Class 12 Economics (Macroeconomics) Chapter 4 Determination of Income and Employment Notes in English

Contents hide

Covers T.R. Jain & V.K. Ohri (2026-27) ch 7-9. Based on NCERT Introductory Macroeconomics, Chapter 4 (Reprint 2026-27), the CBSE curriculum 2026-27 (Unit 3, 12 marks) and the CBSE Supplementary Reading Material.

What you will learn
  • Tell ex ante (planned) values from ex post (actual) values
  • Work out the consumption function, saving function, APC, APS, MPC and MPS and prove how they are related
  • Find equilibrium income both with the 45° line diagram and with algebra
  • Explain the investment multiplier, its round-by-round mechanism and the paradox of thrift
  • Identify full employment, involuntary unemployment, excess demand and deficient demand, measure the gaps and state the measures to correct them
Ex anteEx postAggregate demandAggregate supplyConsumption functionAutonomous consumptionInduced consumptionMPCMPSAPCAPSBreak-even pointAutonomous investmentAutonomous expenditureUnintended changes in inventories45° lineEquilibrium incomeInvestment multiplierParadox of thriftParametric shiftEffective demand principleFull employmentInvoluntary unemploymentExcess demandDeficient demandInflationary gapDeflationary gap

1 The model of this chapter and its two assumptions

  • Macroeconomics builds models to explain the forces that decide the values of variables such as national income, the price level and the rate of interest
  • It is hard to explain all variables at once, so while studying one variable we hold the others constant
  • This is the assumption of ceteris paribus, which literally means “other things remaining equal”
  • It works like solving two equations in x and y: solve for one variable in terms of the other first, then substitute to get the full solution
  • In this chapter national income is determined under two assumptions: a fixed price of final goods and a constant rate of interest
  • The model is based on the theory given by John Maynard Keynes

2 Ex ante and ex post values

In Chapter 2, consumption, investment and GDP were used in the accounting sense: what actually happened in a year. The same terms have a second meaning: what people planned to do.

Learn by heartDefinition 1

The ex ante value of a variable (consumption, investment, output of final goods) is its planned value, what was planned to happen in a period.

Learn by heartDefinition 2

The ex post value of a variable is its actual or accounting value, what actually happened in that period.

Book example
  • A producer plans to add goods worth ₹100 to her stock by the end of the year: planned (ex ante) investment = ₹100
  • An unforeseen rise in demand makes her sell goods worth ₹30 from her stock
  • So her inventory rises by only ₹(100 − 30) = ₹70: actual (ex post) investment = ₹70
Basis Ex ante Ex post
Meaning Planned, what was intended Actual, what really happened
Investment in the example ₹100 ₹70
Used in Theory of income determination (this chapter) National income accounting (Chapter 2)
Equality Ex ante demand = ex ante supply only at equilibrium Ex post output = ex post C + I always (accounting identity)

3 Aggregate demand and its components

Learn by heartDefinition 3

Aggregate demand (AD) is the total ex ante (planned) demand for final goods and services in an economy in a period, that is, total planned expenditure on final goods.

1

Consumption demand (C)

Private final consumption expenditure of households

2

Investment demand (I)

Planned investment expenditure of firms

3

Government demand (G)

Government expenditure on final goods and services

4

Net exports (X − M)

Exports minus imports

  • Full form: AD=C+I+G+(X−M)AD = C + I + G + (X – M)
  • The main model of this chapter is the two-sector model (households and firms), so here AD=C+IAD = C + I
Learn by heartDefinition 4

Aggregate supply (AS) is the total planned (ex ante) output of final goods and services in an economy in a period. At a fixed price it equals GDP (national income, Y).

4 The consumption function and the saving function

The consumption function

  • The most important determinant of consumption demand is household income
  • Even when income is zero some consumption still takes place; this part is independent of income
Learn by heartDefinition 5

A consumption function describes the relation between consumption and income. The simplest form is C=Cˉ+cYC = \bar{C} + cY …(4.1)

What the symbols mean
CCConsumption expenditure by households₹
Cˉ\bar{C}Autonomous consumption, consumption even at zero income₹
cYcYInduced consumption, the part that depends on income₹
ccMarginal propensity to consume (MPC)ratio
Learn by heartDefinition 6

Autonomous consumption (Cˉ\bar{C}) is consumption that is independent of income; if consumption takes place even when income is zero, it is because of autonomous consumption. The book also calls it the subsistence consumption level of an economy, which stays more or less stable over time.

Learn by heartDefinition 7

Induced consumption (cYcY) is the part of consumption that depends on income; when income rises by ₹1, it rises by the MPC (c).

Marginal propensity to consume (MPC) and marginal propensity to save (MPS)

Learn by heartDefinition 8

The marginal propensity to consume (MPC) is the change in consumption per unit change in income. It is denoted by c: MPC=ΔCΔY=cMPC = \dfrac{\Delta C}{\Delta Y} = c

  • The change in consumption (ΔC\Delta C) can never exceed the change in income (ΔY\Delta Y), so the maximum value of c is 1
  • A consumer may not change consumption at all when income changes; then MPC = 0
  • Generally 0≤MPC≤10 \le MPC \le 1 (both values included): MPC = 0 (no rise in consumption), MPC = 1 (the whole extra income is consumed), 0<MPC<10 \lt MPC \lt 1 (part of the extra income is consumed)
Imagenia (book example)
  • Imagenia’s consumption function: C=100+0.8YC = 100 + 0.8Y
  • Even with no income its citizens consume goods worth ₹100: autonomous consumption = 100
  • Its MPC = 0.8: if income goes up by ₹100, consumption goes up by ₹80
Learn by heartDefinition 9

Saving is that part of income that is not consumed: S=Y−CS = Y – C

Learn by heartDefinition 10

The marginal propensity to save (MPS) is the change in saving per unit change in income. It is denoted by s: MPS=ΔSΔY=s=1−cMPS = \dfrac{\Delta S}{\Delta Y} = s = 1 – c

Prove that MPC + MPS = 1 (the book’s derivation):

S=Y−CS = Y – Cdefinition of saving
s=ΔSΔY=Δ(Y−C)ΔYs = \dfrac{\Delta S}{\Delta Y} = \dfrac{\Delta (Y – C)}{\Delta Y}take changes and divide by the change in income
s=ΔYΔY−ΔCΔY=1−cs = \dfrac{\Delta Y}{\Delta Y} – \dfrac{\Delta C}{\Delta Y} = 1 – cΔY/ΔY=1\Delta Y / \Delta Y = 1 and ΔC/ΔY=c\Delta C / \Delta Y = c
s+c=1s + c = 1, that is, MPC+MPS=1MPC + MPS = 1extra income is either consumed or saved

Average propensity to consume (APC) and average propensity to save (APS)

Learn by heartDefinition 11

The average propensity to consume (APC) is consumption per unit of income: APC=CYAPC = \dfrac{C}{Y}

Learn by heartDefinition 12

The average propensity to save (APS) is saving per unit of income: APS=SYAPS = \dfrac{S}{Y}

Y=C+SY = C + Sincome is either consumed or saved
YY=CY+SY\dfrac{Y}{Y} = \dfrac{C}{Y} + \dfrac{S}{Y}divide both sides by Y
1=APC+APS1 = APC + APSput in the definitions

The saving function and the break-even point

Learn by heartDefinition 13

The saving function describes the relation between saving and income: S=Y−(Cˉ+cY)=−Cˉ+(1−c)YS = Y – (\bar{C} + cY) = -\bar{C} + (1 – c)Y. Its intercept is −Cˉ-\bar{C} (dissaving at zero income) and its slope is (1−c)=MPS(1 – c) = MPS.

Learn by heartDefinition 14

The break-even point is the level of income at which consumption equals income (C=YC = Y), saving is zero (S=0S = 0) and APC=1APC = 1. In the diagram the consumption function cuts the 45° line here.

  • At income below break-even, consumption exceeds income; households sell old assets or borrow to finance it, which is called dissaving (negative saving)
  • At income above break-even, consumption is less than income and saving is positive
  • Dissaving at zero income is exactly equal to autonomous consumption (Cˉ\bar{C})
Solved example 1: Imagenia’s schedule (C=100+0.8YC = 100 + 0.8Y)
Income Y (₹) Consumption C (₹) Saving S = Y − C (₹) APC = C/Y APS = S/Y APC + APS
0 100 −100 not defined not defined –
250 300 −50 1.2 −0.2 1
500 500 0 1.0 0 1
750 700 50 0.933 0.067 1
1000 900 100 0.9 0.1 1
  • Every ₹250 rise in income raises C by ₹200: MPC = 200 ÷ 250 = 0.8, MPS = 50 ÷ 250 = 0.2 (constant at every level)
  • Break-even income: C=Y⇒Y=100+0.8Y⇒0.2Y=100⇒Y=C = Y \Rightarrow Y = 100 + 0.8Y \Rightarrow 0.2Y = 100 \Rightarrow Y = ₹500
  • Saving function: S=−100+0.2YS = -100 + 0.2Y
  • Interpretation: below ₹500 of income Imagenia’s people dissave, above ₹500 they save; as income rises APC falls and APS rises
Figure 1: Consumption function C = 100 + 0.8Y with the 45° line, and the saving function S = −100 + 0.2Y derived from it; the break-even point P is at income 500 in both
Figure 1: Consumption function C = 100 + 0.8Y with the 45° line, and the saving function S = −100 + 0.2Y derived from it; the break-even point P is at income 500 in both
Feature APC MPC
Formula C/Y (ratio of totals) ΔC/ΔY (ratio of changes)
Can exceed 1? Yes, below break-even income (dissaving) No, at most 1
As income rises Falls (when Cˉ>0\bar{C} \gt 0) Constant on a straight-line function
Sum rule APC + APS = 1 MPC + MPS = 1
Zero or negative? APS can be negative MPS is not negative (0 to 1)
Solved example 2: MPC and APC from a schedule

Q. When income rises from ₹2,000 crore to ₹2,400 crore, consumption rises from ₹1,700 crore to ₹2,000 crore. Find MPC, MPS, and APC and APS at income ₹2,000 crore.

Given

ΔY\Delta Y = 2,400 − 2,000 = 400; ΔC\Delta C = 2,000 − 1,700 = 300 (₹ crore)

To find

MPC, MPS, APC, APS

  • Formula: MPC=ΔCΔYMPC = \dfrac{\Delta C}{\Delta Y} (½)
  • Substituting: MPC=300400=MPC = \dfrac{300}{400} = 0.75 (½); MPS=1−0.75=MPS = 1 – 0.75 = 0.25 (½)
  • At ₹2,000 crore: APC=17002000=APC = \dfrac{1700}{2000} = 0.85; APS=1−0.85=APS = 1 – 0.85 = 0.15 (½)
  • Interpretation: 75% of extra income is consumed and 25% saved; 85% of total income is consumed
Common mistake
  • Writing “MPC + APC = 1” is wrong. The correct pairs are MPC + MPS = 1 and APC + APS = 1
  • Taking total C ÷ total Y (that is APC) when MPC is asked is wrong; MPC uses changes (ΔC ÷ ΔY)
  • Believing APC can never exceed 1 is wrong; below break-even APC > 1

5 Investment

Learn by heartDefinition 15

Investment is the addition to the stock of physical capital (such as machines, buildings, roads, anything that adds to the future productive capacity of the economy) and changes in the inventory (stock of finished goods) of a producer.

  • Investment goods (such as machines) are also final goods; they are not intermediate goods like raw materials
  • Machines produced in a year are not “used up” to produce other goods in that year; they yield services over many years
  • Investment decisions by producers (such as buying a new machine) depend, to a large extent, on the market rate of interest
  • For simplicity, firms are assumed to plan to invest the same amount every year: I=IˉI = \bar{I} …(4.2)
Learn by heartDefinition 16

Autonomous investment (Iˉ\bar{I}) is investment that does not depend on the level of income; it is a given (exogenous) positive constant in a year. In a diagram it is a horizontal line at height Iˉ\bar{I} above the horizontal axis.

6 Determination of income in the two-sector model

6.1 The aggregate demand equation

AD=C+IAD = C + Ieconomy without government: ex ante consumption + ex ante investment
AD=Cˉ+Iˉ+cYAD = \bar{C} + \bar{I} + cYsubstituting (4.1) and (4.2)
Y=Cˉ+Iˉ+cYY = \bar{C} + \bar{I} + cYfinal goods market in equilibrium: planned output Y = AD
Y=A+cYY = A + cY …(4.3)A=Cˉ+IˉA = \bar{C} + \bar{I} = total autonomous expenditure
Learn by heartDefinition 17

Autonomous expenditure (A) is total expenditure that does not depend on income: A=Cˉ+IˉA = \bar{C} + \bar{I}. Of these, Cˉ\bar{C} stays more or less stable, while Iˉ\bar{I} undergoes periodic fluctuations.

6.2 Equation (4.3) is not an accounting identity

  • Y on the left of (4.3) is ex ante output (planned supply); the right side is ex ante aggregate demand
  • Ex ante supply equals ex ante demand only at equilibrium
  • The accounting identity of Chapter 2 says that ex post output always equals ex post consumption + ex post investment
  • If ex ante demand falls short of planned output, (4.3) does not hold; stocks pile up in warehouses, which is unintended accumulation of inventories
  • This extra output shows up as unintended inventories inside ex post investment, so actual Y = actual (C + I) still holds
Learn by heartDefinition 18

Inventories (stocks) are the part of output produced that is not sold and remains with the firm. A change in inventory is called inventory investment; a rise is positive and a depletion is negative inventory investment.

Planned inventory investment

  • The firm decides to keep some stocks for various reasons
  • Part of ex ante investment

Unplanned inventory investment

  • Sales differ from planned sales, so the firm is forced to add to or run down stocks
  • Shows only in ex post investment

6.3 Introducing the government

  • The government’s main fiscal variables are tax (T) and government expenditure (G), both autonomous in the analysis
  • G adds directly to aggregate demand, like spending by firms and households
  • Taxes take part of household income away, so disposable income becomes Yd=Y−TY_d = Y – T and households consume a fraction of this
  • The equation becomes: Y=Cˉ+Iˉ+G+c(Y−T)Y = \bar{C} + \bar{I} + G + c(Y – T)
  • G−cTG – cT, like Cˉ\bar{C} and Iˉ\bar{I}, just adds to the autonomous term A; it does not change the analysis qualitatively, so the government is ignored for the rest of the chapter
  • Without indirect taxes and subsidies, GDP is identically equal to national income, so Y is called GDP or national income interchangeably
Solved example 3: equilibrium with government

Q. Cˉ\bar{C} = 40, c = 0.8, Iˉ\bar{I} = 10, G = 30, T = 25 (₹ crore). Find equilibrium income.

  • Autonomous term: A=Cˉ+Iˉ+G−cT=40+10+30−0.8×25=60A = \bar{C} + \bar{I} + G – cT = 40 + 10 + 30 – 0.8 \times 25 = 60
  • Equilibrium: Y=A1−c=600.2=Y = \dfrac{A}{1 – c} = \dfrac{60}{0.2} = ₹300 crore
  • Check: YdY_d = 300 − 25 = 275; C = 40 + 0.8 × 275 = 260; C + I + G = 260 + 10 + 30 = 300 = Y

7 Determination of equilibrium income in the short run

In microeconomics the demand and supply curves together decide price and quantity. Macroeconomics proceeds in two stages: first equilibrium with the price level fixed, then equilibrium with the price level allowed to vary.

Two reasons for taking the price level as fixed
  1. At the first stage the economy has unused resources (machinery, buildings, labour); the law of diminishing returns does not apply, so additional output can be produced without increasing marginal cost, and the price level does not change when output changes
  2. It is just a simplifying assumption, to be changed later

7.1 Graphical method

  • Intercept form of a linear equation: in Y=a+bXY = a + bX, a = intercept on the Y-axis (the value of Y when X is zero) and b = slope of the line (tan⁡θ=b\tan\theta = b)
  • By the same logic the consumption function C=Cˉ+cYC = \bar{C} + cY is a straight line: intercept = Cˉ\bar{C}, slope = c=tan⁡αc = \tan\alpha
  • The investment function I=IˉI = \bar{I} is a horizontal line at height Iˉ\bar{I}, the same whatever the level of income
  • The aggregate demand function is obtained by vertically adding the consumption and investment functions; it shows ex ante demand
Figure 2: The consumption function, the investment function and the aggregate demand line formed by adding them vertically (book Fig. 4.4)
Figure 2: The consumption function, the investment function and the aggregate demand line formed by adding them vertically (book Fig. 4.4)
  • In the figure OM = Cˉ\bar{C}, OJ = Iˉ\bar{I} and OL = Cˉ+Iˉ\bar{C} + \bar{I} (the letters of the book’s Fig. 4.4)
  • The AD line is parallel to the consumption line because both have slope c; the vertical gap between them is Iˉ\bar{I} everywhere
  • The gap between the AD line and the investment line is consumption (C), which grows with income; so the AD curve moves further away from the investment curve as income rises

Aggregate supply: the 45° line

  • At the first stage the price is fixed and unused resources of all types are available, so whatever the level of GDP, that much is supplied; the price level plays no role
  • Such supply is shown by the 45° line, every point on which has the same horizontal and vertical coordinates
  • Book example: if GDP is ₹1,000 at point A, ₹1,000 worth of goods will be supplied; this supply is at point B, where the vertical line at A meets the 45° line

Equilibrium

Learn by heartDefinition 19

Equilibrium income is the level of income at which ex ante aggregate demand = ex ante aggregate supply. In the diagram it is the point E where the AD line cuts the 45° line.

Figure 3: Ex ante aggregate demand AD = 50 + 0.8Y (C = 40 + 0.8Y, I = 10) cuts the 45° line at E; equilibrium income is 250
Figure 3: Ex ante aggregate demand AD = 50 + 0.8Y (C = 40 + 0.8Y, I = 10) cuts the 45° line at E; equilibrium income is 250

7.2 Algebraic method

Cˉ+Iˉ+cY=Y\bar{C} + \bar{I} + cY = Yex ante aggregate demand = ex ante aggregate supply
Y(1−c)=Cˉ+IˉY(1 – c) = \bar{C} + \bar{I}take cY to the left
Y=Cˉ+Iˉ1−cY = \dfrac{\bar{C} + \bar{I}}{1 – c} …(4.4)divide both sides by (1 − c)
Solved example 4: the book’s example

Q. If C=40+0.8YC = 40 + 0.8Y and I=10I = 10, find equilibrium income.

Given

Cˉ\bar{C} = 40, c = 0.8, Iˉ\bar{I} = 10

To find

Equilibrium income Y

  • Equilibrium condition: Y=C+IY = C + I (½)
  • Y=40+0.8Y+10⇒Y−0.8Y=50Y = 40 + 0.8Y + 10 \Rightarrow Y – 0.8Y = 50 (½)
  • Y=501−0.8=500.2=Y = \dfrac{50}{1 – 0.8} = \dfrac{50}{0.2} = 250 (1)
  • Interpretation: only at income 250 do households and firms together plan to buy exactly what producers plan to make

7.3 The adjustment mechanism: why the economy returns to equilibrium

Solved example 5: equilibrium from a schedule (C=40+0.8YC = 40 + 0.8Y, I=10I = 10)
Income/output Y C S = Y − C I AD = C + I Situation Income will
0 40 −40 10 50 AD > Y rise
100 120 −20 10 130 AD > Y rise
200 200 0 10 210 AD > Y rise
250 240 10 10 250 AD = Y, S = I equilibrium
300 280 20 10 290 AD < Y fall
400 360 40 10 370 AD < Y fall

Interpretation: income 200 is the break-even level (S = 0), but it is not equilibrium, because even there AD (210) > Y (200). Equilibrium is only where AD = Y.

When AD > planned output (left of E)

  • People want to buy more than is produced
  • Unplanned fall in inventories
  • Producers raise output and employment
  • Income rises to equilibrium

When AD < planned output (right of E)

  • Not all that is produced is sold
  • Unplanned accumulation of inventories
  • Producers cut output and employment
  • Income falls to equilibrium

7.4 The saving-investment approach (S = I)

  • In the two-sector model Y=C+SY = C + S and at equilibrium Y=C+IY = C + I; so at equilibrium ex ante saving = ex ante investment
  • If ex ante S > ex ante I, spending is too low: unplanned accumulation of inventories, output falls
  • If ex ante S < ex ante I: unplanned fall in inventories, output rises
  • In example 4, S=−40+0.2YS = -40 + 0.2Y and I=10I = 10: −40+0.2Y=10⇒Y=250-40 + 0.2Y = 10 \Rightarrow Y = 250, the same answer
Figure 4: Saving-investment approach: S = −40 + 0.2Y and I = 10 are equal at E, at income 250
Figure 4: Saving-investment approach: S = −40 + 0.2Y and I = 10 are equal at E, at income 250
Solved example 6: equilibrium from the saving function

Q. The saving function is S=−50+0.25YS = -50 + 0.25Y and autonomous investment is ₹100 crore. Find equilibrium income and consumption at that income.

  • Equilibrium condition: S = I (½)
  • −50+0.25Y=100⇒0.25Y=150-50 + 0.25Y = 100 \Rightarrow 0.25Y = 150 (½)
  • Y=150÷0.25=Y = 150 \div 0.25 = ₹600 crore (1)
  • Consumption: C = Y − S = 600 − 100 = ₹500 crore (1) [check: C = 50 + 0.75 × 600 = 500]
Common mistake
  • Treating the break-even point (C = Y) as the equilibrium point (AD = Y) is wrong; at break-even S = 0, at equilibrium S = I
  • “When S > I inventories fall” is wrong; S > I means spending is low, so inventories rise

8 Effect of an autonomous change in aggregate demand on income and output

Equilibrium income depends on aggregate demand, so when AD changes, equilibrium income changes. This can happen in any one or a combination of these ways:

1

Change in consumption

(i) a change in autonomous consumption Cˉ\bar{C}, or (ii) a change in the MPC (c)

2

Change in investment

Investment does not depend on income, but other factors move it: availability of credit (easy credit encourages investment) and the interest rate (the cost of investible funds; at higher rates firms invest less)

Solved example 7: investment rises from 10 to 20 (book example)
  • Before: C=40+0.8YC = 40 + 0.8Y, I=10I = 10 ⇒ Y1∗=500.2=250Y_1^* = \dfrac{50}{0.2} = 250
  • Investment rises to 20: Y2∗=40+200.2=600.2=Y_2^* = \dfrac{40 + 20}{0.2} = \dfrac{60}{0.2} = 300
  • Rise in investment = 10, but rise in income = 300 − 250 = 50, five times as much
Figure 5: A rise in autonomous investment shifts AD₁ up in parallel to AD₂; with MPC 0.8 the rise in income E₁G is 5 times the rise in investment E₁F (book's example: I from 10 to 20, income from 250 to 300; not to scale)
Figure 5: A rise in autonomous investment shifts AD₁ up in parallel to AD₂; with MPC 0.8 the rise in income E₁G is 5 times the rise in investment E₁F (book’s example: I from 10 to 20, income from 250 to 300; not to scale)
  • When autonomous investment rises, the AD₁ line shifts up in parallel to AD₂
  • At the old income Y1∗Y_1^* aggregate demand is now Y1∗FY_1^*F, which exceeds output Y1∗E1Y_1^*E_1 by E1FE_1F; E1FE_1F is the excess demand created by the rise in autonomous expenditure
  • So E1E_1 is no longer equilibrium; the new equilibrium is where AD₂ cuts the 45° line, at E2E_2
  • Output and AD rise by E1G=E2GE_1G = E_2G, which is larger than the initial rise in autonomous expenditure ΔI=E1F=E2J\Delta I = E_1F = E_2J

9 The multiplier mechanism

Why did a rise of 10 in investment raise income by 50? The answer lies in a process that runs round after round.

  • Final goods are produced with labour, capital, land and entrepreneurship; without indirect taxes or subsidies the whole value of output is distributed as factor payments (wages, interest, rent, profit)
  • So national income (the sum of factor payments) = value of the output of final goods (GDP)
  • That is why an extra output of 10 becomes an extra income of 10
Round 1Autonomous rise of 10 in investment ⇒ excess demand 10 ⇒ producers raise output by 10 ⇒ income rises by 10
↓
Round 2Income up 10, MPC 0.8 ⇒ consumption rises by (0.8)10 = 8 ⇒ excess demand of 8 ⇒ output and income rise by 8
↓
Round 3Consumption rises by (0.8)²10 = 6.4 ⇒ output and income rise by 6.4
↓
OnwardsEach round is 0.8 times the previous one; the increments shrink towards zero (a convergent process)
Round Rise in consumption Rise in aggregate demand Rise in output/income
Round 1 0 10 (autonomous increment) 10
Round 2 (0.8)10 = 8 8 8
Round 3 (0.8)²10 = 6.4 6.4 6.4
Round 4 (0.8)³10 = 5.12 5.12 5.12
Round 5 (0.8)⁴10 = 4.096 4.096 4.096
… … … …
Total 40 50 50

The book’s Table 4.1 “The Multiplier Mechanism in the Final Goods Market”, with the numbers filled in. After the first 4 rounds income has already risen by 29.52; the infinite series sums to 50. Total rise in consumption = 50 − 10 = 40.

ΔY=10+(0.8)10+(0.8)210+…\Delta Y = 10 + (0.8)10 + (0.8)^2 10 + \dotsinfinite geometric series in the last column
=10{1+0.8+(0.8)2+… }= 10\{1 + 0.8 + (0.8)^2 + \dots\}take 10 out
=101−0.8=50= \dfrac{10}{1 – 0.8} = 50sum of the infinite series is 11−r\dfrac{1}{1 – r}, r = 0.8
Learn by heartDefinition 20

The investment multiplier is the ratio of the total increment in the equilibrium value of final goods output (income) to the initial increment in autonomous expenditure: k=ΔYΔA=11−c=1sk = \dfrac{\Delta Y}{\Delta A} = \dfrac{1}{1 – c} = \dfrac{1}{s} …(4.5). The book’s key-concept list also calls it the autonomous expenditure multiplier.

Multiplier formulas
k=ΔYΔI=11−MPC=1MPSk = \frac{\Delta Y}{\Delta I} = \frac{1}{1 – MPC} = \frac{1}{MPS}
ΔY=k×ΔIMPC=1−1k\Delta Y = k \times \Delta I \qquad MPC = 1 – \frac{1}{k}
The larger the MPC, the larger the multiplier. At MPC = 0, k = 1; at MPC = 1, k is infinite; so the multiplier lies between 1 and infinity.
MPC MPS Multiplier k ΔY when ΔI = ₹100 crore
0.5 0.5 2 ₹200 crore
0.75 0.25 4 ₹400 crore
0.8 0.2 5 ₹500 crore
0.9 0.1 10 ₹1,000 crore
Solved example 8: four kinds of multiplier questions
  1. MPC = 0.75, ΔI = ₹200 crore; ΔY? k = 1 ÷ (1 − 0.75) = 4; ΔY = 4 × 200 = ₹800 crore
  2. k = 5, ΔY = ₹1,000 crore; ΔI? ΔI = ΔY ÷ k = 1,000 ÷ 5 = ₹200 crore
  3. ΔI = ₹500 crore gives ΔY = ₹2,000 crore; MPC? k = 2,000 ÷ 500 = 4; MPC = 1 − 1/4 = 0.75
  4. MPS = 0.1; k? k = 1 ÷ 0.1 = 10

Interpretation: the larger the share of extra income people spend, the larger the new demand in each round, so the larger the final effect on income.

Common mistake
  • Writing k = 1/MPC is wrong; correct is k = 1/(1 − MPC) = 1/MPS. (At MPC = 0.8, 1/MPC gives 1.25; the correct k is 5)
  • The multiplier works in reverse too: if investment falls by ₹100 crore and k = 4, income falls by ₹400 crore
  • “The multiplier can be less than 1” is wrong; since 0 ≤ MPC ≤ 1, k ≥ 1

10 The paradox of thrift

Learn by heartDefinition 21

Paradox of thrift: if all the people of the economy increase the proportion of income they save (that is, if the MPS of the economy increases), the total value of savings in the economy will not increase; it will either decline or remain unchanged. As people become more thrifty they end up saving less or the same as before.

Solved example 9: the book’s example
  • Start: Cˉ\bar{C} = 40, Iˉ\bar{I} = 10 (A = 50), MPC = 0.8 ⇒ Y1∗Y_1^* = 250
  • News of an imminent war or some other disaster makes people suddenly more thrifty: MPC falls from 0.8 to 0.5 (MPS rises from 0.2 to 0.5)
  • At income 250, consumption (and AD) falls by (0.8 − 0.5) × 250 = 75; this is treated as an autonomous reduction in consumption
  • An excess supply of 75, stocks pile up ⇒ producers cut output by 75 in the next round ⇒ income falls by 75
  • With the new MPC 0.5, consumption falls by (0.5)75 ⇒ excess supply again ⇒ output falls further; the process is convergent
  • Total fall in output: 75+(0.5)75+(0.5)275+⋯=751−0.5=75 + (0.5)75 + (0.5)^2 75 + \dots = \dfrac{75}{1 – 0.5} = 150
  • New equilibrium: Y2∗=250−150=100Y_2^* = 250 – 150 = 100 [directly: Y2∗=501−0.5=100Y_2^* = \dfrac{50}{1 – 0.5} = 100]
MPC Equilibrium income Total saving S = Y − (Cˉ\bar{C} + cY)
Before 0.8 250 250 − (40 + 0.8 × 250) = 10
After 0.5 100 100 − (40 + 0.5 × 100) = 10

Interpretation: people wanted to save more, but income fell by 150 and total saving stayed at 10. Reason: at equilibrium S = I, and investment is fixed at 10, so saving cannot go beyond 10.

Figure 6: Paradox of thrift: when MPC falls from 0.8 to 0.5 the AD line swings down about A = 50 and equilibrium income falls from 250 to 100
Figure 6: Paradox of thrift: when MPC falls from 0.8 to 0.5 the AD line swings down about A = 50 and equilibrium income falls from 250 to 100

10.1 Parametric shift: parallel shift versus swing

Learn by heartDefinition 22

A parametric shift is a change in the position of a line caused by a change in a parameter of its equation (the intercept or the slope). In AD = A + cY, when A changes the line shifts up or down in parallel; when c changes the line swings up or down about the same intercept.

Change in parameter Effect on the AD line Equilibrium income
A (intercept) rises Parallel shift up (Fig. 4.7) Rises
A falls Parallel shift down Falls
c (slope) rises, MPS falls Swings up, steeper Rises
c falls, MPS rises Swings down, flatter (Fig. 4.8) Falls

11 The effective demand principle

Learn by heartDefinition 23

Effective demand principle: with a constant final goods price and a constant rate of interest in the short run, and aggregate supply perfectly elastic at that price, aggregate output is determined solely by the level of aggregate demand.

  • The aggregate demand at the equilibrium point is called effective demand, because this is the demand that actually decides output (and employment)
  • An increase (decrease) in autonomous spending causes aggregate output to increase (decrease) by a larger amount through the multiplier process

12 Full employment and involuntary unemployment

  • Given the quantities of other factors, equilibrium output also determines the level of employment (think of a production function at the aggregate level)
  • The output fixed by Y = AD is not necessarily the output at which everyone is employed
Learn by heartDefinition 24

The full employment level of income is the level of income at which all the factors of production are fully employed in the production process. (CBSE supplement: when the entire labour force, all who are able and willing to work, is employed.)

Learn by heartDefinition 25

Involuntary unemployment occurs when those who are able and willing to work at the going wage rate do not get work.

Involuntary unemployment

  • Able and willing, yet no work
  • Ready to work at the going wage
  • Cause: deficiency of aggregate demand
  • Absent at full employment

Voluntary unemployment

  • Able to work but prefer not to
  • Not ready to work at the going wage
  • The person’s own choice
  • Can exist even at full employment
  • Equilibrium only means that, if left to itself, the level of income will not change, even when there is unemployment in the economy
  • An equilibrium below full employment is an under-employment equilibrium; involuntary unemployment persists there
  • Equilibrium output may be more or less than full employment output; this is where the problems of excess and deficient demand come from

13 Deficient demand and excess demand

13.1 Deficient demand and the deflationary gap

Learn by heartDefinition 26

Deficient demand is the situation in which equilibrium output is less than full employment output because demand is not enough to employ all factors of production; that is, at full employment income aggregate demand falls short of aggregate supply.

Learn by heartDefinition 27

The deflationary gap is the amount by which actual aggregate demand at full employment income falls short of the aggregate demand needed for full employment: deflationary gap = YfY_f − (AD at YfY_f). It measures deficient demand.

Figure 7: Deficient demand: at full employment income Yf, AD (point G) lies below the 45° line (point F); FG is the deflationary gap and equilibrium E is below full employment
Figure 7: Deficient demand: at full employment income Yf, AD (point G) lies below the 45° line (point F); FG is the deflationary gap and equilibrium E is below full employment
1

On output

Equilibrium output below full employment; resources lie idle

2

On employment

Involuntary unemployment; under-employment equilibrium

3

On prices

Prices fall in the long run (hence “deflationary”)

13.2 Excess demand and the inflationary gap

Learn by heartDefinition 28

Excess demand is the situation in which aggregate demand is more than the level of output produced at full employment; that is, the equilibrium level of output works out above the full employment level.

Learn by heartDefinition 29

The inflationary gap is the amount by which actual aggregate demand at full employment income exceeds the aggregate demand needed for full employment: inflationary gap = (AD at YfY_f) − YfY_f. It measures excess demand.

Figure 8: Excess demand: at full employment income Yf, AD (point G) lies above the 45° line (point F); GF is the inflationary gap
Figure 8: Excess demand: at full employment income Yf, AD (point G) lies above the 45° line (point F); GF is the inflationary gap
1

On output

All resources are already employed, so real output cannot rise further

2

On employment

Full employment already exists; employment does not rise

3

On prices

The extra demand only pushes prices up (demand-pull inflation); prices rise in the long run

Solved example 10: measuring deficient demand

Q. C=100+0.8YC = 100 + 0.8Y, II = ₹140 crore, full employment income YfY_f = ₹1,500 crore. (a) Find equilibrium income. (b) Identify the situation and measure the gap. (c) By how much must government spending rise to close the gap?

  • (a) Y=Cˉ+Iˉ1−c=100+1400.2=Y = \dfrac{\bar{C} + \bar{I}}{1 – c} = \dfrac{100 + 140}{0.2} = ₹1,200 crore (1)
  • (b) Y (1,200) < YfY_f (1,500), so deficient demand. AD at YfY_f = 100 + 0.8 × 1,500 + 140 = 1,440; deflationary gap = 1,500 − 1,440 = ₹60 crore (1)
  • (c) Income must rise by 300, k = 1 ÷ 0.2 = 5, so the required rise = 300 ÷ 5 = ₹60 crore (equal to the gap) (1). Check: (100 + 140 + 60) ÷ 0.2 = 1,500
  • Through taxes: G − cT adds to the autonomous term, so a tax cut ΔT raises A by c × ΔT: 0.8 × ΔT = 60 ⇒ ΔT = ₹75 crore
  • Interpretation: a shortfall of ₹60 crore in demand keeps ₹300 crore of output from being produced and leaves involuntary unemployment
Solved example 11: measuring excess demand

Q. C=200+0.75YC = 200 + 0.75Y, II = ₹300 crore, YfY_f = ₹1,600 crore. Identify the situation and measure the gap.

  • Y=200+3001−0.75=5000.25=Y = \dfrac{200 + 300}{1 – 0.75} = \dfrac{500}{0.25} = ₹2,000 crore > YfY_f, so excess demand (1)
  • AD at YfY_f = 200 + 0.75 × 1,600 + 300 = 1,700; inflationary gap = 1,700 − 1,600 = ₹100 crore (1)
  • Check: k = 4; (2,000 − 1,600) ÷ 4 = 100; if autonomous spending falls by 100, Y = 400 ÷ 0.25 = 1,600
  • Interpretation: output cannot rise beyond full employment, so the extra ₹100 crore of demand will push up the price level
Basis Deficient demand Excess demand
Meaning At YfY_f, AD < AS At YfY_f, AD > AS
Gap Deflationary gap Inflationary gap
Equilibrium Below full employment (under-employment equilibrium) Above full employment in money value
Output Low, resources idle Real output does not rise
Employment Involuntary unemployment Full employment
Price level Falls in the long run Rises (inflation)
Remedy Raise AD Reduce AD
Common mistake
  • Measuring the gap at equilibrium income is wrong; the gap is always measured at full employment income (YfY_f), between AD and the 45° line
  • Writing the deflationary gap as the income gap (YfY_f − Y) is wrong; the income gap = gap × multiplier
  • “Employment rises under excess demand” is wrong; full employment already exists, only prices rise

14 Measures to correct excess and deficient demand

  • Under deficient demand, aggregate demand must be raised by the deflationary gap; under excess demand it must be reduced by the inflationary gap
  • There are two routes: fiscal policy (government spending and taxes) and monetary policy (money supply and credit, controlled by the central bank, the Reserve Bank of India)
Measure For deficient demand (raise AD) For excess demand (reduce AD) How it works
Government spending (G) Increase (public works, roads, buildings) Reduce G is a direct component of AD; the multiplier enlarges its effect on income
Taxes (T) Reduce Increase Disposable income Y − T changes, so consumption changes (c × ΔT)
Bank rate / repo rate Reduce Increase Borrowing becomes cheaper/dearer for banks ⇒ interest rates and investment change
Cash reserve ratio (CRR), statutory liquidity ratio (SLR) Reduce Increase Funds banks can lend change ⇒ credit creation and money supply change
Open market operations Central bank buys government securities Central bank sells securities A purchase puts cash with banks (money supply rises), a sale takes it away
Margin requirement Lower Raise Loans against securities rise/fall
Moral suasion Persuade banks to lend more Persuade banks to lend less The central bank’s advice and pressure
Deficient demandCut CRR or the repo rate / buy government securities
↓
Link 1Banks have more loanable funds, interest rates fall
↓
Link 2Credit is easily available, investment (I) rises
↓
ResultAD rises; through the multiplier income and employment rise and the deflationary gap closes
Exam tip

In a “measures” question, write each measure with its route: measure → effect on money supply/disposable income/interest rate → effect on C or I → effect on AD. Naming the measure alone does not make a full answer. The monetary instruments are explained in Chapter 3 (Money and Banking).

15 A question like Exercise 5: is the economy in equilibrium?

Solved example 12

Q. Autonomous expenditure A = ₹50 crore, MPS = 0.2, income Y = ₹4,000 crore. Find ex ante aggregate demand and say whether the economy is in equilibrium.

  • MPC = 1 − MPS = 1 − 0.2 = 0.8 (½)
  • Formula: AD = A + cY (½)
  • AD = 50 + 0.8 × 4,000 = ₹3,250 crore (1)
  • AD (3,250) < Y (4,000): the economy is not in equilibrium; ₹750 crore of goods will be added to inventories unsold (1)
  • Producers will cut output; equilibrium income = 50 ÷ 0.2 = ₹250 crore (1)

16 At a glance: formulas, definitions and revision

All formulas
C=Cˉ+cYC = \bar{C} + cY    S=−Cˉ+(1−c)YS = -\bar{C} + (1 – c)Y
MPC=ΔCΔYMPC = \dfrac{\Delta C}{\Delta Y}   MPS=ΔSΔYMPS = \dfrac{\Delta S}{\Delta Y}   MPC+MPS=1MPC + MPS = 1
APC=CYAPC = \dfrac{C}{Y}   APS=SYAPS = \dfrac{S}{Y}   APC+APS=1APC + APS = 1
AD=C+I=Cˉ+Iˉ+cYAD = C + I = \bar{C} + \bar{I} + cY    equilibrium: AD=YAD = Y or S=IS = I
Y∗=Cˉ+Iˉ1−c=A1−cY^* = \dfrac{\bar{C} + \bar{I}}{1 – c} = \dfrac{A}{1 – c}    break-even: Y=Cˉ1−cY = \dfrac{\bar{C}}{1 – c}
k=ΔYΔI=11−MPC=1MPSk = \dfrac{\Delta Y}{\Delta I} = \dfrac{1}{1 – MPC} = \dfrac{1}{MPS}    1≤k≤∞1 \le k \le \infty
With government: Y=Cˉ+Iˉ+G+c(Y−T)Y = \bar{C} + \bar{I} + G + c(Y – T), Yd=Y−TY_d = Y – T
Deflationary gap = Yf−ADYfY_f – AD_{Y_f}    Inflationary gap = ADYf−YfAD_{Y_f} – Y_f
All definitions in one place
Ex anteThe planned value of a variable
Ex postThe actual (accounting) value of a variable
Aggregate demandTotal planned demand for final goods and services; C + I in the two-sector model
Aggregate supplyTotal planned output of final goods; the 45° line at a fixed price
Consumption functionRelation between consumption and income, C = C̄ + cY
Autonomous consumptionConsumption independent of income, even at zero income
Induced consumptionConsumption that depends on income, cY
MPCChange in consumption per unit change in income, ΔC/ΔY
SavingThe part of income not consumed, Y − C
MPSChange in saving per unit change in income, ΔS/ΔY = 1 − c
APCConsumption per unit of income, C/Y
APSSaving per unit of income, S/Y
Saving functionRelation between saving and income, S = −C̄ + (1 − c)Y
Break-even pointC = Y, S = 0, APC = 1
InvestmentAddition to physical capital + change in inventory
Autonomous investmentGiven investment that does not depend on income, I = Ī
Autonomous expenditureA = C̄ + Ī, total spending independent of income
InventoriesOutput not sold that remains with the firm; its change is inventory investment
Equilibrium incomeWhere ex ante AD = ex ante AS
Investment multiplierΔY/ΔA = 1/(1 − c) = 1/s
Paradox of thriftWhen MPS rises, total saving falls or stays the same
Parametric shiftIntercept changes: parallel shift; slope changes: the line swings
Effective demand principleAt a fixed price, output is decided solely by aggregate demand
Full employment level of incomeWhere all factors of production are fully employed
Involuntary unemploymentAble and willing people get no work even at the going wage
Deficient demandEquilibrium output below full employment
Deflationary gapShortfall of AD at Yf from the AD needed
Excess demandAD more than full employment output
Inflationary gapExcess of AD at Yf over the AD needed
Quick revision: read this the night before the exam
  • Ex ante = planned, ex post = actual; income is determined by ex ante values
  • Income is the main determinant of consumption; C = C̄ + cY, 0 ≤ c ≤ 1
  • MPC + MPS = 1 and APC + APS = 1; APC = 1 at break-even
  • Investment is taken as autonomous; it changes with the interest rate and the availability of credit
  • Equilibrium: AD = Y (45° line) or S = I; Y* = (C̄ + Ī)/(1 − c)
  • AD > Y ⇒ stocks fall, output rises; AD < Y ⇒ stocks pile up, output falls
  • Multiplier k = 1/(1 − MPC) = 1/MPS, from 1 to infinity; book: I up by 10, income 250 to 300
  • Paradox of thrift: MPC 0.8 to 0.5, income 250 to 100, saving stays 10
  • A changes ⇒ AD shifts in parallel; c changes ⇒ AD swings
  • Equilibrium need not be at full employment; under-employment equilibrium has involuntary unemployment
  • Deficient demand ⇒ deflationary gap ⇒ raise G, cut taxes, raise money supply
  • Excess demand ⇒ inflationary gap ⇒ cut G, raise taxes, reduce money supply
Check yourself before the exam
  • Can I prove MPC + MPS = 1 and APC + APS = 1?
  • Can I draw the 45° line equilibrium diagram from memory, with point E and both axes named?
  • Can I write the multiplier rounds (10, 8, 6.4, …) in a table and reach 50?
  • Can I show that saving is 10 both times in the paradox of thrift?
  • Can I mark the deflationary and inflationary gaps in the right place (at YfY_f)?
  • Can I write each measure with its route to AD?
Read this chapter in:English Mediumहिंदी माध्यम