All the questions the NCERT textbook Exploration, Chapter 8, “Journey Inside the Atom,” asks inside the chapter (Think It Over, Think as a Scientist, all eighteen Pause and Ponder questions and the other in-text questions), then all fifteen questions under its “Revise, Reflect, Refine” heading exactly as printed, and finally The Journey Beyond and The Quest Continues, with a full model answer under each. Write your own answer first, then compare.
1 Think It Over
Q. (a) Are atoms the smallest indivisible particles? (b) Why do electrons not fall into the nucleus even though they are attracted to protons in it? (c) Why did scientists keep modifying atomic models?
Answer: (a) No. Atoms are made of still smaller subatomic particles: electrons, protons and neutrons. The discovery of radioactivity and of the electron showed that atoms are not indivisible.
(b) According to Bohr’s model, electrons move only in certain fixed shells (stationary states) of definite energy, and an electron does not lose energy while it stays in such a shell, so it does not spiral into the nucleus.
(c) Each model explained the evidence known at its time, but new experiments brought results it could not explain (for example the gold foil experiment for Thomson’s model and the stability of atoms for Rutherford’s model), so the model was changed and improved.
2 Pause and Ponder 1, 2 and 3: Thomson’s Model
Q. 1. Suppose you made up your own ‘atom’, as Thomson described, using clay for the positive charge and small beads for the electrons spread through it. What will happen if: (i) the positive charge on the clay is lesser than the total negative charge of the beads? (ii) by mistake, the clay itself carries a bit of negative charge? Would your model still represent a neutral atom? 2. Could an orange or a lemon, which also contain seeds inside soft pulp, be a good comparison? In what ways does it match Thomson’s idea and where does it fall short? 3. Why did Thomson conclude that electrons are present in all atoms?
Answer: 1. (i) The model would carry an overall negative charge, so it would represent a negatively charged particle, not a neutral atom. (ii) No. The total positive charge would then be less than the total negative charge of the beads, so the model would not be neutral.
2. It matches Thomson’s idea in that small particles (seeds, like electrons) are embedded in a larger soft mass (pulp, like the positive sphere). It falls short because orange or lemon seeds carry no electric charge, so the fruit cannot show negative electrons balancing a positive sphere; the seeds are also bunched in segments near the centre rather than spread evenly through the pulp.
3. The nature of the cathode rays was the same whatever material the cathode was made of and whatever gas filled the tube. So the negatively charged particles (electrons) had to be a basic part of every atom, present in every element.
3 Ready to Go Beyond: Atoms in a Sheet of Paper
Q. Can you calculate how many atoms would be needed to make a sheet of paper that is 0.1 mm thick, like the one in your textbook?
Answer: The diameter of one atom is about 10−10 m and the sheet is 0.1 mm = 10−4 m thick. Number of atoms across the thickness ≈ 10−4 m ÷ 10−10 m = 106, that is, about one million atoms stacked together.
4 Think as a Scientist: A Thicker Gold Foil
Q. Observe Fig. 8.4 of the gold foil experiment. Predict the observations you would expect if the gold foil in the experiment were made thicker. Also, draw a simple diagram to show the observations you expect.
Answer: A thicker foil has many more layers of gold atoms, so each alpha particle has a greater chance of passing close to a nucleus. So fewer particles would pass straight through undeflected, more would be deflected, more would be deflected through large angles or bounced back, and some might be stopped inside the foil. The diagram shows a thick foil with only a few straight arrows passing through and many arrows bending away or turning back, compared with the thin foil, where most arrows go straight through.
5 Pause and Ponder 4, 5 and 6: The Gold Foil Experiment
Q. 4. What do you think would happen if α-particles were replaced with negatively charged particles in Rutherford’s gold foil experiment? 5. Rutherford found that a few α-particles bounced back sharply. How does this single surprising result completely rule out Thomson’s ‘plum pudding model’ of the atom? 6. If you could ask Rutherford one question about his work, what would it be?
Answer: 4. Negatively charged particles would be attracted, not repelled, by the positive nucleus. Instead of bouncing back, those passing close to a nucleus would be pulled towards it and bent around it, while most would still pass through the mostly empty atom.
5. In Thomson’s model the positive charge is spread thinly through the whole atom, so it could only deflect a fast, heavy α-particle slightly; it could never turn it back. A particle bouncing back needs a very strong repulsion from a tiny region holding a large positive charge and most of the mass, which is a nucleus. So even one bounce-back is enough to rule out the plum pudding model.
6. Open answer, for example: “How did you know that the rare large deflections were caused by a single close encounter with a nucleus and not by many small deflections added together?” or “Why did you choose gold for the foil?”
6 Pause and Ponder 7: Assertion and Reason
Q. Assertion (A): Rutherford concluded that most of the mass of an atom is concentrated in a small region at the centre called the nucleus. Reason (R): According to Thomson’s model, electrons are embedded in a uniformly distributed positive charge sphere. Choose: (i) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A. (ii) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A. (iii) A is true, but R is false. (iv) A is false, but R is true.
Answer: (ii). Both statements are true, but R only describes Thomson’s model; Rutherford’s conclusion came from the results of the gold foil experiment (a few α-particles deflected through large angles or bouncing back), so R does not explain A.
7 Threads of Curiosity: Shell Names and Protons in the Nucleus
Q. Why are Bohr’s shells called K, L, M, N… and not, A, B, C, D?
Answer: The naming came from early X-ray experiments by the physicist Charles Barkla, who called the first observed X-ray line K. He did not start from A, to leave room for a possible series earlier than the K series (none was ever found). Bohr adopted the same notation for atomic shells.
Q. You may wonder that since all the protons with like charges are squished together in a nucleus why do they not push each other away?
Answer: Every proton repels every other proton because they all carry positive charge. Neutrons, being neutral, reduce this repulsion by coming in between the protons and increasing the distance between them, and they also strengthen the nuclear force that binds all the particles together. That is why heavier atoms need many more neutrons to keep the nucleus tightly bound.
8 What If an Atom Had No Empty Space?
Q. What if an atom had no empty space? How would this have affected the size of various objects?
Answer: Almost all the volume of an atom is empty space around a nucleus that is about 105 (one lakh) times smaller than the atom. If there were no empty space, all the matter would be packed as densely as a nucleus, so every object would shrink enormously while keeping the same mass: a book would shrink to a speck only about a micrometre across, far too small to see, and even a large building would shrink to roughly the size of a grain of sand. Everything would be extremely dense. (These sizes are rough estimates, not from the book.)
9 Pause and Ponder 8 and 9: Symbols of Elements
Q. 8. Imagine you are a scientist who has discovered a new element. Name this element after yourself and justify that the symbol you have chosen follows the IUPAC rules. 9. What problems could arise if every scientist used different symbols for the same element?
Answer: 8. Example: an element named “Ravium” after Ravi could be given the symbol Rv: it uses the first letter of the name as a capital letter and one more letter of the name as a small letter, and it is not already used by any other element. (A form like RV or rv would break the rule: the first letter must be a capital and any second letter must be small.)
9. Scientists in different countries could not understand each other’s results; the same symbol might stand for different elements, causing mistakes in formulas, calculations, medicines and industry. A common, internationally agreed set of symbols lets everyone communicate clearly regardless of language.
10 The Lithium Atom (Fig. 8.10)
Q. Can you now say that elements with different atomic numbers are distinct from each other, and the atomic number uniquely identifies an element? Observe Fig. 8.10. How many neutrons and protons are present in a lithium atom, and what is its atomic number?
Answer: Yes. The atomic number is the number of protons, and every element has its own atomic number, so the atomic number identifies an element uniquely. A lithium atom has 3 protons and 4 neutrons (mass number 7), and its atomic number is 3.
11 Pause and Ponder 10 to 13: Counting Particles
Q. 10. An atom with an atomic number of 26 has 56 nucleons. Find out its number of electrons, protons and neutrons. 11. The nucleus of an atom contains 20 protons. If its mass number is 41, find the number of neutrons in it. 12. An atom has 18 neutrons and an atomic number of 17. What is its mass number? 13. An atom 23A has 11 electrons. Find the number of neutrons in it.
Answer: 10. Protons = electrons = 26; neutrons = 56 – 26 = 30.
11. Neutrons = 41 – 20 = 21.
12. Mass number = 17 + 18 = 35.
13. Protons = electrons = 11; neutrons = 23 – 11 = 12.
12 Electrons of Helium
Q. Helium contains two protons in its nucleus and two electrons. In which way will the two electrons be arranged in its atomic shell?
Answer: Both electrons go into the K-shell (n = 1), which can hold a maximum of 2 × 12 = 2 electrons. So helium’s electronic configuration is 2, and its only shell is complete.
13 Pause and Ponder 14, 15 and 16: Electron Distribution
Q. 14. Identify the number of electrons in the outermost shell of the following elements: (i) 126C (ii) 199F (iii) 2814Si. 15. Write the electronic configuration of the elements having atomic numbers 12, 16 and 18. 16. Solve this riddle: I am an atom with a mass number of 23 and 11 protons. I am a soft metal and react vigorously with water. Who am I and how many neutrons do I have?
Answer: 14. (i) Carbon, 2, 4: 4 electrons. (ii) Fluorine, 2, 7: 7 electrons. (iii) Silicon, 2, 8, 4: 4 electrons.
15. Atomic number 12 (magnesium): 2, 8, 2. Atomic number 16 (sulfur): 2, 8, 6. Atomic number 18 (argon): 2, 8, 8.
16. An atom with 11 protons is sodium (Na); it has 23 – 11 = 12 neutrons. A riddle of your own could be: “I have 17 protons and 18 neutrons, I am a gas used to disinfect water. Who am I?” (chlorine-35).
14 Combining Capacity and Valency
Q. In NH3 (ammonia) and MgCl2 (magnesium chloride), what will be the combining capacities of nitrogen and magnesium respectively? Can you predict what happens to the atoms that already have eight electrons in their outermost shell? Will they still try to lose or gain electrons? Examine Table 8.4. Add one more column to it, and write down the common valency of each element.
Answer: Nitrogen combines with three hydrogen atoms, so its combining capacity is 3; magnesium combines with two chlorine atoms, so its combining capacity is 2.
Atoms that already have eight electrons in the outermost shell (or two, for helium) are stable and largely unreactive, so they do not try to lose or gain electrons; their valency is taken as 0.
Common valencies for Table 8.4: H 1, He 0, Li 1, Be 2, B 3, C 4, N 3, O 2, F 1, Ne 0, Na 1, Mg 2, Al 3, Si 4, P 3, S 2, Cl 1, Ar 0.
15 Electrons in the Isotopes of Hydrogen
Q. Protium, deuterium and tritium all contain one proton each, whereas deuterium contains one neutron and tritium contains two neutrons. Can you guess how many electrons each of these isotopes have?
Answer: Each has one electron, because each has one proton and a neutral atom has equal numbers of protons and electrons. Neutrons do not change the number of electrons.
16 Pause and Ponder 17 and 18: Isotopes and Average Atomic Mass
Q. 17. Two different atoms have 11 protons each, but one has 12 neutrons, and the other has 13 neutrons. How do their atomic numbers and mass numbers compare? Are they the same element or different elements? 18. If a bromine atom is available in the form of, say two isotopes, 7935Br (49.7%) and 8135Br (50.3%), calculate the average atomic mass of the bromine atom.
Answer: 17. Both have atomic number 11; their mass numbers are 11 + 12 = 23 and 11 + 13 = 24. Same atomic number, different mass numbers, so they are the same element (sodium): they are isotopes.
18. Average atomic mass = 79 × (49.7/100) + 81 × (50.3/100) = 39.263 + 40.743 = 80.006 u, about 80 u.
17 Correct and incorrect statements: the gold foil experiment
Q. Choose the correct options and explain the reason for the correct and incorrect options in the context of Ernest Rutherford’s gold foil experiment:
(i) The experiment clearly showed the existence of neutrons in the nucleus.
(ii) The results disproved the plum pudding model and led to the idea of a nucleus at the centre of the atom.
(iii) The large deflection of a few alpha particles indicated that most of the mass of the atom and positive charge are packed into a tiny centre.
(iv) The way alpha particles were deflected showed that electrons move around the nucleus.
Answer: Statements (ii) and (iii) are correct; (i) and (iv) are incorrect.
(i) Incorrect. The gold foil experiment revealed the nucleus and showed that it concentrates the atom’s mass and positive charge, but it said nothing about neutrons. The neutron was discovered separately by James Chadwick, twenty-one years later in 1932, using a different experiment altogether.
(ii) Correct. Thomson’s plum pudding model, with positive charge spread evenly through the atom, predicted that alpha particles should barely deflect. The sharp deflections and rare back-scattering actually observed could not be explained by a spread-out charge, so the model was disproved and replaced by Rutherford’s nuclear model.
(iii) Correct. Only a very small, dense, heavily charged region could repel a few fast alpha particles through large angles while leaving most particles undisturbed; this is exactly why Rutherford concluded that the atom’s mass and positive charge are concentrated in a tiny central nucleus.
(iv) Incorrect. The deflection pattern told Rutherford about the size, mass and charge of the nucleus. It did not, by itself, show how electrons move. Rutherford did include electrons revolving around the nucleus in his planetary model, but that was part of his proposal, not something the scattering pattern directly showed; it was Bohr who later described how electrons move, in fixed shells.
18 Correct and incorrect statements: Bohr’s atomic model
Q. Which of the following statements are correct or incorrect according to the Bohr’s atomic model? Give a reason for each statement.
(i) Electrons lose energy while moving in fixed orbits and slowly fall into the nucleus.
(ii) Electrons can exist anywhere around the nucleus with no fixed energy.
(iii) Electrons revolve around the nucleus in orbits of fixed energy without losing energy.
(iv) Electrons can be found between energy levels as they move around the nucleus.
Answer:
(i) Incorrect. This is exactly what Bohr’s model rules out: an electron in one of the allowed, fixed orbits does not lose energy at all, which is precisely why atoms are stable and do not collapse.
(ii) Incorrect. Bohr proposed that electrons are confined to certain fixed, quantised circular paths, each with a definite energy, not free to exist anywhere around the nucleus with any energy.
(iii) Correct. This is the central postulate of Bohr’s model: electrons revolve only in fixed orbits (also called shells or stationary states) of definite energy, and they do not lose energy while they stay in one such orbit.
(iv) Incorrect. In Bohr’s model electrons occupy only the allowed shells; they cannot exist in the space between two energy levels, and moving between shells happens as a sudden jump, not a gradual drift through the gap.
19 The composition of atomic species X, Y and Z
Q. The composition of the nuclei of three atomic species X, Y, and Z are given as follows.
| X | Y | Z | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of protons | 18 | 17 | 17 |
| Number of neutrons | 19 | 18 | 20 |
Explain the relation between the following: (i) Y and Z (ii) Z and X
Answer:
(i) Y and Z are isotopes. Both have 17 protons, so both are atoms of the same element (chlorine), but Y has 18 neutrons (mass number 17 + 18 = 35) while Z has 20 neutrons (mass number 17 + 20 = 37). Same atomic number, different mass number is exactly the definition of isotopes.
(ii) Z and X are isobars. Z’s mass number is 17 + 20 = 37, and X’s mass number is 18 + 19 = 37, so the two share the same mass number, while their atomic numbers differ (17 for Z, 18 for X). Same mass number, different atomic number is exactly the definition of isobars.
20 Rutherford’s conclusion about the atom’s positive part
Q. What conclusion did Rutherford draw about the position and characteristics of the atom’s positively charged part based on the few alpha particles that bounced back or were deflected at large angles in the gold foil experiment?
Answer: Rutherford concluded that the positively charged part of the atom is not spread throughout its volume but is concentrated in an extremely small region at the centre, which he named the nucleus. Since only a very small fraction of the alpha particles were deflected sharply or bounced back, this central region had to be tiny compared to the size of the whole atom, and since it could repel and even reverse a fast, heavy alpha particle, it also had to carry most of the atom’s mass along with all of its positive charge. Everywhere else inside the atom, he concluded, is essentially empty space.
21 Chronological order of atomic models
Q. Explain and arrange the following statements in the correct chronological order to show how atomic models have evolved over time.
(i) Bohr’s model proposed that electrons move in fixed orbits around the nucleus, each with a definite energy.
(ii) Thomson’s model depicted the atom as a ‘plum pudding’ with electrons embedded in a sphere of positive charge.
(iii) Rutherford’s model proposed that atoms have a dense central nucleus.
(iv) Dalton’s model described atoms as indivisible particles.
Answer: The correct chronological order is (iv), (ii), (iii), (i).
(iv) Dalton, 1808: the first scientific atomic model, describing atoms as solid, indivisible particles with no internal structure.
(ii) Thomson (electron discovered in 1897): after discovering the electron, Thomson proposed a model to a sphere of positive charge with electrons embedded in it, since an atom needed both charges to be neutral overall.
(iii) Rutherford, 1911: the gold foil experiment showed that positive charge and mass are concentrated in a tiny central nucleus, replacing Thomson’s spread-out positive sphere.
(i) Bohr, 1913: to fix Rutherford’s stability problem, Bohr proposed that electrons move only in fixed orbits of definite energy around this nucleus.
22 Why electrons do not fly away from the nucleus
Q. Electrons move around the nucleus in orbits. Why do they not fly away from the atom? Explain what keeps them attracted to the nucleus.
Answer: An electron carries a negative charge and the nucleus carries a positive charge, and unlike charges attract each other. This electrostatic force of attraction between the negatively charged electrons and the positively charged nucleus acts as the centre-seeking (centripetal) force that keeps the electrons moving in orbit around the nucleus, in much the same way that the Sun’s gravitational pull keeps the planets from flying off into space. As long as this attraction exists, the electrons stay bound to the atom instead of flying away.
23 Assertion and Reason: subatomic particles and atomic structure
Q. Assertion (A): The discovery of subatomic particles helped in understanding the atomic structure.
Reason (R): The number of electrons is equal to the number of protons in an atom.
Choose the correct option:
(i) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
(ii) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(iii) A is true, but R is false.
(iv) A is false, but R is true.
Answer: (ii) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A. The assertion is true: discovering the electron, proton and neutron, and how they are arranged, is exactly what let scientists build atomic models and understand atomic structure. The reason is also true: in a neutral atom the number of electrons does equal the number of protons. But this particular fact about a neutral atom’s charge balance is not what explains why discovering subatomic particles advanced the understanding of atomic structure in general, so R does not correctly explain A.
24 Protons, neutrons and electrons of magnesium
Q. Magnesium is essential for many biological processes, including muscle contraction. For an atom of magnesium with a mass number of 24 and atomic number 12, determine the number of (i) protons, (ii) neutrons, and (iii) electrons, and also illustrate the arrangement of electrons in a magnesium atom.
Answer:
(i) Protons = atomic number = 12.
(ii) Neutrons = mass number − atomic number = 24 − 12 = 12.
(iii) Electrons = number of protons (atom is neutral) = 12.
Arrangement of electrons (shells filled K, then L, then M): K shell (max 2) takes 2 electrons; L shell (max 8) takes the next 8, using up 10 of the 12 electrons; the remaining 12 − 10 = 2 electrons go into the M shell. So magnesium’s electronic configuration is 2, 8, 2, with 2 electrons in its outermost (valence) shell.
25 Reading the electron-shell diagrams of Fig. 8.17
Q. Find the following information for the elements shown in Fig. 8.17: (i) Name of the element (ii) Symbol (iii) Total number of electrons (iv) Number of valence electrons (v) Valency of the element (vi) Number of protons (vii) Atomic number.
Answer: Counting the electron dots shown in each shell diagram of Fig. 8.17 gives:
| Diagram | Name | Symbol | Total electrons | Valence electrons | Valency | Protons | Atomic number |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (a) | Lithium | Li | 3 | 1 | 1 | 3 | 3 |
| (b) | Nitrogen | N | 7 | 5 | 3 | 7 | 7 |
| (c) | Aluminium | Al | 13 | 3 | 3 | 13 | 13 |
| (d) | Fluorine | F | 9 | 7 | 1 | 9 | 9 |
(a) Lithium’s configuration is 2, 1: one valence electron, which it loses, giving valency 1. (b) Nitrogen’s configuration is 2, 5: five valence electrons, three short of an octet, which it gains, giving valency 3. (c) Aluminium’s configuration is 2, 8, 3: three valence electrons, which it loses, giving valency 3. (d) Fluorine’s configuration is 2, 7: seven valence electrons, one short of an octet, which it gains, giving valency 1.
26 Why Bohr succeeded where Rutherford’s model failed
Q. Both Rutherford’s and Bohr’s models have electrons orbiting the nucleus. Why did Rutherford’s model fail to explain atomic stability, while Bohr’s model succeeded?
Answer: In Rutherford’s model, an electron orbiting the nucleus is constantly changing direction, so it is constantly accelerating, and the laws of electromagnetism say that an accelerating charge must continuously radiate away energy. An electron losing energy this way would spiral inward and eventually fall into the nucleus, so Rutherford’s model predicts that atoms should collapse, which plainly does not happen.
Bohr succeeded by adding a new rule on top of Rutherford’s picture: electrons move only in certain special, fixed orbits (stationary states), each with a definite energy, and an electron loses no energy at all as long as it stays in one such orbit. Energy is exchanged only when an electron jumps between one fixed orbit and another, and only in a fixed amount. This extra rule, which experiments went on to confirm, is exactly what explains why real atoms are stable.
27 Neutrons in an atom of mass number 70
Q. An atom 70X has 31 electrons. How many neutrons are there in its nucleus?
Answer: Since the atom is neutral, its number of protons equals its number of electrons, so it has 31 protons, meaning its atomic number is 31. Its mass number is given as 70. Number of neutrons = mass number − atomic number = 70 − 31 = 39.
28 Neutrons and electrons in an atom of 79 protons
Q. An atom has 79 protons and a mass number of 197. Calculate (i) the number of neutrons, and (ii) the number of electrons.
Answer:
(i) Neutrons = mass number − protons = 197 − 79 = 118.
(ii) Electrons = number of protons (neutral atom) = 79.
29 Completing the atomic data table
Q. Complete Table 8.5:
| Atomic number | Mass number | Number of neutrons | Number of protons | Number of electrons | Name of the element |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | ? | 6 | ? | ? | ? |
| ? | 14 | ? | ? | 7 | Nitrogen |
| ? | 24 | ? | 12 | ? | ? |
| 15 | ? | 16 | ? | ? | ? |
| ? | 1 | 0 | ? | ? | ? |
Answer: The completed table is:
| Atomic number | Mass number | Number of neutrons | Number of protons | Number of electrons | Name of the element |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 11 | 6 | 5 | 5 | Boron |
| 7 | 14 | 7 | 7 | 7 | Nitrogen |
| 12 | 24 | 12 | 12 | 12 | Magnesium |
| 15 | 31 | 16 | 15 | 15 | Phosphorus |
| 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | Hydrogen |
Each row uses atomic number = protons = electrons (for a neutral atom) and mass number = protons + neutrons, filling whichever two of these three quantities were missing.
30 Element X: mass number 35, 18 neutrons
Q. Aman was discussing the structure of atom with his classmates. During the discussion, he learnt that an element X has a mass number of 35 and contains 18 neutrons. Based on this information, answer the following questions:
(i) How many electrons and protons does element X have?
(ii) What is its atomic number?
(iii) Identify the element X.
(iv) Write its electronic configuration.
(v) How many valence electrons does it have?
(vi) What will be the mass number if two neutrons are added to its nucleus?
(vii) What will be the relation of X with the new atom?
Answer:
(i) Protons = mass number − neutrons = 35 − 18 = 17; electrons = protons (neutral atom) = 17.
(ii) Atomic number = number of protons = 17.
(iii) Atomic number 17 is chlorine (Cl).
(iv) With 17 electrons, filling K, L, M in order: 2, 8, 7.
(v) Valence electrons (in the outermost, M shell) = 7.
(vi) New mass number = 35 + 2 = 37.
(vii) The new atom still has 17 protons (same element, chlorine) but a different mass number (37 instead of 35), so X and the new atom are isotopes of each other.
31 A thought experiment: heavier hypothetical electrons
Q. In an atom, there are 12 protons and 12 neutrons in the nucleus. Now, imagine that all the electrons are replaced with some hypothetical particles that have the same charge as electrons but are 500 times heavier. What effect will this replacement have on the atom’s: (i) Atomic number (ii) Atomic mass (iii) Mass number (iv) Overall charge?
Answer:
(i) Atomic number: no change. The atomic number counts only the protons in the nucleus, which are untouched by this replacement, so it stays 12.
(ii) Atomic mass: it would increase. An ordinary electron’s mass is normally so small (about 1/1836 of a proton’s mass) that it is ignored when calculating atomic mass. A particle 500 times heavier than an electron is no longer negligible, so the 12 such particles would now add a noticeable amount of mass that the usual calculation does not otherwise include.
(iii) Mass number: no change. The mass number, by definition, counts only protons and neutrons (nucleons) in the nucleus; it never included electrons in the first place, so replacing the electrons, however heavy, does not change this count, which stays 12 + 12 = 24.
(iv) Overall charge: no change. The question states the hypothetical particles carry the same charge as electrons, so the total negative charge still exactly balances the 12 positive protons, and the atom remains electrically neutral, exactly as before.
32 The Journey Beyond
Q. Create an ‘Atomic Prediction Board’ game; prepare a report on how the properties of atoms impact us in healthcare, energy, agriculture and technology; create a role-play or story about the ‘Journey Inside the Atom’; create animations or simulations of atomic models; watch a film or documentary on the structure of the atom and write a report; draw a bar graph showing the number of electrons in each energy level for any three elements.
Answer: These are projects. Pointers: for the game, give clues such as “11 protons, 12 neutrons” and ask for the element, mass number and valency; for the report, use the chapter’s isotope uses (uranium-235 as nuclear fuel, cobalt-60 for cancer treatment, iodine-131 for goitre and thyroid cancer, carbon-14 for dating fossils) and neutron-scattering research at BARC; the role-play can follow the order Kanada and Democritus, Dalton, Thomson, Rutherford, Bohr and Chadwick. Sample bar graph data: sodium K 2, L 8, M 1; chlorine K 2, L 8, M 7; argon K 2, L 8, M 8.
33 The Quest Continues
Q. Is it possible to completely understand everything that happens inside an atom?
Answer: An open question for discussion. Every model so far has been improved by a later one: Bohr’s fixed orbits have given way to the quantum mechanical model, in which we can only predict the regions where electrons are most likely to be, not their exact paths. Science keeps discovering new details, so our understanding keeps growing, but it may never be final.