Class 11 English Book 2 Chapter 5 The Tale of Melon City Notes in English

What you will learn in this chapter
  • Retell the whole story of “The Tale of Melon City” in the right order, from the arch being built to the melon being crowned
  • Describe every character’s part in the chain of blame, and explain why each one escapes punishment
  • Explain the poem’s central irony: how the King’s own decree ends up killing him
  • Point out humour and irony in the poem with the exact lines that show them
  • Name the poetic devices used (irony, humour, personification, repetition) with the exact line each one appears in
  • Explain what the poem is satirising, and what its closing couplet on “laissez faire” means
Vikram Sethnarrative poemsatireironyjust and placidlaissez faire

1About the Poet and the Poem

Vikram Seth, the poet who wrote "The Tale of Melon City". Photograph by Amrhelweh / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0.
Vikram Seth, the poet who wrote “The Tale of Melon City”. Photograph by Amrhelweh / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0.

“The Tale of Melon City” is written by Vikram Seth. The NCERT
textbook itself gives the poem’s source: it says the poem “is taken from
Mappings which was published in 1981 and is included in the
Collected Poems by Vikram Seth.” Directly under the title, the book
also prints a second line: “(After Idries Shah)”. This tells you the
poem is Seth’s own retelling of an older tale, one that the book credits to
Idries Shah. So this is not a story Seth invented from nothing; the book’s
fifth question calls it “an ancient tale”. It is an absurd, almost
fable-like story about a king and his justice, told again in Seth’s own
witty rhyming verse.

Exam Tip

Know these three names together: Vikram Seth (poet),
Mappings, 1981 (the collection the poem is taken from), and
Idries Shah (the source the poem is “after”).

Before the poem begins, the textbook itself prints a short note that
tells you exactly what to look out for while reading:

“The king, in this poem, is ‘just and placid.’ Does he carry his notion of justice a bit too far?”

the NCERT textbook’s own introduction to the poem

Keep that question in mind through the whole story. The poem calls
the King “just and placid” (calm, not easily
disturbed) more than once, right up to the point where his own idea of
justice gets him hanged. One way to read the poem is that this gap, between
what the King believes about himself and what actually happens because of
his rulings, is its joke.

One possible answer to the book’s question: yes. Once the King’s
justice means finding someone to hang rather than finding out who is at
fault, each order goes further wrong. He says, “Let us postpone
consideration / Of finer points like guilt,” and the chain of blame ends
with his own changes: “You made certain amendments to / The plans when I
showed them to you.”

2The Story in Sequence

The poem tells one continuous chain of events, each caused by the one
before it. Read it in this order: every next step is caused by the one
before it.

1A “just and placid” King orders a triumphal arch built across the city’s main road, “To edify spectators there” (to impress and instruct the people who would watch him ride under it).
↓
2The workmen build it, “since he was the King”: nobody questions the order.
↓
3The King rides under the finished arch and loses his crown: the arch was built too low.
↓
4A frown appears on the King’s placid face. He calls it “a disgrace” and orders the chief of builders hanged.
↓
5The chief of builders shouts, “O King, it was the workmen’s fault.” The King halts the hanging and, “being just,” orders all the workmen hanged instead.
↓
6The workmen say, “The bricks were made of the wrong size.” The King summons the masons.
↓
7The masons, “quivering,” say, “It was the architect…” The architect is summoned and sentenced to hang.
↓
8The architect reminds the King: “You made certain amendments to / The plans when I showed them to you.” The fault traces back to the King himself.
Common Mistake

Students often stop the chain of blame at the architect. Do not miss
the King himself, who is where the chain of blame actually ends: the
architect reminds him, “You made certain amendments to / The plans when
I showed them to you.”

The King “saw red” and “nearly lost his head”, yet he still holds
back “being a just and placid King,” and instead asks for outside help:

9Calling it “a tricky thing”, the King asks for counsel and sends for “the wisest man in this country”.
↓
10The wisest man is found: he is so old that he “could not walk and could not see,” and has to be carried in. His verdict, in a “quavering” (trembling) voice: “Truly, the arch it was that banged / The crown off, and it must be hanged.”
↓
11As the arch is led to the scaffold, a Councillor objects: “How can we hang so shamefully / What touched your head, Your Majesty?” The King says, “True,” and the arch is not hanged.
↓
12By now a restless crowd is muttering aloud. The King perceives their mood and trembles, and postpones the question of guilt: “Let us postpone consideration / Of finer points like guilt. The nation / Wants a hanging. Hanged must be / Someone, and that immediately.”
↓
13A noose is set up “somewhat high”, and each man is measured against it. Only one man is tall enough to fit: the King himself.
↓
14The King is hanged “by Royal Decree”: his own law, meant for someone else, ends up killing him.

3How the City Got Its New King

15The Ministers are relieved, not sorry: “Thank Goodness we found someone… for if instead / We had not, the unruly town / Might well have turned against the Crown.” Then they say, “Long live the King! The King is dead.”
↓
16Being “practical-minded,” the Ministers send out heralds to proclaim, “As is our custom,” that whoever next passes the City Gate will choose the ruler of the state. The heralds proclaim it “In His [former] Majesty’s name”, that is, in the name of the dead King.
↓
17The first person to pass is an idiot. When the guards cry, “Who is to be the King? Decide!”, he answers, “A melon,” which was simply his standard answer to every question, since he liked melons.
↓
18The Ministers accept this literally: they crown a melon, carry it to the throne and “reverently set it down.”
Learn by heartDefinition 1

Melon City is the title’s name for the city in the poem: the
city whose King is a melon. The poem itself never gives the city any
other name.

4Years Later: The People’s View

The poem then jumps forward in time: “This happened years and years
ago.” When people are now asked how the city ended up with a melon as its
King, they answer, “Well, on / Account of customary choice,” and say it is
“OK” with them, “as long as he / Leaves us in Peace and Liberty.” The poem
does not say whether this is good or bad. Its very last couplet is:

“The principles of laissez faire
Seem to be well-established there.”

the poem’s closing lines

Term (not defined in the NCERT text)Definition 2

Laissez faire (French, literally “let (people) do (as they
choose)”) means a policy of leaving people alone to run their own lives,
with as little interference from the ruler or government as possible. In
the poem, a melon is King, so the people are left free from
interference. Asked about their melon king, they say they value “Peace
and Liberty”; the poem does not say whether this is good or bad.

5Characters at a Glance

Character Role in the story
The King “Just and placid”; orders the arch built, starts the chain of hangings, and is finally hanged by his own decree
The chief of builders First blamed for the low arch; escapes by blaming the workmen
The workmen Blamed next; escape by blaming bricks that “were made of the wrong size”; the King then summons the masons
The masons Blamed next; escape, “quivering,” by blaming the architect
The architect Blamed last among the humans; escapes by reminding the King that the King himself changed the plans
The wisest man in this country Old, blind and unable to walk; gives the verdict that the arch itself must be hanged
A Councillor Saves the arch by objecting that it is shameful to hang “What touched your head, Your Majesty”
The Ministers Relieved that someone was found, since “the unruly town / Might well have turned against the Crown”; later proclaim the City Gate custom (“As is our custom”) and crown the melon
The idiot The first person to pass the City Gate; answers “A melon” out of habit, and unintentionally becomes the kingmaker

6Satire and Themes

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 3

Satire is a way of writing that uses humour, exaggeration or
irony to criticise foolish or unjust behaviour, usually in society,
rulers or institutions. “The Tale of Melon City” can be read as a satire on rulers
and officials who follow the outward form of “justice” and procedure
while losing all sense of what justice actually means.

1

Justice reduced to a formality

One reading: the King insists on being “just,” but his idea of justice is simply
find someone to hang, not find out who is actually at fault. Being
“placid” only means he stays calm while doing this.

2

A chain of scapegoating

Every person blamed passes the blame further down the chain: chief
of builders → workmen → masons → architect → (finally) the King
himself, whom the architect blames for his “amendments” to the plans.

3

Mob pressure over reasoned judgement

When the crowd grows restless, the King postpones “consideration /
Of finer points like guilt”: “The nation / Wants a hanging,” whoever
deserves it.

4

A ruler who does nothing

One reading: a melon cannot govern, so it also cannot oppress. The
closing couplet suggests that a ruler who does nothing may leave people
free, but the poem’s satirical tone leaves its verdict open.

7Poetic Devices, with the Exact Lines

Every device below is quoted exactly as it appears in the poem. Learn
the quotation together with the device’s name.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 4

Irony is when what actually happens is the opposite of what is
expected. The poem’s biggest irony: “He was the King. His Majesty /
Was therefore hanged by Royal Decree”
: the King’s own law,
meant to punish someone else, ends up killing the King who made it.
A second example: “‘Long live the King!’ the Ministers said. / ‘Long
live the King! The King is dead.'”
: the very words used to
wish the King long life are said right after his death.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 5

Humour comes from the poem’s matter-of-fact tone about absurd
events. Examples: the masons who “stood there quivering”; the wisest man
in this country being chosen even though he “could not walk and could not
see” (“So old (and therefore wise) was he”); and a melon being crowned
and carried to the throne, where the Ministers “reverently set it down”
as though it were a real king.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 6

Personification is giving a non-living thing human qualities or
treatment. The arch, an object, is treated exactly like a guilty person:
it is “led” to the scaffold and the wise man rules that “it must be
hanged,” as if the arch itself could be tried and punished.

Literary term (not from the NCERT text)Definition 7

Repetition (refrain): the phrase “just and placid” is used for
the King more than once, and its variation “being just / (And placider
now)” appears again right before he orders the workmen hanged. Repeating
this phrase keeps reminding the reader of the gap between what the King
believes about his own fairness and what he actually does.

Exam Tip

“Suggest a few instances in the poem which highlight humour and irony”
is one of the book’s own 5 exercise questions. Answer it with the
exact quoted line, not just a description, because the question
asks for “instances in the poem”.

8Form and Style

Versea narrative poem, not a prose story
AABBmostly rhyming couplets throughout
Short linessimple, song-like rhythm, easy to read aloud

The book’s own fifth question asks students to notice that this old tale
is “narrated in a verse form,” which “lends extra charm to an ancient
tale.” Writing an absurd, almost fable-like story in short rhyming couplets
gives it the light, sing-song feel of a nursery rhyme or a folk tale told
aloud. One reading is that this lets its serious point about injustice land
as comedy rather than a lecture.

9Words to Know

Word / phrase Meaning (the book’s own footnote, where given)
triumphally in a grand, celebratory manner, as if marking a victory
edify to instruct or improve someone’s mind; here, roughly, to impress the spectators
thoroughfare a main road or public street
placid calm, not easily upset or angered
ordain to officially order or decree
quavering trembling (the book’s own footnote)
scaffold a raised platform for the execution of criminals (the book’s own footnote)
laissez faire a policy of leaving people free to act with little government interference

10All Definitions in One Place

All definitions in one place
Melon CityThe title’s name for the city whose King is a melon; the poem itself never names the city
Laissez faireLeaving people free to run their own lives with almost no interference from the ruler
SatireUsing humour, exaggeration or irony to criticise foolish or unjust behaviour
IronyWhen what happens is the opposite of what is expected, e.g. the King hanged by his own decree
HumourComedy from the poem’s calm, matter-of-fact tone about absurd events
PersonificationGiving a non-living thing human treatment, e.g. the arch “led” to the scaffold
Repetition (refrain)Repeating a phrase for effect, e.g. “just and placid” for the King
Check yourself before the exam
  • Can I narrate the whole story in order, without skipping the King himself in the chain of blame?
  • Can I explain the poem’s central irony in one sentence?
  • Can I name all four poetic devices with their exact quoted lines?
  • Can I explain what “laissez faire” means and why the poem ends on that idea?
Quick Revision: read this the night before the exam
  • Poet: Vikram Seth; from Mappings (1981), in Collected Poems; “(After Idries Shah)”
  • A “just and placid” King builds an arch “To edify spectators there”; it is too low and knocks off his crown
  • Chain of blame: chief of builders → workmen → masons → architect → the King’s own changes to the plan
  • The wisest man (old, blind, carried in) rules the arch itself must be hanged; a Councillor saves it
  • The restless crowd wants “a hanging,” so every man is measured for the noose; only the King is tall enough
  • The King is hanged “by Royal Decree”: his own law kills him; the Ministers are relieved that “we found someone”
  • Whoever next passes the City Gate must choose the new ruler; an idiot answers “A melon,” out of habit
  • The melon is crowned King; years later, the people accept it as “customary choice” and value their “Peace and Liberty”
  • Closing idea: “The principles of laissez faire / Seem to be well-established there”: the people are left free, though the poem leaves its verdict open
  • Devices to remember with their lines: irony (his own decree kills him), humour (the quivering masons, the crowned melon), personification (the arch “led” to the scaffold), repetition (“just and placid”)