All questions of NIOS Secondary English (202), Lesson 14 “Stealing and Atonement” (M.K. Gandhi): Intext Questions, Let us learn new words, Let us talk, Let us do, the grammar exercises, the message-writing exercise, the Terminal Questions and every question of Worksheet 14. The questions are in the book’s own words. Answers are in simple English in the marking-scheme style (2-mark answers in 20-30 words). A Hindi help line (हिंदी में) follows some answers; it is for understanding only, do not write it in the exam. The full text is free in the official NIOS book at nios.ac.in (मूल पाठ nios.ac.in पर निःशुल्क उपलब्ध है).
1 Intext Questions and activities
Intext Questions 14.1 (Part 1)
1. Tick the correct answer.
a. Who did Gandhiji try to imitate as a child?
(i) his father (ii) his friend (iii) his servant (iv) his uncle
b. From where did Gandhiji first get money to smoke Indian cigarettes?
(i) he earned it (ii) from his father (iii) he stole it (iv) from his friend
c. Why did he and his friend go to Ramji Mandir?
(i) to pray (ii) to make an offering (iii) to ask for cigarettes (iv) to calm themselves
Answer: a. (iv) his uncle b. (iii) he stole it c. (iv) to calm themselves
हिंदी में: उन्होंने चाचा की नकल की, नौकर के पैसे चुराए और मन शांत करने रामजी मंदिर गए।
Q. Why did their courage fail them when they wanted to swallow the dhatura seeds?
Answer: Their courage failed because they feared they might not die at once, and they were not sure that killing themselves would solve their problem.
हिंदी में: उन्हें डर लगा कि तुरंत मौत न हुई तो क्या होगा, और यह भी पक्का नहीं था कि मरने से समस्या हल होगी।
Q. When did Gandhiji give up the idea of smoking?
Answer: Gandhiji and his relative gave up smoking stubs (and stealing the servant’s coins for it) after they had given up the idea of suicide.
हिंदी में: आत्महत्या का विचार छोड़ने के बाद उन्होंने सिगरेट के टुकड़े पीना और उसके लिए नौकर के पैसे चुराना भी छोड़ दिया।
Q. How did Gandhiji regard the habit of smoking when he grew up?
Answer: When he grew up, he regarded smoking as barbarous, dirty and harmful. He never wished to smoke and felt choked among smokers.
हिंदी में: बड़े होकर वे धूम्रपान को जंगली, गंदी और हानिकारक आदत मानते थे।
Let us learn new words 14.1
a. Write the opposites of the following words from the text using the prefixes ‘un-‘ or ‘in’: auspicious, available, dependence, decided, effective
Answer: inauspicious, unavailable, independence, undecided, ineffective
b. Make sentences with the new words you made by using prefixes.
Model sentences:
- Some people think it is inauspicious to start a journey on that day.
- The doctor was unavailable on Sunday.
- India won independence in 1947.
- I am still undecided about which course to join.
- The old medicine proved ineffective.
हिंदी में: un- या in- लगाने से शब्द का उल्टा अर्थ बनता है।
Intext Questions 14.2 (Part 2)
1. How much was Gandhiji’s brother’s debt?
Answer: His brother had run into a debt of about twenty-five rupees.
2. Why did Gandhiji take out a bit of gold from the armlet?
Answer: He took the bit of gold so that he could use it to clear his brother’s debt.
3. What do you think Gandhiji did with the bit of gold?
Answer: He probably sold the gold and paid off his brother’s debt with the money, or gave the gold itself to end the debt. The text says only that “the debt cleared”.
4. Why did Gandhiji decide to confess to his father?
Answer: He felt disturbed and guilty after the theft. He knew it was wrong, and he felt his mind could be truly clean only if he confessed.
हिंदी में: कर्ज़ लगभग पच्चीस रुपये था; सोना कर्ज़ चुकाने के लिए लिया गया; अपराध-बोध से मुक्ति के लिए उन्होंने पिता से स्वीकार करने का निश्चय किया।
The book’s explanation of Part 2 says Gandhiji “decided to confess to his brother”. The text says “I also made up my mind to confess it to my father”, and Part 3 shows him handing the note to his father. Write “father”.
हिंदी में: स्वीकारोक्ति पिता से की गई थी, भाई से नहीं।
Q. Have you ever done something wrong to help someone close to you? How did you feel afterwards? Write about it in approximately 100 words.
Model answer: Last year my younger brother broke our neighbour’s window with his cricket ball. He was scared, so I told the neighbour that a boy from another street had done it. I wanted to save my brother from a scolding. But that night I could not sleep. The neighbour had always been kind to us, and I had lied to him. The lie felt heavier than the broken glass. The next morning I took my brother to the neighbour, and we told him the truth. We said sorry and offered our pocket money for the glass. He forgave us. I learnt that helping someone with a lie is not real help.
हिंदी में: अपना अनुभव ईमानदारी से लिखें: गलत काम, उस समय की भावना और उससे मिली सीख।
Intext Questions 14.3 (Part 3)
1. How did Gandhiji’s father react on reading his letter of confession?
Answer: Tears trickled down his cheeks. He closed his eyes in thought, tore up the note and lay down again. He forgave his son peacefully, without a single angry word.
2. Who taught Gandhiji the lesson on ‘Ahimsa’?
Answer: His father taught him the lesson on Ahimsa through his loving, peaceful forgiveness.
3. ‘Ahimsa’ in the story means ____
Answer: to avoid causing pain or being violent, and to bring about change in a peaceful and loving manner.
4. What according to Gandhiji is the purest type of repentance?
Answer: A clean confession combined with a promise never to commit the sin again is the purest type of repentance. (The book’s key also adds asking for adequate punishment, as Gandhiji did in his letter.)
हिंदी में: पिता रोए और माफ़ कर दिया; उन्हीं से अहिंसा की सीख मिली; सच्ची स्वीकारोक्ति और दोबारा न करने का वचन सबसे शुद्ध पश्चाताप है।
Let us talk 14.1 (Ratnakar and Narada)
Read the Ratnakar story aloud to two friends or relatives, discuss, and note the main points.
1. Do you think it is easy to accept that what one is doing is wrong, and then change?
Model points: It is not easy. Pride, fear of shame and habit stop us. But it is possible, as Ratnakar and young Gandhiji show: once a person honestly sees the harm, repents and gets support from someone like Narada or a loving father, change becomes possible.
2. Do you know of any person who changed for the better, or gave up a bad habit (smoking, drinking, drugs, stealing, etc.)? How do you think he/she could do it?
Model points: My uncle gave up smoking after a health check-up. He was helped by a firm decision, by his doctor’s advice, by keeping away from smoking friends, and by the family’s encouragement.
हिंदी में: गलती मानकर बदलना कठिन है, पर दृढ़ निश्चय और अपनों के साथ से संभव है।
Let us do 14.1 (the broken glass)
Suppose your father gives you a sheet of wrapping paper and a cardboard box that has six glasses in it, and asks you to wrap it as a gift. Before wrapping, you take out one glass; it slips and breaks. What would you do? Select three options that you find most suitable. Justify your reason for selecting them in about 40-50 words.
Options (in short): (a) throw the pieces away and wrap the gift; (b) leave the pieces in the box and wrap it; (c) mend the glass with glue; (d) apologise to your father; (e) borrow money and buy more glasses; (f) take money from someone’s purse secretly; (g) ask someone to tell your father it broke by mistake; (h) ask someone to say she/he broke it; (i) say you found it broken; (j) blame a cat/dog/monkey; (k) admit it broke accidentally and offer your own money towards new glasses; (l) say the glasses are not nice; (m) say you want to keep the glasses; (n) any other choice.
Model answer: I would choose (d) apologise to my father, (k) admit that the glass broke accidentally and offer my own savings towards new glasses, and (n) any other choice: phone him at once, so that he knows before the evening and can plan another gift. Honesty keeps his trust; paying for the loss shows I take responsibility.
हिंदी में: सच बोलना, माफ़ी माँगना और नुकसान की भरपाई करना ही सही विकल्प हैं; झूठ, बहाना या चुपके से पैसे लेना गलत है।
2 Let us learn grammar 14.3
Fill in the blanks with the appropriate form (present participle) of the words given in brackets:
a. ____ dogs seldom bite. (bark) b. Detergents are ____ powders. (cleanse) c. Mala showed me her ____ doll. (dance) d. The king wanted a ____ bird. (sing) e. ____ beings need air, water and food. (live)
Answer: a. Barking b. cleansing c. dancing d. singing e. Living
हिंदी में: क्रिया में -ing लगाकर उसे विशेषण की तरह प्रयोग करें; अंतिम e हटाकर -ing लगता है (dance → dancing)।
Fill in the blanks using the suitable form of the verbs in brackets.
a. Please open the ____ (lock) cupboard. b. We should try to use ____ (recycle) products as they are eco-friendly. c. It was a ____ (plan) holiday. d. Kamla comforted the ____ (frighten) child. e. Please submit the ____ (complete) assignments.
Answer: a. locked b. recycled c. planned d. frightened e. completed
हिंदी में: पूरी हो चुकी या संज्ञा पर की गई क्रिया के लिए -d/-ed रूप लगाएँ; plan में n दोहराकर planned बनता है।
3 Let us write 14.4 (message writing)
Q. Imagine that you need money to buy a book for school. You take fifty rupees from your father’s shirt pocket without telling him about it. You know that your father will be confused and angry when he finds the money missing. You decide to write a short note to explain to him what you have done and why. Write the note in about 5-6 sentences.
Model note:
22 November, 7.30 am
Papa,
I took fifty rupees from your shirt pocket this morning. I needed it to buy my English workbook, which the teacher wants by today. You were asleep and I did not want to wake you. I know I should have asked first, and I am sorry. I will return the money from my pocket money this Sunday. It will not happen again.
Ravi
हिंदी में: Gandhiji की तरह सच साफ़ लिखें: क्या लिया, क्यों लिया, माफ़ी और लौटाने का वचन।
4 Terminal Questions
Q. Gandhiji and his friend smoked cigarette stubs and stalks of some plants. Do you think they were right in doing so? Give your opinion.
Answer: No, they were wrong. Smoking is injurious to health, and they did it only to copy the uncle. They even stole the servant’s coins for it, which made it worse.
हिंदी में: वे गलत थे, क्योंकि धूम्रपान सेहत के लिए हानिकारक है और उसके लिए उन्होंने चोरी भी की।
Q. Why did Gandhiji and his friend want to commit suicide? Do you think suicide is a solution to problems?
Answer: They were unhappy that they needed their elders’ permission for everything; they wanted independence. Taking one’s own life solves nothing. Problems must be faced bravely, with the help of people we trust.
हिंदी में: वे हर काम के लिए बड़ों की अनुमति से दुखी थे; आत्महत्या कभी हल नहीं है।
Q. Gandhiji took gold from his brother’s armlet. Do you think his action was correct or incorrect? Give reasons for your answer, in 20-30 words.
Answer: It was incorrect. Taking the gold secretly, without his brother’s knowledge, was theft. A good aim such as paying off a debt can never make theft right.
हिंदी में: बिना बताए लेना चोरी है, और अच्छे काम के लिए भी चोरी सही नहीं।
Q. Why did his father weep when he read Gandhiji’s confession?
Answer: He wept in pain that his son had stolen, and in love, because the son had honestly confessed and promised never to steal again. They were tears of love and forgiveness.
हिंदी में: पिता बेटे की चोरी से दुखी थे, पर उसकी ईमानदारी पर प्रेम से भर गए; ये क्षमा के आँसू थे।
The book’s answer says the father “was angry and sad”. The text does not support “angry”: Gandhiji “had thought that he would be angry”, “But he was so wonderfully peaceful”. “Sad” is right (“I could see my father’s agony”). Do not write “angry”.
हिंदी में: पाठ के अनुसार पिता गुस्सा नहीं हुए, वे शांत रहे।
Q. You see your friend stealing. How will you deal with the situation? What will you say or do? Answer in 20-30 words.
Answer: I will stop my friend calmly, explain that stealing is wrong and hurts others, and ask him to return the thing and say sorry. If needed, I will tell an elder.
हिंदी में: दोस्त को शांति से समझाएँगे, चीज़ लौटाने और माफ़ी माँगने को कहेंगे।
5 Worksheet 14 Solutions (कार्यपत्रक 14 हल)
Q. Gandhiji and his friend smoked cigarette stubs and stalks of some plants. Do you think they were right in doing so? Give your opinion.
Answer: They were not right. Smoking harms health, it was only blind copying of the uncle, and they stole money to do it. A wrong habit stays wrong even if elders have it.
Read the passage (the smoking passage from ‘My Experiments with Truth’) and answer:
(a) Who did Gandhiji try to imitate as a child?
Answer: He tried to imitate his uncle, who smoked.
(b) From where did Gandhiji first get money to smoke Indian cigarettes?
Answer: He stole coins from the servant’s pocket money.
(c) How did Gandhiji regard the habit of smoking when he grew up? What led to his transformation?
Answer: He regarded it as barbarous, dirty and harmful. The failed suicide attempt was the turning point: after dropping the idea of suicide, the boys also gave up smoking stubs and stealing coins for it.
(d) Why did he and his friend go to Ramji Mandir?
Answer: To compose (calm) themselves and to dismiss the thought of suicide.
हिंदी में: नकल चाचा की; पैसा नौकर से चुराया; बड़े होकर धूम्रपान से घृणा; रामजी मंदिर मन शांत करने गए।
(a) Do you think his action was correct or incorrect? Give reasons for your answer, in 20-30 words.
Answer: Incorrect. He took his brother’s gold without telling him, which is stealing. A good aim like clearing a debt cannot make stealing right.
(b) What do you think Gandhiji did with the bit of gold? Why did Gandhiji decide to confess to his father?
Answer: He probably sold it and cleared his brother’s debt. He confessed because the guilt was unbearable and he felt there could be no cleansing without a confession.
(c) How did Gandhiji’s father react on reading his letter of confession?
Answer: Tears ran down his cheeks; he closed his eyes, tore up the note and forgave his son, calmly and lovingly.
(d) Do you think it is easy to accept that what one is doing is wrong, and then change?
Answer: It is not easy, because pride and fear of shame stop us. But it is possible with courage and honesty, as Gandhiji’s confession shows.
The worksheet passage says the father “was angry and sad”. The lesson text shows his sorrow (“agony”) but says he was “wonderfully peaceful”, not angry; answer (c) follows the text.
Q. What do you mean by Ahimsa in the story? Who taught Gandhiji the lesson on “Ahimsa”? What according to Gandhiji is the purest type of repentance?
Answer: Ahimsa means avoiding pain and violence and bringing change in a peaceful, loving way. His father taught him this lesson. The purest repentance is a clean confession combined with a promise never to commit the sin again.
हिंदी में: अहिंसा = शांति और प्रेम से बदलाव; सीख पिता से मिली; सच्ची स्वीकारोक्ति + दोबारा न करने का वचन = शुद्धतम पश्चाताप।
Q. Why did Gandhiji and his friend want to commit suicide?
Answer: They were unhappy that they needed their elders’ permission to do anything. They wanted to be independent, and this lack of freedom upset them.
Q. “Committing suicide is definitely not a solution to any problem. We should rather face problems with courage.” Do you think suicide is a solution to problems? Give your opinion.
Answer: No. Suicide ends life, not problems, and it leaves deep pain for the family. Problems that look huge in the teenage years can be solved by talking to parents, teachers or friends. Gandhiji himself realised it was better to “put up with” the problem.
हिंदी में: आत्महत्या समस्या का हल नहीं; बात करें और साहस से सामना करें।
Q. “In the lesson that you just read, Gandhiji wanted to help his brother who was in debt. To clear that debt, he steals some gold. However, he realises that wrong means cannot justify the right end.” Comment on the above lines in your own words. What do you think about the act of stealing?
Answer: A good goal does not make a wrong method right. Gandhiji wanted to help his brother, but stealing the gold was still wrong, and the guilt troubled him until he confessed. Stealing breaks trust and hurts others, so it is wrong in every case.
हिंदी में: अच्छे उद्देश्य के लिए भी गलत रास्ता सही नहीं होता; चोरी हर हाल में गलत है।
Q. Do you think it is easy to accept that what one is doing is wrong, and then change?
Answer: It is difficult, because habit, pride and fear of punishment hold us back. Yet Gandhiji and Ratnakar show it can be done: admit the wrong, feel sorry, promise not to repeat it, and keep the promise.
Q. Do you know of any person who changed for the better, or gave up a bad habit (smoking, drinking, drugs, stealing, etc.)? How do you think he/she could do it?
Model answer: Our neighbour gave up chewing tobacco after his doctor warned him about mouth cancer. He took a firm decision, threw away all his tobacco, kept fennel seeds to chew instead and avoided friends who chewed tobacco. His family praised every week he stayed away from it.
Q. You are Anjali. Your mother had recently gone for a medical checkup. You received a call from the doctor regarding the result of her medical reports. Since you have to go out, you leave a message for her. Draft a message regarding the same in not more than 50-80 words.
Model message:
22 November, 2.00 pm
Mummy,
Dr. Mehta called at 1.30 pm about your medical reports. Your blood test and X-ray reports are normal, but your sugar level is a little high. He wants you to collect the reports from the clinic before 7 pm today and meet him tomorrow at 11 am. Please carry your old prescription. I have gone to the library and will be back by 6 pm.
Anjali
हिंदी में: message में तारीख-समय, संबोधन में केवल नाम, मुख्य सूचना (किसने, क्या, कब) और नीचे लिखने वाले का नाम।