Class 12 Economics (Indian Economic Development) Chapter 2 Indian Economy 1950-1990 Notes in English

Covers T.R. Jain & V.K. Ohri (2026-27) ch 2. Based on NCERT Indian Economic Development, Chapter 2 (Reprint 2026-27) and the CBSE 2026-27 curriculum, Unit 6.

Board note: CBSE teaches this book in Class 12; UP, Bihar, Rajasthan and MP Boards teach it in Class 11.

What you will learn in this chapter
  • Tell a capitalist, a socialist and a mixed economy apart, and explain why India chose a mixed economy
  • Define a plan and explain the four goals of the five year plans (growth, modernisation, self-reliance, equity) with examples
  • Explain land reforms, the Green Revolution and both sides of the debate over subsidies
  • Explain the Industrial Policy Resolution 1956, small-scale industry and the policy of import substitution
  • Judge the achievements and failures of 1950-1990 using the book’s tables
mixed economyplanperspective planPlanning Commissiongrowthmodernisationself-relianceequityland reformsland ceilingGreen RevolutionHYV seedsmarketed surplussubsidyIPR 1956small-scale industryimport substitutiontariffsquotaspermit licence raj

1 Introduction: which economic system did India choose?

  • On 15 August 1947 India became free after some two hundred years of British rule
  • The leaders now had to decide which economic system would suit the nation best, one that would promote the welfare of all rather than a few
  • Socialism appealed to Jawaharlal Nehru the most, but not the kind set up in the former Soviet Union
  • In the Soviet Union all the means of production (all factories and farms) were owned by the government, and there was no private property
  • In a democracy like India the government could not change the ownership of its citizens’ land and property in that way
  • So the leaders looked for an alternative to the extreme versions of capitalism and socialism: the best features of socialism without its drawbacks
  • India would be a socialist society with a strong public sector, but also with private property and democracy
  • The government would plan for the economy, and the private sector would be encouraged to be part of the plan effort
  • The Industrial Policy Resolution of 1948 and the Directive Principles of the Indian Constitution reflected this outlook
  • In 1950 the Planning Commission was set up with the Prime Minister as its Chairperson. The era of five year plans had begun

The central objective of Planning in India… is to initiate a process of development which will raise the living standards and open out to the people new opportunities for a richer and more varied life.

First Five Year Plan (quoted in the book)

1.1 The three central questions every society answers

1

What to produce?

Which goods and services should be produced in the country?

2

How to produce?

Should producers use more human labour or more capital (machines)?

3

For whom?

How should the goods and services be distributed among people?

1.2 Types of economic systems

Learn by heartDefinition 1

A market economy (capitalism) is a system in which the market forces of supply and demand answer the three questions: only the consumer goods that are in demand and can be sold profitably are produced, and goods are distributed not by need but by purchasing power, the ability to buy goods and services.

Learn by heartDefinition 2

A socialist economy is a system in which the government decides what goods are produced, how, and how they are distributed, in accordance with the needs of society; distribution is based on what people need, and there is no private property.

Learn by heartDefinition 3

A mixed economy is a system in which the government and the market together answer the three questions: the market provides whatever goods and services it can produce well, and the government provides the essential goods and services which the market fails to provide.

Basis Capitalist (market) Socialist Mixed
What to produce Goods in demand that sell profitably (cars if cars are in demand) Government, according to society’s needs Market + government
How to produce Labour-intensive if labour is cheaper, capital-intensive if capital is cheaper Government decides Both together
Basis of distribution Purchasing power (money in the pocket) Need (e.g. free health care for all citizens) Market + government’s essential services
Private property Yes No (everything owned by the state) Yes
Book’s examples Low-cost housing for the poor is needed but is not “demand” in the market sense, since the poor lack purchasing power Cuba and China (most activities governed by socialistic principles) Most economies, India
  • Capitalism did not appeal to Nehru, because the great majority of people would be left behind without a chance to improve their quality of life

1.3 What is a plan?

Learn by heartDefinition 4

A plan spells out how the resources of a nation should be put to use. It has some general goals as well as specific objectives which are to be achieved within a specified period of time.

  • In India plans were of five years’ duration and were called five year plans
  • The idea was borrowed from the former Soviet Union, the pioneer in national planning
  • Plan documents up to the year 2017 specified not only the objectives of the five years but also what was to be achieved over twenty years
Learn by heartDefinition 5

A perspective plan is a long-term plan covering a period such as twenty years. The five year plans were supposed to provide the basis for it.

  • Not all goals can get equal importance in every plan, and goals may even be in conflict
  • Example: if modern technology reduces the need for labour, the goal of modernisation conflicts with the goal of increasing employment. Planners have to balance the goals
  • India’s plans did not spell out how much of every good and service to produce. This is neither possible nor necessary (the former Soviet Union tried and failed)
  • A plan is specific only about sectors where it plays a commanding role, such as power generation and irrigation, leaving the rest to the market
194715 August: independence; the question of which economic system to choose
1948Industrial Policy Resolution: the mixed-economy outlook. (Just a year after independence, steps were also taken to abolish intermediaries.)
1950Planning Commission set up, PM as Chairperson; era of five year plans begins
1955Village and Small-Scale Industries Committee (Karve Committee)
1956Industrial Policy Resolution 1956; basis of the Second Five Year Plan (built on Mahalanobis’s ideas)
Mid-1960sFirst phase of the Green Revolution; self-sufficiency in food grains by the late 1960s
Mid-1980sUntil now, no serious thought had been given to export promotion
1990End of the first seven plans; services have the largest share of GDP
1991New economic policy (Chapter 3)

2 The goals of five year plans

  • A plan should have clearly specified goals. The goals of the five year plans were growth, modernisation, self-reliance and equity
  • Because resources are limited, each plan has to choose which goal gets primary importance
  • Still, planners have to ensure that, as far as possible, policies do not contradict these four goals

2.1 The four goals at a glance

1

Growth

Raise the country’s capacity to produce; indicator: steady increase in GDP

2

Modernisation

Adopt new technology + change in social outlook

3

Self-reliance

Avoid imports of goods that can be produced in India

4

Equity

Benefits of prosperity reach the poor

2.2 Growth

Learn by heartDefinition 6

Growth refers to an increase in the country’s capacity to produce goods and services. It implies a larger stock of productive capital, or a larger size of supporting services like transport and banking, or an increase in the efficiency of productive capital and services.

Learn by heartDefinition 7

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the market value of all the final goods and services produced in the country during a year. A steady increase in GDP is a good indicator of economic growth.

  • Think of GDP as a cake: growth is an increase in the size of the cake. A larger cake can be enjoyed by more people
  • In the words of the First Plan, more goods and services are needed for a “more rich and varied life”
  • GDP comes from three sectors: agriculture, industry and services. Their contributions make up the structural composition of the economy (the exercise calls it “sectoral composition”)
  • In some countries growth in agriculture contributes more to GDP growth, in others the service sector does
Learn by heartDefinition 8

The sectoral (structural) composition of an economy is the pattern of contributions (shares) made by agriculture, industry and services to its GDP.

Box 2.4: The service sector

As a country develops it undergoes structural change: usually the share of agriculture declines and industry becomes dominant, and at higher levels of development the service sector contributes more to GDP than the other two. In India the change was peculiar. Agriculture’s share in GDP was more than 50 per cent (as expected for a poor country), but by 1990 the share of the service sector was 40.59 per cent, more than that of agriculture or industry, as in developed nations. The trend accelerated after 1991 (the onset of globalisation).

Figure 1: Share of sectors in GDP (%), 1950-51 and 1990-91 (data from the book's "Work These Out" table)
Figure 1: Share of sectors in GDP (%), 1950-51 and 1990-91 (data from the book’s “Work These Out” table)
Sector 1950-51 (%) 1990-91 (%) Change (percentage points)
Agriculture 59.0 34.9 −24.1
Industry 13.0 24.6 +11.6
Services 28.0 40.5 +12.5
Total 100.0 100.0
Exam tip: reading the table

When you interpret this table, say two things: (1) in 1950-51 agriculture had the largest share (59%), and by 1990-91 services had the largest (40.5%); (2) industry’s share almost doubled (13% to 24.6%), which is an indicator of development. (Box 2.4 gives the 1990 service share as 40.59%; the table rounds it to 40.5 for 1990-91.)

2.3 Modernisation

Learn by heartDefinition 9

Modernisation is the adoption of new technology to increase production, together with changes in social outlook, such as the recognition that women should have the same rights as men.

  • Technology example: a farmer raises output by using new seed varieties instead of old ones; a factory raises output with a new type of machine
  • Social outlook example: in a traditional society women are supposed to remain at home while men work
  • A modern society uses the talents of women in banks, factories and schools, and such a society is in most cases also prosperous

2.4 Self-reliance

Learn by heartDefinition 10

Self-reliance means avoiding imports of those goods which could be produced in India itself. The first seven five year plans gave it importance.

  • A nation can promote growth and modernisation with its own resources or with imported ones
  • Self-reliance was considered necessary to reduce dependence on foreign countries, especially for food
  • It is understandable that people recently freed from foreign domination valued self-reliance
  • It was also feared that dependence on imported food, foreign technology and foreign capital could make India’s sovereignty vulnerable to foreign interference in its policies

2.5 Equity

Learn by heartDefinition 11

Equity means ensuring that the benefits of economic prosperity reach the poor sections as well, instead of being enjoyed only by the rich: every Indian should be able to meet basic needs such as food, a decent house, education and health care, and inequality in the distribution of wealth should be reduced.

  • Growth, modernisation and self-reliance by themselves may not improve the kind of life people live
  • A country can have high growth and the most modern technology developed at home and still have most of its people living in poverty
  • Hence “growth with equity”: the cake should grow and also be shared
Common mistake

Self-reliance does not mean stopping all imports. In the book it means avoiding imports of only those goods which could be produced in India itself.

2.6 Mahalanobis: the architect of Indian planning (Box 2.3)

  • The statistician Prasanta Chandra Mahalanobis is regarded as the architect of Indian planning
  • Planning in the real sense began with the Second Five Year Plan, which laid down the basic ideas on the goals of Indian planning and was based on his ideas
  • Born in 1893 in Calcutta; educated at Presidency College, Calcutta and Cambridge University, England
  • His contributions to statistics brought him international fame; in 1945 he became a Fellow of Britain’s Royal Society, one of the most prestigious organisations of scientists
  • He set up the Indian Statistical Institute (ISI) in Calcutta and started the journal Sankhya
  • During the Second Plan he invited distinguished economists from India and abroad; some later won the Nobel Prize, and some were very critical of the plan’s socialist principles. He was willing to listen to his critics
  • Many economists today reject his approach to planning, but he will be remembered for putting India on the road to economic progress

3 Agriculture (1950-1990)

  • Under colonial rule there was neither growth nor equity in agriculture (Chapter 1)
  • Independent India’s policy makers used two measures: land reforms (institutional reform) and High Yielding Variety (HYV) seeds (the new agricultural strategy), which ushered in a revolution in Indian agriculture

3.1 Land reforms

Learn by heartDefinition 12

Land reforms primarily refer to a change in the ownership of landholdings. They included the abolition of intermediaries (making the tillers the owners of land) and land ceiling.

Why land reforms were needed

  • At independence the land tenure system was dominated by intermediaries (zamindars, jagirdars etc.)
  • They merely collected rent from the actual tillers without contributing to improvements on the farm
  • Low productivity in agriculture forced India to import food from the United States of America (USA)
  • Equity in agriculture called for land reforms

Types of land reforms

1. Abolition of intermediaries

  • Steps taken just a year after independence
  • Make the tillers the owners of land
  • Idea: ownership gives tillers the incentive to invest in improvements, provided sufficient capital is available

2. Land ceiling

  • Definition: fixing the maximum size of land which could be owned by an individual
  • Purpose: reduce the concentration of land ownership in a few hands
  • A second policy to promote equity

Results

  • Abolition of intermediaries brought some 200 lakh tenants into direct contact with the government, freeing them from exploitation by zamindars
  • Ownership gave them the incentive to increase output, contributing to growth in agriculture

Limits: the goal of equity was not fully served

  • In some areas former zamindars kept large areas of land by using loopholes in the legislation
  • In some cases tenants were evicted and landowners claimed to be self-cultivators (the actual tillers)
  • Even when tillers got ownership, the poorest agricultural labourers (sharecroppers and landless labourers) did not benefit
  • Big landlords challenged the land ceiling legislation in the courts, delaying its implementation
  • They used the delay to register their lands in the names of close relatives, escaping the legislation; they also exploited its loopholes
  • Land reforms were successful in Kerala and West Bengal, whose governments were committed to the policy of land to the tiller; other states lacked the same commitment, so vast inequality in landholding continues to this day
Box 2.5: Ownership and incentives

The policy of “land to the tiller” rests on the idea that cultivators who own the land have more incentive to increase output, because ownership lets them profit from it. Tenants have no incentive to improve the land, since the landowner gains more. Farmers in the former Soviet Union packed rotten fruit together with fresh fruit for sale: since they owned no land, they neither enjoyed the profits nor suffered the losses. With no incentive to be efficient, Soviet agriculture performed poorly despite vast areas of fertile land. (Source: Thomas Sowell, Basic Economics, 2004)

3.2 The Green Revolution

  • At independence about 75 per cent of the population depended on agriculture
  • Productivity was very low: old technology and no infrastructure for most farmers
  • Agriculture depended on the monsoon; if it fell short, farmers were in trouble, as very few had irrigation
  • The stagnation of the colonial period was permanently broken by the Green Revolution
Learn by heartDefinition 13

The Green Revolution refers to the large increase in production of food grains resulting from the use of high yielding variety (HYV) seeds, especially for wheat and rice.

Learn by heartDefinition 14

High Yielding Variety (HYV) seeds are seeds that give a large proportion of output, but need fertiliser and pesticide in the correct quantities and a regular supply of water; applying these inputs in correct proportions is vital.

InputsHYV seeds + fertiliser + pesticide + reliable irrigation (in correct proportions)
↓
ConditionThe farmer needs reliable irrigation and the money to buy fertiliser and pesticide
↓
ResultLarge rise in wheat and rice output; self-sufficiency in food grains
Figure 2: The two phases of the Green Revolution (approximate periods given in the book)
Figure 2: The two phases of the Green Revolution (approximate periods given in the book)
Basis First phase Second phase
Period Approximately mid-1960s to mid-1970s Mid-1970s to mid-1980s
Region More affluent states: Punjab, Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu Spread to a larger number of states
Crops Primarily benefited the wheat-growing regions only Benefited more varieties of crops
Why limited / how it spread HYV seeds needed irrigation and money, which the affluent states had Spread of HYV technology
  • The spread of Green Revolution technology enabled India to achieve self-sufficiency in food grains; India no longer had to be at the mercy of America, or any other nation, for its food
  • By the late 1960s agricultural productivity had increased enough for India to be self-sufficient in food grains

Marketed surplus

Learn by heartDefinition 15

Marketed surplus is the portion of agricultural produce which is sold in the market by the farmers. (The exercise calls it “marketable surplus”.)

  • If farmers consume most of the extra output themselves, it makes little difference to the economy as a whole
  • If a substantial amount is sold in the market, the higher output makes a difference to the economy
1During the Green Revolution farmers sold a good proportion of their rice and wheat in the market (marketed surplus)
↓
2The price of food grains declined relative to other items of consumption
↓
3Low-income groups, who spend a large percentage of income on food, benefited
↓
4The government could procure enough food grains to build a stock for use in times of food shortage

Risks of the Green Revolution and the government’s steps

Risk (fear) Government’s step Outcome
Disparity between small and big farmers would grow, as only big farmers could afford the inputs Loans at low interest to small farmers and subsidised fertilisers Output on small farms equalled that on large farms in time
HYV crops more prone to pest attack; a small farmer could lose everything Services of research institutes set up by the government Risk to small farmers considerably reduced
  • As a result the Green Revolution benefited small as well as rich farmers
  • It would have favoured only the rich farmers if the state had not played an extensive role

3.3 The debate over subsidies

Learn by heartDefinition 16

A subsidy is monetary assistance given by the government for production activities, such as cheaper fertiliser for farmers.

  • It is generally agreed that subsidies were necessary to give farmers, and small farmers in particular, an incentive to adopt the new HYV technology, since farmers see any new technology as risky
  • The debate today is whether to continue them

Phase subsidies out

  • The technology is profitable and widely adopted; their purpose has been served
  • A substantial part of fertiliser subsidy benefits the fertiliser industry
  • Among farmers, it largely benefits those in prosperous regions
  • It does not benefit the target group and is a huge burden on government finances

Continue subsidies

  • Farming in India is still a risky business
  • Most farmers are very poor and cannot afford inputs without subsidies
  • Removing them would increase inequality between rich and poor farmers and violate equity
  • These experts argue that the correct policy is not to abolish subsidies but to ensure that only poor farmers enjoy the benefits
Box 2.6: Prices as signals

Prices are signals about the availability of goods. When a good becomes scarce its price rises, and users have the incentive to use it carefully: if water becomes costlier, people may stop watering the garden; a rise in the price of petrol signals that less petrol is available, so people use less or look for alternative fuels. Some economists point out that subsidies do not allow prices to indicate the supply of a good: subsidised or free electricity and water are used wastefully; with free water, farmers grow water-intensive crops even where water is scarce; fertiliser and pesticide subsidies lead to overuse that can harm the environment. (The book asks: is it wise, economically, to provide free electricity to farmers?)

3.4 Population dependent on agriculture: a major failure

  • Self-sufficiency in food grains was an achievement to be proud of, but on the negative side some 65 per cent of the population was still employed in agriculture as late as 1990
  • Economists have found that as a nation becomes more prosperous, the share of GDP from agriculture and the share of the population working in it both decline considerably
  • In India, between 1950 and 1990, agriculture’s share of GDP declined significantly, but not the population depending on it: 67.5 per cent in 1950 to only 64.9 per cent by 1990
  • Reason: the industrial and service sectors did not absorb the people working in agriculture; the output could have grown with far fewer people
  • Many economists call this an important failure of the policies of 1950-1990
Figure 3: Occupational structure of India, share of the workforce by sector (%) (the book's "Work These Out" table)
Figure 3: Occupational structure of India, share of the workforce by sector (%) (the book’s “Work These Out” table)
Exam tip: compare the two figures

In Figure 1 agriculture’s share of GDP fell by 24.1 percentage points, but in Figure 3 its share of the workforce fell by only 5.3 percentage points (72.1 to 66.8). The income share of agriculture shrank fast while the people depending on it stayed almost the same. These numbers illustrate the answer to “why did 65 per cent stay in agriculture” (Exercise 15). Note the book’s figures come from different measures: the text gives the population dependent on agriculture as 67.5% (1950) and 64.9% (1990), while the activity table gives the workforce share as 72.1 (1950-51) and 66.8 (1990-91).

4 Industry and trade

  • Economists have found that poor nations can progress only if they have a good industrial sector
  • Industry provides employment more stable than in agriculture and promotes modernisation and overall prosperity; hence the plans placed a lot of emphasis on industry
  • At independence the variety of industries was very narrow, largely cotton textiles and jute
  • There were two well-managed iron and steel firms: one in Jamshedpur and one in Kolkata

4.1 Public and private sectors: why the government led

1

No capital

Indian industrialists did not have the capital for the investment industrial development needed

2

Small market

The market was not big enough to encourage major projects even with capital

3

Socialist lines

The state would control the “commanding heights of the economy”, as the Second Five Year Plan put it

  • This meant the government would have complete control of industries vital for the economy
  • The policies of the private sector would be complementary to those of the public sector, with the public sector leading the way

4.2 Industrial Policy Resolution 1956 (IPR 1956)

  • In line with the goal of the state controlling the commanding heights, the Industrial Policy Resolution of 1956 was adopted
  • It formed the basis of the Second Five Year Plan, which tried to build the basis for a socialist pattern of society
  • It classified industries into three categories:
IPR 1956: three categories of industries
First categoryIndustries exclusively owned by the government
Second categoryPrivate sector could supplement the public sector, but the government took sole responsibility for starting new units
Third categoryThe remaining industries, in the private sector

Regulating the private sector: the licence system

  • Although the third category was left to the private sector, it was kept under state control through a system of licences
  • No new industry was allowed unless a licence was obtained from the government
  • A licence was easier to obtain for a unit in an economically backward area, which also got concessions such as tax benefits and electricity at a lower tariff; purpose: regional equality
  • Even an existing industry needed a licence to expand output or to diversify (produce a new variety of goods)
  • Purpose: output should not exceed what the economy required; a licence to expand was given only if the government was convinced more was needed

4.3 Small-scale industry

  • In 1955 the Village and Small-Scale Industries Committee, also called the Karve Committee, noted the possibility of using small-scale industries for promoting rural development
Learn by heartDefinition 17

A small-scale industry is defined with reference to the maximum investment allowed on the assets of a unit. In 1950 a small-scale unit was one which invested a maximum of ₹5 lakh; according to the book the limit at present is ₹1 crore.

1955Karve Committee
₹5 lakhinvestment limit in 1950
₹1 crorelimit at present (book)

Role and importance

  • Small-scale industries are believed to be more labour intensive, i.e. they use more labour than large-scale industries and so generate more employment
  • They help rural development and let people without much capital get into business

Protection given to them

  • They cannot compete with big industrial firms, so they had to be shielded from them
  • The production of a number of products was reserved for the small-scale industry; the criterion of reservation was the ability of these units to manufacture the goods
  • Concessions: lower excise duty and bank loans at lower interest rates

5 Trade policy: import substitution

  • India’s industrial policy was closely related to its trade policy
  • In the first seven plans trade followed an inward looking trade strategy, technically called import substitution
Learn by heartDefinition 18

Import substitution is a policy that aims at replacing or substituting imports with domestic production. Example: instead of importing vehicles made abroad, industries are encouraged to produce them in India.

5.1 Two forms of protection: tariffs and quotas

Tariffs

  • A tax on imported goods
  • Make imported goods more expensive and discourage their use

Quotas

  • Specify the quantity of goods which can be imported
  • Nothing beyond that quantity can come in
Tariffs and quotasImports restricted
→
Imports fallForeign goods costlier or limited
→
ProtectionDomestic firms shielded from foreign competition
→
Domestic outputreplaces imports

5.2 The basis of protection

  • Industries of developing countries were not in a position to compete with goods from more developed economies
  • It was assumed that protected domestic industries would learn to compete in the course of time
  • Planners feared that without restrictions, foreign exchange would be spent on imports of luxury goods
  • No serious thought was given to export promotion until the mid-1980s

6 Effect of the policies: achievements and criticism

6.1 Effect of policies on industrial development (achievements)

13% → 24.6%industry’s share of GDP, 1950-51 to 1990-91
6%annual growth rate of the industrial sector
  • The rise in industry’s share of GDP is an important indicator of development
  • Industry was no longer restricted largely to cotton textiles and jute; by 1990 it was well diversified, largely due to the public sector
  • Promotion of small-scale industries gave people without capital for large firms the chance to get into business
  • Protection from foreign competition enabled indigenous industries in electronics and automobiles, which otherwise could not have developed

6.2 Criticism

Despite the public sector’s contribution, some economists are critical of the performance of many public sector enterprises. The book’s points:

Problem Book’s example / argument
State enterprises in areas where no longer required (often monopolies) Telecommunication stayed reserved for the public sector even after private firms could provide it; with no competition, one waited a long time for a telephone connection even till the late 1990s. Modern Bread, a bread-making firm, as if the private sector could not make bread; sold to the private sector in 2001
No distinction between public and private roles After four decades no distinction was made between (i) what only the public sector can do (e.g. national defence) and (ii) what the private sector can also do (e.g. hotels, which the government also runs). This has led some scholars to argue that the state should get out of areas the private sector can manage and concentrate its resources on important services the private sector cannot provide
Loss-making units kept running Hard to close a government undertaking even when it drains the nation’s limited resources; a loss-making private firm will not waste resources this way (some public firms were private firms near closure, nationalised to protect workers’ jobs)
Misuse of licences A big industrialist would get a licence not to start a firm but to prevent competitors from starting new firms
Permit licence raj (defined below) Industrialists spent time getting licences and lobbying ministries rather than improving their products
Poor quality under protection Restrictions on imports forced consumers to buy whatever Indian producers made; producers had a captive market (defined below), so they sold low-quality items at high prices. Protection was also criticised because it continued even after it proved to do more harm than good. Competition from imports forces producers to be efficient
Learn by heartDefinition 19

The permit licence raj was the excessive regulation of industry through licences and permits, which prevented certain firms from becoming more efficient.

Learn by heartDefinition 20

A captive market is one in which consumers have no alternative, as when import restrictions forced Indian consumers to buy only what Indian producers made.

6.3 The other side

  • A few economists argue that the public sector is meant not for earning profits but to promote the welfare of the nation, so it should be judged by its contribution to people’s welfare, not by profits
  • On protection, some hold that we should protect our producers as long as the rich nations continue to do so
  • Owing to these conflicts economists called for a change in policy; along with other problems this led the government to introduce a new economic policy in 1991

7 Conclusion: the 1950-1990 balance sheet

7.1 Achievements and failures

✓ Achievements

  • Industries far more diversified than at independence
  • Self-sufficiency in food production through the Green Revolution
  • Land reforms abolished the hated zamindari system
  • Industry’s share of GDP rose from 13% to 24.6%

✗ Failures

  • Dissatisfaction with the performance of many public sector enterprises
  • Excessive government regulation prevented the growth of entrepreneurship
  • Protection gave producers no incentive to improve quality
  • Inward-oriented policies failed to develop a strong export sector
  • Even in 1990, 65% of people depended on agriculture
  • With the global economic scenario changing, the need for reform of economic policy was widely felt
  • The new economic policy was initiated in 1991 to make the Indian economy more efficient (next chapter)
Key dates and terms
Date / term Linked to
1948 Industrial Policy Resolution
1950 Planning Commission (PM as Chairperson); SSI limit ₹5 lakh
1955 Karve Committee (Village and Small-Scale Industries Committee)
1956 Industrial Policy Resolution; basis of the Second Plan
1893 / 1945 Mahalanobis born / Fellow of the Royal Society
2001 Modern Bread sold to the private sector
1991 New economic policy
Growth, modernisation, self-reliance, equity The four goals of the five year plans
Tariff / quota Tax on imports / limit on the quantity of imports
Common mistakes
  • Writing “the Green Revolution benefited only rich farmers”: the book says government steps made it benefit small as well as rich farmers.
  • Calling land reforms equally successful everywhere: the book says they succeeded in Kerala and West Bengal, where governments were committed; other states lacked that commitment.
  • Calling the third category of IPR 1956 “completely free”: it too was controlled through licences.
  • Writing marketed surplus as total output: it is only the part sold in the market.
Quick revision: read this the night before the exam
  • India chose a mixed economy: strong public sector + private property + democracy; Planning Commission in 1950
  • Four goals: growth, modernisation, self-reliance, equity; modernisation can conflict with employment
  • Mahalanobis: architect of Indian planning; Second Plan based on his ideas; ISI and Sankhya
  • Land reforms: abolition of intermediaries + land ceiling; some 200 lakh tenants gained; success in Kerala and West Bengal
  • Green Revolution: HYV seeds (wheat, rice); two phases; self-sufficiency by the late 1960s; marketed surplus lowered prices and built a stock
  • Subsidies: needed for adoption; today a burden vs a need of poor farmers
  • Dependence on agriculture fell only from 67.5% to 64.9%: industry and services did not absorb workers
  • IPR 1956: three categories, licences, regional equality; SSI: Karve Committee 1955, reservation, concessions
  • Import substitution: tariffs and quotas; industry’s GDP share 13% to 24.6%, 6% annual growth
  • Criticism: inefficient PSUs, permit licence raj, captive market and poor quality → new economic policy 1991
Check yourself before the exam
  • Can I distinguish the three economic systems using the three central questions?
  • Can I define the four goals with an example each?
  • Can I give the limits of land reforms and the risks of the Green Revolution with the government’s steps?
  • Can I explain the three categories of IPR 1956 and the licence policy?
  • Can I read the 1950-51 and 1990-91 sector shares from the table and write a conclusion?
Read this chapter in:English Mediumहिंदी माध्यम