports. (31,892 ÷ 25,232) × 100 = 126.4% is “imports as % of exports”, which the question does not ask.
7 Conclusion
- India, China and Pakistan have travelled seven decades of development with varied results
- Till the late 1970s all three were at the same low level of development; the last three decades have taken them to different levels
| India | Pakistan | China |
|---|---|---|
| Moderate performance with democratic institutions | Political instability | Lack of political freedom and its implications for human rights are major concerns |
| A majority of people still depend on agriculture | Over-dependence on remittances and foreign aid | Used the “market system without losing political commitment” and raised growth along with poverty alleviation |
| Many initiatives to develop infrastructure and raise living standards | Volatile performance of agriculture; also attempting to privatise public sector enterprises | Used the market mechanism to “create additional social and economic opportunities” |
| Attempting to privatise public sector enterprises | In the last five years, positive and moderate growth in many macroeconomic indicators, i.e. economic recovery | Collective ownership of land with individual cultivation ensures rural social security; pre-reform social infrastructure brought positive human development results |
| Date / term | What it goes with |
|---|---|
| 1947 / 1949 | India and Pakistan independent / People’s Republic of China |
| 1951-56 / 1953 / 1956 | First Five Year Plan of India / China / Pakistan |
| 1958 | Great Leap Forward, 26,000 communes |
| 1966-76 | Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution (introduced by Mao in 1965) |
| 1978 / 1988 / 1991 | Reforms in China / Pakistan / India |
| Late 1970s | China’s one-child norm |
| March 2017 | India stops the Five Year Plan model |
| SOE, SEZ | State Owned Enterprises, special economic zones (China) |
| Medium Term Development Plan | Name of Pakistan’s first plan |
- With globalisation, developing countries want to understand their neighbours, as they compete with developed nations and with each other
- The three have similar physical endowments but totally different political systems
- All three followed planned development, but the structures used to carry out policy differ
- Until the early 1980s, growth rates and sectoral contributions to national income were similar
- Reforms: China 1978, Pakistan 1988, India 1991; China on its own initiative, India and Pakistan under international agencies
- The one-child norm arrested China’s population growth; India and Pakistan are yet to see a major change
- A large share of the workforce still depends on agriculture, highest in India (43%)
- China followed the classical path from agriculture to manufacturing to services; India and Pakistan moved directly to services
- China’s high industrial growth made its per capita income rise faster
- China leads on most human development indicators, credited to its pre-reform strategies, not to the reforms
- Liberty indicators must also be weighed when assessing development
- Can I write the GLF, communes, the Cultural Revolution and the 1978 reforms with the right years?
- Can I give Pakistan’s sequence (import substitution, nationalisation, denationalisation, 1988 reforms)?
- Can I compare the three countries from Tables 8.1, 8.3 and 8.5 without looking?
- Can I write three effects of the one-child norm and two examples of liberty indicators?
- Can I list four factors behind China’s growth and three reasons for Pakistan’s poverty?