- Tell the story of “Vitamin-M” in order: home, Grandpa’s day out, and the twist at the end
- Describe Grandpa, Ravi and Ravi’s mother with evidence from the story
- Explain the irony of the title: who really needs Vitamin-M?
- Explain Tagore’s poem stanza by stanza, with the sense each stanza uses
- Spot refrain, symbolism, imagery, alliteration and onomatopoeia, with exact lines
- Use the unit’s grammar: prepositions, question types, reported questions and intonation
1 The Unit at a Glance
Unit 4 of Kaveri has two texts, and both are covered in full in these notes. Both are about the bond between generations and about memory.
| Vitamin-M | I Cannot Remember My Mother | |
|---|---|---|
| Writer | Asha Nehemiah | Rabindranath Tagore |
| Form | Prose short story in three parts (I, II, III) | Poem, three stanzas, free verse (no rhyme scheme) |
| About | A grandfather everyone thinks is forgetful, who outwits his grandson and his daughter | A child who cannot remember his mother but feels her through a tune, a scent and the sky |
| Mood | Funny, warm, ironic | Tender, nostalgic, calm |
Vitamin-M is an imaginary memory vitamin. Ravi’s mother wishes “that somebody would invent a memory — Vitamin-M, they could call it, and we could give it to old people to help them improve their memories”. The title comes from her wish.
2 Vitamin-M: The Story in Three Parts
The whole story takes place in one day. Here is its shape before the details.
2.1 Part I: Why Grandpa lives with them now
- Ravi’s mother, Vidya, puts Grandpa’s tablets on a saucer and wishes for a “memory” vitamin.
- She says Grandpa does not hear, see or remember well. He is frail (weak), sits in a rocking chair and holds the newspaper “inches from his nose”.
- Grandpa came to live with them only last month, because he was getting too old to live alone. It was a difficult month:
- he was admitted to hospital after absent-mindedly taking a double dose of his medicines;
- he once went for a walk and got lost, forgetting the way home.
- Before that, he had slipped and fallen in the garden of his own house while pottering around (doing small jobs slowly) and lain outside all night because no one was home. So Vidya locked up his house and brought him to the city.
Grandpa’s own house in town
- “small brick house”
- “big mango tree in the garden”
- So quiet “that at dusk you can even hear a leaf fall!”
- But he lived alone: no help after his fall
His daughter’s flat in the city
- “this poky little flat” (poky = small and cramped)
- “this horrible, crowded city”
- He hates its “noise and bustle” (busy activity)
- He is not allowed out alone
Grandpa’s protest shows his pride. With “the firmness that had been a natural part of his job as a lawyer“, he tells Vidya he has looked after himself “for the better part of my seventy-five years“. After his wife died ten years ago he cooked, shopped and kept house himself.
2.2 Part I: Mother leaves, Grandpa slips out
Grandpa leaves with his shiny-black mahogany walking stick, its brass handle carved in the shape of an eagle’s head, and his bright-yellow cap, “twirling his walking stick jauntily” (happily and confidently).
If he insists on going along, Grandpa will feel hurt. If he lets Grandpa go alone, his mother will be furious. His solution: follow Grandpa secretly, at a safe distance. A dilemma is a situation where you must choose between two difficult options.
2.3 Part II: Grandpa’s day out, and Ravi’s troubles
| Stop | What Grandpa does | What happens to Ravi |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Children’s park | Buys a paper-cone of peanuts, sits on a bench, watches children play | Crouches behind a bush “trimmed in the shape of an elephant”. A child asks, “Are you playing hide and seek?” The child’s mother booms, “How dare you shoo my child?” and raises her umbrella. Ravi crawls out on all fours: “the ultimate humiliation” |
| 2. Tea stall | Sips a sugary cup of tea (sugar is forbidden at home), eats two bananas (also banned), then an ice cream from the cart | Hides behind a big banyan tree. Loud women vendors (one selling plastic combs, one selling ribbons and clips) think he wants their spot: “This area is booked by us”. He gives up and ducks behind a shiny silver car |
| 3. Road and barber shop | Zigzags through traffic (a screech of brakes), enters a barber shop although he is “as bald as a table tennis ball” | Ducks into the shop next door and is thrown out “amidst a volley of feminine shrieks”: it is a Ladies’ Hairdressing Salon |
| 4. Bus stop | Ravi spots a man in Grandpa’s clothes and yellow cap walking briskly to the bus stop and boarding the first bus; he takes him for Grandpa | Sprints and jumps on the bus, pushes to the front to confront the cap-wearer |
On the bus the man takes off the cap and has “a full head of grey hair”. He is a total stranger in a white pyjama and shirt (Grandpa’s standard attire) wearing Grandpa’s yellow cap, the one with the coffee stain on its rim. He says a kind old gentleman in the barber shop insisted he take the cap because it was such a hot day. Ravi has been following the wrong man. “But where was Grandpa?”
2.4 Part III: Home, and the twist
- Grandpa is not at the barber shop or the park. Ravi is frantic (very frightened). He calls his mother, then his father, from a telephone booth; both lines are busy.
- At home he hears “the gentle whirr of Grandpa snoring”. Relief. He kneels, puts his cheek against Grandpa’s face (skin with “more creases than lines on a map”, smelling of eucalyptus ointment and shaving cream) and hugs him.
- Ravi does not question Grandpa, because he would have to admit he had been following him.
- In the evening Grandpa answers “coolly”: “I had a quiet morning, but I don’t know about Ravi. He just disappeared instead of staying at home to look after me like you told him to.” Ravi looks confused and embarrassed.
- Grandpa gives Ravi a gift. Mother: “But, Papa, Ravi’s birthday was three months ago. Have you forgotten?”
- Grandpa “countered”: he always gives a gift to every child in the house on his own birthday. “Have you forgotten?” Mother flushes and darts “a stricken look” at the calendar, where she had circled the date in red and written ‘Papa’s birthday’. There are gifts for her and Ravi’s father too; he still considers them his ‘babies’.
- Grandpa to Ravi’s father: “My daughter needs some Vitamin-M, I think—for her memory.”
- Ravi’s gift: a thick hardcover book, The Best Detective Stories, with tips on “How to avoid getting fooled when one is trailing a suspect”. Ravi cannot decide whether the twinkle in Grandpa’s eye is “an innocent gleam or a mischievous one”.
3 The Twist: Who Really Needs Vitamin-M?
Irony is when the result is the opposite of what we expect. In this story the mother wants a memory vitamin for her old father, but she is the one who forgets his birthday.
What everyone believes
- Grandpa is forgetful and must be watched
- Ravi is the “detective” watching him
- Mother is the sensible one in charge
What the story shows
- Grandpa remembers his birthday, chess games and his gift custom
- Grandpa stays one step ahead: Ravi ends up following a stranger in Grandpa’s cap
- Mother forgot “Papa’s birthday”
3.1 Did Grandpa know he was being followed?
The story never says so directly, but the clues point to yes:
The cap
He gave away the one thing Ravi was tracking, the bright-yellow cap.
“He just disappeared”
He tells Vidya Ravi left him, turning the tables on Ravi.
The gift
A detective book, with tips on not “getting fooled when one is trailing a suspect”.
The twinkle
Ravi cannot tell if it is innocent or mischievous.
The book says Grandpa “is portrayed as a person with failing memory in the beginning of the story” and asks for two evidences to disprove the statement: (1) he remembers thousands of chess games, like Karpov’s opening move against the computer and Bobby Fischer’s mistake against Spassky; (2) he remembers his own birthday and his custom of giving gifts, which his daughter forgot. His absent-mindedness about medicines and people’s names is real, so do not claim his memory is perfect.
4 Characters
| Character | Traits | Evidence from the story |
|---|---|---|
| Grandpa (Vidya’s father, 75, a former lawyer) | Independent and proud; clever and crafty; playful; generous; sharp mind | Protests at being kept indoors; traps Ravi with his own words; Ravi ends up trailing a stranger in his cap; gives his cap to a stranger on a hot day (“always generous”); gifts to everyone on his birthday; expert at chess |
| Ravi (the grandson) | Caring and responsible; loyal; sensitive; determined; a clumsy “detective” | Tries to keep his promise by secretly following Grandpa, though Grandpa still goes out alone; winces at mother’s tone; hugs Grandpa with affection; chases the bus; but is spotted by a child, the vendors and a salon full of ladies |
| Ravi’s mother (Vidya) | Loving but anxious; over-protective; impatient; herself forgetful | Brings Grandpa home after his fall; forbids him to go out; speaks to him as to a child; forgets his birthday |
| Ravi’s father (Ravi calls his father “Papa”; Vidya also calls Grandpa “Papa”) | Kind; a little puzzled | Usually buys Grandpa the Tamil paper on his way home; “looked confused” at the end |
5 Themes and Message
Care for the elderly
Old people need care, but also respect and freedom.
Dignity and independence
Being protected too much hurts Grandpa’s pride (“keep me a prisoner”).
Memory
Everyone forgets something. Forgetting is not only a problem of old age.
Age bias
People dismiss the old (and the young) because of age. Grandpa proves them wrong.
Family bonds
Ravi and Grandpa share chess, affection and a secret.
Do not judge people by their age. The “forgetful” grandfather remembered what mattered; the busy daughter forgot.
the message of Vitamin-M
6 How the Story Is Written
| Feature | Example from the text |
|---|---|
| Humour (situational comedy) | Ravi hiding behind an elephant-shaped bush; thrown out of a Ladies’ Hairdressing Salon |
| Simile (comparison using “as” or “like”) | “as bald as a table tennis ball” |
| Exaggeration (hyperbole: an overstated image) | skin with “more creases than lines on a map” |
| Suspense | The screech of brakes; the grey hair under the yellow cap; “But where was Grandpa?” |
| Irony | “My daughter needs some Vitamin-M, I think—for her memory.” |
| Lively verbs of movement and sound | crouch, crawl, duck, zigzag, sprint; boomed, thudded, shrieks, whirr, grunted |
| Open ending | “an innocent gleam or a mischievous one” leaves the reader to decide |
7 Words from Vitamin-M
7.1 Glossary (the book’s own meanings where it gives them)
| Word | Meaning | Word | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| frail | weak and delicate | shuddered | shook with fear or horror |
| poky | small and cramped | forbid | order someone not to do something |
| pottering | doing small jobs in a slow, relaxed way | winced | showed an expression of embarrassment |
| bustle | busy activity | jauntily | happily and confidently |
| crouch | bend the body low | ducking | moving your head or body down |
| a volley of | a lot of | deterred | prevented (from doing) |
| confront | face | frantic | very frightened |
| creases | lines | darted | looked at somebody quickly |
| trailing | following | solemnly | seriously |
| furious | very angry | boomed | spoke in a loud, deep voice |
| craftily | cleverly, in a sly way | dilemma | a difficult choice (synonyms: quandary, predicament) |
| attire | clothes | humiliation | a feeling of shame and loss of dignity |
7.2 Movement words and sound words
Movement words
- pottering, twirling, crouch, bustle, crawl, creeping
- ducked, zigzagging, evicted, briskly, sprinting
- jumping, darted, trailing
Sound words
- boomed, thudded, shrieks
- whirr, grunted, snoring
7.3 Words of emotion and expression
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| embarrassed | felt uncomfortable |
| countered | replied to an argument |
| flushed | became red in the face |
| stricken | affected severely by an unpleasant feeling |
| gleam | an expression of emotion (in the eye) |
8 Grammar from Vitamin-M
8.1 Prepositions
“Prepositions are words used to show the relationship of a noun or pronoun to other words in a sentence, often indicating direction, location, time, or manner.”
From the story: walk across to the corner shop; a shadow fall over him; vendors sitting under the tree; position behind a big banyan.
8.2 Two types of questions (interrogative sentences)
| Type | How it starts | Example from the story | Intonation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yes/No type | helping verb (are, have, shall, do) | “Are you playing hide and seek?” · “Have you forgotten?” | rising at the end |
| Wh- type | who, what, where, why, how | “Who are you?” · “What did you both do today?” | falling at the end |
8.3 Direct and indirect (reported) speech
The words in quotes are the exact words of the speaker, so they are direct speech. In indirect or reported speech, somebody else reports these words at some other time and place.
| Direct | Indirect | Direct | Indirect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Present | Past | here | there |
| Past | Past Perfect | today | that day |
| Present Progressive | Past Progressive | tomorrow | the following day |
| Past Progressive | Past Perfect Progressive | now | then |
| I | he/she | we | they |
| you | he/she/they | our | their |
Direct: “Do you have grandparents living with you?” Priya asked Arvind.
Reported: Priya asked Arvind whether he had grandparents living with him.
Direct: “How do you manage your grandparents’ medical needs?” Arvind asked.
Reported: Arvind enquired how she managed her grandparents’ medical needs.
8.4 Intonation in questions (Speaking)
Intonation refers to the pitch of the voice while speaking. In questions, it can show the speaker’s feeling or the answer they expect.
| Kind of question | Example | Intonation |
|---|---|---|
| Wh- and How questions | What is your name? | falling |
| Yes/No questions | Are you feeling okay? | rising |
| Question tag, speaker fairly sure (expects agreement) | This is your notebook, isn’t it? | falling on the tag |
| Question tag, speaker unsure (a real question) | You weren’t in the library yesterday, were you? | rising on the tag |
| Question with choices | “Shall we play chess or watch the cricket match on TV, Grandpa?” | rise-fall |
9 Writing Task Format: The Article
Title at the top · your name and grade below it
Paragraph 1: brief introduction; the main idea, no details
Paragraph 2: details that support the main idea (how the elderly inspire): examples, facts, quotations
Paragraph 3: how they overcame challenges, and their inspiring impact on you
Paragraph 4: conclusion; leave the reader with the most important ideas
The book’s topic: an article for the school magazine on ‘Our Inspiring Elderly’. A full model answer is in the NCERT Solutions.
10 I Cannot Remember My Mother: The Poem

- Poet: Rabindranath Tagore.
- Speaker: a child (“I”) who cannot remember his mother; he recalls her only through a tune, a scent and a gaze.
- Form: three stanzas in free verse: no fixed rhyme scheme, no fixed metre. Each stanza begins with the same line.
- Key idea: he cannot remember her, yet a sound, a smell and a sight bring her back.
Free verse is poetry with no regular rhyme scheme or metre. Its music comes from repetition, rhythm and images instead.
10.1 Stanza by stanza
| Stanza | Exact lines | What it means | Sense | Setting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | “only sometimes in the midst of my play / a tune seems to hover over my playthings, / the tune of some song that she used to / hum while rocking my cradle.” | While he plays, a tune seems to hang over his toys. It is the song his mother hummed as she rocked his cradle. He remembers the tune, not the mother. | auditory (hearing) | indoor |
| 2 | “but when in the early autumn morning / the smell of the shiuli flowers floats in the air / the scent of the morning service in the temple / comes to me as the scent of my mother.” | On early autumn mornings the fragrance of shiuli flowers and of the temple’s morning service feels like his mother’s own scent. | olfactory (smell) | outdoor |
| 3 | “only when from my bedroom window I send / my eyes into the blue of the distant sky, / I feel that the stillness of / my mother’s gaze on my face / has spread all over the sky.” | Looking at the far blue sky from his window, he feels his mother’s calm, steady look has spread across the whole sky. | visual (sight) | indoor (looking out) |

The book tells us shiuli flowers are also known as Parijat, Parijata and Harsingar; they are used in ceremonies, give a sweet fragrance, appear in many Indian legends, and bloom only at night. It also mentions Kurinji or Neelakurinji, a flower that blooms once in twelve years.
10.2 Words from the poem
| Word | Meaning | Word | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| hover | linger or remain near a place | hum | sing a tune with your lips closed |
| cradle | a small bed for a baby | shiuli | a type of flower (coral jasmine) |
| morning service | rituals conducted in a temple | gaze | look steadily for a long time |
11 Poetic Devices
“Refrain is a poetic device defined as a line or a group of lines that is repeated at regular intervals in a poem.”
“Symbolism is a literary device in which a writer uses a tangible object, abstract idea, or phenomenon that represents something beyond the literal meaning. It helps the poet convey deeper meanings and to connect with readers on an emotional level.”
Imagery is language that appeals to our senses (sight, sound, smell, touch, taste), so the reader can picture, hear or smell what the poet describes.
Alliteration is the repetition of the same consonant sound at the beginning of nearby words.
Onomatopoeia is a word that sounds like the thing it describes.
| Device | Exact example | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Refrain | “I cannot remember my mother” (first line of every stanza) | Stresses his loss; each time, a memory follows that contradicts it |
| Alliteration | “my mother”; “the scent of the morning service”; “stillness … spread … sky” | Soft, musical sound |
| Onomatopoeia | “hum” | We hear the lullaby |
| Auditory imagery | “a tune seems to hover over my playthings” | Memory through sound |
| Olfactory imagery | “the smell of the shiuli flowers floats in the air” | Memory through smell |
| Visual imagery | “I send / my eyes into the blue of the distant sky” | Memory through sight |
| Personification-like image | a tune that can “hover”; a gaze that has “spread all over the sky” | Makes the mother’s presence feel alive |
11.1 The symbols
The tune
Her lullaby, her love when he was a baby.
Shiuli flowers and the temple’s morning service
Her fragrance, purity and gentle devotion.
The sky
Her gaze: calm, vast and always watching over him.
12 Central Idea, Tone and Title
A mother is never truly gone: even when a child cannot remember her, her love lives on in sounds, scents and sights around him.
the central idea of the poem
- Tone: nostalgic, wistful and tender, ending in calm (serenity). He does not cry out in grief; he quietly feels her near.
- Title: “I Cannot Remember My Mother” sets a mood of loss and longing. The poem then shows the opposite: he remembers her through his senses. This contrast makes the poem moving.
- Why it is enjoyable without rhyme: the refrain, the gentle rhythm of the lines and the rich sensory images give it music.
- Role of nature: shiuli flowers, the autumn morning and the blue sky are what bring her back. The mother seems to become part of nature.
13 Sensory Words and the Diary Entry
13.1 Sensory words
| Visual (sight) | Auditory (hearing) | Olfactory (smell) | Tactile (touch) |
|---|---|---|---|
| glowing, gigantic, minuscule, gloomy, vibrant, crimson | hiss, rustle, sizzle, deafening, squeaky, ear-splitting | aroma, stale, scent, pungent, stinky, fragrant | sticky, rough, chilled, fluffy, smooth, slimy, hairy |
The unit practises these words with a passage by Sarojini Naidu about a March morning. The box words that fill its blanks are scarlet, scents, sweetness, shrill, perfumes, essence and flaming (sizzle and smooth are the two extra words).
13.2 Diary entry format
Begin with day, date and time · use only the first person (I, my) · capture sensory details · express emotions · focus on significant moments · conclude with reflection
The book notes that Anne Frank and Zlata Filipovic treated their diaries as friends and began with ‘Dear diary’. Samuel Pepys treated his diary as a record of facts, thoughts and feelings, so he did not.
13.3 Speaking and discussion tasks
- Reflect and Respond I (before the story): from your experience with an elderly person, complete a graphic organiser on Caring for the Elderly with four questions: Why should we care for the elderly? What are the problems faced by the elderly? What could be the possible reasons for the problems faced? How can we take care of the elderly? Then discuss it in class.
- Speaking Activity II: make a presentation about a brief personal experience of taking care of an older person. The book’s prompts: the background (“The person I had the privilege of taking care of was…”); what you learned about yourself (“Caring for someone taught me valuable lessons about myself, including…”); and what you learned about the older person (“Understanding the needs and preferences of the older person, I learned that…”, “Their challenges offered insights into the difficulties of aging, such as…”).
- Poem Speaking Activity I: speak about a memorable object, song or place: introduce it, describe it with sensory details, narrate the memory, explain its impact on your life and summarise why it is meaningful.
The unit also offers two texts to read and enjoy: “The Lost Child” by Mulk Raj Anand (a child lost at a fair who wants only his parents) and “I Remember, I Remember” by Thomas Hood (a poem of childhood memories). They support the unit’s themes of family and memory. The two listening tasks (a podcast on meditation, and four speakers recalling childhood memories) are answered in the NCERT Solutions.
14 Recap
- Vitamin-M: Asha Nehemiah; one day in three parts: home, the chase, the twist.
- Grandpa, 75, a former lawyer, was brought to the city after a fall; he hates the “poky little flat” and longs for his quiet brick house.
- He tricks Ravi into letting him out; Ravi follows him to the park, tea stall, barber shop and bus.
- The yellow cap on the bus belongs to a stranger; Grandpa gave it away and went home.
- The twist: Vidya forgot her father’s birthday, so she is the one who “needs some Vitamin-M”.
- Grandpa is independent, crafty, generous and sharp; Ravi is caring, loyal and a clumsy detective; Vidya is loving, anxious and over-protective.
- Grammar: prepositions; Yes/No vs Wh- questions; reporting questions with if/whether or the wh- word; intonation rules.
- Poem: Tagore; three stanzas, free verse; refrain “I cannot remember my mother”.
- Stanza 1 sound (the hummed tune), stanza 2 smell (shiuli, temple), stanza 3 sight (the sky and her gaze).
- Symbols: tune = her love, shiuli = her scent and purity, sky = her ever-present gaze; tone nostalgic and serene.
- Can I give two evidences that Grandpa’s memory is not failing?
- Can I explain the irony of the title in three lines?
- Can I quote the refrain and one image from each stanza exactly?
- Can I report a Yes/No question and a Wh- question correctly?