Complete solutions to every exercise of NCERT Kaveri (Class 9 English), Unit 4: “Vitamin-M” by Asha Nehemiah and “I Cannot Remember My Mother” by Rabindranath Tagore. Every section is answered in the order the book prints it. Open-ended tasks (speaking, projects) get a model response you can adapt. Try each question yourself first, then compare.
1 Vitamin-M: Reflect and Respond
Q. From your experience with an elderly person at home or in your neighbourhood, complete the following graphic organiser. (Caring for the Elderly)
Answer (sample):
Why should we care for the elderly? They raised us and gave their lives to the family; they carry experience, stories and traditions; they deserve comfort and respect in old age.
What are the problems faced by the elderly? Weak eyesight and hearing, poor memory, illness and many medicines, loneliness, loss of independence, being ignored in decisions.
What could be the possible reasons for the problems faced? Ageing of the body, living alone, busy family members with little time, small city homes, lack of patience from the young.
How can we take care of the elderly? Spend time talking and playing with them, help with medicines and doctor visits, include them in decisions, respect their choices and let them stay independent where it is safe.
Q. Fill in the table given below. You may check your answers with the help of a dictionary. 1. frail 2. shuddered 3. poky 4. forbid 5. pottering 6. winced
Answer: (The first three columns are about your own knowledge; the meanings are:)
1. frail: weak and delicate, usually because of old age or illness
2. shuddered: shook suddenly with fear or horror
3. poky: (of a room or house) small and cramped
4. forbid: order someone not to do something
5. pottering: doing small, unimportant jobs in a slow, relaxed way
6. winced: made a face showing pain or embarrassment (the book’s margin gloss: “showed an expression of embarrassment”)
Q. Think of a tradition, story, or recipe passed down by grandparents or an elderly relative in your family. What does it mean to you? How does it connect you to your growing-up years? Share with your classmates and teacher.
Answer (sample): My grandmother makes besan ladoos every Diwali from a recipe her mother taught her. Each year I roast the gram flour while she tells stories of her childhood village. To me it means that our family’s festivals have the same taste across three generations. It connects me to my growing-up years because every Diwali I remember standing on a stool in her kitchen, too small to reach the stove.
2 Vitamin-M: Check Your Understanding (Part I)
Q. Why did Grandpa dislike living in the city with his daughter?
Answer: Grandpa hated “the noise and bustle of city life”. He called his daughter’s home “this poky little flat” in “this horrible, crowded city”, and he longed for his small, quiet brick house in town with its big mango tree. He also resented losing his independence: his daughter now forbade him to go out on his own.
Q. Why did Vidya not want her father to go out alone?
Answer: She was afraid for his safety. In his first month with them he had got lost on one occasion when he went for a walk and forgot the way back home, and he had been hospitalised after absent-mindedly taking a double dose of his medicines. Earlier he had fallen in his own garden and lain outside all night. She believed his memory, hearing and sight were failing.
Q. Was Ravi in favour of his mother treating Grandpa like a child? How can you say so?
Answer: No. “Ravi winced at the over-loud tone his mother used when speaking to Grandpa, as though she were speaking to a child who couldn’t hear or understand too well.” He also admired Grandpa’s chess and learnt from him, and he loyally told Grandpa, “Mamma would never treat you like a baby … or a prisoner.”
Q. Would Ravi be able to keep up his promise to his mother?
Answer: Not fully. He had promised that Grandpa would “be fine at home” with him, but Grandpa cleverly got his permission to go out. Ravi kept the spirit of the promise by following Grandpa secretly to keep him safe, but he could not keep Grandpa at home, and in the end he even lost sight of him.
3 Vitamin-M: Check Your Understanding (Part II)
Q. Complete the flow chart by describing Grandpa’s day out.
Answer:
Grandpa goes out to get Tamil newspaper → Ravi follows Grandpa → Grandpa first stops at 1. the children’s park → buys 2. a paper-cone of peanuts and watches the children play → Ravi hides behind a bush to observe → Grandpa next goes to 3. the tea stall → Ravi hides behind a banyan tree and watches → Ravi gets scolded by 4. the vendor selling plastic combs and the vendor selling ribbons and clips → Ravi ducks behind a shiny silver car and watches his grandfather → Grandpa drinks 5. a sugary cup of tea and eats two bananas (and an ice cream) → Grandpa then crosses the road and enters a 6. barber shop → Next Grandpa walks quickly to a 7. bus stop and boards the first bus → Ravi enters the bus only to discover that he had been fooled.
Note: in blank 7 it is really the stranger in Grandpa’s cap whom Ravi sees; Ravi believes it is Grandpa.
Q. Was Grandpa lost as feared by Ravi’s mother?
Answer: No. Grandpa knew exactly where he was going: the park, the tea stall and the barber shop. He even gave his cap away and found his way home by himself; Ravi later found him safely asleep in his bedroom. It was Ravi who “lost” Grandpa.
Q. How would Ravi feel after seeing Grandpa?
Answer: He would feel great relief and delight after hours of worry, together with deep affection for Grandpa. He might also feel a little foolish for having followed a stranger. In the story he is “suddenly overcome with affection” and hugs the sleeping Grandpa.
Q. Do you think Ravi’s mother will get to know about what had happened?
Answer: Probably not the whole story. Ravi decides not to question Grandpa because he would have to reveal that he had followed him, and Grandpa only tells her that Ravi “just disappeared”. So she learns that Ravi went out, but not about Grandpa’s day out, the banned snacks or the chase.
4 Vitamin-M: Check Your Understanding (Part III)
Q. Describe how Ravi’s emotional reaction upon finding Grandpa safe at home reveals his feelings towards his grandfather.
Answer: Ravi feels “great delight and relief” on hearing Grandpa snoring. He kneels by the bed, puts his cheek against Grandpa’s wrinkled face, notices his smell of eucalyptus ointment and shaving cream, and is “suddenly overcome with affection”, giving him a hug. This shows that Ravi loves Grandpa deeply and had been truly afraid of losing him.
Q. What might be the significance of Grandpa’s habit of giving gifts to everyone on his birthday rather than receiving them?
Answer: It shows his generous, giving nature: he finds joy in making others happy rather than in being honoured. It also shows that he still sees himself as the head of the family, caring for his “babies”, and it keeps the family bond alive. In the story it also exposes his daughter’s forgetfulness.
Q. Why do you think Grandpa gave Ravi a detective story book as a gift? What might this suggest about Grandpa’s awareness of Ravi’s actions earlier in the day?
Answer: The gift is a playful hint. Grandpa says Ravi can learn “How to avoid getting fooled when one is trailing a suspect”. This may suggest that Grandpa knew Ravi had been following him, and that Ravi had been fooled into trailing a stranger in Grandpa’s cap. The story never says so directly, and the twinkle in his eye, “an innocent gleam or a mischievous one”, leaves it open.
5 Vitamin-M: Critical Reflection
Q. Read the extract (“Grandpa hated the noise and bustle of city life … no one at home to help him up.”) and answer the questions.
(i) Choose the emotion displayed by the Grandfather. A. regretful B. apologetic C. nostalgic D. wistful
Answer: C. nostalgic. He speaks “longingly” of his old house and garden.
(ii) Complete the following sentence with a reason. Grandpa hated the busy and noisy city life because ___.
Answer: he was used to the peace of his small brick house in town, where it was so quiet that at dusk you could hear a leaf fall.
(iii) Why did Grandpa come to the city despite his dislike for city life?
Answer: He was getting too old to live on his own. He had slipped and fallen in his garden while pottering around and lain outside all night with no one to help him. After this, his daughter locked up his house and brought him to live with her.
(iv) Choose an expression similar in meaning to, ‘you can even hear a leaf fall’. A. end of one’s life B. arrival of autumn C. sign of good luck D. pin drop silence
Answer: D. pin drop silence.
(v) State one advantage and one disadvantage of the Grandfather living in the house in town.
Answer: Advantage: peace, quiet and independence in his own home with a garden. Disadvantage: he lived alone, so there was no one to help him in an emergency, as when he fell and lay outside all night.
Q. Read the extract (“I had a quiet morning, but I don’t know about Ravi … exclaimed Ravi’s mother, impatiently.”) and answer the questions.
(i) Choose the option that displays the tone of the Grandfather’s response. A. apologetic B. hurtful C. calm D. puzzled
Answer: C. calm. The text says Grandpa answered “coolly”.
(ii) Why was Ravi confused and embarrassed?
Answer: Grandpa, who had himself slipped out, was now blaming Ravi for disappearing. Ravi could not defend himself without admitting that he had been following Grandpa, and he was puzzled about how much Grandpa knew.
(iii) Complete the sentence with a suitable reason. Ravi’s mother was impatient because ___.
Answer: she thought her forgetful father had mixed up Ravi’s birthday, which was three months ago.
(iv) State whether the following sentence is true or false. Grandfather forgot that Ravi’s birthday was three months ago.
Answer: False. He knew; the gift was for his own birthday, as was his custom.
(v) Why did Grandpa say he didn’t know what kind of morning Ravi might have had?
Answer: He was teasing Ravi and hinting that he knew Ravi had been out following him. By claiming his own “quiet morning” he hid his adventure and turned the tables on Ravi.
Q. Grandpa is portrayed as a person with failing memory in the beginning of the story. Give two evidences to disprove the statement.
Answer: (1) He remembers thousands of chess games, such as Karpov’s opening move against the computer and the mistake Bobby Fischer made in his historic match against Spassky. (2) He remembers his own birthday and his custom of giving a gift to every child in the house, while his daughter forgets it.
Q. Give two characteristic traits of each of the following characters. (i) Grandfather (ii) Ravi (iii) Ravi’s mother
Answer:
(i) Grandfather: independent (hates being treated “like a baby”); clever and crafty (tricks Ravi into letting him go, and Ravi ends up trailing a stranger in his cap); also generous.
(ii) Ravi: caring and responsible (follows Grandpa to keep him safe); sensitive and loyal (winces at his mother’s tone, defends her to Grandpa).
(iii) Ravi’s mother: loving but anxious and over-protective (forbids Grandpa to go out alone); impatient and herself forgetful (forgets her father’s birthday).
Q. Why was Ravi worried about what Grandfather had at the tea stall?
Answer: Grandpa had a sugary cup of tea although “he was forbidden sugar at home”, ate two bananas (“another banned item”) and then an ice cream. These were bad for his health, and Ravi knew his mother “would faint if she saw this”.
Q. Do you think it was easy for Ravi to follow his Grandfather? If yes, why? If no, why not?
Answer: No. At the park a child noticed him and the child’s mother threatened him with her umbrella, so he had to crawl out on all fours. At the tea stall loud vendors surrounded him. He panicked when Grandpa crossed through traffic, was thrown out of a Ladies’ Hairdressing Salon, and had to sprint to catch a bus, only to find he had followed the wrong man.
Q. ‘Ravi is a good detective’. Give one argument in favour of and against the given statement.
Answer: In favour: he was determined; he kept Grandpa in sight through the park, the tea stall and the road, and did not give up even when he had to sprint for a moving bus. Against: he was spotted again and again (by a child, the vendors, the salon) and was finally fooled by a simple trick: he followed a yellow cap on the wrong man.
Q. Was Grandfather aware that Ravi was following him? How do you know?
Answer: It seems so. He gave his yellow cap, the thing Ravi was tracking, to a stranger and went home; in the evening he said Ravi “just disappeared”; he gave Ravi a detective book with tips on not “getting fooled when one is trailing a suspect”; and his eye had a twinkle that might have been “a mischievous one”.
Q. In your opinion, who needs Vitamin-M? And why?
Answer: Ravi’s mother needs Vitamin-M. She wished for a memory vitamin for old people like her father, yet she forgot his birthday although she had circled it in red on the calendar. Grandpa himself says, “My daughter needs some Vitamin-M, I think—for her memory.” Being busy, anyone can forget; forgetfulness is not only a problem of the old.
Q. Some people believe society shows bias based on age (being young or old). Give an example where you might have experienced or observed such discrimination, when opinions were disregarded because of age.
Answer (sample): At a family meeting about buying a new phone, my suggestion about a better model was brushed aside with “You are too young to understand.” Later the elders found my point was right. In the same way, my grandfather’s advice about repairing the old roof was ignored because people thought his ideas were outdated. Both show that opinions should be judged on their merit, not on the speaker’s age, just as Grandpa in “Vitamin-M” is wrongly written off.
6 Vitamin-M: Vocabulary and Structures in Context
Q. Classify the words given in the box into movement words in Column 1 and sound words in Column 2. (pottering, boomed, twirling, crouch, bustle, crawl, creeping, thudded, ducked, shrieks, zigzagging, whirr, evicted, briskly, sprinting, grunted, jumping, darted, trailing, snoring)
Answer:
Column 1 (movement): pottering, twirling, crouch, bustle, crawl, creeping, ducked, zigzagging, evicted, briskly, sprinting, jumping, darted, trailing
Column 2 (sound): boomed, thudded, shrieks, whirr, grunted, snoring
Fill in the blanks (Detective Shankar): 1. trailing 2. bustle 3. briskly 4. thudded 5. twirling 6. crouch 7. zigzagging (also accepted: creeping) 8. grunted 9. darted 10. whirr (also accepted: snoring)
Q. Study the highlighted word in the given sentence from the text and fill in the boxes with synonymous words. Off he went, twirling his walking stick jauntily, leaving Ravi in a dilemma. 1. QU_ ND_ _ Y 2. PR_ D _ C _ M _ NT
Answer: 1. QUANDARY 2. PREDICAMENT
Q. Fill in the table given below. Check your answers with the help of a dictionary. 1. craftily 2. dilemma 3. furious 4. boomed 5. humiliation 6. attire
| Word | Meaning | Part of speech | Synonym | Antonym |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| craftily | in a clever, sly way | adverb | cunningly | openly / honestly |
| dilemma | a situation needing a choice between two difficult options | noun | quandary | certainty |
| furious | extremely angry | adjective | enraged | calm |
| boomed | spoke in a loud, deep voice | verb (past tense) | thundered | whispered |
| humiliation | a feeling of shame and loss of dignity | noun | embarrassment | pride |
| attire | clothes | noun | clothing / dress | no exact antonym |
Q. Match the emotions/expressions in Column 1 with their meanings in Column 2. One meaning is extra.
Answer: 1. embarrassed: (v) felt uncomfortable
2. countered: (iv) reply to an argument
3. flushed: (vi) became red in the face
4. stricken: (i) affected severely by an unpleasant feeling
5. gleam: (iii) expression of emotion
Extra meaning: (ii) to be confused
Q. Read the highlighted words in the following phrases from the story. Now, revisit the story and underline the prepositions. 1. I’ll just walk across to the corner shop… 2. … he felt a shadow fall over him… 3. …the vendors sitting under the tree… 4. Ravi took position behind a big banyan…
Answer: 1. across (the phrase also has “to” in “to the corner shop”) 2. over 3. under 4. behind
Fill in the blanks with appropriate prepositions: (i) through (ii) over (iii) near (iv) in (v) along (vi) towards
Completed passage: I walked through the village, crossed a bridge over a brook, and found a quiet garden near a cottage. Sitting on a bench in the garden, I enjoyed the peaceful surroundings. Later, I strolled along a riverbank, exploring the forest and heading towards the unknown. (vi) towards (also accepted: into).
Q. Read the following dialogues from the story. Now, choose the correct answer. A. The words in the quotes are (i) ___ (exclamatory/interrogative) sentences. B. Sentences 1, 4, and 5 are (ii) ___ (Wh-/Yes, No type) interrogative sentences. C. Sentences 2 and 3 are (iii) ___ (Wh-/Yes, No type) interrogative sentences. So, there are (iv) ___ (two/three) types of interrogative sentences.
Answer: (i) interrogative (ii) Yes, No type (iii) Wh- (iv) two
Q. Read the conversation between Arvind and Priya. Now, complete the following sentences in reported speech.
Answer: Arvind asked Priya if she 1. helped in taking care of her grandparents at home, for which Priya replied in the affirmative and said that they 2. took turns making sure they were alright. Priya further asked Arvind 3. whether he had grandparents living with him. Arvind replied in the negative and said that 4. his parents and he visited his grandpa every weekend. He further enquired 5. how she managed her grandparents’ medical needs. Priya responded by saying that they 6. had a schedule for giving medications and visits to the doctor.
7 Vitamin-M: Listen and Respond
Q. You will listen to a podcast on meditation. As you listen, complete the sentences with not more than three exact words that you hear.
Answer (from the audio transcript in the book’s Appendix, p. 266):
1. Meditation is a form of yoga that usually refreshes the mind and helps with stress management.
2. Meditation leads to a better health condition both physically and emotionally.
3. Meditation also aids in lessening undesirable feelings and improving self-awareness.
4. It is advised that we meditate every day so that it becomes a routine.
5. Meditating on a daily basis is beneficial in comfortably tackling exam-related pressure.
8 Vitamin-M: Speaking Activity
Q. Now, revisit the story and select different questions. Work in pairs and practise speaking them aloud according to the examples shared.
Answer (questions from the story, with the intonation the book’s rules give):
“Shall we play chess or watch the cricket match on TV, Grandpa?” (choice question): rise-fall
“Who are you?” (Wh- question): falling
“What did you both do today?” (Wh- question): falling
“Are you playing hide and seek?” (Yes/No question): rising
“Have you forgotten?” (Yes/No question): rising
“Do I look as though I’m selling anything?” (Yes/No question): rising
“Who are you hiding from?” (Wh- question): falling
Note on question tags: when the speaker is fairly sure and expects agreement (“This is your notebook, isn’t it?”), the voice falls on the tag; when the speaker is unsure and is really asking (“You weren’t in the library yesterday, were you?”), the voice rises on the tag.
Q. Make a presentation about a brief personal experience related to taking care of an older person.
Model response: The person I had the privilege of taking care of was my grandfather, after his knee operation last winter. For two weeks I helped him walk to the balcony every morning, read the newspaper aloud because his glasses tired his eyes, and reminded him of his tablets at lunch. Caring for him taught me valuable lessons about myself, including that I can be patient and keep a routine. Understanding his needs, I learned that he did not want pity; he wanted to do as much as possible himself. His challenges offered insights into the difficulties of ageing, such as slow healing and feeling dependent. Caring for him deepened my understanding of the ageing process, particularly how much respect and small freedoms matter to an older person.
9 Vitamin-M: Writing Task
Q. As you read in the story, we have a lot to learn from our elderly. Based on the lessons learned from them, write an article for your school magazine on the topic ‘Our Inspiring Elderly’.
Model answer:
Our Inspiring Elderly
by Aditi Sharma, Grade 9
Grey hair is often seen as a sign of weakness, but the elderly around us are some of our greatest teachers. Their lives are full of lessons in courage, patience and kindness.
Our grandparents have lived through hardships we can barely imagine, yet they meet each day with calm. My grandmother still wakes at five, tends her tulsi plant and walks to the market. Our neighbour, a retired teacher, tutors children from the colony free of cost. As the saying goes, “Old is gold”: their experience saves us from repeating their mistakes.
Many of them have overcome real challenges. My grandfather lost his job at fifty, learnt tailoring and supported his family for twenty more years. His refusal to give up has taught me to keep trying when my marks disappoint me. Like Grandpa in “Vitamin-M”, our elders are often sharper and wiser than we assume.
Let us spend time with the elderly, listen to their stories and respect their choices. If we value them as teachers and not as burdens, we will inherit not just their homes but their wisdom.
10 Vitamin-M: Learning Beyond the Text
Q. Revisit the story and choose the image that correctly displays Grandpa’s walking stick.
Answer: The correct image is the stick with a brass (golden) handle carved in the shape of an eagle’s head, the second picture from the left in the book. The story describes it as a “shiny-black mahogany walking stick with a brass handle carved in the shape of an eagle’s head”. The others are wrong: one has a plain black knob, one a silver head, and one a plain curved golden handle.
Q. A picture is worth a thousand words! Explore and revisit memories. Collect a few memorable photographs of yourself and your family. Make a slide show. Mention: When and where was it clicked? Who are the people in the photograph? Why is it memorable for you?
Approach: Choose 5 to 6 photographs across years. Give each slide one photo with three short lines. Example slide: “Clicked: Diwali 2019, our old house in Jaipur. People: my grandparents, cousins and me. Why memorable: the last Diwali we spent in that house before we moved.” End with a slide on what these memories mean to you.
Q. Read the story given below (“The Lost Child” by Mulk Raj Anand). Discuss with your classmates and teacher.
Discussion points: At a spring festival fair, a little boy keeps lagging behind his parents. He pleads for a toy, but his father looks at him “red-eyed” and his mother distracts him with the mustard fields. At the fair he wants burfi, a garland and balloons, and he moves on without waiting for an answer because he knows his parents will refuse; he also passes the snake-charmer, whose music they have forbidden. At the roundabout he makes “a bold request”, but there is no reply: his parents are gone. A kind man lifts him out of the crowd and offers him the roundabout, the snake-charmer’s music, a balloon, a garland and sweets, but the child only sobs, “I want my mother, I want my father!” The story shows that a child’s real need is the security of family, not things. It connects with “Vitamin-M”: both show how deeply family members need each other.
11 I Cannot Remember My Mother: Reflect and Respond
Q. Work in pairs. Discuss the memories from your childhood that you remember. List them and share with your classmates and teacher.
Answer (sample list): learning to ride a bicycle with my father holding the seat; my first day at school; flying kites on Makar Sankranti; my grandmother’s bedtime stories; the smell of rain on the terrace in the first monsoon.
Q. Discuss how children’s relationship with their mother can influence their emotions and memories.
Answer: A mother is usually a child’s first source of love, comfort and security. A warm bond makes a child feel safe and confident, and the small things linked with her, a lullaby, a smell, her cooking, become lasting memories that bring comfort even years later. Her absence can leave a deep sense of loss, which is exactly what Tagore’s poem explores.
Q. Match the words given in Column 1 with their meanings in Column 2.
Answer: 1. hover: (v) linger or remain near a place
2. hum: (i) sing a tune with your lips closed
3. cradle: (vi) a small bed for a baby
4. shiuli: (ii) a type of flower (coral jasmine)
5. morning service: (iv) rituals conducted in a temple
6. gaze: (iii) look steadily for a long time
12 I Cannot Remember My Mother: Check Your Understanding
Q. Fill in the blanks with appropriate words.
Answer:
Stanza 1: 1. The poet remembers his mother while he plays. 2. The poet remembers the tune but not the mother. Setting: indoor (he is at play among his playthings; the stanza does not name a place)
Stanza 2: 1. The poet remembers his mother in the (early) autumn season. 2. The poet remembers his mother by the smell of the shiuli flowers. Setting: outdoor
Stanza 3: 1. The poet feels that his mother gazes at him from the sky. Setting: indoor (he looks out from his bedroom window)
Note: for stanza 1, “the tune … but not the song (its words)” is also accepted, since he recalls only “the tune of some song”.
Q. The senses of olfactory (smell), auditory (hearing), and visual (sight), are three of the five basic senses in humans. Give examples of references to senses from the poem. Complete the table given below.
| Stanza | Lines from the Poem | Senses |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | “a tune seems to hover over my playthings” | auditory |
| 3. | “…the tune of some song that she used to hum while rocking my cradle” (given) | auditory |
| 2. | “the smell of the shiuli flowers floats in the air / the scent of the morning service in the temple / comes to me as the scent of my mother” | olfactory |
Note: the given line is about hearing (auditory). The poem’s reference to sight (visual) is in stanza 3: “I send / my eyes into the blue of the distant sky, / I feel that the stillness of / my mother’s gaze on my face / has spread all over the sky.” Write this too, to show all three senses.
Q. Read the poem silently once again and complete the following.
1. Two examples of alliteration from the poem are (i) ___ and (ii) ___.
Answer: (i) “my mother” (ii) “the scent of the morning service” (also: “stillness … spread … sky”)
2. An example of onomatopoeia is ___.
Answer: “hum”
3. The poem uses imagery extensively. Explain.
Answer: Each stanza builds a picture through a sense. Stanza 1 uses auditory imagery: a tune hovering over his playthings, the song hummed while rocking his cradle. Stanza 2 uses olfactory imagery: the smell of shiuli flowers and the scent of the temple’s morning service on an early autumn morning. Stanza 3 uses visual imagery: the blue of the distant sky and his mother’s still gaze spread over it. The images let the reader feel the mother’s presence though she is absent.
4. Although the poem does not have a rhyme scheme, it is enjoyable because ___.
Answer: it has a gentle, musical rhythm, a repeated refrain, and rich sensory images that make the reader hear, smell and see the poet’s memories.
5. What is the tone of the poet? Why do you say so?
Answer: The tone is nostalgic and tender, with a quiet sadness that turns into calm. He admits he cannot remember his mother, yet he lovingly finds her in a tune, a scent and the sky, without bitterness or loud grief.
6. What impact does the title of the poem have on the overall mood of the poem?
Answer: The title announces loss, so the mood starts sad and longing. As the poem shows that he senses her everywhere, the mood becomes bittersweet and comforting. The title makes this contrast stronger.
7. The poet uses ‘I cannot remember my mother’ as a refrain because ___.
Answer: it stresses his loss and longing, and each time it is followed by a memory that shows she is still present in his life; the repetition also gives the free-verse poem its music and structure.
8. The poet uses symbolism to indicate the memory of his mother’s presence. Identify the symbols used in the poem.
Answer: The tune (her lullaby and love), the shiuli flowers and the scent of the morning service (her fragrance, purity and devotion), and the sky (her calm, vast, ever-watchful gaze). The cradle stands for the time when she cared for him as a baby.
13 I Cannot Remember My Mother: Critical Reflection
Q. Read the extract (“I cannot remember my mother / only sometimes in the midst of my play / a tune seems to hover over my playthings,”) and answer the questions.
(i) Complete the following sentence appropriately. The poet is reminded of his mother during his ___.
Answer: play (playtime).
(ii) What is the primary emotion conveyed by the line ‘a tune seems to hover over my playthings’? A. It enhances the joy of play. B. It disrupts the playtime atmosphere. C. It activates memories of the mother. D. It symbolises the carefree nature of childhood.
Answer: C. It activates memories of the mother.
(iii) In the context of the poem, what role does the hovering tune play during the speaker’s playtime?
Answer: It is a gentle reminder of his mother: the tune of the song she hummed while rocking his cradle brings back a sense of her presence while he plays.
(iv) State whether the following sentence is true or false. The poet experiences the tune lingering over playthings only occasionally during playtime.
Answer: True. The poem says “only sometimes in the midst of my play”.
(v) How could the poet feel his mother’s presence, even though she isn’t there?
Answer: Through his senses: the tune she hummed, the smell of shiuli flowers and the temple’s morning service, and the stillness of the sky that feels like her gaze.
Q. Read the extract (“I feel that the stillness of / my mother’s gaze on my face / has spread all over the sky.”) and answer the questions.
(i) What does the poet suggest about the stillness of his mother’s gaze spreading over the sky? A. The mother’s gaze is physically present in the sky. B. The sky is a symbolic extension of the mother’s presence. C. The sky mirrors the mother’s emotions. D. The stillness is fleeting and unrelated to the mother.
Answer: B. The sky is a symbolic extension of the mother’s presence.
(ii) What emotion does the poet associate with the ‘stillness’ of his mother’s gaze? A. a sense of grief B. a sense of anticipation C. a sense of nostalgia D. a sense of serenity
Answer: D. a sense of serenity. “Stillness” suggests calm and peace.
(iii) State whether the following sentence is true or false. The poet suggests that the mother’s gaze has a tangible and visual effect on the sky.
Answer: False. The effect is felt (“I feel”), symbolic, not a real, physical change in the sky.
(iv) What is the purpose of likening the mother’s gaze to the sky?
Answer: To show that her love is vast, calm and all around him, watching over him everywhere, just as the sky covers everything.
(v) Complete the sentence appropriately. The tone of the poet in the given extract is ___ because ___.
Answer: The tone of the poet in the given extract is serene and tender because he feels comforted by his mother’s calm, loving gaze spread across the whole sky.
Q. What is the emotional impact of the refrain, ‘I cannot remember my mother’?
Answer: It fills the poem with a sense of loss and longing, and makes the reader feel the child’s sadness. Because every repetition is followed by a memory of her, it also creates a moving contrast: he cannot remember her, yet he feels her everywhere.
Q. Interpret the connection between the poet’s mother and the following: (i) shiuli flowers (ii) humming tune
Answer: (i) Shiuli flowers: on early autumn mornings their smell, together with the scent of the temple’s morning service, “comes to me as the scent of my mother”. The fragrance stands for her gentle, pure presence. (ii) Humming tune: it is the song she used to hum while rocking his cradle; hearing it hover over his toys brings back her love from his babyhood.
Q. What role does nature play in the poet’s description of the memory of his mother?
Answer: Nature is the bridge to his mother. The autumn morning, the fragrant shiuli flowers and the vast blue sky are what bring her back to him. Her scent is in the flowers and her gaze is in the sky, so she seems to have become part of nature itself, present everywhere around him.
Q. What can be inferred about the poet’s perception of the mother-child relationship?
Answer: He sees it as a bond deeper than conscious memory. Even without remembering her face, the child feels her love through his senses. The relationship is lasting, protective and comforting; it continues after her absence and shapes his feelings throughout life.
14 I Cannot Remember My Mother: Vocabulary in Context
Q. Work in pairs to classify the sensory words given in the box below. One example has been done for you.
| Visual | Auditory | Olfactory | Tactile |
|---|---|---|---|
| glowing, gigantic, minuscule, gloomy, vibrant, crimson | hiss, rustle, sizzle, deafening, squeaky, ear-splitting | aroma, stale, scent, pungent, stinky, fragrant | sticky, rough, chilled, fluffy, smooth, slimy, hairy |
Note: “fluffy” can also be seen (visual), but it mainly describes touch.
Q. Fill in the blanks with sensory words in the box for the following passage written by Sarojini Naidu. There are two extra words. (scarlet, shrill, sizzle, perfumes, flaming, scents, sweetness, essence, smooth)
Answer: 1. scarlet 2. scents 3. sweetness 4. shrill 5. perfumes 6. essence 7. flaming
Extra words: sizzle, smooth.
2 and 5 are both smell words: 2. scents, 5. perfumes (also accepted: 2. perfumes, 5. scents).
Q. Write numbers against each picture with the phrases that describe them with their sensorial associations. One example has been done for you.
Answer: tabla drums: 1 (given, “beats of music echo in air”)
incense sticks with rising smoke: 2 (“melody of soothing scent, dancing in the air”)
a hand holding white flowers: 3 (“fragrant breeze of blooming buds”)
a mother rocking a baby’s cradle: 4 (“gentle lullaby, a soft melody”)
kites in a blue sky: 5 (“colourful sky, painting a lively sight”)
a sunset over water: 6 (“attractive canvas painting the horizon”)
15 I Cannot Remember My Mother: Listen and Respond
Q. You will listen to four short extracts of people expressing their childhood memories. As you listen, match each statement 1-6 to each speaker (i)-(iv). There are two statements that you do not need.
Answer (from the audio transcript in the book’s Appendix, pp. 266-267):
Speaker (i): 2. My grandfather’s encouragement influences me in moments of difficulty.
Speaker (ii): 4. Childhood days are about freedom and ordinary pleasures in outdoor activities.
Speaker (iii): 5. Memories of school days are grandparents and my funny tales.
Speaker (iv): 1. The precious memories by the seaside are not the same anymore.
Not needed: statements 3 and 6. (Speaker (ii) explored nature “without restrictions”, so statement 6 does not fit.)
16 I Cannot Remember My Mother: Speaking Activity
Q. Work in pairs. Think of an object, song, or a place that is memorable for you. Take turns to speak about it using the prompts given.
Model response: During my childhood, the object I treasured most was a small wooden radio in my grandfather’s room. It was dark brown, warm to touch, and it crackled before the music began; the room always smelt of his mustard-oil hair tonic. I have a clear memory of Sunday mornings when he tuned it to old film songs and taught me to hum along. That radio made me love music, and today I play the harmonium. Thinking about my early years, I recall that radio as the sound of being safe and loved, which is why the memory is still meaningful to me.
17 I Cannot Remember My Mother: Writing Task
Q. Imagine you had been on a school trip to a scenic place which appealed to all your senses. Write a diary entry describing the place and why it was a memorable experience.
Model answer:
Monday, 12 October 2026
9:30 p.m.
Dear diary,
Today our class visited a tea estate in the hills, and I still feel as if I am standing among those green slopes. The moment we got off the bus, the cool air touched my face and the whole valley smelt of fresh leaves and wet earth. Rows of tea bushes rolled down the hills like green waves, and white clouds drifted below us.
We walked along a narrow path while birds chirped and a stream gurgled somewhere nearby. The tea pickers showed us how to pluck “two leaves and a bud”; the leaves felt soft and slightly waxy. At the factory, the strong, sweet aroma of drying tea filled the room, and we tasted a cup that was lighter and more fragrant than any tea I have had at home.
The best moment came at sunset, when the whole valley turned golden and everyone fell silent. I felt calm and grateful in a way I cannot fully explain.
I realised today that we rush past so much beauty. I want to notice the world with all my senses more often.
Riya
Note (from the book): Anne Frank and Zlata Filipovic began their entries with ‘Dear diary’ because they treated their diaries as friends; Samuel Pepys did not, as his diary was a record of facts, thoughts and feelings.
18 I Cannot Remember My Mother: Learning Beyond the Text
Q. You read about the shiuli flowers from the poem. Gather more information on unique flowers of India: where they are found, how they look, what smell they emit, and what the historical significance is, if any. Add more flowers to this list.
Answer (sample list):
Shiuli (from the book): known as Parijat, Parijata and Harsingar; revered and used for ceremonial purposes; releases a sweet fragrance; associated with numerous Indian legends; blooms only at night.
Kurinji / Neelakurinji: blooms once in twelve years (from the book); it covers hillsides in blue in the Western Ghats when it flowers.
Lotus: the national flower of India; pink or white, grows in ponds; a symbol of purity in Indian culture.
Brahma Kamal: a white Himalayan flower that blooms at night; the state flower of Uttarakhand, offered in temples.
Palash (Flame of the Forest): bright orange flowers on a leafless tree in spring; traditionally used to make Holi colours.
Q. You must have read poems and songs related to the theme of family, friends and their reminiscences, in English and also in your own language. Collect these poems and songs, and share with your classmates and teacher. Now, read and enjoy the poem given below (“I Remember, I Remember” by Thomas Hood).
Approach: Collect two or three poems or songs on family and memory, one in English and one in your own language, and share why each moves you. Hood’s poem fits the unit well: like Tagore’s speaker, Hood’s speaker remembers his childhood home through small sensory details, “The little window where the sun / Came peeping in at morn”, the roses, violets and lilacs, and the laburnum his brother planted. Unlike Tagore’s calm ending, Hood’s memory carries a note of sadness: “But now, I often wish the night / Had borne my breath away.”